The present study focuses on the effect of size-scale combination of silica on the mechanical and dynamic mechanical properties of acrylate based (50% Bis-GMA and 50% TEGDMA by weight) composites with an aim to overcome the conventional problem of high-volume fraction filling of acrylate based composites, typically used in restorative dentistry. Two classes of light-cured composites based on the size-scale combination of silica (7nm+2μm; 14nm+2μm) as the filler were prepared. FTIR spectroscopy revealed functionality and interactions whereas morphological investigations concerning the state of distribution and dispersion of nano- and micro-silica has been carried out by SEM–EDX Si-dot mapping. The dynamic mechanical properties, compressive, flexural and diametral tensile strengths were characterized. Micromechanical analysis of viscoelastic storage moduli following Kerner composite model has revealed an enhancement in the reinforcement efficiency of the nanohybrid composites based on the filler size-scale combination of 14nm+2μm with 10wt.% nanofiller loading. The compressive strength of the micro-filled composite (with 2μm silica only) was found to remain comparable to that of the nanohybrid with 5wt.% of 7nm silica and 10wt.% of 14nm silica filled composites. Diametral tensile strength has been observed to be influenced by the size-scale combination and extent of nanofiller loading. The effective volume fractions in the composites validating the experimentally determined DTS were calculated following Nicolais–Narkis model. Our study demonstrates the conceptual feasibility of exploring the optimization of size-scale combinations of filler for enhancement in reinforcement efficiency by manipulating the volume fraction of filler induced immobilized polymer chains by resorting to the principle of micromechanics.