A tilt integral derivative (TID) controller modifies the proportional integral derivative (PID) controller in the fractional domain. It converts the proportional gain as a function of frequency and is thereby capable of achieving optimal system response. The usual practice for the parameter estimation of the TID controller is by minimization of the error-based objective functions using optimization techniques. Although precise results can be achieved, these nature-inspired algorithms are stochastic and hence produce different solutions during different iterations. Therefore, a comparative statistical study is usually necessary to validate the best possible result. This study shows a deterministic analytical procedure for the paramssseter estimation of TID controllers. The magnitude and phase angle criteria, along with the frequency-domain loop shaping specifications, are used for the explicit evaluation of the TID parameters. Because of its model-independent nature, this tuning strategy can be used for a variety of integral and nonintegral order systems with different plant structures. In this article, the authenticity of the applied procedure is demonstrated through suitable numerical examples. The complexity of the design problem is enhanced by using it for both integer and non-integer (fractional) order plus time-delay systems. Further, the robustness of the control system in the presence of a TID controller was examined under the influence of external parameters and input reference changes. Simulation studies validate the supremacy of TID controllers over PID controllers in terms of reference tracking and disturbance rejection capabilities.