This research investigates the thermal performance of shaded roofs in the composite climate of Roorkee, India, by examining four shading materials (three opaque, one translucent) over an unobstructed roof for eight consecutive days. Using ‘Designbuilder’ software simulations and a mathematical model, the study meticulously triangulates experimental, simulated, and modelled data. The hourly temperature profile of the roof under different shades is analysed and the results showed negligible differences among opaque shading materials, while the translucent material significantly altered the roof’s thermal performance due to solar transmittance. Opaque shades reduced peak heat gain through the roof by up to 77% and 71.5% on cloudy and sunny days, respectively, and reduced nighttime heat loss by 40% and 33%, respectively. This research underscores the importance of considering shading material properties in sustainable building design and confirms the reliability of simulation tools. Highlights The study finds that in parasol roofs, the shading material's thermal properties do not impact the roof's thermal performance, but the solar transmittance does. The study also found that opaque shading could reduce the hourly peak heat gain through the roof by up to 77% and 71.5% on a cloudy day and sunny day, respectively, and reduced the nighttime hourly peak heat loss from the roof by up to 40% and 33%, respectively. Despite considering shading elements in BPS tools to be thermally inactive, the tools perform valid energy simulations.