Outburst Recurrence Time Research Articles

A large population of neutron star low-mass X-ray binaries with long outburst recurrence time?

ABSTRACT Low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) with neutron stars show quite different features that depend on the rate of mass transfer from the donor star. With a high transfer rate, the Z sources are in a persistent soft spectral state, and with a moderate transfer rate the transient Atoll sources have outburst cycles like the black hole X-ray binaries. The observations document very long outburst recurrence times for quite a number of sources. We follow with our computations the evolution of the accretion disc until the onset of the ionization instability. For sources with a low mass transfer rate, the accumulation of matter in the disc is essentially reduced due to the continuous evaporation of matter from the disc to the coronal flow. Different mass transfer rates result in nearly the same amount of matter accumulated for the outburst, which means that the outburst properties are similar for sources with short outburst cycles and sources with long outburst cycles, contrary to some expectations. Then, for systems with long recurrence time, less sources will be detected and the total population of LMXBs could be larger than it appears. This would relieve the apparent problem that the observed number of LMXBs as progenitors of millisecond pulsars (MSPs) is too small compared to the number of MSPs. Concerning the few quasi-persistent sources with year-long soft states, we argue that these states are not outbursts, but quasi-stationary hot states as in Z sources.

Typical X-Ray Outburst Light Curves of Aql X-1

We show that the typical X-ray outburst light curve of Aql X-1 can be reproduced by accretion onto a neutron star in the frame of the disk instability model without invoking partial accretion or the propeller effect. The knee and the subsequent sharp decay in the X-ray light curve can be generated naturally by taking into account the weak dependence of the disk aspect ratio, h/r, on the disk mass-flow rate, Ṁin , in the X-ray irradiation flux calculation. This Ṁin dependence of h/r only slightly modifies the irradiation temperature profile along the hot disk in comparison to that obtained with a constant h/r. Nevertheless, this small difference has a significant cumulative effect on the hot disk radius, leading to a much faster decrease in the size of the hot disk and thereby to a sharper decay in the X-ray outburst light curve. The same model also produces the long-term evolution of Aql X-1, consistent with its observed outburst recurrence time and typical light curve. Our results imply that the source accretes matter from the disk in the quiescent state as well. We also estimate that the dipole moment of the source μ ≲ 4 × 1026 G cm3 (B ≲ 4 × 108 G at the surface).

The activity of the dwarf nova RU Pegasi with rapidly changing outburst types

ABSTRACT RU Pegasi is a dwarf nova (DN) of the U Geminorum type. This analysis of its long-term optical activity uses data from the data base of the American Association of Variable Star Observers (AAVSO). It concentrates on investigating the properties of the individual outbursts and the time evolution of the ensemble of these events. No significant irradiation of the disc by the white dwarf was detected. In the interpretation, a variable steepness of the rising branches of the individual outbursts shows that the start of outbursts of RU Peg can occur at various distances from the disc centre without remarkable changes of the outburst recurrence time TC. The disc overflow of the inflowing mass stream, varying with time, could contribute to the changes in the starting position of the heating front, and hence the variations of the outburst types. A typical length of TC was 90 d. The segments of the relatively stable length of TC were accompanied by the primarily little variable and small values of the fluence (the energy radiated in the optical band in the individual outbursts). Jumps of TC, accompanied by the big scatter of the fluences, sometimes replaced them. In the interpretation, a combination of variations of TC with the unstable properties of the outbursts, including an unstable mass transfer rate between the components, shows the influence of several mechanisms on the state of the disc in various time segments.

The Observed Mass Distribution of Galactic Black Hole LMXBs Is Biased against Massive Black Holes

Abstract The discovery of gravitational-wave radiation from merging black holes (BHs) also uncovered BHs with masses in the range of ≈20–160 M ⊙. In contrast, the most massive Galactic stellar-mass BH currently known has a mass of ≈21 M ⊙. While low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) will never independently evolve into a binary BH system, and binary evolution effects can play an important role in explaining the different BH masses found through studies of X-ray binaries and gravitational-wave events, (electromagnetic) selection effects may also play a role in this discrepancy. Assuming BH LMXBs originate in the Galactic plane, we show that the spatial distributions of the current samples of confirmed and candidate BH LMXBs are both biased to sources that lie at a large distance from the plane. Specifically, most of the confirmed and candidate BH LMXBs are found at a Galactic height larger than three times the scale height for massive star formation. In addition, the confirmed BH LMXBs are found at larger distances to the Galactic center than the candidate BH LMXBs. Interstellar absorption makes candidate BH LMXBs in the plane and bulge too faint for a dynamical mass measurement using current instrumentation. Given the observed and theoretical evidence for BH natal and/or Blaauw kicks, their relation with BH mass and binary orbital period, and the relation between outburst recurrence time and BH mass, the observational selection effects imply that the current sample of confirmed BH LMXBs is biased against the most massive BHs.

A Systematic Search for Outbursting AM CVn Systems with the Zwicky Transient Facility

Abstract AM CVn systems are a rare type of accreting binary that consists of a white dwarf and a helium-rich, degenerate donor star. Using the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF), we searched for new AM CVn systems by focusing on blue, outbursting stars. We first selected outbursting stars using the ZTF alerts. We cross matched the candidates with Gaia and Pan-STARRS catalogs. The initial selection of candidates based on the Gaia BP-RP contains 1751 unknown objects. We used the Pan-STARRS g-r and r-i color in combination with the Gaia color to identify 59 strong AM CVn candidates. We obtained identification spectra of 35 sources, of which 18 are high-priority candidates, and discovered nine new AM CVn systems and one magnetic CV that shows only He-ii lines. Using the outburst recurrence time, we estimate the orbital periods of the nine new AM CVn systems that are in the range of 29–50 minutes. We conclude that targeted follow up of blue, outbursting sources is an efficient method to find new AM CVn systems and we plan to follow up all candidates we identified to systematically study the population of outbursting AM CVn systems.

The X-Ray Pulsar XTE J1858+034 Observed with NuSTAR and Fermi/GBM: Spectral and Timing Characterization plus a Cyclotron Line

Abstract Accreting X-ray pulsars (XRPs) undergo luminous X-ray outbursts during which the spectral and timing behavior of the neutron star can be studied in detail. We analyze a NuSTAR observation of the XRP XTE J1858+034 during its outburst in 2019. The spectrum is fit with a phenomenological, a semiempirical, and a physical spectral model. A candidate cyclotron line is found at 48 keV, implying a magnetic field of 5.4 × 1012 G at the site of emission. This is also supported by the physical best-fit model. We propose an orbital period of about 81 days based on the visual inspection of the X-ray outburst recurrence time. Based on Fermi/GBM data, the standard disk accretion-torque theory allowed us to infer a distance of 10.9 ± 1.0 kpc. Pulse profiles are single-peaked and show a pulsed fraction that is strongly energy-dependent at least up to 40 keV.

Statistical properties of dwarf novae-type cataclysmic variables: the outburst catalogue

The Outburst Catalogue contains a wide variety of observational properties for 722 dwarf nova-type (DN) cataclysmic variables (CVs) and 309 CVs of other types from the Catalina Real-time Transient Survey. In particular, it includes the apparent outburst and quiescent V-band magnitudes, duty cycles, limits on the recurrence time, upper- and lower-limits on the distance and absolute quiescent magnitudes, colour information, orbital parameters, and X-ray counterparts. These properties were determined by means of a classification script presented in this paper. The DN in the catalogue show a correlation between the outburst duty cycle and the orbital period (and outburst recurrence time), as well as between the quiescent absolute magnitude and the orbital period (and duty cycle). This is the largest sample of dwarf nova properties collected to date. Besides serving as a useful reference for individual systems and a means of selecting objects for targeted studies, it will prove valuable for statistical studies that aim to shed light on the formation and evolution of cataclysmic variables.

Long-term X-ray variability of ultraluminous X-ray sources

Long-term X-ray modulations on timescales from tens to hundreds of days have been widely studied for X-ray binaries located in the Milky Way and the Magellanic Clouds. For other nearby galaxies, only the most luminous X-ray sources can be monitored with dedicated observations. We here present the first systematic study of long-term X-ray variability of four ultraluminous X-ray sources (ESO 243-49 HLX-1, Holmberg IX X-1, M81 X-6, and NGC 5408 X-1) monitored with Swift. By using various dynamic techniques to analyse their light curves, we find several interesting low-frequency quasi-periodicities. Although the periodic signals may not represent any stable orbital modulations, these detections reveal that such long-term regular patterns may be related to superorbital periods and structure of the accretion discs. In particular, we show that the outburst recurrence time of ESO 243-49 HLX-1 varies over time and suggest that it may not be the orbital period. Instead, it may be due to some kinds of precession, and the true binary period is expected to be much shorter.

ASASSN-14cc: A likely helium analog of RZ Leonis Minoris

Abstract We identified that ASASSN-14cc is a very active dwarf nova spending approximately 60% of the time in outburst. Our long-term photometry revealed that the object shows long outbursts recurring with a period of 21–33 d and very brief short outbursts lasting less than 1 d. The maximum fading rate exceeds 2.8 mag d−1. The duration of the long outbursts is 9–18 d, comprising 50%–60% of the recurrence time of long outbursts. We detected 0.01560–0.01562 d (22.5 min) modulations during long outbursts, which we identified as superhumps. These features indicate that ASASSN-14cc has outburst parameters very similar to the extremely unusual dwarf nova RZ LMi but with a much shorter superhump period. All the observations can be naturally understood, considering that this object is a helium analog (AM CVn-type object) of RZ LMi. The highest outburst activity among AM CVn-type objects can be understood as the high-mass transfer rate expected for the orbital period giving a condition close to the stability limit of the accretion disk. In contrast to RZ LMi, this object shows little evidence for premature quenching of the superoutburst, which has been proposed to explain the unusual outburst parameters in RZ LMi.

Revisiting a fundamental test of the disc instability model for X-ray binaries

We revisit a core prediction of the disc instability model (DIM) applied to X-ray binaries. The model predicts the existence of a critical mass transfer rate, which depends on disc size, separating transient and persistent systems. We therefore selected a sample of 52 persistent and transient neutron star and black hole X-ray binaries and verified if observed persistent (transient) systems do lie in the appropriate stable (unstable) region of parameter space predicted by the model. We find that, despite the significant uncertainties inherent to these kinds of studies, the data are in very good agreement with the theoretical expectations. We then discuss some individual cases that do not clearly fit into this main conclusion. Finally, we introduce the transientness parameter as a measure of the activity of a source and show a clear trend of the average outburst recurrence time to decrease with transientness in agreement with the DIM predictions. We therefore conclude that, despite difficulties in reproducing the complex details of the lightcurves, the DIM succeeds to explain the global behaviour of X-ray binaries averaged over a long enough period of time.

HS 2325 + 8205—An Ideal Laboratory for Accretion Disk Physics

ABSTRACTWe identify HS 2325 + 8205 as an eclipsing, frequently outbursting, dwarf nova with an orbital period of Porb = 279.841731(5) minutes. Spectroscopic observations are used to derive the radial velocity curve of the secondary star from absorption features and also from the Hα emission lines, originating from the accretion disk, yielding Ksec = Kabs = 237 ± 28 km s-1 and Kem = 145 ± 9 km s-1, respectively. The distance to the system is calculated to be 400(+200,-140) pc. A photometric monitoring campaign reveals an outburst recurrence time of ∼12–14 days. The combination of magnitude range (17–14 mag), high declination, and eclipsing nature and frequency of outbursts makes HS 2325 + 8205 the ideal system for “real-time” studies of the accretion disk evolution and behavior in dwarf nova outbursts.

DISCOVERY OF A 205.89 Hz ACCRETING MILLISECOND X-RAY PULSAR IN THE GLOBULAR CLUSTER NGC 6440

We report on the discovery of the second accreting millisecond X-ray pulsar (AMXP) in the globular cluster NGC 6440. Pulsations with a frequency of 205.89 Hz were detected with RXTE on 2009 August 30, October 1 and October 28, during the decays of ≲4 day outbursts of a newly X-ray transient source in NGC 6440. By studying the Doppler shift of the pulsation frequency, we find that the system is an ultra-compact binary with an orbital period of 57.3 minutes and a projected semimajor axis of 6.22 lt-ms. Based on the mass function, we estimate a lower limit to the mass of the companion to be 0.0067 M☉ (assuming a 1.4 M☉ neutron star). This new pulsar shows the shortest outburst recurrence time among AMXPs (∼1 month). If this behavior does not cease, this AMXP has the potential to be one of the best sources in which to study how the binary system and the neutron star spin evolve. Furthermore, the characteristics of this new source indicate that there might exist a population of AMXPs undergoing weak outbursts which are undetected by current all-sky X-ray monitors. NGC 6440 is the only globular cluster to host two known AMXPs, while no AMXPs have been detected in any other globular cluster.

The cyclic variation of the outburst recurrence time in GRS 1747–312

We present an analysis of the long-term evolution of outbursts in the neutron star soft X-ray transient GRS 1747–312. Observations taken from ASM/ RXTE, in the 1.5–12 keV passband, are utilized. We reveal a cyclic behavior in the residuals of the outburst recurrence time with respect to the mean value of T C = 136 ± 2 days. The profile of this cycle is approximately sinusoidal; the remaining cycle-to-cycle fluctuations possess a considerably smaller amplitude. We find that, although the peak flux of the outbursts displays a significant scatter at a given phase of the cycle, the most luminous outbursts occur after the longest T C. The fluence displays a large scatter for the individual outbursts and tends to decrease with time. We argue that although the cycle-length of ∼5.4 yr is compatible with that of the presumed magnetic activity of the late-type donor, it cannot be explained by variations of the mass outflow from the donor to the disk. In our interpretation, the stellar activity is translated to variations of T C via interaction of the magnetic field of the spots on the donor with the magnetic field of the disk. This gives rise to a variable efficiency of the removal of the angular momentum from the quiescent disk during the activity cycle of the donor. This mechanism can be strengthened by accompanying variations of the radius of the optically thin advection-dominated accretion flow in quiescence. We show that the peak mass accretion rate onto the neutron star in the individual outbursts of GRS 1747–312 is considerably more stable than in two other similar systems with frequent outbursts, Aql X-1 and 4U 1608–52; this allows the cyclic modulation of T C to show itself in GRS 1747–312.

The Low Quiescent X‐Ray Luminosity of the Neutron Star Transient XTE J2123−058

We report on the first X-ray observations of the neutron star soft X-ray transient (SXT) XTE J2123-058 in quiescence made by the Chandra X-Ray Observatory and BeppoSAX, as well as contemporaneous optical observations. In 2002, the Chandra spectrum of XTE J2123-058 is consistent with a power-law model or the combination of a blackbody plus a power law, but it is not well described by a pure blackbody. Using the interstellar value of NH, the power-law fit gives Γ = 3.1 and indicates an 0.3-8 keV unabsorbed luminosity of 9 × 1031(d/8.5 kpc)2 ergs s-1 (90% confidence errors). Fits with models consisting of thermal plus power-law components indicate that the upper limit on the temperature of a 1.4 M☉, 10 km radius neutron star with a hydrogen atmosphere is kTeff < 66 eV, and the upper limit on the unabsorbed, bolometric luminosity is L∞ < 1.4 × 1032 ergs s-1, assuming d = 8.5 kpc. Of the neutron star SXTs that exhibit short (<1 yr) outbursts, including Aql X-1, 4U 1608-522, Cen X-4, and SAX J1810.8-2609, the lowest temperatures and luminosities are found for XTE J2123-058 and SAX J1810.8-2609. From the BeppoSAX observation of XTE J2123-058 in 2000, we obtained an upper limit on the 1-10 keV unabsorbed luminosity of 9 × 1032 ergs s-1. Although this upper limit allows for the X-ray luminosity to have decreased between 2000 and 2002, that possibility is not supported by our contemporaneous R-band observations, which indicate that the optical flux increased significantly. Motivated by the theory of deep crustal heating by Brown and coworkers, we characterize the outburst histories of the five SXTs. The low quiescent luminosity for XTE J2123-058 is consistent with the theory of deep crustal heating without requiring enhanced neutron star cooling if the outburst recurrence time is 70 yr.

1RXS J232953.9+062814: A Possible Progenitor of AM CVn Stars

AbstractWe revealed that the hydrogen-rich cataclysmic variable lRXS J232953.9+062814 is an SU UMa-type dwarf nova with a superbump period of 66.774±0.010 min. A photometric orbital period is determined to be 64.184± 0.003 min, which is below the period minimum. Although the standard evolutionary scenario of cataclysmic variables predicts lower mass-transfer rates in systems with shorter orbital periods, its short recurrence time of outbursts and bright apparent magnitude indicate that this object has a relatively high mass-transfer rate. With the analogous system V485 Cen, these objects establish the first subpopulation in hydrogen-rich cataclysmic variables below the period minimum. Concerning the evolutionary status of them, we propose that they are progenitors of AM CVn stars on evolutionary courses in which systems have an evolved secondary star with a hydrogen-exhausted core.

A change in the outburst recurrence time of the Rapid Burster

An apparent sudden change in the outburst recurrence time displayed by the Rapid Burster occurred around the end of 1999. The time between consecutive outbursts shrinked from ≈200 to ≈100 days somewhere between November 1999 and March 2000. In parallel, the average peak intensity also decreased of a factor ~2 in all outbursts occurred after November 1999 with respect to those occurred before this date. I discuss these results by comparing them with similar cases of changes in the recurrence time of other transient X–ray binaries and with the behaviour of Dwarf Novae. A viable explanation is connected with changes in the value of the quiescence mass transfer rate from the secondary, although the detailed origin of these changes remains at best speculative. Further, this result has important implications for programming time-constrained observations of the Rapid Burster both in outburst and in quiescence.

The nature of dwarf nova outbursts

We show that if the dwarf-nova disc instability model includes the effects of heating by stream impact and tidal torque dissipation in the outer disc, the calculated properties of dwarf-nova outbursts change considerably, and several notorious deficiencies of this model are repaired. In particular: (1) outside-in outbursts occur for mass transfer rates lower than in the standard model as required by observations; (2) the presence of long (wide) and short (narrow) outbursts with similar peak luminosities is a natural property of the model. Mass-transfer fluctuations by factors ~ 2 can explain the occurrence of both long and short outbursts above the cataclysmic variable period gap, whereas below 2 hr only short normal outbursts are expected (in addition to superoutbursts which are not dealt with in this article). With additional heating by the stream and tidal torques, such fluctuations can also explain the occurrence of both outside-in and inside-out outbursts in SS Cyg and similar systems. The occurrence of outside-in outbursts in short orbital-period, low mass-transfer-rate systems requires the disc to be much smaller than the tidal-truncation radius. In this case the recurrence time of both inside-out and outside-in outbursts have a similar dependence on the mass-transfer rate.

Complex outburst behaviour from the black hole candidate 4U1630--47

We present data from different epochs in 1978, 1987-1991 and 1996 from the black-hole candidate 4U1630-47. For the first time we present almost complete coverage of the outbursts which started in 1987, 1988 and 1996. We find that the outburst behaviour of 4U1630-47 is more complex than previously realized. The source shows outbursts with durations on the order of ~100-200 days and sometimes intervals of long-term X-ray activity. The relatively short outbursts which occurred in 1987 and 1996 exhibited different colour behaviour: the outburst in 1987 showed softening of the X-ray spectrum, whereas the outburst in 1996 showed hardening of the X-ray spectrum, as the outbursts proceeded. The outburst which started in 1977 may have lasted for up to ~10 months, whereas the outburst which started in 1988 showed activity for up to ~2.4 years. Such long-term activity is reminiscent of that seen in GRS1716-249 and in the galactic superluminal sources GRS1915+105 and GROJ1655-40. We refine the outburst ephemeris of 4U\1630-47 and find that the outburst recurrence time scale may have changed from ~600 days to ~690 days between the 1984 and 1987 outbursts. If the recurrence interval of ~690 days continues, the next outburst of 4U1630-47 is predicted to occur in 1998 January.

Discovery of a New SU UMa-Type Dwarf Nova, V1113 Cygni

Abstract A faint dwarf nova, VI113 Cyg, was observed for five nights during its long outburst in 1994 September. V-band CCD photometry revealed superhumps with a period of 0.0792 (±0.0001)d. This finding confirms V1113 Cygni as being a new member of SU UMa-type dwarf novae. VI113 Cyg is unique among SU UMatype dwarf novae with similar superhump periods in that this star shows both a short (∼ 10 d) outburst recurrence time and a large (∼ 6 mag) outburst amplitude, which seem to imply discordant mass-transfer rates. A possible explanation of this phenomenon is briefly discussed.

Disk instability and outburst properties of the intermediate polar GK Persei

The present study reproduces the observed recurrence time scales and duration of the 1981-1989 dwarf nova-type outbursts of the intermediate polar GK Per with a model based on the time-dependent disk instability model. The model gives approximately symmetric (type B, inside-out) outbursts, as observed. This agreement suggests that the outbursts cannot result from a mass transfer instability. A modest variation of the mass transfer rate from the companion is sufficient to account for the variable outburst recurrence time scale. Contamination from the companion and the hot spot dominate the light from the disk except during a bright outburst. An intermediate temperature stagnation wave followed by a full heating wave is consistent with the observed rapid rise and double-peaked structure in the UV and optical light curves. It is argued that the hard X-ray efficiency is dime-dependent, and it is found to be much smaller in outburst than in quiescence.