Mutilating upper limb injuries present complex challenges to both patients and surgeons, necessitating prompt and effective management strategies to achieve favorable outcomes. This retrospective study examines the cases of five consecutive patients with mangled upper limbs resulting from blunt trauma, evaluating demographics, injury mechanisms, injury patterns, and 60-day limb salvage outcomes. Among 2128 admissions between January and December 2022, five patients were identified with mangled upper limbs and open fractures, with an average age of 40.2 years and a notable male predominance (80%). The dominant hand was affected in 60% of cases, primarily due to blunt high-velocity road traffic accidents. The mean Mangled Extremity Severity Score (MESS) was 7.2, and the Ganga Hospital Open Injury Score averaged 16, indicating substantial injury severity without limb ischemia or compartment syndrome. All patients underwent definitive surgery within 48 hours, with various soft tissue reconstruction techniques employed, including free flaps, pedicle flaps, and local muscle mobilization, along with nerve grafting procedures. At the 60-day follow-up, successful limb salvage was achieved in all cases, with no instances of surgical site infection and excellent acceptance of skin grafted areas exceeding 95%. The findings underscore the importance of timely surgical intervention and comprehensive soft tissue coverage in achieving successful limb salvage outcomes in patients with mutilating upper limb injuries, emphasizing the critical role of early intervention and multidisciplinary collaboration.