Orbital Volume Ratio Research Articles

Assessment of the Correlation Between Types of Orbital Fractures and Ocular Symptoms, and the Effect of Manual Preformed and Patient-Specific Mesh Implants: A Retrospective Study.

Although certain orbital fractures are associated with specific clinical symptoms, these relationships should be reviewed comprehensively. The optimal choice between manual preformed mesh implants (MPIs) and patient-specific mesh implants (PSIs) for orbital reconstruction remains undetermined due to inconclusive evidence regarding their effectiveness. This retrospective study investigated 280 patients with unilateral orbital fractures to explore the correlation between clinical ocular symptoms, including diplopia, enophthalmos, limitation of ocular movement, blindness, and the specific type of orbital fracture. The effects on orbital volume (OV) and orbital volume ratio (OVR) of MPI and PSI with and without the use of navigation were also evaluated in this study. Patients were categorized into 4 groups: MPI, PSI, navigation-assisted MPI, and navigation-assisted PSI. After this categorization, alterations in OV and OVR were analyzed before and after surgical intervention. Significant correlations were observed between the orbital fracture type and diplopia, enophthalmos, and limitation of ocular movement (P < 0.05). Patients in the MPI group exhibited a notable difference in the postoperative OV between the injured and normal sides (P < 0.05), but no statistically significant difference was found in the postoperative OV between the injured and normal sides among the patients in the other 3 groups (P > 0.05). Moreover, the MPI group demonstrated significantly higher postoperative OVR than the other groups (P < 0.05). Notably, PSI remained effective with or without navigation, MPI combined with navigation technology achieved a reconstruction quality similar to that of PSI by rectifying positioning errors during surgery. The authors found significant correlations (P < 0.05) between orbital fracture type and diplopia, enophthalmos, and limitations of ocular movement. Patient-specific mesh implant plays an important role in orbital reconstruction. It is also a good method for reconstructing orbital fractures using MPI assisted by navigation technology.

Correlation between Orbital Computed Tomography Scan Measurements and Clinical Enophthalmos in Acute Isolated Orbital Floor Fractures

Abstract Purpose: To analyze the correlation between orbital computed tomography (CT) scan measurements including the fracture area (FA), the fracture location, the soft-tissue herniation volume (HV), the fractured orbital volume ratio (OVR) to the normal orbit, and the clinical enophthalmos in acute isolated orbital floor fractures. Methods: We enrolled 100 patients with acute isolated unilateral orbital floor fractures from May 2017 to January 2021. Based on the CT scan findings, we measured the FA, HV, OVR, and fracture site. We assessed enophthalmos using both clinical (CE) and radiographic (RE) measurements. Additionally, we investigated the correlation between CE and the measured parameters, along with the relationship between the pattern of diplopia and the fracture site. Results: We identified enophthalmos in 81% and diplopia in 78% of the patients with an acute blowout orbital floor fracture. CE was moderately correlated with the FA (R 2 = 0.4341, P &lt; 0.001). CE was weakly correlated with the HV (R 2 = 0.2861, P = 0.04). Anterior fractures caused diplopia in both vertical gazes, but posterior fractures were mostly associated with diplopia in the up gaze. OVR was strongly associated with RE (R 2 = 0.663, P &lt; 0.0001) and moderately associated with CE (R 2 = 0.4378, P &lt; 0.0001). The univariate regression analysis also showed that OVR could significantly predict CE and RE. Conclusions: OVR surpasses other CT scan measurements such as FA and HV in the prediction of clinical enophthalmos. Thus, OVR could be utilized to estimate clinical enophthalmos at the time of presentation, especially when the acute clinical setting prohibits the proper clinical evaluation.

Orbital wall restoration with primary bone fragments in complex orbital fractures.

Complex orbital fractures are impure orbital fractures because they involve the orbital walls and mid-facial bones. The author reported an orbital wall restoration technique in which the primary orbital wall fragments were restored to their prior position in complex orbital fractures in 2020. As a follow-up to a previous preliminary study, this study retrospectively reviewed the surgical results of complex orbital wall fractures over a 4-year period and compared the surgical outcomes by dividing them into groups with and without balloon restoration. Data of 939 patients with facial bone fractures between August 2018 and August 2022 were reviewed. Of these, 154 had complex orbital fractures. Among them, 44 and 110 underwent reduction with and without the balloon technique respectively. Pre- and postoperative Naugle exophthalmometer (Good-Lite Co.) scales were evaluated. The orbital volume and orbital volume ratio were calculated from preoperative and 6 months postoperative computed tomography images. Among 154 patients with complex orbital fractures, 44 patients underwent restoration with the balloon technique, and 110 patients underwent restoration without it. The Naugle scale did not differ significantly between the two groups, but the orbital volume ratio significantly decreased by 3.32% and 2.39% in groups with and without the balloon technique and the difference in OVR was significantly greater in patients in the balloon restoration group compared with the control group. Postoperative balloon rupture occurred in six out of 44 cases (13.64%). None of the six patients with balloon rupture showed significant enophthalmos at 6 months of follow-up. The balloon rupture rate was 13.64% (6/44 cases) with marginal screw fixation, blunt screws, and extra protection with a resorbable foam dressing. Furthermore, we restored the orbital wall with primary orbital fragments using balloon support in complex orbital wall fractures.

Difference of anterior and posterior orbital development in patients with congenital microphthalmia: a retrospective cohort study from China

To evaluate volume differences between anterior and posterior orbit and demographic characteristics of Chinese patients with congenital microphthalmia. A retrospective cohort study, involving 169 unilateral congenital microphthalmia patients aged between 1 and 57 years old was conducted. Three-dimensional images of the orbit were generated from past CT scans, and digital orbital volume comprehensive measurement was done. The measured data included orbital volume (OBV), posterior orbital volume (POV), orbital width (OBW), orbital height (OBH), orbital depth (OBD), and posterior orbital area ratio. Significant differences were observed among OBV, POV, OBW, OBH, and OBD of the affected and unaffected eyes in different age-based groups (all P<0.001). Among them, OBH had the greatest different. The mean microphthalmic to contralateral ratio (MCR) of OBV, POV, OBW, and OBH continuously increased from 1 to 3 years old, whereas the MCR of POV decreased from 3 to 17 years old. The MCR of OBD was not found to be correlated to age. There was no significant difference between OBV, POV, OBW, and OBH in ages from 13 years old to adulthood (all P>0.05). The difference in posterior orbital area ratio between the affected and unaffected groups was not statistically significant (P>0.05). OBH is maximally affected, whereas OBD is minimally affected by microphthalmia. Posterior orbital retardation began 2y prior to orbital retardation and occurred at 3 years old in the affected eye, suggesting that intervention therapy should be done before the age of 4.

Computer guided calvarial bone grafting for reconstruction of orbital floor blow out fracture.

Calvarial grafts represents a superior option for orbital floor reconstruction, however the difficulty of intraoperative moulding and placement remains as a major limitation. We used patient specific guides and sterolithographic models to facilitate this procedure. The study was conducted on 10 patients with orbital floor blow out fracture. A graft harvesting guide was virtually constructed based on the defect using mirroring of the normal side. The virtual guide and the defective orbital floor were then printed. The graft was harvested using the guide and adjusted to the defect using the model, finally seated in place. All patients showed no enophthalmos or diplopia. Orbital volume was comparable for both traumatised and normal orbits with no statistical significance difference (p value 0.28), and orbital volume ratio was 101.76±4.7%. The use of graft harvesting guide and orbital floor models for intraoperative graft moulding showed promising results.

Radiographic volumetric risk factors for late enophthalmos prediction in orbital blow-out fractures: A retrospective study

The aim of this study was to assess the correlation between volumetric risk factors, orbital volume (OV), orbital volume ratio (OVR), herniated volume (HV), and the newly described herniated volume ratio (HVR), with the occurrence of late enophthalmos.Patients presenting a unilateral unoperated blow-out fracture were retrospectively included. OV and HV were measured using planimetry on the initial CT scan images. OVR and HVR were then calculated. Enophthalmos was measured on the 2-month follow-up CT scan images. The population was divided into two groups according to their enophthalmos status. Correlations and multiple linear regression model were used.17 patients out of 45 presented a late enophthalmos of 1 mm or more. There were significantly higher OVR (107 (3.76); p < 0.0001), HV (0.8 (0.47); p < 0.0001) and HVR (3.3 (1.82); p < 0.0001) in the enophthalmos group. A very strong linear correlation between enophthalmos and OVR (rs = 0.806), HV (rs = 0.948) and HVR (rs = 0.951) was found.Enophthalmos prediction using these volumetric parameters can help the surgeon's decision-making in orbital blow-out fractures in order to prevent late enophthalmos. Measurement is simple and reproducible. However, larger prospective studies are needed to confirm these results.

Hand Posture Inversion Effect: Inverted and Individual Identification Paradigm

Blowout fractures are common in midfacial trauma and often involve other parts of facial bones. Sometimes, patients have complications caused by inadequate management. Surgical indications, such as clinical symptoms, can be inaccurate owing to post-traumatic swelling or hematoma formation. Previous studies on the prediction of enophthalmos used the orbital volume ratio (OVR) or only the volume of herniated tissue. This study examined which of these values is more predictive of the degree of enophthalmos. In addition, the predictive values for a 2-mm enophthalmos in unoperated blowout fractures were assessed.A total of 191 patients underwent nonoperative treatment for blowout fractures at our institution; they were divided into 2 groups according to the degree of enophthalmos (>2 mm vs 0 to 2 mm) and were further divided into 3 subgroups according to the location of the fracture (inferior, medial, or inferomedial). Multifactor logistic regression analysis was performed to determine the relationship between the degree of enophthalmos and these values.We observed a correlation between the OVR and the degree of enophthalmos, as well as a correlation between the volume of herniated tissue and the degree of enophthalmos. Regarding the anatomic location of herniation, the orbital floor was found to be more correlated with the amount of enophthalmos.The OVR is a more reliable predictor than measurement of the volume of herniated tissue. The relationship found between radiologic examination findings and the degree of enophthalmos can be used as a surgical indication in addition to consideration of the anatomic location.

Orbital volume, ophthalmic sequelae and severity in unilateral coronal synostosis

PurposeUnilateral coronal synostosis (UCS) results in an asymmetrical skull, including shallow and asymmetrical orbits, associated with reduced orbital volume and high prevalences of ophthalmic sequelae. Aim is to link orbital volumes in patients with UCS to severity according to UCSQ (Utrecht Cranial Shape Quantifier) and presence of ophthalmic sequelae.MethodsWe included preoperative patients with UCS (≤ 18 months). Orbital volume was measured on CT scans by manual segmentation (Mimics software (Materialise, Leuven, Belgium)), and severity of UCS was determined by UCSQ. Orbital volume of affected side was compared to unaffected side using Wilcoxon signed rank test. Orbital volume ratio was calculated (affected/unaffected volume) and compared to the category of UCSQ by Kruskal-Wallis test. Opthalmic sequelae were noted.ResultsWe included 19 patients (mean age 7 months). Orbital volume on affected side was significantly lower (p = 0.001), mean orbital volume ratio was 0.93 (SD 0.03). No significant differences in group means of orbital volume ratio between different levels of severity of UCSQ were found (Kruskal-Wallis H (2) = 0.873; p > 0.05). Ophthalmic sequelae were found in 3 patients; one had adduction impairment and strabismus (mild UCS), one had astigmatism (moderate UCS), and one had abduction impairment (on both ipsi- and contralateral side) and vertical strabismus (severe UCS).ConclusionNo association between orbital volume ratio and severity of UCS was found. Side-to-side asymmetry in orbital volume was noted. No association between either preoperative orbital volume ratio or severity of UCS and the presence of preoperative ophthalmic sequelae was found.

Orbital wall restoration with primary bone fragments in complex orbital fractures: A preliminary study.

Background We have reported orbital wall restoration surgery with primary orbital wall fragment in pure blowout fractures using a combination of transorbital and transnasal approach in pure blow out fractures. However, this method was thought to be difficult to use for complex orbital wall fractures, since the sharp screw tip that fixate the maxillary wall increases the risk of balloon ruptures. In this study, we reviewed 23 cases of complex orbital fractures that underwent orbital wall restoration surgery with primary orbital wall fragment and evaluated the result.Methods A retrospective review was conducted of 23 patients with complex orbital fracture who underwent orbital restoration surgery with primary orbital wall fragments between 2012 and 2019. The patients underwent orbital wall restoration surgery with primary orbital wall fragment with temporary balloon support. The surgical results were evaluated by the Naugle scale and a comparison of preoperative and postoperative orbital volume ratio. Complex fracture type, type of screw used for fixation and complications such as balloon rupture were also investigated.Results There were 23 patients with complex orbital fracture that used transnasal balloon technique for restoration. 17 cases had a successful outcome with no complications, three patients had postoperative balloon rupture, two patients had soft-tissue infection, and one patient had balloon malposition.Conclusion The orbital wall restoration technique with temporary balloon support can produce favorable results when done correctly even in complex orbital wall fracture. Seventeen cases had favorable results, six cases had postoperative complications thus additional procedure seems necessary to complement this method.

Natural Course of Mild Graves Orbitopathy: Increase of Orbital Fat But Decrease of Muscle Volume With Increased Muscle Fatty Degeneration During a 4-Year Follow-Up.

To describe the natural course of orbital fat volume and extraocular muscle volume in mild Graves orbitopathy during a 4-year follow-up. To describe fatty changes within the extraocular muscles. Twenty-five patients with mild Graves orbitopathy, who did not require any therapeutic intervention other than supportive therapy, were followed for 4 years. CT scans were performed in all patients at baseline and follow-up. A validated technique using Mimics (Materialise) was used to calculate fat and muscle volumes. Outcomes were compared with previously collected data. The amount of intramuscular fat was assessed on CT scans in a semi-quantitative way by two blinded observers according to a four-point scale. After a median follow-up of 4.3 years, the median fat to orbital volume ratio increased with 0.08 from 0.57 to 0.65 (p = 0.000), whereas the median muscle volume to orbital volume ratio decreased with 0.03 from 0.17 to 0.14 (p = 0.000). In this control group in patients between 49 and 54 years old, the changes were 0.01 and -0.002, respectively. The Clinical Activity Score decreased to zero (p = 0.000), and the median eyelid aperture decreased from 12 to 10 mm (p = 0.007). A significant increase of intramuscular fat was found in patients with Graves orbitopathy. The natural course of mild Graves orbitopathy, as observed over 4 years, is characterized by an increase of orbital fat volume, a decrease in muscle volume, and an increased intramuscular fatty degeneration.

Choroidal volume changes following blow-out fracture repair.

To investigate the serial choroidal volume change following orbital blow-out fracture (BOF) repair. The choroidal volume was measured by optical coherence tomography in patients who underwent BOF repair, preoperatively and postoperatively at 1, 4, 12 and 24weeks. The orbital volume ratio (OVR) was obtained by dividing the orbital volume of the traumatized orbit by that of the contralateral side using three-dimensional computed tomography imaging. The choroidal volume change was compared between both eyes using a linear mixed model. We analyzed the choroidal volume of 11 patients. Choroidal volume showed a trend of slight increase during the immediate postoperative period, and then, choroidal volume decreased abruptly between postoperative 1 to 4weeks (β-coefficient - 0.22, P < 0.001). Choroidal volume also showed gradual decrease between postoperative 4 to 24weeks (β-coefficient - 0.02, P < 0.001). During the study period, there were no significant differences in choroidal volume change between BOF and contralateral unaffected eyes (β-coefficient - 0.20, P = 0.711). The hyperopic refractive errors (β-coefficient 0.27, P = 0.028) and the larger preoperative OVR (β-coefficient 10.37, P = 0.013) were associated with larger choroidal volume. Choroidal volume showed a similar decreasing change following BOF repair between the BOF and the contralateral unaffected eyes. Moreover, choroidal volume of both eyes was associated with the degree of orbital volume expansion due to BOF, suggesting that choroidal volume change after BOF repair was affected not only by trauma-associated local hemodynamic changes but also by systemic influences such as inflammatory response.

Orbital wall restoring surgery with resorbable mesh plate.

BackgroundOrbital resorbable mesh plates are adequate to use for isolated floor and medial wall fractures with an intact bony buttress, but are not recommended to use for large orbital wall fractures that need load bearing support. The author previously reported an orbital wall restoring surgery that restored the orbital floor to its prior position through the transnasal approach and maintained temporary extraorbital support with a balloon in the maxillary sinus. Extraorbital support could reduce the load applied on the orbital implants in orbital wall restoring surgery and the use of resorbable implants was considered appropriate for the author’s orbital wall restoring technique.MethodsA retrospective review was conducted of 31 patients with pure unilateral orbital floor fractures between May 2014 and May 2018. The patients underwent transnasal restoration of the orbital floor through insertion of a resorbable mesh plate and maintenance of temporary balloon support. The surgical results were evaluated by the Hertel scale and a comparison of preoperative and postoperative orbital volume ratio (OVR) values.ResultsThe OVR decreased significantly, by an average of 6.01% (p< 0.05) and the preoperative and postoperative Hertel scale measurements decreased by an average of 0.34 mm with statistical significance (p< 0.05). No complications such as buckling or sagging of the implant occurred among the 31 patients.ConclusionThe use of resorbable mesh plate in orbital floor restoration surgery is an effective and safe technique that can reduce implant deformation or complications deriving from the residual permanent implant.

3-Dimensional Volumetric Analysis of Relationship Between the Orbital Volume Ratio and Enophthalmos in Unoperated Blowout Fractures

Blowout fractures are common in midfacial trauma and often involve other parts of facial bones. Sometimes, patients have complications caused by inadequate management. Surgical indications, such as clinical symptoms, can be inaccurate owing to post-traumatic swelling or hematoma formation. Previous studies on the prediction of enophthalmos used the orbital volume ratio (OVR) or only the volume of herniated tissue. This study examined which of these values is more predictive of the degree of enophthalmos. In addition, the predictive values for a 2-mm enophthalmos in unoperated blowout fractures were assessed. A total of 191 patients underwent nonoperative treatment for blowout fractures at our institution; they were divided into 2 groups according to the degree of enophthalmos (>2mm vs 0 to 2mm) and were further divided into 3 subgroups according to the location of the fracture (inferior, medial, or inferomedial). Multifactor logistic regression analysis was performed to determine the relationship between the degree of enophthalmos and these values. We observed a correlation between the OVR and the degree of enophthalmos, as well as a correlation between the volume of herniated tissue and the degree of enophthalmos. Regarding the anatomic location of herniation, the orbital floor was found to be more correlated with the amount of enophthalmos. The OVR is a more reliable predictor than measurement of the volume of herniated tissue. The relationship found between radiologic examination findings and the degree of enophthalmos can be used as a surgical indication in addition to consideration of the anatomic location.

Patient-specific puzzle implant preformed with 3D-printed rapid prototype model for combined orbital floor and medial wall fracture

The management of combined orbital floor and medial wall fractures involving the inferomedial strut is challenging due to absence of stable cornerstone. In this article, we proposed surgical strategies using customized 3D puzzle implant preformed with Rapid Prototype (RP) skull model. Retrospective review was done in 28 patients diagnosed with combined orbital floor and medial wall fracture. Using preoperative CT scans, original and mirror-imaged RP skull models for each patient were prepared and sterilized. In all patients, porous polyethylene-coated titanium mesh was premolded onto RP skull model in two ways; Customized 3D jigsaw puzzle technique was used in 15 patients with comminuted inferomedial strut, whereas individual 3D implant technique was used in each fracture for 13 patients with intact inferomedial strut. Outcomes including enophthalmos, visual acuity, and presence of diplopia were assessed and orbital volume was measured using OsiriX software preoperatively and postoperatively. Satisfactory results were achieved in both groups in terms of clinical improvements. Of 10 patients with preoperative diplopia, 9 improved in 6 months, except one with persistent symptom who underwent extraocular muscle rupture. 18 patients who had moderate to severe enophthalmos preoperatively improved, and one remained with mild degree. Orbital volume ratio, defined as volumetric ratio between affected and control orbit, decreased from 127.6% to 99.79% (p < 0.05) in comminuted group, and that in intact group decreased from 117.03% to 101.3% (p < 0.05). Our surgical strategies using the jigsaw puzzle and individual reconstruction technique provide accurate restoration of combined orbital floor and medial wall fractures.

Prediction of Late Enophthalmos Using Preoperative Orbital Volume and Fracture Area Measurements in Blowout Fracture.

Enophthalmos caused by orbital volume expansion is the traditional indication for blowout fracture operation, but it may not appear immediately after orbital trauma due to periorbital swelling. The purpose of this study was to investigate the correlations of the orbital volume ratio (OVR) and, orbital fracture area (OFA) with the late enophthalmos measurement in unilateral pure blowout fracture. Seventy-two patients who had experienced a blowout fracture were divided into 2 groups, the conservative treatment group (n = 40) and the operative treatment group (n = 32). The authors measured the preoperative OVR and OFA using three-dimensional facial bone computed tomography and investigated their relationship with late enophthalmos that obtained 6 months after orbital trauma. In both conservative and operative groups, there were significant positive correlations between the OVR and OFA (P < 0.05). In the conservative group, both the OVR and OFA showed significant positive correlations with late enophthalmos, but the OVR (r = 0.777) was more closely correlated with enophthalmos than the OFA (r = 0.739). Quantitative measurements of OVR and OFA are useful parameters that can predict the extent of late enophthalmos and are useful in planning the treatment of blowout fracture.

The Correlation between the Orbital Volume Ratio and Enophthalmos in Unoperated Blowout Fractures.

BackgroundEnophthalmos may not appear immediately after trauma due to periorbital swelling in a blowout fracture, and preoperative measurements of enophthalmos cannot be used as a reliable guideline. It is important to predict the eventual final extent of enophthalmos in order to determine whether to perform surgery, and there have been several attempts to predict the degree of late enophthalmos using preoperative orbital volume. The purpose of this study is to investigate the correlation between the orbital volume ratio (OVR) with final enophthalmos and the palpebral fissure, and to find the OVR that induced 2 mm of enophthalmos in unilateral unoperated blowout fractures.MethodsWe retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 38 patients and divided them into 3 groups, determined by the fracture location. The relationships between the OVR and both the degree of enophthalmos and the palpebral fissure ratio (PFR) were assessed and, in particular, the OVR that induced 2 mm of enophthalmos was sought.ResultsEnophthalmos increased in proportion to the OVR, and there was a highly significant correlation between the increase in the OVR and the degree of enophthalmos (P<0.05). On the other hand, there was no correlation between OVR and PFR (P>0.05). The OVR that induced 2-mm enophthalmos was 112.18%.ConclusionsThe final degree of enophthalmos can be estimated by the preoperative measurement of OVR. Preoperative measurements of OVR can be used as quantitative values to predict the final degree of enophthalmos in pure blowout fractures.

Application of Rapid Prototyping Technique and Intraoperative Navigation System for the Repair and Reconstruction of Orbital Wall Fractures.

BackgroundRestoring the orbital cavity in large blow out fractures is a challenge for surgeons due to the anatomical complexity. This study evaluated the clinical outcomes and orbital volume after orbital wall fracture repair using a rapid prototyping (RP) technique and intraoperative navigation system.MethodsThis prospective study was conducted on the medical records and radiology records of 12 patients who had undergone a unilateral blow out fracture reconstruction using a RP technique and an intraoperative navigation system from November 2014 to March 2015. The surgical results were assessed by an ophthalmic examination and a comparison of the preoperative and postoperative orbital volume ratio (OVR) values.ResultsAll patients had a successful treatment outcome without complications. Volumetric analysis revealed a significant decrease in the mean OVR from 1.0952±0.0662 (ranging from 0.9917 to 1.2509) preoperatively to 0.9942±0.0427 (ranging from 0.9394 to 1.0680) postoperatively.ConclusionThe application of a RP technique for the repair of orbital wall fractures is a useful tool that may help improve the clinical outcomes by understanding the individual anatomy, determining the operability, and restoring the orbital cavity volume through optimal implant positioning along with an intraoperative navigation system.

Orbital Wall Restoring Surgery for Inferomedial Blowout Fracture

Repairing a large inferomedial blowout fracture remains a challenge to orbital surgeon. The authors restored the fracture using combined transnasal and transorbital approaches using support of both paranasal sinuses. The authors compared surgical results of this novel method with those of the traditional procedure. Of 106 inferomedial blowout fracture patients who underwent surgical treatment between March 2007 and July 2013, 50 patients were selected in our study: 25 patients underwent the traditional procedure as controls, and the other 25 patients underwent orbital wall restoring surgery by our combined approach. Outcomes were evaluated in terms of the orbital volume ratio (OVR) and changes in Hertel scale. The OVR in the experimental group (7.19%) decreased more significantly than in the control group (2.71%) (P < 0.05). In conclusion, the orbit was restored more successfully following orbital wall restoring surgery with dual support than by using the traditional inferomedial blowout fracture procedure.

Orbital wall restoring surgery in pure blowout fractures.

BackgroundRestoring orbital volume in large blowout fractures is still a technically challenge to the orbital surgeon. In this study, we restored the orbital wall using the combination of transorbital and transnasal approach with additional supports from the paranasal sinuses, and we compared the surgical outcome to that of a conventional transorbital method.MethodsA retrospective review of all patients with pure unilateral blowout fractures between March 2007 and March 2013 was conducted. 150 patients were classified into two groups according to the surgical method: conventional transorbital method (group A, 75 patients, control group), and the combination of transorbital and transnasal approach with additional supports from the paranasal sinuses (group B, 75 patients, experimental group). Each group was subdivided depending on fracture location: group I (inferior wall), group IM (inferomedial wall), and group M (medial wall). The surgical results were assessed by the Hertel scale and a comparison of preoperative and postoperative orbital volume ratio (OVR) values.ResultsIn the volumetric analysis, the OVR decreased more by the experimental groups than each corresponding control groups (P<0.05). Upon ophthalmic examination, neither the differences among the groups in the perioperative Hertel scale nor the preoperative and postoperative Hertel scales were statistically significant (P>0.05).ConclusionsOur surgical results suggest that orbital volume was more effectively restored by the combination of transorbital and transnasal approach with additional supports from the paranasal sinuses than the conventional method, regardless of the type of fracture.

Change of the Orbital Volume Ratio in Pure Blow-out Fractures Depending on Fracture Location

The purposes of this study were to observe bony orbital volume (OV) changes in pure blow-out fractures according to fracture location using a facial computed tomographic scan and to investigate whether the OV measurements can be used as a quantitative value for the evaluation of the surgical results of the acute blow-out fracture.Forty-five patients with unilateral pure blow-out fracture were divided into 3 groups: inferior (group I), inferior medial (group IM), and medial (group M) orbital wall fracture. The OV and the orbital volume ratio (OVR) were prospectively measured before and 6 months after surgery with the use of 3-dimensional computed tomographic scans, and the Hertel scale was measured with a Hertel exothalmometer.The preoperative OVR increased to the greatest extent in group IM, and the mean preoperative OVR was 121.46. The mean preoperative OVR in group I was significantly higher than that of group M (P = 0.005). The OV and OVR revealed a statistically significant decrease after the surgery (P = 0.000). The Hertel scale improved from -1.04 mm before the surgery to -0.78 mm after the surgery, but no significant difference was observed (P = 0.051).The OVR was useful as a quantitative value to evaluate pure blow-out fractures, compared with that of the Hertel scale. Fracture location-associated OVR studies are needed to make volume guidelines of blow-out fracture surgery.