Outstanding Reviewer Award Research Articles

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2023

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2023

Viewpoint: the evolving landscape of peer review

PurposeThe purpose of this viewpoint is to spotlight the role of reviewers within the collaborative triad of academic publishing. It argues that the significance of reviewers is often disregarded, leading to a gap in our understanding of the peer review process. This perspective emphasizes reviewers as unsung heroes in the publishing ecosystem, providing intentional and thought-provoking insights into the less-discussed yet impactful developments in the evolving peer review landscape.Design/methodology/approachLeveraging the author’s distinguished background as a recipient of the Journal of Service Marketing Outstanding Reviewer Award, this paper offers a personal reflection and synthesised viewpoints on the peer review process. Serving as a representative voice for reviewers, it provides insightful perspectives from the vantage point of a peer reviewer, diverging from conventional editorials and commentaries authored by editors.FindingsAcknowledging the shrinking reviewer pool, this viewpoint suggests a mandatory “review for review” system alongside incentives like editorial positions, while considering financial rewards for reviewers. The rise of generative artificial intelligence (AI) in review prompts ethical concerns but offers solutions for handling diverse submissions and dealing with “Reviewer 2.” While embracing open review for its transparency, potential pitfalls surrounding article confidence and copyright require attention. Ultimately, this viewpoint advocates for a collaborative approach, valuing reviewers, exploring innovative solutions, navigating ethical dilemmas in the technological age and implementing transparent practices responsibly for the betterment of scholarly discourse.Originality/valueThis viewpoint highlights the invaluable contributions of reviewers, enriching the scholarly community and promoting intellectual growth.

JACIII Distinguished Editor & Outstanding Reviewer Awards 2023

The JACIII Distinguished Editor and Outstanding Reviewer Awards were established for the purpose to honor editors who have made a significant contribution to the growth of the JACIII in 2018 and to acknowledge reviewers who have made a significant contribution to reviewing in 2022. We express our deepest gratitude for their professional work, which we believe conductive to development of not only the JACIII but also scientific research.

Announcing the 2023 Manfred Kroger Outstanding Reviewer Award winner—and thanks to all reviewers

Announcing the 2023 Manfred Kroger Outstanding Reviewer Award winner—and thanks to all reviewers

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2022

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2022

The 2017-2020 ITSM Outstanding Paper Awards and The 2017-2020 ITSM Outstanding Reviewer Awards [Society News

The 2017-2020 ITSM Outstanding Paper Awards and The 2017-2020 ITSM Outstanding Reviewer Awards [Society News

JACIII Distinguished Editor & Outstanding Reviewer Awards 2022

The JACIII Distinguished Editor and Outstanding Reviewer Awards were established for the purpose to honor editors who have made a significant contribution to the growth of the JACIII in 2018 and to acknowledge reviewers who have made a significant contribution to reviewing in 2021. We express our deepest gratitude for their professional work, which we believe conductive to development of not only the JACIII but also scientific research. JACIII DISTINGUISHED EDITOR AWARD 2022 Bin Xin (Beijing Institute of Technology, China), Fei Yan (Changchun University of Science and Technology, China), Guohun Zhu (The University of Queensland, Australia), Jinhua She (Tokyo University of Technology, Japan), Keigo Watanabe (Okayama University, Japan), Luefeng Chen (China University of Geosciences, China), Tomohiro Yoshikawa (Suzuka University of Medical Science, Japan), Tomomi Hashimoto (Saitama Institute of Technology, Japan), Yasufumi Takama (Tokyo Metropolitan University, Japan), Zhen-Tao Liu (China University of Geosciences, China), and Zhihong Peng (Beijing Institute of Technology, China) JACIII OUTSTANDING REVIEWER AWARD 2022 Emi Yuda (Tohoku University, Japan), Kehan Chen (Changchun University of Science and Technology, China), and Weiwu Ren (Changchun University of Science and Technology, China)

Manfred Kroger Outstanding Reviewer award – Thanks to all reviewers

Manfred Kroger Outstanding Reviewer award – Thanks to all reviewers

Coatings 2021 Outstanding Reviewer Award: Announcement and Interview with the Winner Dr. Valentina Marascu

The Coatings Editorial Board and Editorial Team would like to acknowledge the time and energy dedicated by the reviewers of manuscripts submitted to Coatings [...]

Coatings 2021 Outstanding Reviewer Award: Announcement and Interview with the Winner Dr. Catalin Pruncu

The Coatings Editorial Board and Editorial Team would like to acknowledge the time and energy dedicated by the reviewers of manuscripts submitted to Coatings [...]

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2021

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2021

2021 Reviewers for IEEE Transactions on Network and Service Management (TNSM)

The success and quality of this journal depends on the dedication and expertise of a large number of reviewers. On behalf of the Editorial Board, I would like to thank them explicitly for their excellent work during the non-trivial year 2021. Their substantial and constructive reviews have proven to be very valuable to the authors and are highly appreciated. <p xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">I am particularly pleased to report that three reviewers for IEEE Transactions on Network and Service Management (TNSM), <p xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><b>Viktoria Fodor</b>, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden <p xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><b>Hani Sami</b>, Concordia University, Canada <p xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><b>Kaiping Xue</b>, University of Science and Technology of China, China have received the IEEE Transactions Outstanding Reviewer Award 2021.

Announcement for “2021 Buildings Outstanding Reviewer Awards” Winners

Peer review is an essential part of the publication process and is important in ensuring that Buildings maintains high-quality standards for its published papers [...]

JACIII Distinguished Editor &amp; Outstanding Reviewer Awards 2021

The JACIII Distinguished Editor and Outstanding Reviewer Awards were established for the purpose to honor and editors who have made a significant contribution to the growth of the JACIII in 2018 and to acknowledge reviewers who have made a significant contribution to reviewing in 2019. We express our deepest gratitude for their professional work, which we believe conductive to development of not only the JACIII but also scientific research. JACIII DISTINGUISHED EDITOR AWARD 2021 Tomomi Hashimoto (Saitama Institute of Technology, Japan) Zhen-Tao Liu (China University of Geosciences, China) Bin Xin (Beijing Institute of Technology, China) Jianqiang Yi (Institute of Automation, Chinese Academy of Sciences, China) Junzo Watada (Waseda University, Japan) Yaping Dai (Beijing Institute of Technology, China) Zhiyang Jia (Beijing Institute of Technology, China) Wentao Gu (Zhejiang Gongshang University, China)

Announcing the 2021 Manfred Kroger Outstanding Reviewer Award winner – and thanks to all reviewers

Announcing the 2021 Manfred Kroger Outstanding Reviewer Award winner – and thanks to all reviewers

Announcement for “Buildings Outstanding Reviewer Award 2020” Winners

Peer review is an essential part of the publication process, ensuring that Buildings maintains high-quality standards for its published papers [...]

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2020

Outstanding Reviewer Award OR Spectrum 2020

JACIII Distinguished Editor &amp; Outstanding Reviewer Awards 2020

The JACIII Distinguished Editor and Outstanding Reviewer Awards were established for the purpose to honor and editors who have made a significant contribution to the growth of the JACIII in 2018 and to acknowledge reviewers who have made a significant contribution to reviewing in 2019. We express our deepest gratitude for their professional work, which we believe conductive to development of not only the JACIII but also scientific research. JACIII DISTINGUISHED EDITOR AWARD 2020 Fei Yan (Changchun University of Science and Technology, China) Guohun Zhu (Guilin University of Electronic Technology, China) Junzo Watada (Waseda University, Japan) Yoshiyuki Yabuuchi (Shimonoseki City University, Japan) JACIII OUTSTANDING REVIEWER AWARD 2020 Fei Yan (Changchun University of Science and Technology, China) Yasufumi Takama (Tokyo Metropolitan University, Japan) Luefeng Chen (China University of Geosciences, China) Xin Chen (China University of Geosciences, China) Tomomi Hashimoto (Saitama Institute of Technology, Japan) Hiroyuki Masuta (Toyama Prefectural University, Japan) Yasutake Takahashi (Fukui University, Japan)

Announcement for “Energies Outstanding Reviewer Award 2020” Winners

Peer review is an essential part of the publication process, ensuring that Energies maintains high-quality standards for its published papers [...]

Keys for authors to be enriched as excellent reviewers: The launch of TRR annual outstanding reviewer award

Keys for authors to be enriched as excellent reviewers: The launch of TRR annual outstanding reviewer award