In this study, the variant effects of alumina and graphene reinforcing nanoparticle percentages on the tensile and wear properties of the nanocomposites, produced using digital light processing (DLP), were determined by employing SEM images of fracture and worn surfaces to introduce a hybrid (alumina + graphene)/PLA nanocomposite with desirable wear and mechanical properties. With the addition of alumina up to 2 wt%, the tensile strength was initially decreased exhibiting a rapid brittle fracture over the flat fracture surface. However, with a continued increase in the amount of reinforcing particles, the tensile strength eventually increased by 16% compared to the pure resin sample at 8 wt% of alumina while changing the fracture mode with plenty of cleavages accompanied by crack deflections. The specific wear rate in the 8 wt% alumina sample decreased by almost 62% compared to the pure resin sample. Graphene caused a significant drop in tensile strength due to the generation of cavities and porosities around the graphene agglomerates, but it greatly improved the wear properties, with the specific wear rate decreasing by almost 77% at just 1 wt%. Then hybrid nanocomposites of alumina and graphene reinforcements were produced with the aim of optimal tensile and wear properties. The 0.5% graphene +3.5% alumina improved the wear resistance and provided moderate tensile properties; however, the 1% graphene +3% alumina could not increase the wear resistance due to the weakening of graphene plates sticking to the polymer substrate.