For gene switching, chromatin must be manipulated, a process initiating at key cis-controlling elements, labelled operationally as DNaseI hypersensitive sites (DHS). This minireview series expands on how the remodelling of chromatin structure comes about and the consequences for gene activation and repression The conventional wisdom embodied (but not, in this age of rapid development, embalmed) in many textbooks has it that chromatin exists in cells either in a linker histone-containing condensed fibre of nucleosomes, diameter 30–40 nm, characteristic of heterochromatin, or as an open extended beads-on-a-string like structure, characteristic of all active genes. Even brief thought gives the lie to the second concept, since in very active tissues such as brain or stem cells in which, say, 40% of all genes are active, were they all fully extended throughout their transcribed length the nuclear volume could not possibly accommodate them. Since the chromatin of an active gene must be opened up at the moment of polymerase passage, it follows that continuous manipulation of chromatin structure must occur at active genes. Indeed, using the criterion of DNaseI accessibility we have recently shown that the overall state of certain active genes differs little from that of an immediately adjacent heterochromatin segment, experimentally demonstrated to be in the form of the 30 nm fibre. This time-averaged observation does not apply, however, to cis-controlling elements such as promoters and enhancers that, since the seminal observations of Hal Weintraub and Mark Groudine in 1976, have been shown to be locally hypersensitive to DNaseI digestion, i.e. in a more open conformation. Thus whereas the presence of bound histones, including the H1 linker, does not in general present a barrier to passage of the polymerase complex through an active gene, access to the DNA at cis elements requires a more open structure. It is worth emphasizing that DNaseI remains a valuable tool in studying local chromatin structure, not only for defining key control points as DNaseI hypersensitive sites, but also for locating the rare segments of open nucleosomal chromatin, i.e. genuine beads-on-a-string structures, sometimes found in the region of promoters or enhancers. This results from the fact that, whereas MNase digestion of nuclei always gives rise to conventional nucleosomal ladders, whether the underlying structure is the 30 nm fibre or open nucleosomal beads, DNaseI does not generate ladders from 30 nm chromatin fibres (the bulk of the chromatin) but it does from open beaded structures. Overall, the controlled manipulation of chromatin structure at such locations, in particular the displacement or even eviction of nucleosomes to permit the ordered recruitment of transcription factors, is a complex process requiring many interdependent components, in particular chromatin remodelling and histone modifying complexes. The following three minireviews address the problem of chromatin manipulation. The first, by Peter Cockerill, takes an overview of the chromatin structure at active genes and then illustrates this with the process of activating the human GM-CSF (granulocyte/macrophage colony stimulating factor) gene during T cell development, emphasizing how the binding of transcription factors is dependent on nucleosome displacement and is accompanied by the appearance of DNaseI hypersensitive sites. The paper by Gordon Hager and colleagues reviews how, following treatment of cells with steroid hormones, the chromatin structure of responsive genes changes in consequence of binding by the immediate hormone targets, the nuclear receptors. Finally, Stefan Dimitrov and his colleague Jan Bednar relate how the bare bone mechanics of chromatin manipulation could occur as nucleosomes and chromatin fibres are put under stress by pulling and tugging whilst held by optical and magnetic tweezers. In a field that can be confounded by the wide variation of experimental conditions, the authors very helpfully provide a summarizing table of published results.
Read full abstract