Wet air oxidation (WAO) is a promising sludge treatment technology but has yet to be used widely. This study evaluates a new integrated pathway of AD plus WAO, juxtaposing against the standalone AD and WAO, from the aspects of carbon emissions, energy efficiency, and cost-benefits. The assessment unit is 1 t dewatered sludge with a water content of 80%, and the greenhouse gases are converted to equivalent CO2. WAO can recover the thermal heat released from organic oxidation, resulting in the lowest carbon emissions, 10.92 to −36.86 kg CO2-eq/t. AD plus WAO also performs well with 32.21 to −48.16 kg CO2-eq/t. All three ways can produce renewable energy through biogas utilization or thermal recovery. WAO has the highest energy efficiency of 35%–42% due to efficient thermal energy recovery, and AD plus WAO has a second-ranked efficiency of 15%–30%. However, WAO needs expensive facilities and external electricity, resulting in a higher expenditure than AD. The integrated systems also require a high investment, but can simplify digested sludge treatment. According to the normalized scores in the three aspects, WAO is recommended chiefly, especially for treating low-organic-content sludge. AD plus WAO ranked second and can be used for high-organic-content sludge.
Read full abstract