Internal derangements of the knee joint appear to be prevalent among British coal-miners. In recent years such injuries have accounted for between 15 and 30 % of all cases admitted to the rehabilitation units provided in each coal-field, and at which a large proportion of miners suffering from acute orthopaedic disabilities are treated, as well as some of those suffering from the more chronic orthopaedic conditions. Occupational and non-occupational conditions are treated alike at these centres. Precise figures are not available for the incidence of these internal derangements among miners, for notification of them is not made to the Inspectorate of Mines, nor is it likely that all are reported at collieries. An indication of their frequency is given by the fact that about 150 such cases (including cases of injury to a collateral ligament, but not of bursitis) are treated annually at the residential rehabilitation unit which serves the South Wales coal-field. If to these is added the number of cases treated solely at hospitals and at the small rehabilita tion units attached to some of their orthopaedic departments, we may assume that certainly not less than 200 fresh cases occur annually in a working population of under 110,000 men. Figures of a similar order are obtained from the English and Scottish coal-fields. Such an incidence is probably higher than that in heavy industry outside the mines in Britain. Figures for a South Wales steelworks employing over 8,000 men (Jones, J. G., 1956, personal communication) suggest that steelworkers suffer an annual incidence of comparable knee joint injuries which is little more than half that experienced by miners. It is known that in other countries also this problem is a large one. In Germany, about 600 fresh cases of meniscus lesions are said to occur annually in the Ruhr coal-field, where damage to a meniscus in mineworkers is accepted for compensa tion; it is suggested that the nature of their work, often performed in a crouching posture, results in degeneration of the meniscus (Husten, 1953). In studies undertaken among miners in Lancashire, Kellgren and Lawrence (1952) and Lawrence (1955) demonstrated a high prevalence of symptoms referable to the knee joint. These workers seem not to have investigated the connexion between various types of injury to the joint and the osteo-arthritis in which they were mainly interested. But they demon strated osteo-arthritic changes radiologically in the knee joints of 17 to 35% of sample populations of underground workers aged 40-50 years, and after investigation of various possible aetiological factors stated that apart from injury to the knee we have found no factor in mining which appears causally related to osteo-arthritis. Bonar (1950), analysing 200 cases of meniscectomy among Scottish miners, noted that injury to the menisci was commonest among coal-face workers, and from his figures it appears that they suffered an incidence 72% above that for miners as a whole. Smillie (1951), whose profound studies of injuries of the knee joint are largely based on his experience among Scottish miners, stresses the aetiological importance of work in narrow seams. It seemed worthwhile to undertake some further examination of the extent of this problem, and particularly to investigate the nature of the accidents and other types of trauma which may be responsible for these injuries. The material for study consisted of patients undergoing rehabilitation at a residential unit in South Wales during 1953. One hundred consecutive cases of presumed damage to a knee cartilage were studied, including 22 cases where a final decision to perform meniscectomy had not been reached, but in which there seemed a likelihood that a meniscus lesion would ultimately declare itself. In 78 cases meniscectomy had been performed, and lesions of a cartilage sufficient to account for 121
Read full abstract