Native Ungulates Research Articles

The dentary of Protolipterna ellipsodontoides: description, taxonomy, and palaeobiology

ABSTRACT Protolipterna ellipsodontoides is a small bunodont South American native ungulate, generally considered an early litoptern, exclusively found in the Palaeogene Itaboraí Basin. Its dentition is well known; however, its mandibular morphology was only known by fragmentary materials. Here, we describe the first complete mandible of this species. A micro-CT scan reveals the first case of alveolus resorption in this putative early litoptern. Two accessory canals on the retromolar region are also described. Canals on the retromolar region are documented for other mammalian orders; however, this represents the first description of this feature for the Protolipternidae. Unlike more advanced litopterns, this species lacks specialisations related to strict herbivory, and its dental and mandibular morphology suggests an omnivore habit. A comparison with the mandible of another Itaboraian protolipternid, Miguelsoria parayirunhor, indicates the presence of different dietary specialisations. Body mass estimations for both species are also provided.

Economic estimates of invasive wild ungulate damage to livestock producers in Hawai'i.

Invasive ungulates (hoofed mammals), including deer, feral pigs, feral goats, and feral sheep, are known to cause damage to agriculture, property, natural resources, and many other commodities. Most of the information regarding the economic impacts of wild ungulates is from North America, where some of these species are native. To evaluate invasive ungulate damage to livestock producers in the Hawaiian Islands, which have no native ungulates, a survey was distributed to livestock producers across the state. Survey results described how total annual costs are distributed among damage, control, and repairs for survey respondents, who represented a significant percentage of total ranchland acreage across the islands. The estimates, excluding fixed fence installation, revealed an annual cost to livestock producers who responded to the survey of US$1.42 million, which ranged from $3.6 million to $7.5 million when extrapolated to the entire state. The large cost contributors included damage to property, pastureland repair, control costs (excluding fencing), supplemental feed, and predation of calves by wild pigs. Additionally, producers reported spending more than $2 million in upfront fence installation costs. Most of these costs were reported by respondents on the islands of Hawai'i and Moloka'i. Study results revealed substantial damage to state livestock producers due to wild ungulates and are useful in determining an invasive ungulate management strategy that can appropriately aid the most impacted sectors of Hawai'i. © 2024 The Author(s). Pest Management Science published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Society of Chemical Industry.

A new dentition-based phylogeny of Litopterna (Mammalia: Placentalia) and ‘archaic’ South American ungulates

Abstract Ever since the discovery of Macrauchenia patachonica by Charles Darwin in 1834, the affinities of litopterns—a group of extinct South American Native Ungulates (SANUs)—have been elusive. In particular, the interfamilial relationships and timing of the familial diversification within the order Litopterna have not been addressed with adequate taxon and character sampling, and modern phylogenetic methods. We address these issues using a new morphological matrix of 703 dental and mandibular characters, scored for the earliest litopterns alongside early SANUs of other orders (Astrapotheria, Notoungulata, Pyrotheria, and Xenungulata). We also included members of families that have been often included within Litopterna, such as Didolodontidae, Protolipternidae, Indaleciidae, and Notonychopidae, the last two sometimes grouped in the order Notopterna. We conducted maximum parsimony and undated and tip-dated Bayesian phylogenetic analyses. Our results indicate that (1) didolodontids, protolipternids, and kollpaniines should be considered early SANUs, but not particularly closely related to any order, (2) Indaleciidae and Notonychopidae usually form a monophyletic group (Notopterna), and (3) Litopterna is a monophyletic unit composed of four families [Adianthidae, Anisolambdidae (subfamilies Anisolambdinae and Sparnotheriodontinae), Macraucheniidae, Proterotheriidae], and tentatively the notoptern families Indaleciidae and Notonychopidae with a probable origin ~64.0 Mya in the Early Palaeocene.

A new South American archaic ungulate and new insight for the early diversification of the South American native ungulates

ABSTRACT Palaeogene South American faunas include enigmatic ungulates that cannot be classified unequivocally within any of the main South American (SA) Native Ungulates clades (Litopterna, Notoungulata, Astrapotheria, Pyrotheria and Xenungulata) because they retain plesiomorphic features, resembling Laurasian ‘archaic ungulates’ traditionally classified within the order ‘Condylarthra’. Most SA ‘condylarths’ are known by partial dental series and isolated teeth and unassociated postcranial remains, hampering comparisons with better-known ungulates. Here, we describe a nearly complete skull and associated mandible of an SA ‘condylarth’, Talquinodus puertai gen. et sp. nov., preserving most of the dentition and basicranium, derived from middle Eocene rocks of the Sarmiento Formation at Central Patagonia. Talquinodus shows a combination of plesiomorphic traits (complete dentition with bunolophodont cheek teeth, ring like ectotympanic, retention of stapedial system, etc.), combined with some autapomorphies, as the reduction of the m3 talonid. Our phylogenetic analyses support consistently that Talquinodus belongs to the SA radiation of Euungulata along with Litopterna, Notoungulata and Astrapotheria. However, the internal relationships could not be resolved unambiguously: Talquinodus could be a didolodontid related to the origin of Litopterna, or could be part of a separate radiation of South American archaic ungulates, along Depaulacoutoia, Lamegoia and Escribania, with no descendants in post-Eocene faunas.

Translocations, rising populations, and phylogeographic consequences: genomic implications for conservation of introduced Aoudad (Ammotragus lervia) in the southwestern United States

Abstract Over the last century, Texas has been inundated with exotic ungulates, with as many as 67 species represented by captive and free-ranging populations. One of the most successful species to have established free-ranging populations is the Aoudad (Ammotragus lervia). Herein, we expand on previous genetic studies in Aoudad by including new genomic profiles based on double-digest restriction site-associated DNA sequencing methods with the intent of better understanding the effects of >70 years of human-mediated translocations, population expansion, and gene flow among populations. Using a range of 4,338 to 5,529 single-nucleotide polymorphisms obtained from 73 individuals that potentially represented A. l. blainei, A. l. lervia, and A. l. sahariensis, we measured genetic patterns of diversity and connectivity between source populations from California and New Mexico and resultant aoudad populations in Texas. Principal component analyses identified phylogeographically structured populations across Texas. Further, we identified a signature of isolation by distance among Texas populations. To assess geographic regions that facilitated or blocked gene flow between populations, we used estimation of effective migration surfaces, which indicated 3 barriers to movement between populations as well as connectivity among populations in close proximity. Comparison of mtDNA haplogroups and nuclear genotypes among the 3 examined subspecies were discordant, indicating that the current subspecific taxonomic classification needs refinement. Given the vulnerable status of Aoudad in their native range of northern Africa and the exponential population growth and potential competition with native ungulates in Texas, we propose that efforts to manage non-native Aoudad should strive to maintain and preserve unique genetic units while minimizing competition and other detriments to native species in Texas. Conservation efforts are especially important given the vulnerable status of Aoudad within their native range of northern Africa.

Body mass estimation of the extinct South American native ungulate Neolicaphrium recens Frenguelli, 1921 (Litopterna, Proterotheriidae): testing classical predictive models

ABSTRACT Neolicaphrium recens (Mammalia, Litopterna) was a slender South American Native Ungulate (SANU). The assessment of its body size is a big challenge because there are no living representatives and no clear close morphological analogues. In this contribution, we report for the first time a femur of N. recens exhumed from Late Pleistocene sediments of Uruguay, improving the knowledge of the postcranial skeleton of the species. This stylopodial element is important for doing palaeobiological inferences, including estimating the body mass. We performed body mass estimations by previous allometric equations. As a method to directly test the models and their usefulness in fossils, we applied the equations on six specimens of extant deers of known body weight and with skeletons preserved. According to the obtained data, the transverse width at the middle of the diaphysis and the circumference of the bone at that level can be used with confidence to estimate the body mass of fossil ungulates. We point out a set of more probable values of body mass for N. recens: 28.76298 ± 10.6412, 27.78496 ± 8.0576, and 26.72 ± 10.42 kg. Morphological variables as well as the models for estimating body masses in fossils are widely discussed.

Evaluating mountain lion diet before and after a removal of feral horses in a semiarid environment

AbstractNon‐native species can affect ecosystems by influencing native predator‐prey dynamics. Therefore, management interventions designed to remove non‐natives may inadvertently lead to increased predation on native species. Feral horses are widely distributed throughout the arid parts of western North America. A growing body of research indicates that horses can be an important prey species to mountain lions in ecosystems where they overlap. In December 2020, the Bureau of Land Management removed 455 horses from the Delamar Mountains, Nevada, USA. We leveraged this management intervention to implement a before–after–control–impact study to test hypotheses about predation on horses and native ungulates. We predicted (1) that horses would comprise an important part of the diet in this mixed‐prey community, (2) following removal, the proportion of horses in the diet would decrease and native ungulates would increase, and (3) mountain lion home ranges overlapping the treatment areas would increase in response to decreased prey availability. From 2018 to 2022, we investigated 1360 clusters from 29 GPS‐collared lions and identified 1056 prey items. To model the probability of a predation event (a kill), we fit a mixed‐effects logistic regression model for ungulate prey as a function of lion sex, treatment area (in/out), and treatment period (pre‐/post‐removal). We used a log‐linear regression model to evaluate changes in home range size. The most common prey were mule deer (55%), feral horses (32%), and coyotes (4%). Twenty‐two of 29 lions consumed horses, although the rate of horse consumption was highly variable across individuals. Horses of both sexes and all age classes were predated. In contrast to predictions, our models detected no effect of removals on diet composition (βinteraction = 0.30 ± 1.1), nor did the removal influence home range size (βinteraction = 0.02 ± 0.02). Despite a 46% reduction in horse abundance, we found no evidence for prey‐switching following the horse removal treatment. Removal magnitude, rapid horse immigration, and/or behavioral specialization of individual mountain lions may help explain these results. Our findings have important implications for mountain lion and feral horse management in arid environments characterized by high prey diversity, but low prey abundance.

Wetland butterfly thriving in abandoned jungle: Neptis rivularis in the Czech Republic.

With ongoing insect declines, species expanding in distribution and abundance deserve attention, as understanding their success may help design conservation strategies for less successful species. Common causes of these successes include warmer climates, novel resources, and exploiting land use change, including land abandonment. These factors affect the nymphalid butterfly Neptis rivularis, developing on Spiraea spp. shrubs and reaching the north-western limits of its trans-Palearctic distribution in Central Europe. We combined mark-recapture, behaviour analysis, and distribution modelling to study N. rivularis in wetlands of the Třeboňsko Protected Landscape (IUCN category V). The long-living adults (up to 4weeks) spent a considerable amount of time searching for partners, ovipositing and nectaring at Spiraea shrubs, alternating this with stays in tree crowns, where they located cool shelters, spent nights, and presumably fed on honeydew. They formed high-density populations (310 adults/ha), exploiting high host plant abundance. They adhered to floodplains and to conditions of relatively mild winters. The ongoing Spiraea encroachment of abandoned alluvial grasslands is, thus, a transient situation, ultimately followed by forest encroachment. Rewilding the habitats by introducing native ungulates presents an opportunity to restore the disturbance regime of the sites. The increased resource supply combined with a warming climate has opened up temperate Europe to colonization by N. rivularis.

Isotopic study of lipids and collagen in bones from archaeological and modern ungulates for the study of paleodiets in Argentina

In this paper we carried out a sequential extraction of lipids and collagen and obtained carbon and nitrogen stable isotope values of archaeological and modern bone samples of native ungulates from the Argentine Patagonia (Lama guanicoe, Pudu puda, Hippocamelus bisulcus) and Northwest (Lama sp., Vicugna vicugna). Collagen and lipids are biomolecules with exceptional survival rates in archaeological bone matrixes and provide complementary information about diet. We studied 28 ungulate specimens and obtained bulk δ13C values (δ13Clip, δ13Ccoll) and δ15N values to evaluate protein diet, whole diet, and offsets between values from lipids and collagen (Δ13Clip-coll). Results showed greater variability in the offsets of the different ungulate species than previously reported for terrestrial herbivores. This variability could be attributed to differences in body mass, particular niche adaptations, seasonal metabolic stress, diet change, and/ or human-ungulate interactions in each case. This study sheds light on the potential of paired lipid-collagen stable isotope values for interpreting paleodiet dynamics and unraveling individual life histories.

Existing evidence on the effects of climate variability and climate change on ungulates in North America: a systematic map

BackgroundClimate is an important driver of ungulate life-histories, population dynamics, and migratory behaviors. Climate conditions can directly impact ungulates via changes in the costs of thermoregulation and locomotion, or indirectly, via changes in habitat and forage availability, predation, and species interactions. Many studies have documented the effects of climate variability and climate change on North America’s ungulates, recording impacts to population demographics, physiology, foraging behavior, migratory patterns, and more. However, ungulate responses are not uniform and vary by species and geography. Here, we present a systematic map describing the abundance and distribution of evidence on the effects of climate variability and climate change on native ungulates in North America.MethodsWe searched for all evidence documenting or projecting how climate variability and climate change affect the 15 ungulate species native to the U.S., Canada, Mexico, and Greenland. We searched Web of Science, Scopus, and the websites of 62 wildlife management agencies to identify relevant academic and grey literature. We screened English-language documents for inclusion at both the title and abstract and full-text levels. Data from all articles that passed full-text review were extracted and coded in a database. We identified knowledge clusters and gaps related to the species, locations, climate variables, and outcome variables measured in the literature.Review findingsWe identified a total of 674 relevant articles published from 1947 until September 2020. Caribou (Rangifer tarandus), elk (Cervus canadensis), and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) were the most frequently studied species. Geographically, more research has been conducted in the western U.S. and western Canada, though a notable concentration of research is also located in the Great Lakes region. Nearly 75% more articles examined the effects of precipitation on ungulates compared to temperature, with variables related to snow being the most commonly measured climate variables. Most studies examined the effects of climate on ungulate population demographics, habitat and forage, and physiology and condition, with far fewer examining the effects on disturbances, migratory behavior, and seasonal range and corridor habitat.ConclusionsThe effects of climate change, and its interactions with stressors such as land-use change, predation, and disease, is of increasing concern to wildlife managers. With its broad scope, this systematic map can help ungulate managers identify relevant climate impacts and prepare for future changes to the populations they manage. Decisions regarding population control measures, supplemental feeding, translocation, and the application of habitat treatments are just some of the management decisions that can be informed by an improved understanding of climate impacts. This systematic map also identified several gaps in the literature that would benefit from additional research, including climate effects on ungulate migratory patterns, on species that are relatively understudied yet known to be sensitive to changes in climate, such as pronghorn (Antilocapra americana) and mountain goats (Oreamnos americanus), and on ungulates in the eastern U.S. and Mexico.

Bone diseases in a Pleistocene South American native ungulate species: the case of Toxodon platensis Owen, 1837 (Mammalia, Notoungulata, Toxodontidae)

ABSTRACTKnowledge of bone pathologies in South American native ungulates is very scarce, which contrasts with other groups of megamammals such as xenarthrans and proboscideans. In this paper, based on morphological and histological analysis, we describe different bone pathologies in two specimens of Toxodon platensis Owen (Notoungulata), one of the most common taxa in the Late Pleistocene faunistic associations of northeastern Argentina. Subchondral erosions on the metacarpus and magnum, non‐marginal syndesmophytes and enthesitis on the vertebral body, the neural column and the zygapophyseal joint of the lumbar vertebrae, as well as a particular periosteal reaction on the ribs, have been interpreted as manifestations of spondyloarthropathies in one of the analyzed individuals. In the same individual, a process of fusion and bone neoformation is observed in the caudal vertebrae, which seems to correspond both to the aforementioned spondyloarthropathy and to an infectious process. A lesion on the fourth metatarsus of a second individual with an evident cloaca is suggestive of osteomyelitis; this is the first report of this pathology in notoungulates. It seems possible that some of these pathologies may have been facilitated by factors such as body mass, mode of locomotion and/or environment. These findings provide insight into some aspects of the ecology of this particular group of extinct South American megamammals.

The impact of seasonal cattle grazing on ungulate spatiotemporal behavior in a multiuse recreational area in central Alberta.

As grazing lands expand it is important to understand the effect cattle (Bos taurus) may have on native ungulates. Cattle presence in a landscape can cause both spatial and temporal partitioning in wild ungulates. We used remote cameras to investigate the impacts of seasonal rest-rotational cattle grazing on both the temporal and spatial behaviors of moose (Alces alces), elk (Cervus canadensis), mule deer (Odocoileus hemonius), and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) in Cooking Lake-Blackfoot Provincial Park near Edmonton, AB, Canada. We found that all wild ungulates decrease their intensity of use in areas while cattle were grazing, and that this effect remains even after cattle have left, suggesting a degree of spatial partitioning. We also observed species specific changes in ungulate daily activity and nocturnality in response to cattle presence indicative of temporal partitioning. Elk increased their nocturnality while both deer species decreased their nocturnality. Understanding how cattle presence affects wild ungulates is essential for wildlife management, disease transmission, and conservation in the wake of potential increased ungulate-cattle interactions in the future.

Feral pig (Sus scrofa) disturbance facilitates establishment of resource‐acquisitive species in Hawaiian forest understories

Abstract Invasive mammals exert pervasive effects on vegetation communities in island systems through several pathways, including by introducing novel disturbances. In Hawai‘i, feral pigs pose a particular threat to endemic species that evolved in the absence of native ungulates. The effects of pig soil disturbance on understory vegetation are contingent on the distribution and density of disturbed patches and subsequent species responses influenced by traits conferring growth and reproductive strategies. However, little is known about how these traits influence native‐ non‐native species turnover in response to pig disturbance, or how such disturbances affect trait‐mediated responses to other environmental variables. Here we quantify the effects of leaf traits and dispersal attributes on species responses to pig soil disturbance at two spatial scales—0.5 m2 patches embedded along 20 m transects within sites—across a gradient of pig density in a Hawaiian montane wet forest using Bayesian mixed models. Native and non‐native species demonstrated divergent responses, with increasing presence and abundance of non‐native species in the understory as soil disturbance within patches and sites increased. Dominant patterns in measured traits tracked the leaf economic spectrum (LES), with non‐native species tending toward resource‐acquisitive traits. Species with resource‐acquisitive traits, regardless of identity, were favoured with disturbance and responded positively to light availability in disturbed sites. Models showed species primarily dispersed by wind were more prevalent in disturbed patches and sites than those dispersed by endozoochory, while seed mass had no effect. Our results suggest pig activity influences community composition and favours non‐native species establishment, and these effects are mediated in part by traits conferring rapid resource acquisition. We also show that the extent of disturbance at the site‐scale is relevant for the influence of leaf architecture on understory responses to light availability, demonstrating how the effects of disturbance are scale‐dependent and can influence species sorting along independent environmental gradients. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.

The Eocene SANUs from the Chubut River Valley (Cerro Pan de Azúcar and Bryn Gwyn, Chubut, Argentina)

As result of the expedition during 1897 in the Valle Inferior del Río Chubut, near Gaiman city (Chubut Province, Argentina), the Swiss naturalist Santiago Roth collected a small but interesting assemblage of South American native ungulates from the Paleogene fossiliferous levels of the Cerro Pan de Azúcar fossil locality. Here, after more than one hundred years after, most of them are first figured and described. We propose a different taxonomic interpretation for Monolophodon minutus and Lelfunia haugi, the two ungulate species endemic for this locality. We also describe the specimens of other historical collections from both Cerro Pan de Azúcar and Bryn Gwyn fossil sites gathered by several expeditions throughout the 20th century. We recognize two clearly distinguished assemblages of South American Native Ungulates. The presence of Henricosbornia lophodonta, Kibenikhoria sp., Isotemnus sp., Notoungulata indet., and Peripantostylops sp. in the upper Las Flores Formation at Cerro Pan de Azúcar establishes affinities with other faunas from the same unit (Cañadón Hondo and Bajo Palangana, Chubut Province) and suggests a slightly older age than the Vacan fauna. On the other hand, the presence of Oldfieldthomasia sp., Henricosbornia lophodonta, Notostylops sp., and Trigonostylops sp. in the Pan de Azúcar Member (lower Sarmiento Formation) at Pan de Azúcar fossil site and Thomashuxleya sp. in Bryn Gwyn fossil site establishes affinities with the Barrancan faunas of the Sarmiento Formation, suggesting a Bartonian age for these levels.

Pleistocene South American native ungulates (Notoungulata and Litopterna) of the historical Roth collections in Switzerland, from the Pampean Region of Argentina

The fossil collections made by early explorers in South America have been fundamental to reveal the past diversity of extinct mammals and unravel their evolutionary history. One important early explorer in South America was the Swiss-Argentine palaeontologist Kaspar Jacob Roth, known as Santiago Roth (1850, Herisau, Switzerland-1924, Buenos Aires, Argentina), who made significant collections of fossil mammals that are housed in museums in Europe and Argentina. The important collections of Roth in Switzerland include iconic Pleistocene megafauna from the Pampean Region (Argentina). The palaeontological significance of the Pampean Region relies on its abundant record of fossil vertebrates that documents diversity dynamics and paleoenvironmental change in southern South America, serving as the basis for the South American biostratigraphical scale of the late Neogene and Quaternary. The South American native ungulates (SANUs) were hoofed placental mammals that radiated in South America. The clades Notoungulata and Litopterna include, among others, the last representatives of SANUs megafauna in the continent. We revise and describe for the first time the SANUs specimens from the Pampean Region of the Roth collections in Switzerland. The collections include two species of notoungulates (Toxodon cf. T. platensis and Mesotherium cristatum) and one litoptern species (Macrauchenia patachonica). The occurrences are restricted to the early and middle Pleistocene (pre-Lujanian Stages/Ages). Although the SANUs diversity in the Roth collections is low in comparison with other groups (e.g., xenarthrans), some of the specimens are very complete, including skulls and postcranial remains. The completeness of the Ma. patachonica material allows an update and reinterpretation of some of the details of the dentition and the postcranial skeleton of this iconic species. In addition to its historical importance, the SANU specimens from the Roth collections provide important information to study the paleobiology and evolution of South American megafauna and evaluate hypotheses about their extinction in the continent.

Spatially and temporally explicit environmental drivers of fawn recruitment in a native ungulate

AbstractRecruitment is one of the fundamental drivers of ungulate population dynamics. Recruitment of neonates into an ungulate population can be influenced by a wide range of abiotic, biotic, and anthropogenic factors. Our objective was to examine which environmental variables most influenced pronghorn (Antilocapra americana) fawn recruitment, as measured by fawn:doe ratios, across six subpopulations in Idaho spanning 35 years (1984–2018) of herd composition surveys. Using a retrospective analysis, we examined the influence of precipitation, minimum and maximum temperatures, Palmer drought severity, normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), vegetation, and elevation across five biological time periods of interest (one and two months pre‐parturition, one and two months post‐parturition, and breeding). Environmental factors, especially the variance in the greenness of vegetation (i.e., NDVI) during the two months post‐parturition (during lactation), were the main drivers of fawn recruitment for subpopulations occupying mountain valleys. Pronghorn fawn recruitment in these mountain valleys was dependent on the condition of the lactating female as influenced by the quality of vegetation, which would subsequently influence fawn growth rates. In contrast, pronghorn recruitment at lower elevations was driven by several environmental variables (i.e., NDVI, drought severity, minimum and maximum temperatures, forb, and grass cover) during the month pre‐parturition. Environmental variables at lower elevations were influencing the condition of the female during gestation which, if favorable, would result in higher birth weights and subsequent increased fawn survival. At intermediate elevation sites, results were mixed with fawn recruitment at one site influenced by low temperatures, which could induce hypothermia in fawns, while recruitment at the other site was influenced by drought severity during gestation (two months pre‐parturition). Influence of these environmental variables was also related to the timing of pronghorn arriving at the high elevation sites (i.e., arriving just prior to fawning); hence, effects were predominantly post‐parturition. In contrast, low elevation sites either had resident pronghorn or earlier arrival; thereby, effects on fawn recruitment were mostly from pre‐parturition variables. Given the range of environmental factors influencing pronghorn subpopulations, managers will need to consider the timing, intensity, and variability of environmental conditions as conditions were spatially and temporally explicit.

Kill rates on native ungulates by Mexican gray wolves in Arizona and New Mexico

AbstractMexican gray wolf (Canis lupus baileyi) reintroduction began in 1998 in Arizona, USA, with 11 individuals initially; wolves from this population dispersed into New Mexico, USA, the following year. Numbers of wolves have steadily increased (≥241 individuals in Dec 2022) and the size of the recovery area has expanded in both states. Understanding kill rates is fundamental to the recovery and management of Mexican wolves to properly maintain a healthy and sustainable population of wolves and their prey species. We used global positioning system (GPS) cluster analysis to locate kill sites and estimate kill rates on native ungulate prey taken in the recovery area by 10 Mexican wolf groups during winter (15 Feb–15 Mar) and 8 wolf groups during summer (15 Jun–15 Jul) in 2015–2017. Elk (Cervus canadensis) composed 94% of the native ungulates documented at Mexican wolf kill sites (n = 139); the remaining 6% were mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus; n = 9). Two‐thirds of all wolf‐killed native ungulates were elk calves. We estimated kill rates as ungulate biomass killed/wolf/day. From combined results for all years, we estimated that each Mexican wolf killed on average 9.0 ± 5.4 kg (±95% CI) of ungulate biomass per day during winter and 7.8 ± 6.2 kg during the summer. Our estimates of kill rates could be overestimated if Mexican wolves obtained a substantial amount of their biomass from scavenging, particularly during 4 months of hunting seasons (Sep–Dec) not captured in winter and summer. Using data from the first 2 years of the study (2015, 2016), we developed a logistic regression model to predict probability of an elk kill occurring at a GPS cluster as a function of hours spent by a collared wolf at that GPS cluster and size of the wolf group. Applying this model to the final year of the study (2017) resulted in similar numbers of predicted (n = 16.1 and 27.2 in winter and summer, respectively) and observed numbers (n = 15 and 26) of elk kills. Additionally, the demographic composition of the 2017 elk kills closely matched that of the previous 2 years. The results of this study indicate similar predation patterns of Mexican wolves to those of wolves in northern locations and can help wildlife managers plan for potential effects from a larger population of wolves across a broad area in Arizona and New Mexico.

Will the grass be greener on the other side of climate change? (with corrigendum)

Increasing atmospheric [CO2] is stimulating photosynthesis and plant production, increasing the demand for nitrogen relative to soil supply with declining global foliar nitrogen concentrations as a consequence. The effects of such oligotrophication on the forage quality of sweetveld, mixed veld, and sourveld grasslands in South Africa, which support livestock production and native ungulates, are unknown. Soil characteristics and the herbage quality of an abundant grass are described from baseline historical (mid- 1980s) data collected across a sweet-mixed-sour grassland gradient in KwaZulu-Natal. Sourveld occurred on the most acidic, dystrophic soils and exhibited a pronounced decline in leaf nitrogen, digestibility, and other macronutrients during winter, in sharp contrast to sweetveld, on nutrient-rich soils, where forage quality varied little seasonally. In a carbon-enriched, warmer, and most likely drier future climate, we predict that forage quality will not be substantially altered in sweetveld where soil nutrients and temperature are not limiting but that sourveld could become ‘sourer’ because soil nutrients will be inadequate to match higher plant production promoted by elevated [CO2] and warmer and longer growing seasons. Reassessing historical data and seasonal and spatial monitoring of forage quality will enable assessment of past and future impacts of climate change on grassland forage quality. Significance: Grassland forage quality will likely decline with elevated [CO2] and warming, particularly in sourveld. Climate change could deepen and widen the sourveld winter forage bottleneck, necessitating greater supplementary feeding of livestock.

Did some extinct South American native ungulates arise from an afrothere ancestor? A critical appraisal of Avilla and Mothé’s (2021) Sudamericungulata – Panameridiungulata hypothesis

Did some extinct South American native ungulates arise from an afrothere ancestor? A critical appraisal of Avilla and Mothé’s (2021) Sudamericungulata – Panameridiungulata hypothesis

Distributions of two native ungulates at the third pole are highly sensitive to global warming

The conservation of native species through the establishment and management of nature reserves needs to take into account the effects of anticipated climate change. Species Distribution Models (SDMs) can be used to obtain key information on the spatiotemporal dynamics of species distributions, which is crucial for management strategies. For two ungulates native to Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, Tibetan gazelle (Procapra picticaudata) and Kiang (Equus kiang), we developed a novel two-step SDM framework with an intermediate step that quantifies the suitability of grassland habitats as essential food availability in the Three River Sources Region (TRSR). We then applied the multi-model inference and bootstrapping techniques to improve accuracy and to estimate uncertainty. We found the best models of grassland suitability included growth degree days, aridity, and topographical roughness as predictors; while common predictors of ungulate distributions included grassland suitability, coldest month temperature, and topographical roughness. The potential ranges of both ungulates will gradually move westward, northward, and upward in the TRSR under two climate change scenarios (SSR245 and SSR585). Within current local reserve boundaries in the TRSR, two focal ungulates would nearly go local extinction in the end of this century in SSR585. However, the northwest corner of the TRSR would become a new distribution center in SSR245 and deserves a higher priority for conservation. In addition to a greenhouse gas reduction agenda to curb the warming trend, our findings advocate adaptive management practices regarding spatiotemporal dynamics of wildlife distributions to prevent the extinction of native species and to increase resilience to climate change.