Nanodisc Preparation Research Articles

Anomalous Oligomerization Behavior of E. coli Aquaporin Z in Detergent and in Nanodiscs.

Aquaporins are tetrameric integral membrane proteins that act as water channels, and can also permeabilize membranes to other solutes. The monomer appears to be the functional form despite all aquaporins being organized as tetramers, which therefore must provide a clear functional advantage. In addition to this quaternary organization, some aquaporins can act as adhesion molecules in membrane junctions, when tetramers located in opposing membranes interact via their extracellular domains. These stacked forms have been observed in a range of aquaporins, whether using lipidic membrane environments, in electron crystallography, or using detergent micelles, in single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). In the latter technique, structural studies can be performed when the aquaporin is reconstituted into nanodiscs of lipids that are surrounded by a protein scaffold. During attempts to study E. coli Aquaporin Z (AqpZ), we have found that in some conditions these nanodiscs tend to form filaments that appear to be either thicker head-to-tail or thinner side-to-side stacks of nanodiscs. Nanodisc oligomerization was observed using orthogonal analytical techniques analytical ultra-centrifugation and mass photometry, although the nature of the oligomers (head-to-tail or side-to-side) could not be determined. Using the latter technique, the AqpZ tetramer itself formed oligomers of increasing size when solubilized only in detergent, which is consistent with multiple stacking of AqpZ tetramers. We observed images consistent with both of these filaments in negative staining EM conditions, but only thicker filaments in cryo-EM conditions. We hypothesize that the apparent nanodisc side-to-side arrangement that can only be visualized in negative staining conditions is related to artifacts due to the sample preparation. Filaments of any kind were not observed in EM when nanodiscs did not contain AqpZ, or after addition of detergent into the nanodisc cryo-EM preparation, at concentrations that did not disrupt nanodisc formation. To our knowledge, these filaments have not been observed in nanodiscs preparations of other membrane proteins. AqpZ, like other aquaporins has a charge asymmetry between the cytoplasmic (more positive) and the extracellular sides, which may explain the likely head-to-tail stacking observed, both in nanodisc preparations and also in detergent micelles.

Lipid packing is disrupted in copolymeric nanodiscs compared with intact membranes

Discoidal lipid-protein nanoparticles known as nanodiscs are widely used tools in structural and membrane biology. Amphipathic, synthetic copolymers have recently become an attractive alternative to membrane scaffold proteins for the formation of nanodiscs. Such copolymers can directly intercalate into, and form nanodiscs from, intact membranes without detergents. Although these copolymer nanodiscs can extract native membrane lipids, it remains unclear whether native membrane properties are also retained. To determine the extent to which bilayer lipid packing is retained in nanodiscs, we measured the behavior of packing-sensitive fluorescent dyes in various nanodisc preparations compared with intact lipid bilayers. We analyzed styrene-maleic acid (SMA), diisobutylene-maleic acid (DIBMA), and polymethacrylate (PMA) as nanodisc scaffolds at various copolymer-to-lipid ratios and temperatures. Measurements of Laurdan spectral shifts revealed that dimyristoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) nanodiscs had increased lipid headgroup packing compared with large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) above the lipid melting temperature for all three copolymers. Similar effects were observed for DMPC nanodiscs stabilized by membrane scaffolding protein MSP1E1. Increased lipid headgroup packing was also observed when comparing nanodiscs with intact membranes composed of binary mixtures of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphocholine (POPC) and di-palmitoyl-phosphocholine (DPPC), which show fluid-gel-phase coexistence. Similarly, Laurdan reported increased headgroup packing in nanodiscs for biomimetic mixtures containing cholesterol, most notable for relatively disordered membranes. The magnitudes of these ordering effects were not identical for the various copolymers, with SMA being the most and DIBMA being the least perturbing. Finally, nanodiscs derived from mammalian cell membranes showed similarly increased lipid headgroup packing. We conclude that nanodiscs generally do not completely retain the physical properties of intact membranes.

Characterization of heterogeneity in nanodisc samples using Feret signatures

Nanodiscs have become a popular tool in structure determination of membrane proteins using cryogenic electron microscopy and single particle analysis. However, the structure determination of small membrane proteins remains challenging. When the embedded protein is in the same size range as the nanodisc, the nanodisc can significantly contribute to the alignment and classification during the structure determination process. In those cases, it is crucial to minimize the heterogeneity in the nanodisc preparations to assure maximum accuracy in the classification and alignment steps of single particle analysis. Here, we introduce a new in-silico method for the characterization of nanodisc samples that is based on analyzing the Feret diameter distribution of their particle projection as imaged in the electron microscope. We validated the method with comprehensive simulation studies and show that Feret signatures can detect subtle differences in nanodisc morphologies and composition that might otherwise go unnoticed. We used the method to identify a specific biochemical nanodisc preparation with low size variations, allowing us to obtain a structure of the 23-kDa single-span membrane protein Bcl-xL while embedded in a nanodisc. Feret signature analysis can steer experimental data collection strategies, allowing more efficient use of high-end data collection hardware, as well as image analysis investments in studies where nanodiscs significantly contribute to the total volume of the full molecular species.

Cell-Free Synthesis of Human Endothelin Receptors and Its Application to Ribosome Display.

Engineering G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) for improved stability or altered function is of great interest, as GPCRs consist of the largest protein family, are involved in many important signaling pathways, and thus, are one of the major drug targets. Here, we report the development of a high-throughput screening method for GPCRs using a reconstituted in vitro transcription-translation (IVTT) system. Human endothelin receptor type-B (ETBR), a class A GPCR that binds endothelin-1 (ET-1), a 21-residue peptide hormone, was synthesized in the presence of nanodisc (ND) composed of a phospholipid, 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1'-rac-glycerol) (POPG). The ET-1 binding of ETBR was significantly reduced or was undetectable when other phospholipids were used for ND preparation. However, when functional ETBR purified from Sf9 cells was reconstituted into NDs, ET-1 binding was observed with two different phospholipids tested, including POPG. These results suggest that POPG likely supports the folding of ETBR into its functional form in the IVTT system. Using the same conditions as ETBR, whose three-dimensional structure has been solved, human endothelin receptor type-A (ETAR), whose three-dimensional structure remains unsolved, was also synthesized in its functional form. By adding POPG-ND to the IVTT system, both ETAR and ETBR were successfully subjected to ribosome display, a method of in vitro directed evolution that facilitates the screening of up to 1012 mutants. Finally, using a mock library, we showed that ribosome display can be applied for gene screening of ETBR, suggesting that high-throughput screening and directed evolution of GPCRs is possible in vitro.

Facile production of tagless membrane scaffold protein for nanodiscs

The initial step in the preparation of nanodiscs is to express and purify the membrane scaffold protein (MSP) to homogeneity. Current methods used for the isolation and purification of MSP utilize nickel affinity chromatography. However, the presence of a polyhistidine tag on the MSP often interferes with downstream steps where nanodiscs reconstituted with protein need to be isolated from empty ones. Therefore, one must engage in the finicky process of removing the polyhistidine tag from the MSP using a protease before the formation of nanodiscs. Herein, we describe a robust streamlined approach to produce tagless MSP by expression as inclusion bodies followed by cleavage with cyanogen bromide, and purification by gel filtration chromatography. In addition, the MSP prepared is devoid of tryptophan residues which facilitates tryptophan-based spectroscopic studies of reconstituted proteins. Dynamic light scattering and transmission electron microscopy showed that the tagless MSP produced was competent to produce nanodiscs.

Rapid preparation of nanodiscs for biophysical studies

Nanodiscs, which are disc-shaped entities that contain a central lipid bilayer encased by an annulus of amphipathic helices, have emerged as a leading native-like membrane mimic. The current approach for the formation of nanodiscs involves the creation of a mixed-micellar solution containing membrane scaffold protein, lipid, and detergent followed by a time consuming process (3–12 h) of dialysis and/or incubation with sorptive beads to remove the detergent molecules from the sample. In contrast, the methodology described herein provides a facile and rapid procedure for the preparation of nanodiscs in a matter of minutes (<15 min) using Sephadex® G-25 resin to remove the detergent from the sample. A panoply of biophysical techniques including analytical ultracentrifugation, dynamic light scattering, gel filtration chromatography, circular dichroism spectroscopy, and cryogenic electron microscopy were employed to unequivocally confirm that aggregates formed by this method are indeed nanodiscs. We believe that this method will be attractive for time-sensitive and high-throughput experiments.

Insect odorant receptor nanodiscs for sensitive and specific electrochemical detection of odorant compounds

An electrochemical sensing methodology using an insect odorant receptor (iOR) as the biological recognition element for detection of odorant compounds is presented. Or22a from the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster (DmOr22a) was used as a model receptor for the study. DmOr22a in phospholipid nanodisc preparations was shown to be functionally active toward its known ligand (ethyl hexanoate), as measured by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). iOR nanodiscs covalently immobilized on a gold substrate were further characterized by atomic force microscopy (AFM), quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) and neutron reflectometry in order to study surface modification and understand the underlying mechanisms associated with ligand binding. The EIS sensor exhibited high sensitivity and specificity towards ethyl hexanoate with a detection limit of 5.5 fM. Neutron reflectometry studies provided evidence to support conformational changes in the receptor upon ligand binding. The EIS based detection strategy provides a facile, sensitive and fast method for detecting odorant compounds and paves the way for further development of odorant biosensors.

The Human UGT2B7 Nanodisc.

The 20 uridine diphosphate glycosyl-transferases (UGTs) encoded in the human genome form an essential homeostatic network of overlapping catalytic functions that surveil and regulate the activity and clearance of scores of small molecule metabolites. Biochemical and biophysical UGT studies have been hampered by the inability to purify these membrane-bound proteins. Here, using cell-free expression and nanodisc technology, we assemble and purify to homogeneity the first UGT nanodisc-the human UGT2B7•nanodisc. The complex is readily isolated in milligram quantities. It is stable and its initial-rate parameters are identical within error to those associated with UGT2B7 in microsomal preparations (i.e., Supersomes). The high purity of the nanodisc preparation simplifies UGT assays, which allows complexities traditionally associated with microsomal assays (latency and the albumin effect) to be circumvented. Each nanodisc is shown to harbor a single UGT2B7 monomer. The methods described herein should be widely applicable to UGTs, and these findings are expected to set the stage for experimentalists to more freely explore the structure, function, and biology of this important area of phase II metabolism. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Lack of access to pure, catalytically competent human uridine diphosphate glucuronosyl-transferases (UGTs) has long been an impediment to biochemical and biophysical studies of this disease-relevant enzyme family. Here, we demonstrate this barrier can be removed using nanodisc technology-a human UGT2B7•nanodisc is assembled, purified to homogeneity, and shown to have activity comparable to microsomal UGT2B7.

Preparation of Lipid Nanodiscs with Lipid Mixtures.

Lipid nanodiscs provide a native-like lipid environment for membrane proteins, and they have become a valuable platform for the study of membrane biophysics. A range of biophysical and biochemical analyses are enabled when membrane proteins are captured in lipid nanodiscs. Two parameters that can be controlled when capturing membrane proteins in lipid nanodiscs are the radius, and hence the surface area of the lipid surface, and the composition of the lipid bilayer. Despite their emergence as a versatile tool, most studies with lipid nanodiscs in the literature have focused on nanodiscs of a single radius with a single lipid. In light of the complexity of biological membranes, it is likely that nanodiscs with multiple membrane components would be more sophisticated models for membrane research. It is possible to prepare nanodiscs with more complex lipid mixtures to probe the effects of lipid composition on several aspects of membrane biochemistry. Detailed protocols are described here for the preparation of nanodiscs with mixtures of phospholipids, incorporation of cholesterol, and incorporation of a spectroscopic lipid probe. These protocols provide starting points for the construction of nanodiscs with more physiological membrane compositions or with useful biophysical probes. © 2019 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Basic Protocol 1: Assembly of mixed lipid nanodiscs Basic Protocol 2: Assembly of nanodiscs with cholesterol Basic Protocol 3: Incorporation of laurdan into nanodiscs for membrane fluidity measurements.

Synthetic Biology-Based Solution NMR Studies on Membrane Proteins in Lipid Environments.

Although membrane proteins are in the focus of biochemical research for many decades the general knowledge of this important class is far behind soluble proteins. Despite several recent technical developments, the most challenging feature still is the generation of high-quality samples in environments suitable for the selected application. Reconstitution of membrane proteins into lipid bilayers will generate the most native-like environment and is therefore commonly desired. However, it poses tremendous problems to solution-state NMR analysis due to the dramatic increase in particle size resulting in high rotational correlation times. Nevertheless, a few promising strategies for the solution NMR analysis of membrane inserted proteins are emerging and will be discussed in this chapter. We focus on the generation of membrane protein samples in nanodisc membranes by cell-free systems and will describe the characteristic advantages of that platform in providing tailored protein expression and folding environments. We indicate frequent problems that have to be overcome in cell-free synthesis, nanodisc preparation, and customization for samples dedicated for solution-state NMR. Detailed instructions for sample preparation are given, and solution NMR approaches suitable for membrane proteins in bilayers are compiled. We further discuss the current strategies applied for signal detection from such difficult samples and describe the type of information that can be extracted from the various experiments. In summary, a comprehensive guideline for the analysis of membrane proteins in native-like membrane environments by solution-state NMR techniques will be provided.

Nanodisc characterization by analytical ultracentrifugation

AbstractDue to their unique properties, tunable size, and ability to provide a near native lipid environment, nanodiscs have found widespread use for the structural and functional studies of reconstituted membrane proteins. They have also been developed, albeit in a few applications, for therapeutic and biomedical use. For these studies and applications, it is essential to characterize the nanodisc preparations in terms of their monodispersity, size, and composition, as these can influence the properties of the membrane protein of interest. Of the many biophysical methods utilized for the study and characterization of nanodiscs, we show that analytical ultracentrifugation is able to report on sample homogeneity, shape, size, composition, and membrane protein stoichiometry or oligomerization state in a direct and simple fashion. The method is truly versatile and does not require nanodisc modification or disassembly.

Nanodiscs and Solution NMR: preparation, application and challenges.

Nanodiscs provide an excellent system for the structure-function investigation of membrane proteins. Its direct advantage lies in presenting a water soluble form of an otherwise hydrophobic molecule, making it amenable to a plethora of solution techniques. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance is one such high resolution approach that looks at the structure and dynamics of a protein with atomic level precision. Recently, there has been a breakthrough in making nanodiscs more susceptible for structure determination by solution NMR, yet it still remains to become the preferred choice for a membrane mimetic. In this practical review, we provide a general discourse on nanodisc and its application to solution NMR. We also offer potential solutions to remediate the technical challenges associated with nanodisc preparation and the choice of proper experimental set-ups. Along with discussing several structural applications, we demonstrate an alternative use of nanodiscs for functional studies, where we investigated the phosphorylation of a cell surface receptor, Integrin. This is the first successful manifestation of observing activated receptor phosphorylation in nanodiscs through NMR. We additionally present an on-column method for nanodisc preparation with multiple strategies and discuss the potential use of alternative nanoscale phospholipid bilayer systems like SMA lipid discs and Saposin-A lipoprotein discs.

Explorations of Lipid Effects in Cyclic Nucleotide-Gated Ion Channels using a Nanodisc Platform

The lipid membranes of cells are complex and dynamic mosaic environments that can alter the activity of membrane proteins including cyclic nucleotide-gated (CNG) ion channels. CNG channels are cation channels modulated by cytoplasmic cyclic nucleotides, which play important roles in sensory signal transduction in eukaryotes. Cell-based assays have accumulated evidence for lipid-modulation of CNG ion channels. To isolate and systematically study the effect of lipids on CNG channels, we reconstituted a model CNG channel into lipid bilayer nanodiscs composed of phosphocholine, phosphoglycerol and phosphoethanolamine lipids. We characterized these nanodisc preparations using size exclusion chromatography, electron microscopy and dynamic light scattering to ensure the formation of nanosized discoidal protein/lipid complexes. The reconstitution of CNG channels into nanodiscs permits the direct thermodynamic measurement of cAMP binding to the channel using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). This platform allowed us to probe the binding of cyclic nucleotides to CNG channels in the presence of different lipids, an important step in understanding the molecular mechanism of lipid modulation of CNG channel gating.

Isolation of Monodisperse Nanodisc-Reconstituted Membrane Proteins Using Free Flow Electrophoresis

Free flow electrophoresis is used for rapid and high-recovery isolation of homogeneous preparations of functionally active membrane proteins inserted into nanodiscs. The approach enables isolation of integral and membrane anchored proteins and is also applicable following introduction of, e.g., fluorescent tags. Preparative separation of membrane protein loaded nanodiscs from empty nanodiscs and protein aggregates results in monodisperse nanodisc preparations ideal for structural and functional characterization using biophysical methods.

On-Column Method for Nanodisc Preparation and its Application to Solution NMR

Several model systems are currently available for studying membrane proteins. One such relatively new system called nanodiscs has been emerging as a promising alternative. Nanodiscs are discoidal nanolipoproteins, having a nanoscale phospholipid bilayer held together by an amphipathic helical membrane scaffold protein (MSP). Due to their soluble nature, ease of concentration, monodispersity, temperature stability, and compatibility with cell free expression, nanodiscs present a competitive edge over other available systems for studying membrane proteins. With our aim of carrying out structural investigation of membrane proteins within nanodiscs using solution NMR we reduced the diameter of the self assembly complex to its potential limit there by achieving shorter rotational correlation times. This is shown by the noticeable improvement in the spectrum quality of the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains of integrin αIIb incorporated into these newly developed minimalistic nanodiscs. With the vested interest in generating large “NMR” quantities of homogenous samples in the shortest possible time we developed an on-column method for preparing protein incorporated nanodiscs. Not only did we achieve a rapid, single step, homogenous preparation at one third the time, but we did so with the concurrent separation of protein incorporated discs from the empty discs. This is beneficial as it improves the yield by reducing the number of purification steps, providing a more pure homogeneous sample typically required for structural studies. We have exemplified our new method by reconstituting both bacteriorhodopsin and integrin αIIb using two different strategies within nanodiscs. The nanodiscs prepared by our method have been characterized by Transmission Electron Microscopy, Dynamic Light Scattering and Differential Scanning Calorimetry.

Modified lipid and protein dynamics in nanodiscs

For membrane protein studies, nanodiscs have been shown to hold great potential in terms of preparing soluble samples while maintaining a lipid environment. Here, we describe the differences in lipid order and protein dynamics in MSP1 nanodiscs compared to lamellar preparations by solid-state NMR. For DMPC, an increase of the dipolar C-H lipid acyl chain order parameters in nanodiscs is observed in both gel- and liquid crystalline phases. Incorporating proteorhodopsin in these nanodiscs resulted in a significantly longer rotating frame spin-lattice relaxation time for 13C leerzeichen and better cross polarisation efficiency due to restricted protein dynamics. A comparison of 13C–13C correlation spectra revealed no structural differences. The incorporation of proteorhodopsin into nanodiscs has been optimised with respect to detergent and to protein/scaffold protein/lipid stoichiometries. Its functional state was probed by time-resolved optical spectroscopy revealing only minor differences between lamellar and nanodisc preparations. Our observations show remarkable dynamic effects between membrane proteins, lipids and scaffold protein. The potential use of nanodiscs for solid-state NMR applications is discussed.

Dynamic Interaction of the Escherichia coli Cell Division ZipA and FtsZ Proteins Evidenced in Nanodiscs

The full-length ZipA protein from Escherichia coli, one of the essential components of the division proto-ring that provides membrane tethering to the septation FtsZ protein, has been incorporated in single copy into nanodiscs formed by a membrane scaffold protein encircling an E. coli phospholipid mixture. This is an acellular system that reproduces the assembly of part of the cell division components. ZipA contained in nanodiscs (Nd-ZipA) retains the ability to interact with FtsZ oligomers and with FtsZ polymers. Interactions with FtsZ occur at similar strengths as those involved in the binding of the soluble form of ZipA, lacking the transmembrane region, suggesting that the transmembrane region of ZipA has little influence on the formation of the ZipA·FtsZ complex. Peptides containing partial sequences of the C terminus of FtsZ compete with FtsZ polymers for binding to Nd-ZipA. The affinity of Nd-ZipA for the FtsZ polymer formed with GTP or GMPCPP (a slowly hydrolyzable analog of GTP) is moderate (micromolar range) and of similar magnitude as for FtsZ-GDP oligomers. Polymerization does not stabilize the binding of FtsZ to ZipA. This supports the role of ZipA as a passive anchoring device for the proto-ring with little implication, if any, in the regulation of its assembly. Furthermore, it indicates that the tethering of FtsZ to the membrane shows sufficient plasticity to allow for its release from noncentral regions of the cytoplasmic membrane and its subsequent relocation to midcell when demanded by the assembly of a division ring.