This contribution investigates the politics of oil extraction and perceptibility in Val d'Agri, an area in the southern Italian region of Basilicata that sits on the largest onshore oil reservoir in the country. In this article, I examine the ways in which diffused industrial contamination emerges in the landscape and is intercepted and translated by human bodily senses. In doing so, I consider how material phenomena of slow and accretive environmental degradation have a spatial affect and shape ontologies of pollution in the region. To explore how oil becomes a highly political process of epistemological reconfiguration, I examine the rift between expert science and environmental monitoring, which are appropriated by oil corporations and the Italian State, and forms of knowledge that are mobilized by local citizens in an attempt to make sense of ecological degradation and claim environmental rights. Drawing from ethnographic fieldwork and open-source investigation, this contribution invokes accounts of situated practices of citizen sensing that navigate and assemble the evidence of slow and chronicle effects of hydrocarbon pollutants in Val d'Agri. Citizens generate fluxes and exchanges of knowledge that stimulate new political possibilities between inhabitants, activists, and experts and are constitutive of environmental resistance. I give resonance to the existing and emerging struggles around environmental justice in the region as an invitation to consider the possibilities of sensing and local knowledge to bring to the surface a different understanding of contamination and challenge the power of extractive economies.