Orthogonal Biophysical Techniques Research Articles

The effects of histidine substitution of aromatic residues on the amyloidogenic properties of the fragment 264–277 of nucleophosmin 1

Histidine (His) plays a key role in mediating protein interactions and its unique side chain determines pH responsive self-assembling processes and thus in the formation of nanostructures. In this study, To identify novel self-assembling bioinspired sequences, we analyzed a series of peptide sequences obtained through the point mutation of aromatic residues of 264–277 fragment of nucleophosmin 1 (NPM1) with single and double histidines. Through several orthogonal biophysical techniques and under different pH and ionic strength conditions we evaluated the effects of these substitutions in the amyloidogenic features of derived peptides. The results clearly indicate that both the type of aromatic mutated residue and its position can have different effect on amyloid-like behaviors. They corroborate the crucial role exerted by Tyr271 in the self-assembling process of CTD of NPM1 in AML mutated form and add novel insights in the accurate investigation of how side chain orientations can determine successful design of innovative bioinspired materials.

Purity and DNA content of AAV capsids assessed by analytical ultracentrifugation and orthogonal biophysical techniques

Development and manufacturing adeno-associated virus (AAV)-based vectors for gene therapy requires suitable analytical methods to assess the quality of the formulations during development, as well as the quality of different batches and the consistency of the processes. Here, we compare biophysical methods to characterize purity and DNA content of viral capsids from five different serotypes (AAV2, AAV5, AAV6, AAV8, and AAV9). For this purpose, we apply multiwavelength sedimentation velocity analytical ultracentrifugation (SV-AUC) to obtain the species' contents and to derive the wavelength-specific correction factors for the respective insert-size. In an orthogonal manner we perform anion exchange chromatography (AEX) and UV-spectroscopy and the three methods yield comparable results on empty/filled capsid contents with these correction factors. Whereas AEX and UV-spectroscopy can quantify empty and filled AAVs, only SV-AUC could identify the low amounts of partially filled capsids present in the samples used in this study. Finally, we employ negative-staining transmission electron microscopy and mass photometry to support the empty/filled ratios with methods that classify individual capsids. The obtained ratios are consistent throughout the orthogonal approaches as long as no other impurities and aggregates are present. Our results show that the combination of selected orthogonal methods can deliver consistent empty/filled contents on non-standard genome sizes, as well as information on other relevant critical quality attributes, such as AAV capsid concentration, genome concentration, insert size length and sample purity to characterize and compare AAV preparations.

In-solution structure and oligomerization of human histone deacetylase 6 - an integrative approach.

Human histone deacetylase 6 (HDAC6) is a structurally unique, multidomain protein implicated in a variety of physiological processes including cytoskeletal remodelling and the maintenance of cellular homeostasis. Our current understanding of the HDAC6 structure is limited to isolated domains, and a holistic picture of the full-length protein structure, including possible domain interactions, is missing. Here, we used an integrative structural biology approach to build a solution model of HDAC6 by combining experimental data from several orthogonal biophysical techniques complemented by molecular modelling. We show that HDAC6 is best described as a mosaic of folded and intrinsically disordered domains that in-solution adopts an ensemble of conformations without any stable interactions between structured domains. Furthermore, HDAC6 forms dimers/higher oligomers in a concentration-dependent manner, and its oligomerization is mediated via the positively charged N-terminal microtubule-binding domain. Our findings provide the first insights into the structure of full-length human HDAC6 and can be used as a basis for further research into structure function and physiological studies of this unique deacetylase.

Deciphering cellular and molecular determinants of human DPCD protein in complex with RUVBL1/RUVBL2 AAA-ATPases

DPCD is a protein that may play a role in cilia formation and whose absence leads to primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD), a rare disease caused by impairment of ciliated cells. Except for high-throughput studies that identified DPCD as a possible RUVBL1 (R1) and RUVBL2 (R2) partner, no in-depth cellular, biochemical, and structural investigation involving DPCD have been reported so far. R1 and R2 proteins are ubiquitous highly conserved AAA + family ATPases that assemble and mature a plethora of macromolecular complexes and are pivotal in numerous cellular processes, especially by guaranteeing a co-chaperoning function within R2TP or R2TP-like machineries. In the present study, we identified DPCD as a new R1R2 partner in vivo. We show that DPCD interacts directly with R1 and R2 in vitro and in cells. We characterized the physico-chemical properties of DPCD in solution and built a 3D model of DPCD. In addition, we used a variety of orthogonal biophysical techniques including small-angle X-ray scattering, structural mass spectrometry and electron microscopy to assess the molecular determinants of DPCD interaction with R1R2. Interestingly, DPCD disrupts the dodecameric state of R1R2 complex upon binding and this interaction occurs mainly via the DII domains of R1R2.

Biophysical Survey of Small-Molecule β-Catenin Inhibitors: A Cautionary Tale.

The canonical Wingless-related integration site signaling pathway plays a critical role in human physiology, and its dysregulation can lead to an array of diseases. β-Catenin is a multifunctional protein within this pathway and an attractive yet challenging therapeutic target, most notably in oncology. This has stimulated the search for potent small-molecule inhibitors binding directly to the β-catenin surface to inhibit its protein–protein interactions and downstream signaling. Here, we provide an account of the claimed (and some putative) small-molecule ligands of β-catenin from the literature. Through in silico analysis, we show that most of these molecules contain promiscuous chemical substructures notorious for interfering with screening assays. Finally, and in line with this analysis, we demonstrate using orthogonal biophysical techniques that none of the examined small molecules bind at the surface of β-catenin. While shedding doubts on their reported mode of action, this study also reaffirms β-catenin as a prominent target in drug discovery.

Discovery of small molecules interacting at lactate dehydrogenases tetrameric interface using a biophysical screening cascade

Lactate dehydrogenases (LDHs) are tetrameric enzymes of therapeutic relevance for cancer therapy due to their important implications in cancer cell metabolism. LDH active site inhibition suffers from different drawbacks due to several features such as high cellular concentration and a shared active site among the dehydrogenase family. Conversely, targeting the LDH oligomeric state is an exciting strategy that could provide a suitable alternative to active-site inhibition. In the present study, we developed a biophysical screening cascade to probe the LDHs tetrameric interface. Using nanoscale differential fluorimetry (nanoDSF) as a primary screening method, we identified a series of hits that destabilize the tetrameric protein. From this primary screening, we validated selected hits using saturation transfer difference nuclear magnetic resonance (STD NMR) and microscale thermophoresis (MST) as a combination of orthogonal biophysical techniques. Finally, we characterized the validated hits and demonstrated that they specifically interact at the tetrameric interface of LDH-1 and LDH-5 and can inhibit the LDH tetramerization process. Overall, this work provides a convenient method for screening ligands at the LDH tetrameric interface and has identified promising hits suitable for further optimization. We believe that this biophysical screening cascade, especially the use of (nano)DSF, could be extended to other homomeric proteins.

Pulse Proteolysis: An Orthogonal Tool for Protein Formulation Screening

Protein formulation stability is difficult to predict a priori and generally involves long-term stability studies. It is of interest to develop an analytical method that can predict stability trends reliably. Here, pulse proteolysis was evaluated as an analytical tool to predict solution-state stability in different formulations. Four proteins formulated in different buffer and excipient compositions were subjected to urea-induced unfolding and brief enzymatic digestion (“pulse” proteolysis), and relative resistance to proteolysis was measured by microfluidics-based capillary electrophoresis–sodium dodecyl sulfate. Biophysical properties of each formulation were measured using orthogonal biophysical techniques such as differential scanning fluorimetry, differential scanning calorimetry, dynamic light scattering, circular dichroism, and fluorescence spectroscopy. Protein stability in all formulations was monitored by size exclusion chromatography on storage at 5°C and 40°C. For all 4 proteins, formulations with greater proteolytic resistance also showed higher monomer content on thermal stability. In contrast, standard biophysical techniques showed reasonable-to-no correlation with size exclusion chromatography data. The data support the use of pulse proteolysis as an orthogonal, quantitative, and predictive tool to measure protein conformational stability and rank-order formulations.

Changes in the stability and biomechanics of P22 bacteriophage capsid during maturation

The capsid of P22 bacteriophage undergoes a series of structural transitions during maturation that guide it from spherical to icosahedral morphology. The transitions include the release of scaffold proteins and capsid expansion. Although P22 maturation has been investigated for decades, a unified model that incorporates thermodynamic and biophysical analyses is not available. A general and specific model of icosahedral capsid maturation is of significant interest to theoreticians searching for fundamental principles as well as virologists and material scientists seeking to alter maturation to their advantage. To address this challenge, we have combined the results from orthogonal biophysical techniques including differential scanning fluorimetry, atomic force microscopy, circular dichroism, and hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry. By integrating these results from single particle and population measurements, an energy landscape of P22 maturation from procapsid through expanded shell to wiffle ball emerged, highlighting the role of metastable structures and the thermodynamics guiding maturation. The propagation of weak quaternary interactions across symmetric elements of the capsid is a key component for stability in P22. A surprising finding is that the progression to wiffle ball, which lacks pentamers, shows that chemical and thermal stability can be uncoupled from mechanical rigidity, elegantly demonstrating the complexity inherent in capsid protein interactions and the emergent properties that can arise from icosahedral symmetry. On a broader scale, this work demonstrates the power of applying orthogonal biophysical techniques to elucidate assembly mechanisms for supramolecular complexes and provides a framework within which other viral systems can be compared.

Biophysical characterization of influenza A virions

Antigenic drift of the influenza A virus requires that vaccine production is targeted to the strains circulating each year. Live-attenuated influenza A vaccine manufacturing is used to produce intact virions with the surface antigens of the circulating strains. Influenza A typically contains a large percentage (>90%) of non-infective virions. The ribonucleoprotein (RNP) content, virion structure, and aggregation are factors that are thought to have an impact on infectivity. However, these factors are difficult to study because of the intrinsic variability in virion size, shape and overall structural integrity. Negative stain TEM for total particle counts and cryoTEM for detailed size/structural analysis are established benchmark techniques for virus characterization. Other methods may be valuable for certain sample types or circumstances. The aim of this work is to establish a benchmark comparison between orthogonal biophysical techniques for particle counts, population size distribution, structural integrity, and aggregate levels. NTA and FFF-MALS rapidly provided total counts, size distribution, and aggregate/elongated virion content. CryoTEM with size analysis and fraction counting yielded detailed information about the pleomorphism of the sample. The structural integrity of virions was inferred from multi-signal AUC-SV and CryoTEM. The current work provides a comparative assessment and a baseline for the selection of biophysical tools for the determination of particle counts, aggregation and pleomorphic characteristics of influenza A virus.

Development of a multipurpose scaffold for the display of peptide loops.

Protein–protein interactions (PPIs) determine a wide range of biological processes and analysis of these dynamic networks is increasingly becoming a mandatory tool for studying protein function. Using the globular ATPase domain of recombinase RadA as a scaffold, we have developed a peptide display system (RAD display), which allows for the presentation of target peptides, protein domains or full-length proteins and their rapid recombinant production in bacteria. The design of the RAD display system includes differently tagged versions of the scaffold, which allows for flexibility in the protein purification method, and chemical coupling for small molecule labeling or surface immobilization. When combined with the significant thermal stability of the RadA protein, these features create a versatile multipurpose scaffold system. Using various orthogonal biophysical techniques, we show that peptides displayed on the scaffold bind to their natural targets in a fashion similar to linear parent peptides. We use the examples of CK2β/CK2α kinase and TPX2/Aurora A kinase protein complexes to demonstrate that the peptide displayed by the RAD scaffold can be used in PPI studies with the same binding efficacy but at lower costs compared with their linear synthetic counterparts.

Discovery of a junctional epitope antibody that stabilizes IL-6 and gp80 protein:protein interaction and modulates its downstream signaling

Protein:protein interactions are fundamental in living organism homeostasis. Here we introduce VHH6, a junctional epitope antibody capable of specifically recognizing a neo-epitope when two proteins interact, albeit transiently, to form a complex. Orthogonal biophysical techniques have been used to prove the “junctional epitope” nature of VHH6, a camelid single domain antibody recognizing the IL-6–gp80 complex but not the individual components alone. X-ray crystallography, HDX-MS and SPR analysis confirmed that the CDR regions of VHH6 interact simultaneously with IL-6 and gp80, locking the two proteins together. At the cellular level, VHH6 was able to alter the response of endothelial cells to exogenous IL-6, promoting a sustained STAT3 phosphorylation signal, an accumulation of IL-6 in vesicles and an overall pro-inflammatory phenotype supported further by transcriptomic analysis. Junctional epitope antibodies, like VHH6, not only offer new opportunities in screening and structure-aided drug discovery, but could also be exploited as therapeutics to modulate complex protein:protein interactions.

Conditions for homogeneous preparation of stable monomeric and oligomeric forms of activated Vip3A toxin from Bacillus thuringiensis.

Bacillus thuringiensis vegetative insecticidal proteins like Vip3A have been used for crop protection and to delay resistance to existing insecticidal Cry toxins. However, little is known about Vip3A's behavior or its mechanism of action, and a structural model is required. Herein, in an effort to facilitate future crystallization and functional studies, we have used the orthogonal biophysical techniques of light scattering and sedimentation to analyze the aggregation behavior and stability of trypsin-activated Vip3A toxin in solution. Both scattering and sedimentation data suggest that at pH 10 the toxin is monomeric and adopts an elongated shape, but after overnight incubation aggregation was observed at all pH values tested (5-12). The narrowest size distribution was observed at pH 7, but it was consistent with large oligomers of ~50nm on average. The addition of β-D-glucopyranoside (OG) helped in achieving preparations that were stable and with a narrower particle size distribution. In this case, scattering was consistent with a 4-nm monomeric globular Vip3A form. After OG dialysis, 40-nm particles were detected, with a molecular weight consistent with homotetramers. Therefore, OG is proposed as the detergent of choice to obtain a Vip3A crystal for structural studies, either before (monomers) or after dialysis (tetramers).

Binary Toxin Subunits of Lysinibacillus sphaericus Are Monomeric and Form Heterodimers after In Vitro Activation

The binary toxin from Lysinibacillus sphaericus has been successfully used for controlling mosquito-transmitted diseases. An activation step shortens both subunits BinA and BinB before their interaction with membranes and internalization in midgut cells, but the precise role of this activation step is unknown. Herein, we show conclusively using three orthogonal biophysical techniques that protoxin subunits form only monomers in aqueous solution. However, in vitro activated toxins readily form heterodimers. This oligomeric state did not change after incubation of these heterodimers with detergent. These results are consistent with the evidence that maximal toxicity in mosquito larvae is achieved when the two subunits, BinA and BinB, are in a 1:1 molar ratio, and directly link proteolytic activation to heterodimerization. Formation of a heterodimer must thus be necessary for subsequent steps, e.g., interaction with membranes, or with a suitable receptor in susceptible mosquito species. Lastly, despite existing similarities between BinB C-terminal domain with domains 3 and 4 of pore-forming aerolysin, no aerolysin-like SDS-resistant heptameric oligomers were observed when the activated Bin subunits were incubated in the presence of detergents or lipidic membranes.

Ligand-Orientation Based Fragment Selection in STD NMR Screening

While saturation transfer difference (STD) is a widely used NMR method for ligand screening, the selection of specific binders requires the validation of the hits through competition experiments or orthogonal biophysical techniques. We show here that the quantitative STD analysis is a reliable and robust approach to discriminate between specific and nonspecific ligands, allowing selection of fragments that bind proteins with a privileged binding mode, in the absence of any structural data for the protein.

Abstract LB-257: Discovery and characterization of novel, highly potent and selective USP7 inhibitors

Abstract Over the past decade, protein ubiquitination has emerged as an important post-translational modification with roles in a plethora of cellular processes, and dysregulation in the ubiquitin proteasome system pathway (UPS) has been implicated in multiple human disorders including cancer. Ubiquitin specific proteases (USPs) are cysteine proteases that catalyse the de-ubiquitination of numerous protein substrates including tumor suppressors and oncogenes, hence regulating their levels and/or functions. USPs therefore represent a fast growing and attractive target class for pharmacological intervention. USP7 in particular has attracted considerable attention for its implications in multiple key oncogenic pathways including most notably MDM2/p53, PTEN and DNA damage. As part of a focussed effort towards targeting USPs, fragment screening was performed against a panel of family members, including USP7. Hits were identified by surface plasmon resonance and validated using orthogonal biophysical techniques (NMR, thermophoresis). Subsequent hit expansion identified molecules for which high-resolution co-crystal structures have been solved providing unique opportunities for structure-based design. Medicinal chemistry optimisation has yielded a series of novel, reversible and potent USP7 inhibitors (e.g. IC50 < 10 nM) with excellent selectivity profiles against deubiquitinating (DUBs) and other non-related enzymes. These inhibitors are cell-permeable and also exhibit potent target engagement in cells (e.g. EC50 < 30 nM). In line with the mechanism of action, further cellular profiling has demonstrated effects on p53, p21 and MDM2 levels in a concentration-dependant manner. From a translational viewpoint, initial studies aimed at identifying cell lines sensitive to these inhibitors will also be discussed. In summary, we report the discovery and detailed biochemical and cellular profiling of novel, potent and selective inhibitors of USP7. These molecules have drug-like properties and may provide opportunities for the development of new anticancer therapeutics. Citation Format: Gerald Gavory, Colin O'dowd, Keeva McClelland, Ewa Odrzywol, Alan Brown, Stephanie Burton, Oliver Barker, Frank Burkamp, Matt Helm, Iain James, Jakub Flasz, Elias Arkoudis, Tim Harrison. Discovery and characterization of novel, highly potent and selective USP7 inhibitors. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 106th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2015 Apr 18-22; Philadelphia, PA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2015;75(15 Suppl):Abstract nr LB-257. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2015-LB-257

Technical Decision-Making with Higher Order Structure Data: Specific Binding of a Nonionic Detergent Perturbs Higher Order Structure of a Therapeutic Monoclonal Antibody

Robust higher order structure (HOS) characterization capability and strategy are critical throughout biopharmaceutical development from initial candidate selection and formulation screening to process optimization and manufacturing. This case study describes the utility of several orthogonal HOS methods as investigational tools during purification process development. An atypically high level of residual detergent in a development drug substance batch of a therapeutic monoclonal antibody triggered a root cause investigation. Several orthogonal biophysical techniques were used to uncover and characterize a specific interaction between the detergent and the antibody. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) was used to quantify the molar ratio and affinity of the binding event, and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) were used to evaluate corresponding impacts on secondary/tertiary structure and thermal stability, respectively. As detergents are used routinely in biopharmaceutical processing, this case study highlights the value and power of HOS data in informing technical investigations and underlines the importance of HOS characterization as a component of overall biopharmaceutical analytical control strategy.

Phosphatidylinositol induces fluid phase formation and packing defects in phosphatidylcholine model membranes

Liposomes consisted of phosphatidylinositol (PI) and phosphatidylcholine (PC) have been utilized as delivery vehicle for drugs and proteins. In the present work, we studied the effect of soy PI on physical properties of 1,2-dimyristoyl- sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) liposomes such as phase state of lipid bilayer, lipid packing and phase properties using multiple orthogonal biophysical techniques. The 6-dodecanoyl-2-dimethylamino naphthalene (Laurdan) fluorescence studies showed that presence of PI induces the formation of fluid phases in DMPC. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), temperature dependent fluorescence anisotropy measurements, and generalized polarization values for Laurdan showed that the presence of as low as 10 mol% of PI induces substantial broadening and shift to lower temperature of phase transition of DMPC. The fluorescence emission intensity of DPH labeled, PI containing DMPC lipid bilayer decreased possibly due to deeper penetration of water molecules in lipid bilayer. In order to further delineate the effect of PI on the physico chemical properties of DMPC is due to either significant hydrophobic mismatch between the acyl chains of the DMPC and that of soy PI or due to the inositol head group, we systematically replaced soy PI with PC species of similar acyl chain composition (DPPC and 18:2 (Cis) PC) or with diacylglycerol (DAG), respectively. The anisotropy of PC membrane containing soy PI showed largest fluidity change compared to other compositions. The data suggests that addition of PI alters structure and dynamics of DMPC bilayer in that it promotes deeper water penetration in the bilayer, induces fluid phase characteristics and causes lipid packing defects that involve its inositol head group.