An Unlikely Alliance: Adam Clayton Powell Sr., Dietrich Bonhoeffer and the Seeds of Transformation Louis Porter II New York City, Harlem, to be exact, and the year was 1930. Two strong forces were about to meet, one influencing the other in a transforming and ultimately historical way. Adam Clayton Powell Sr., then the prominent pastor of Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem, was one of the most powerful African Americans in the nation at that time, but probably did not expect to come into contact with one Deitrich Bonhoeffer, then a Lutheran German visiting on a post‐graduate fellowship at nearby Union Theological Seminary. Surely, the fact that the church he led would have a profound effect on someone from the other side of the globe—at least in part creating level of understanding and sensitivity that would lead Bonhoeffer to become a martyr in World War II—could not have been foreseen. In reflecting upon his book, Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy, () Eric Metaxas said: “For the first time Bonhoeffer saw the gospel preached and lived out in obedience to God's commands. He was entirely captivated, and for the rest of his time in New York he was there every Sunday to worship and teach a Sunday School class of boys; he was active in a number of groups in the church…” Bonhoeffer later shared the power the old Negro spirituals had on him and would even teach them to students in his native country. In his online column, “The Report from Washington,” () Ellis Washington wrote: “Bonhoeffer returned to Germany by late June 1931, where he was one of the first citizens to begin actively plotting against Hitler and Nazism with other courageous Germans.” In 1945, Bonhoeffer was assassinated just before the end of the war. Much has been written about Bonhoeffer's time in Harlem; yet, the results of that visit deserve further reflection, particularly, the effects of Abyssinian and its then, pastor, the elder Powell (and father of the more famous Adam Clayton Powell Jr. who succeeded his father as pastor before being elected to Congress.) Beyond Bonhoeffer's symbolic act of defiance in attending an African American church in 1930, Bonhoeffer and Powell exemplified what would now be given various labels, including cross‐cultural communication and learning, a diversity case study, the difference an ally can make and the power of inclusion. Observers have noted that Bonhoeffer's ability to see and sympathize with “the other” at Powell's Abyssinian Baptist Church undoubtedly played a role in his later resistance to Hitler. “The black Baptist experience not only introduced him to an entirely new form of Christianity, but also provided the possibility for balancing the probable tensions in his own life and his central European Christianity between emotion and reason, between thought and action, between individual and group needs,” wrote Ruth Zerner in Union Seminary Quarterly Review. (Summer, ) Zerner also noted: The life‐affirming leitmotifs of black Christianity resounded with an emphasis upon the centrality of Jesus Christ and the supportive experience of community solidarity. The themes of Christ and community were familiar to Bonhoeffer, but novel was the unique, passionate exuberance with which they were expressed. Unforgettable for Bonhoeffer was the joyful, emotional liberation of Black Baptist worship, particularly in its music and audience participation. The action‐oriented program of Abyssinian Baptist Church also could not have escaped Bonhoeffer's attention. Abyssinian's pastor when Bonhoeffer attended, The Rev. Dr. Adam Clayton Powell Sr., was born in May of 1865, the son of an African‐Cherokee slave woman and a slave owner who was of German descent. Although a delinquent in his youth, Powell accepted Christ as a young man and eventually studied rigorously for the ministry. With Powell's light skin and straight, bushy hair, he could have passed for white, as many others of his era chose to do. Instead, he became an outspoken advocate for black people, with Abyssinian serving as his base. More than a place of rousing sermons and electrifying music, Powell's church during the time of Bonhoeffer's extended visit was an epicenter of community life, including not only Christian study, but educational, recreational, charitable, social and youth...
Read full abstract