In The Nature of Demography, the eminent French demographer Herve Le Bras presents an imaginative and compelling vision of what demography might become if it were to take seriously the scientific task of theory building and codification. Ranging across a wide array of substantive areas – mortality, fertility, marriage, migration, population projections, population and economic development, life-cycle economics and pensions, social mobility, settlement patterns, population density – Le Bras constructs simple (but not simplistic) mathematical models of population processes. The focus on process is central to his vision. Demographic measurement (a sort of land surveying applied to populations) is important, but secondary to the development of demography as an independent scientific discipline: Demography is a science of processes (p.345). It is necessary to get down to individual behaviour in real cohorts (time-lines in the language of the Lexis diagram), in short, to provide micro explanations for macro-demographic period observations. The latter are seen as unreliable guides to what is really going on, as a consequence of censoring (to which Le Bras devotes three chapters) and of wrong perspective: this interpretation reverses the true direction of the process, attempting to derive causes from their consequences (p.94). Le Bras works almost exclusively with mathematical models, spending little time on less rigorous conceptual or visual models. The models are constructed with an eye to specific empirical observations, and are solved analytically if possible, or by micro-simulation where necessary. A model is considered interesting and useful if it provides insight into the workings of the demographic system. A model is deemed empirically adequate if it can closely reproduce the original empirical observations. Le Bras does not speak of validity or truth of a model or theory. He avoids the logical fallacy of affirming the consequent by taking an ecumenical view of theory. Commenting on the large array of ________________________________ ________________________________ ________________________________
Read full abstract