Open Marsh Water Management Research Articles

The evolution of saltmarsh mosquito control water management practices relative to coastal resiliency in the Mid-Atlantic and northeastern United States

Salt marshes are dynamic ecosystems that change in response to local geographic and geologic factors as well as sea level changes. Most east coast salt marshes are the result of rising sea levels since the end of the last ice age, about 20,000 ybp. To compound this natural process, anthropogenic manipulations for farming, development and other purposes have occurred for centuries. Alterations to salt marshes for the purpose of controlling larval mosquitoes at their source, at least along the east coast of the United States, have occurred since the early twentieth century. These alterations have included large-scale manipulations such as extensive parallel grid-ditching and impounding. Within the last 50 years, more selective source reduction methods such as Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) have been employed with fewer deleterious impacts to marsh resources. Even more recently, the more holistic approach of Integrated Marsh Management (IMM) has been used with considerable success particularly in the northeastern and Mid-Atlantic states. IMM not only uses OMWM techniques but incorporates the judicious use of mosquito control pesticides, tidal flow restoration, impoundment management, wildlife habitat enhancement, invasive plant control, and selective shallow ditching (“runneling”) depending on local conditions and management plans. As many marshes are becoming wetter and either drowning or migrating inland (where possible) due to the effects of increasing rates of sea level rise, the compounding long-term impacts of parallel grid-ditching and past manipulations on marsh surface elevation and hydrology are being more intently studied. These changes in saltmarsh dynamics have had and will continue to have impacts on where saltmarsh mosquitoes are produced, which could have corollary effects on public health and quality of life near coastal communities. As salt marshes continue to change, mosquito control agencies can play a significant role in providing input for salt marsh restoration and management in addition to their primary objective of vector control and enhancing quality of life.

An Australian form of Open Marsh Water Management (runnelling): long term monitoring, ancillary and extended research

The paper outlines the evolution of an Australian form of Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) called runnelling which was implemented in relatively pristine saltmarshes. Runnelling involves shallow channels and was distinguished from OMWM which involves ditching. Both methods aim to conserve tidal hydrology. The core research covers 28 years of research on the original experimental site (Coomera Island, Queensland), in routine monitoring and impact assessments that were made periodically. It also introduces and incorporates information from associated research. This includes effects of runnelling on non-target aspects—snails and crabs. Emerging issues during the course of the longer-term research included the risk of mobilising acid sulfates and of mangrove encroachment into the saltmarsh. As well, use of the data was extended to retrofit it to address broader questions about saltmarsh processes and how to identify them. That identified progressive changes at the Coomera site, and so a further query was whether the system showed signs of approaching a tipping point. In summary, there were some identifiable effects of runnelling in all parts of the research. These were mostly related to the increased wetness near runnels, as flooding by tides would occur at tides up to 0.30 m lower than the pre-runnelling situation. The increased wetness was related to plants, snails and crabs. From a mosquito management perspective the method was successful. From an environmental perspective the environmental changes were only very close to runnels (within 10 m). The overall changes at the experimental site were consistent with other changes in eastern Australia, especially of mangrove encroachment into saltmarshes. Once the runnelling method appeared to manage mosquitoes without damaging wetland values it was adopted widely throughout south east Queensland, encouraged by the positive attitude of permitting agencies, but longer-term evaluation was hindered by lack of relevant records.

Drainage enhancement effects on a waterlogged Rhode Island (USA) salt marsh

Drainage enhancement (e.g., ditch digging, open-marsh water management, runnelling) has long been used to reduce tidal marsh soil waterlogging and surface ponding to promote salt hay production and mosquito control. Now it is also being used as a tool to enhance marsh resilience to sea-level rise despite a lack of studies that evaluate its effectiveness as an intervention approach. We therefore conducted a controlled field experiment to evaluate short-term responses to drainage enhancement of a Rhode Island (USA) salt marsh. Drainage enhancement elicited rapid physical changes in portions of the marsh including declines in water levels and marsh elevation, but the biological components examined (e.g., vegetation and bird community composition) were largely unaffected. In two of the four areas monitored, marsh surface inundation duration declined from >75% to 3–10% and low water levels dropped by 20 cm. Mean annual marsh surface elevation in monitoring plots increased 5 mm one year after drainage enhancement but dropped to 11 mm below initial conditions after three years. The decline in elevation varied among habitats, with the greatest decline (18 mm) found in areas dominated by Spartina alterniflora and/or bare ground. Vegetation community composition and % cover and heights of dominant species were unchanged, but areas that were initially bare had fully revegetated after three years. Drainage enhancement also had no effects on bird community composition or marsh sparrow (Ammodramus spp.) density. Our study provides evidence that drainage enhancement can relieve waterlogging and some of its impacts without any apparent adverse effects on the composition and abundance of existing vegetation and bird communities. At the same time, it can induce a loss of marsh platform elevation that has the potential to offset declining water levels and inhibit high marsh enhancement. Finally, unanticipated findings from our study provide evidence that the effects of larger-scale drivers such as sea-level rise may predominate over localized responses to drainage enhancement itself.

Assessment of Plant Community Characteristics in Natural and Human-Altered Coastal Marsh Ecosystems

Salt marsh ecosystems provide many critical ecological functions, yet they are subject to considerable disturbance ranging from direct human alteration to increased inundation due to climate change. We assessed emergent salt marsh plant characteristics in the Tuckerton Peninsula, a large expanse (~ 2000 ha) of highly inundated habitat along the southern New Jersey coast, USA. Key salt marsh plant parameters were monitored in the heavily grid-ditched northern segment, Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) altered central segment, and the shoreline altered southern segment of the peninsula in the summer months of 2011 and 2013. Plant species composition and three metrics of abundance and structure (maximum canopy height, percent areal cover, and shoot density) were examined among marsh segments, along transects within segments, seasonally by month and between years. Despite seasonal or annual variability, the northern segment of the marsh differed in plant species composition from the central and southern segments. This difference was partly due to greater percent areal cover in the northern segment of upper marsh species such as Spartina patens and Distichlis spicata. S. patens also exhibited higher shoot densities in the northern segment than the central segment. Despite the higher abundance of upper marsh species, marsh surface elevations were lower in the northern segment than in the central or southern segments, suggesting the influence of altered hydrology due to human activities. Understanding current variation in the emergent salt marsh vegetation along the peninsula will help inform future habitat change in other coastal wetlands of New Jersey and the mid-Atlantic region subject to natural and anthropogenic drivers.

Carbon Sequestration in Tidal Salt Marshes of the Northeast United States.

Tidal salt marshes provide important ecological services, habitat, disturbance regulation, water quality improvement, and biodiversity, as well as accumulation and sequestration of carbon dioxide (CO2) in vegetation and soil organic matter. Different management practices may alter their capacity to provide these ecosystem services. We examined soil properties (bulk density, percent organic C, percent N), C and N pools, C sequestration and N accumulation at four marshes managed with open marsh water management (OMWM) and four marshes that were not at U.S. Fish and Wildlife National Wildlife Refuges (NWRs) on the East Coast of the United States. Soil properties (bulk density, percent organic C, percent N) exhibited no consistent differences among managed and non-OMWM marshes. Soil organic carbon pools (0-60-cm depth) also did not differ. Managed marshes contained 15.9 kg C/m(2) compared to 16.2 kg C/m(2) in non-OMWM marshes. Proportionately, more C (per unit volume) was stored in surface than in subsurface soils. The rate of C sequestration, based on (137)Cs and (210)Pb dating of soil cores, ranged from 41 to 152 g/m(2)/year. Because of the low emissions of CH4 from salt marshes relative to freshwater wetlands and the ability to sequester C in soil, protection and restoration of salt marshes can be a vital tool for delivering key ecosystem services, while at the same time, reducing the C footprint associated with managing these wetlands.

The Effects of Integrated Marsh Management (IMM) on Salt Marsh Vegetation, Nekton, and Birds

An integrated marsh management (IMM) project in an urbanized watershed on Long Island, New York, USA, aimed to mitigate salt marsh degradation and to reduce mosquito production by an innovative combination of restoration and open marsh water management methods. The grid ditch network at two treatment marshes was replaced with naturalized tidal channels and ponds. Effects of the hydrologic alterations were monitored utilizing a before–after–control–impact approach. The treatment marshes experienced a number of beneficial outcomes including a fourfold reduction in the invasive Phragmites australis and increased native vegetation cover in the most degraded portions of the marsh, increased abundance and diversity of marsh killifish and estuarine nekton species, higher shorebird and waterfowl densities, and increased avian species diversity. The successful implementation of IMM concept led to improved marsh health and diminished mosquito production. Therefore, this study may serve as a template for similar large-scale integrated salt marsh restoration projects.

Responses of Salt Marsh Ecosystems to Mosquito Control Management Practices along the Atlantic Coast (U.S.A.)

Open marsh water management (OMWM) of salt marshes modifies grid‐ditched marshes by creating permanent ponds and radial ditches in the high marsh that reduce mosquito production and enhance fish predation on mosquitoes. It is preferable to using pesticides to control salt marsh mosquito production and is commonly presented as a restoration or habitat enhancement tool for grid‐ditched salt marshes. Monitoring of nekton, vegetation, groundwater level, soil salinity, and bird communities before and after OMWM at 11 (six treatment and five reference sites) Atlantic Coast (U.S.A.) salt marshes revealed high variability within and among differing OMWM techniques (ditch‐plugging, reengineering of sill ditches, and the creation of ponds and radial ditches). At three marshes, the dominant nekton shifted from fish (primarily Fundulidae species) to shrimp (Palaemonidae species) after manipulations and shrimp density increased at other treatment sites. Vegetation changed at only two sites, one with construction equipment impacts (not desired) and one with a decrease in woody vegetation along existing ditches (desired). One marsh had lower groundwater level and soil salinity, and bird use, although variable, was often unrelated to OMWM manipulations. The potential effects of OMWM manipulations on non‐target salt marsh resources need to be carefully considered by resource planners when managing marshes for mosquito control.

Effects of Open Marsh Water Management on the Reproductive Success and Nesting Ecology of Seaside Sparrows in Tidal Marshes

Open marsh water management (OMWM), a method of mosquito reduction through habitat alteration, is widely practiced in Mid-Atlantic salt marshes. The effect of these habitat modifications on obligate salt marsh breeding birds is poorly understood. The present study was conducted to quantify the extent of OMWM and determine if the technique affected Seaside Sparrow (Ammodramus maritimus) reproductive success and nesting ecology. Seaside Sparrow territory density, nest density, nest survival, productivity and vegetation cover was estimated on 19 plots (1–3 ha) within tidal marshes in Sussex County, Delaware in May–August 2006–2007. Plots were characterized as limited (N = 10) or extensive OMWM (N = 9) based on the amount of alterations and time since manipulations. Seaside Sparrow territory density and nest density were two times greater on limited OMWM plots than extensive OMWM plots. Also, the number of Seaside Sparrow eggs/ha and fledglings/ha were greater on limited OMWM plots. Seaside Sparrow nest survival rates did not differ between limited and extensive OMWM plots, but reproductive output (# nests/ha, eggs/ha, and fledglings/ha) was greater on areas with limited OMWM. OMWM may be an alternative means of mosquito control but should not be considered a method of habitat enhancement for Seaside Sparrows and possibly other obligate salt marsh bird species.

Effects of Open Marsh Water Management on Numbers of Larval Salt Marsh Mosquitoes

Open marsh water management (OMWM) is a commonly used approach to manage salt marsh mosquitoes than can obviate the need for pesticide application and at the same time, partially restore natural functions of grid-ditched marshes. OMWM includes a variety of hydrologic manipulations, often tailored to the specific conditions on individual marshes, so the overall effectiveness of this approach is difficult to assess. Here, we report the results of controlled field trials to assess the effects of two approaches to OMWM on larval mosquito production at National Wildlife Refuges (NWR). A traditional OMWM approach, using pond construction and radial ditches was used at Edwin B. Forsythe NWR in New Jersey, and a ditch-plugging approach was used at Parker River NWR in Massachusetts. Mosquito larvae were sampled from randomly placed stations on paired treatment and control marshes at each refuge. The proportion of sampling stations that were wet declined after OMWM at the Forsythe site, but not at the Parker River site. The proportion of samples with larvae present and mean larval densities, declined significantly at the treatment sites on both refuges relative to the control marshes. Percentage of control for the 2 yr posttreatment, compared with the 2 yr pretreatment, was >90% at both treatment sites.

Geostatistical evaluation of integrated marsh management impact on mosquito vectors using before-after-control-impact (BACI) design

BackgroundIn many parts of the world, salt marshes play a key ecological role as the interface between the marine and the terrestrial environments. Salt marshes are also exceedingly important for public health as larval habitat for mosquitoes that are vectors of disease and significant biting pests. Although grid ditching and pesticides have been effective in salt marsh mosquito control, marsh degradation and other environmental considerations compel a different approach. Targeted habitat modification and biological control methods known as Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) had been proposed as a viable alternative to marsh-wide physical alterations and chemical control. However, traditional larval sampling techniques may not adequately assess the impacts of marsh management on mosquito larvae. To assess the effectiveness of integrated OMWM and marsh restoration techniques for mosquito control, we analyzed the results of a 5-year OMWM/marsh restoration project to determine changes in mosquito larval production using GIS and geostatistical methods.MethodsThe following parameters were evaluated using "Before-After-Control-Impact" (BACI) design: frequency and geographic extent of larval production, intensity of larval production, changes in larval habitat, and number of larvicide applications. The analyses were performed using Moran's I, Getis-Ord, and Spatial Scan statistics on aggregated before and after data as well as data collected over time. This allowed comparison of control and treatment areas to identify changes attributable to the OMWM/marsh restoration modifications.ResultsThe frequency of finding mosquito larvae in the treatment areas was reduced by 70% resulting in a loss of spatial larval clusters compared to those found in the control areas. This effect was observed directly following OMWM treatment and remained significant throughout the study period. The greatly reduced frequency of finding larvae in the treatment areas led to a significant decrease (~44%) in the number of times when the larviciding threshold was reached. This reduction, in turn, resulted in a significant decrease (~74%) in the number of larvicide applications in the treatment areas post-project. The remaining larval habitat in the treatment areas had a different geographic distribution and was largely confined to the restored marsh surface (i.e. filled-in mosquito ditches); however only ~21% of the restored marsh surface supported mosquito production.ConclusionThe geostatistical analysis showed that OMWM demonstrated considerable potential for effective mosquito control and compatibility with other natural resource management goals such as restoration, wildlife habitat enhancement, and invasive species abatement. GPS and GIS tools are invaluable for large scale project design, data collection, and data analysis, with geostatistical methods serving as an alternative or a supplement to the conventional inference statistics in evaluating the project outcome.

Managing Salt Marshes for Mosquito Control: Impacts of Runnelling, Open Marsh Water Management and Grid-ditching in Sub-tropical Australia

Three salt marsh sites in south-east Queensland, Australia, have been modified for mosquito control. The problem species is Ochlerotatus vigilax, a vector of Ross River virus that is an epidemic polyarthritic disease. All sites have similar vegetation and tidal influences. Each site has a different form of modification to manage the mosquitoes: runnelling, Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) and grid-ditching. Results are compared of a treatment and control experimental design, similar for each site, but analysed separately for each site, and over the same 3-year time period. Environmental variables monitored included: for the water table, the depth, salinity and pH; for the substrate, its moisture, salinity and pH; for the vegetation, the size and density of the dominant grass (Sporobolus virginicus) and the number of mangrove (Avicennia marina) pneumatophores. Crab activity was indicated by crab hole numbers. ANOVA analyses, comparing treatment and control at each site, indicated that runnelling had the least significant impact on the environmental variables, whereas most impacts were at the grid-ditched site. Of the 10 variables included here, 5 were affected by runnelling, 7 by OMWM and 9 by grid-ditching. Statistically significant results are summarised, compared to the relevant controls, as follows: Water table: the level was significantly higher near ditches in the grid-ditched site; pH was higher at the treatment in the OMWM site but was lower in the grid-ditched site; salinity was significantly lower in the runnelled and in part of the grid-ditched marsh. Substrate: the moisture was higher at both the OMWM and grid-ditched sites; pH was higher in the OMWM treatment but lower in the grid-ditched marsh; salinity was significantly lower at the runnelled and grid-ditched sites, but was higher near the ditch at the OMWM site. Vegetation and crabs: The grass Sporobolus virginicus was less dense in the treatments in both the OMWM and grid-ditched sites, but was taller in the runnelled site and in part of the grid-ditched site. There were fewer mangrove pneumatophores in the runnelled area, but more in the OMWM one. There was more crab activity in both the runnelled and OMWM sites. It was concluded that runnelling has least impact and that grid-ditching has the most, but that none of these appears to have destroyed the marsh environment.

Does habitat modification affect oviposition by the salt marsh mosquito, Ochlerotatus vigilax (Skuse) (Diptera: Culicidae)?

Studies were conducted at sites in south-east Queensland, Australia, to investigate the effect of habitat modification for mosquito control on the distribution of eggshells of the salt marsh mosquito, Ochlerotatus vigilax (Skuse). Modifications were mainly runnelling, but an Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) site and a grid-ditched site were also included. There were two separate experimental designs: one was data collected Before and After (BA) modification and the other was for other sites with a Treatment and Control (TC) experimental design. For the BA data, there were significant reductions in eggshells after modification. Eggshells were generally fewer after modification in areas which were close to unrestricted tidal flushing. A sandy substrate and vegetation changes which resulted in reduced Sporobolus virginicus or mixed Sporobolus and Sarcocornia quinqueflora also contributed to the effect. In the TC experiment, there was no effect of modification at the runnelled site, eggshells were fewer at the OMWM site, but there were more eggshells at the grid-ditched site. There was some general indication that recent oviposition activity was reduced in sites that had been modified, evidenced by a relatively small proportion of young (dark coloured) eggshells.

Quantifying the habitat structure and spatial pattern of New Jersey (U.S.A.) salt marshes under different management regimes

Mosquito control measures have resulted in majorstructural alterations of many coastal marshes, withrelatively unknown consequences to larger ecosystemfunctioning. Parallel grid ditching and open marshwater management (OMWM) techniques are purposefullydesigned to alter the hydrological regime and therelative availability and/or characteristics ofstanding water on the marsh surface. With the growingrecognition of the important influence that habitatstructure and the configuration of the marsh-edgeboundary has on nekton utilization of salt marshsystems, the impact of mosquito control managementtechniques on the availability and quality of saltmarsh habitat deserves increased scrutiny. Usingdigital image processing techniques, we completed adetailed mapping effort for a 1800 ha study area inTuckerton, New Jersey to provide a picture ofsubtidal and intertidal habitat availability. Spatialanalysis techniques were used to quantify the relativeamount of habitat types and spatial pattern of theland-water interface under different managementregimes: parallel grid-ditched, OMWM and an unalteredreference. The parallel grid-ditched site had a muchlower incidence of marsh ponds which serve asimportant low tide and over-wintering refuge forcertain species of fish. In comparison, the OMWM sitehad a much greater amount of ponded water habitats.The grid-ditched site had a higher density of marshsurface-to-tidal water interface resulting in a lowermedian distance between the marsh interior and theadjacent tidal channel network. This study serves tobenchmark the habitat structure and spatial pattern ofa highly functioning natural marsh for use as areference site in regional wetland creation orrestoration efforts.

The Effect of Open-Marsh Water Management on Summer Bird Populations on Topsail Island, North Carolina

Open-marsh water management (OMWM) manipulates selected areas of an estuarine marsh by constructing narrow, deep ditches that harbor resident populations of predators of mosquito larvae. It does not, however, alter the surrounding vegetation by deposition of spoil mounds. We censused the summer (breeding and nonbreeding) bird populations in two adjacent salt marsh sites on Topsail Island, North Carolina, for two summers before OMWM ditching occurred and for four seasons postditching. A total of 53 nonbreeding species and five breeding species of birds were encountered on the study sites. None of the interannual changes in bird populations can be attributed to OMWM.

Waterbird use of saltmarsh ponds created for open marsh water management : R. M. Erwin, J. S. Hatfield, M. A. Howe & S. S. Klugman, Journal of Wildlife Management, 58(3), 1994, pp 516–524

Waterbird use of saltmarsh ponds created for open marsh water management : R. M. Erwin, J. S. Hatfield, M. A. Howe & S. S. Klugman, Journal of Wildlife Management, 58(3), 1994, pp 516–524

Waterbird Use of Saltmarsh Ponds Created for Open Marsh Water Management

Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) as an alternative to pesticides for mosquito control in saltmarshes along the Atlantic Coast has created debate among biologists. We designed an experiment to determine waterbird (American black duck [Anas rubripes] and other waterfowl, wading birds, shorebirds, gulls, and terns) use (during daylight) of ponds created for mosquito control compared with use of preexisting water bodies (i.e., natural tidal ponds, creeks, old ditches) and refuge impoundments. We also evaluated the influence of pond size and depth on waterbird use of wetlands. We documented bird use of different habitats for 1 year

Open marsh water management in the mid-atlantic region: Aerial surveys of waterbird use

Nine marsh sites were selected in Maryland, Delaware, and New Jersey to assess the importance of ponds created by Open Marsh Water Management (OMWM) to migratory birds. Ateight of the nine sites, OMWM ponds were paired with areas of similar-sized natural ponds. Eleven aerial surveys were conducted, mostly in fall and winter of 1987 and 1988 to compare relative use of ponds and sites by black ducks (Anas rubripes), other waterfowl, shorebirds, wading birds, gulls, and other species of birds. We noted a high degree of variation in bird use. Seasonal effects were significant, but treatment (OMWM vs. natural ponds) effect was not. Water/marsh (W/M) area ratio was positively correlated with waterfowl and black ducks, but pond number was not. Larger ponds (>0.25 ha) tended to be used more than smaller ponds by most bird species.

Fish Species Composition in New Jersey Salt Marshes: Effects of Marsh Alterations for Mosquito Control

Fish species composition and richness were compared among an unaltered New Jersey salt marsh and marshes altered for mosquito control, based on monthly seine collections over a year. Impounded marshes (stop-ditched and low-level impoundments) had distinctly different fish assemblages from that of an unaltered marsh. Marshes altered by open marsh water management (OMWM) techniques had tidal flows and assemblages similar to that of an unaltered marsh. The most pronounced dissimilarities in species composition were attributable to differences in salinity. Freshwater and oligohaline species dominated in low salinities, such as in some impounded areas. In the higher-salinity areas, as in OMWM and unaltered marshes, a typical estuarine assemblage was abundant. Movements of some species from OMWM and unaltered sites in winter caused characteristic changes in faunal composition and abundance. Among impoundments, however, seasonal patterns of species composition, richness, and abundance varied inconsistently. Regardless of type of alteration, salinity and habitat preference appeared to account for most of the variation in species composition and richness.

Waterfowl and Wetlands Management in the Coastal Zone of the Atlantic Flyway: Meeting Summary and Comments

-A conference on waterfowl and wetlands along the Atlantic coast of North America was held in Wilmington, Delaware in September 1986. Discussions centered around coastal impoundments and Open Marsh Water Management as methods of mosquito control and waterfowl enhancement. Single purpose management of coastal marshes, whether for mosquito control or waterfowl, may not be the most beneficial approach. Where management options are available, the management for habitat heterogeneity may be indi-

Habitat Use by Salt Marsh Birds and Response to Open Marsh Water Management

Habitat Use by Salt Marsh Birds and Response to Open Marsh Water Management