The production of recombinant enzymes, primarily used for obtaining pure and functional target molecules, holds significant importance in modern biotechnology. This study aimed to obtain and characterize recombinant, extracellularly expressed α-amylases (Amy3500 and Amy1974), derived from B. amyloliquefaciens MDC1974 and B. subtilis MDC3500, respectively, using the pBE-S shuttle vector. Both α-amylase genes were molecularly cloned into the E. coli/B. subtilis pBE-S shuttle vector, both with (Amy1974sig and Amy3500sig) and without their signal peptides (Amy1974 and Amy3500), along with a signal peptide originating from the plasmid, and tested in flask fermentations. For recombinant Amy3500, the amylase variants resulted in similar levels of volumetric activity (700–750 U/mL). In contrast, the expression of Amy1974 nearly doubled compared to Amy1974sig with double signal peptides, reaching 2000 U/mL. SDS-PAGE estimated the molecular weight of Amy1974 α-amylase to be 54.6 kDa, which is consistent with the theoretical molecular mass calculations. However, the estimated molecular weight of Amy3500 α-amylase was significantly lower upon exiting the producer cells. Ca2⁺ ions exhibit a modest activating effect on the activities of Amy1974 and Amy3500 amylases, likely due to their tight binding to the protein scaffold. Both enzymes exhibited broad activity peaks between 45 and 70 °C, with a maximum at 65 °C. The Amy1974 and Amy3500 α-amylases demonstrated broad pH optima and pH-dependent thermostability, with optimum pH values at 6.5 and 5.8, and thermal stability peaks at pH 7.6 and 5.9, respectively. Both α-amylases displayed high relative activity against various starches, including corn amylopectin and potato amylose, while showing comparatively lower activity towards α-, β-, and γ-cyclodextrins. The Amy1974 amylase is effective in converting starch into dextrins of varying lengths, while Amy3500 primarily converts starch into glucose. These characteristics make them promising candidate enzymes for industrial applications.