Abstract Background Cardiovascular Implantable Electronic Devices (CIEDs) may be associated with peri- and post-procedural complications like device-related infection, one of the most serious challenge of CIEDs therapy associated with significant morbidity, mortality, and financial healthcare burden. Despite a routine use of antibiotics, recent studies reported an increase in CIEDs infections, with or without systemic involvement, that often require surgical interventions like transvenous lead extraction. Purpose This study evaluates the outcomes of transvenous lead extraction in patients with infected CIEDs, focusing on the impact of early versus delayed extraction timing on patient outcomes. Methods A retrospective analysis of 165 patients who underwent transvenous lead extraction for CIED infections between 2019 and 2022 was conducted. Patients were categorized into systemic (n=64) or local (n=101) infection groups and further into early (within 7 days from admission, n=102) or delayed (after 7 days, n=63) extraction groups. Post-procedural outcomes, including septic shock, complications, and mortality rates were described. Results The majority of patients were male (75%) with a median age of 73 (IQR 64-80) years. In the early extraction group, the 1-year mortality rate was significantly lower at 6.4%, compared to 25% in the delayed group. Patients with systemic infections had higher 1-month and 1-year mortality rates compared to those with local infections. The success rates of complete device removal were similar across groups. However, the delayed extraction group exhibited higher rates of comorbidities like anemia, chronic kidney disease, and elevated C-reactive protein levels, which were prevalent in 70% of these patients, compared to 45% in the early extraction group. Conclusions Timely management of CIED infections is crucial for improving patient outcomes. Early extraction within 7 days from hospital admission is associated with significantly lower mortality, regardless of local or systemic infection. Patients undergoing delayed extraction often present with greater comorbidity, which may contribute to their higher mortality rates. This underscores the importance of considering patient comorbidities and prompt intervention in managing CIED infections.