This monograph is a vital source of reference to the library of both researchers and amateurs engaged in the study of Lower Middle Jurassic ammonites. It remains the most comprehensive atlas of morphospecies found in strata of the Aalenian to Lower Bajocian part of the Inferior Oolite Group, particularly the Graphoceratidae and Sonniniidae. The original was issued in 14 parts, some of which are now of extreme rarity. The present volume succeeds in compiling the entire work in a paperback format in two volumes mirroring exactly the content of the original and reducing the space taken up on the bookshelf due to the use of lighter weight paper. The plates are of a slightly less good resolution, some with reduced contrast. Buckman strived to depict figured specimens at actual size; however, in this publication, the scale used has reduced them slightly. Although of minor importance, this discrepancy is not brought to the reader's attention in the preface to the new volumes. Sydney Savory Buckman (1860–1929) spent his early life at Bradford Abbas in Dorset where he was able to study first hand specimens obtained from local exposures, mostly with good stratigraphical provenance. By the time he commenced his monograph (1887), he had taken up residence in Gloucestershire and was advancing his knowledge of localities there. He had a sound grasp of time-rock duality and the need for a terminology to enable written discrimination of the morphologies he observed. He devised a vocabulary to facilitate this. While this may be of historical interest, it does nothing to clarify some of his descriptions and much of the terminology employed in his monograph was never widely used. Buckman's keen eye for slight differences of morphology led to him become a prolific taxonomic ‘splitter’, erecting numerous generic names throughout his work, some of which have been abandoned through synonymy. Due to the time over which the monograph continued, Buckman considered it necessary to revise some of his earlier conclusions in a Supplement (1898–1907), to designate many additional type specimens and to include a number of ‘in-text’ figures as photographs; the reproduction of which is good in the new volumes. In 1907, further parts of the monograph were abandoned due to disagreement with the Council of the Palaeontographical Society. Major ammonite families of the Bajocian and Lower Bathonian are therefore absent from the monograph; however, the treatment of taxa included still represents a fundamental source of reference relevant to the global study of Jurassic ammonites and is a classical work of historical interest. The new volumes are priced reasonably, of sturdy construction with a wipe-clean, attractive cover that depicts miniature images of some of the ammonites included. Ideally, a modern revision of the genera in this monograph should have been included as an appendix as a large number of the described taxa have undergone extensive revision after Buckman's time.
Read full abstract