The 1-phenylbenzazepine scaffold has yielded several D1R targeting ligands, but some gaps remain in our understanding of the structure–activity relationships in this scaffold. In particular, there is a paucity of studies that have investigated the effects of substituents at the C2′ position of 1-phenylbenzazepines on their affinity and selectivity towards D1R. In this study, a set of methyl- and fluoro- C2′-substituted 1-phenylbenzazepines, with ring A catechol or 8-hydroxy-7-methoxy moieties in tandem with N-methyl or N-allyl substituent groups, was synthesized and evaluated for affinity at a subset of dopamine receptors - D1R, D2R and D5R. These studies indicate that an N-methyl group is generally preferred over N-unsubstituted or N-allyl groups for strong D1R affinity. In addition, it was revealed that compounds with a ring A 8-hydroxy-7-methoxy motif displayed stronger D1R affinity than analogous compounds with a ring A catechol moiety. Furthermore, the presence of a C2′ substituent does not significantly impact D1R selectivity over D5R. However, for all analogs assessed, D1R selectivity over D2R was maintained. D1R vs D5R selectivity was generally poor or modest (less than 10-fold) among members of the series. A new high affinity selective D1R ligand − 10b (Ki = 5.7 nM), was identified in this study; further pharmacological characterization indicates that 10b is an antagonist at D1R (IC50 = 10.7 nM). Docking studies on 10b indicate that a number of interactions with hydrophobic residues (Trp321, Val317, Phe313, Phe289, Phe288, Phe285, Phe203, Tyr194, Leu190, Ser188, His 164, Ile104, Val100 and Trp99) in addition to the typical N-Asp103 salt bridge are important for its D1R affinity.