Abstract Background AB0 incompatible kidney transplantation has become a genuine treatment for end-stage renal disease. Non-inferiority in long term graft function compared to AB0 compatible transplantation has been shown. However, the assumed burden due to complications owing to increased immunosuppression inherent to AB0 incompatible transplantation has not yet been quantified. Aims The aim of the study was to determine if AB0 incompatible recipients have additional morbidity and whether this burden is justified or whether kidney paired donation programs should be advocated. Methods From January 2000 to March 2020 46 AB0 incompatible living kidney transplantations were performed. Patients were matched with AB0 compatible recipients according to sex, age, underlying disease, year of transplantation, and duration of dialysis. Number and duration of readmissions, surgical complication rates according to Clavien-Dindo and its comprehensive complication index (CCI), kidney function, occurrence of new onset diabetes, as well as tumor incidence were analyzed. Results Readmission rate was not higher in AB0 incompatible recipients. The median difference in length of hospital stay for readmissions, CCI during primary hospital stay, and CCI for readmissions at 3, 6, 12 and >12 months after transplantation were comparable. Incidence of tumor and new onset diabetes after transplantation was not increased in incompatible recipients. Conclusions AB0 incompatible recipients do not suffer from a higher burden compared to AB0 compatible recipients. We currently recommend not delaying transplantation in AB0 incompatible pairs.