Foot and ankle fractures are the most common military health problem. Automated diagnosis can save time and personnel. It is crucial to distinguish fractures not only from normal healthy cases, but also robust against the presence of other orthopedic pathologies. Artificial intelligence (AI) deep learning has been shown to be promising. Previously, we have developed HAMIL-Net to automatically detect orthopedic injuries for upper extremity injuries. In this research, we investigated the performance of HAMIL-Net for detecting foot and ankle fractures in the presence of other abnormalities. HAMIL-Net is a novel deep neural network consisting of a hierarchical attention layer followed by a multiple-instance learning layer. The design allowed it to deal with imaging studies with multiple views. We used 148K musculoskeletal imaging studies for 51K Veterans at VA San Diego in the past 20 years to create datasets for this research. We annotated each study by a semi-automated pipeline leveraging radiology reports written by board-certified radiologists and extracting findings with a natural language processing tool and manually validated the annotations. HAMIL-Net can be trained with study-level, multiple-view examples, and detect foot and ankle fractures with a 0.87 area under the receiver operational curve, but the performance dropped when tested by cases including other abnormalities. By integrating a fracture specialized model with one that detecting a broad range of abnormalities, HAMIL-Net's accuracy of detecting any abnormality improved from 0.53 to 0.77 and F-score from 0.46 to 0.86. We also reported HAMIL-Net's performance under different study types including for young (age 18-35) patients. Automated fracture detection is promising but to be deployed in clinical use, presence of other abnormalities must be considered to deliver its full benefit. Our results with HAMIL-Net showed that considering other abnormalities improved fracture detection and allowed for incidental findings of other musculoskeletal abnormalities pertinent or superimposed on fractures.
Read full abstract