Multi-user Collusion Research Articles

A Spatial Domain Approach of Fingerprinting for Colored Digital Images

In this paper, a spatial domain approach of fingerprinting is presented for colored digital images. A semi-blind fingerprinting conveys a secure arrangement for trading of digital images. The operational significance of the digital fingerprinting system is verified and estimated. Digital fingerprint implanted doesn’t disturb the perceptible feature of the host digital image. Multi-user collusion attacks are prevented using the proposed apparoach. Variable fingerprint size and dissimilar location insertion play significant role for inhibiting attack.

Cooperation and Coalition in Multimedia Fingerprinting Colluder Social Networks

Users in multimedia social networks actively interact with each other. It is crucial to study the complex user dynamics and analyze its impact on the performance of multimedia social networks. This paper uses multimedia fingerprinting as an example and studies user dynamics in colluder social networks. During collusion, a group of attackers collectively attack multimedia fingerprinting system and use multimedia content illegally. This paper analyzes the incentives of cooperation among attackers and investigates how colluders form their coalitions to maximize their payoffs. We present a game-theoretic framework to model the complex dynamics among colluders, analyze when attackers cooperate with each other, and investigate how a colluder selects his/her fellow attackers to maximize his/her own payoff. We analyze multiuser collusion in two scenarios: when all attackers receive fingerprinted copies of the same resolution, and when they have copies of different resolutions. The proposed framework considers both the colluders' risk of being detected by the digital rights enforcer and the reward received from illegal usage of multimedia content. Our analysis shows that in both scenarios, colluding with more attackers does not always increase an attacker's utility, and attackers may not always want to cooperate with each other. We first examine the necessary conditions for attackers to collude together, and study how they select the collusion parameters such that cooperation benefits all colluders. We then study how the number of colluders affects each attacker's utility, and investigate the optimum strategy that an attacker should use to select fellow attackers and to form a coalition in order to maximize his or her own payoff.

Game-theoretic strategies and equilibriums in multimedia fingerprinting social networks

Multimedia social network is a network infrastructure in which the social network users share multimedia contents with all different purposes. Analyzing user behavior in multimedia social networks helps design more secured and efficient multimedia and networking systems. Multimedia fingerprinting protects multimedia from illegal alterations and multiuser collusion is a cost-effective attack. The colluder social network is naturally formed during multiuser collusion with which colluders gain reward by redistributing the colluded multimedia contents. Since the colluders have conflicting interest, the maximal-payoff collusion for one colluder may not be the maximal-payoff collusion for others. Hence, before a collusion being successful, the colluders must bargain with each other to reach agreements. We first model the bargaining behavior among colluders as a noncooperative game and study four different bargaining solutions of this game. Moreover, the market value of the redistributed multimedia content is often time-sensitive. The earlier the colluded copy being released, the more the people are willing to pay for it. Thus, the colluders have to reach agreements on how to distribute reward and risk among themselves as soon as possible. This paper further incorporates this time-sensitiveness of the colluders' reward and studies the time-sensitive bargaining equilibrium. The study in this paper reveals the strategies that are optimal for the colluders; thus, all the colluders have no inventive to disagree. Such understanding reduces the possible types of collusion into a small finite set.

Impact of Social Network Structure on Multimedia Fingerprinting Misbehavior Detection and Identification

Users in video-sharing social networks actively interact with each other, and it is of critical importance to model user behavior and analyze the impact of human factors on video sharing systems. In video-sharing social networks, users have access to extra resources from their peers, and they also contribute their own resources to help others. Each user wants to maximize his/her own payoff, and they negotiate with each other to achieve fairness and address this conflict. However, some selfish users may cheat to their peers and manipulate the system to maximize their own payoffs, and cheat prevention is a critical requirement in many social networks to stimulate user cooperation. It is of ample importance to design monitoring mechanisms to detect and identify misbehaving users, and to design cheat-proof cooperation stimulation strategies. Using video fingerprinting as an example, this paper analyzes the complex dynamics among colluders during multiuser collusion, and explores possible monitoring mechanisms to detect and identify misbehaving colluders in multiuser collusion. We consider two types of colluder networks: one has a centralized structure with a trusted ringleader, and the other is a distributed peer-structured network. We investigate the impact of network structures on misbehavior detection and identification, propose different selfish colluder identification schemes for different colluder networks, and analyze their performance. We show that the proposed schemes can accurately identify selfish colluders without falsely accusing others even under attacks. We also evaluate their robustness against framing attacks and quantify the maximum number of framing colluders that they can resist.

Traitor-Within-Traitor Behavior Forensics: Strategy and Risk Minimization

Multimedia security systems have many users with different objectives and they influence each other's performance and decisions. Behavior forensics analyzes how users with conflicting interests interact with and respond to each other. Such investigation enables a thorough understanding of multimedia security systems and helps the digital rights enforcer offer stronger protection of multimedia. This paper analyzes the dynamics among attackers during multiuser collusion. The colluders share not only the profit from the redistribution of multimedia but also the risk of being detected by the content owner, and an important issue in collusion is fairness of the attack (i.e., whether all attackers share the same risk) (e.g., whether they have the same probability of being detected). While they might agree so, some selfish colluders may break their fair-play agreement in order to further lower their risk. This paper investigates the problem of within traitors in multimedia forensics, in an effort to formulate the dynamics among attackers and understand their behavior to minimize their own risk and protect their own interests. As the first work on the analysis of this colluder dynamics, this paper explores some possible strategies that a selfish colluder can use to minimize his or her probability of being caught. We show that processing his or her fingerprinted copy before multiuser collusion helps a selfish colluder further lower his or her risk, especially when the colluded copy has high resolution and good quality. This paper also investigates the optimal precollusion processing strategies for selfish colluders to minimize their risk under the quality constraints

Behavior forensics for scalable multiuser collusion: fairness versus effectiveness

Multimedia security systems involve many users with different objectives and users influence each other's performance. To have a better understanding of multimedia security systems and offer stronger protection of multimedia, behavior forensics formulate the dynamics among users and investigate how they interact with and respond to each other. This paper analyzes the behavior forensics in multimedia fingerprinting and formulates the dynamics among attackers during multi-user collusion. In particular, this paper focuses on how colluders achieve the fair play of collusion and guarantee that all attackers share the same risk (i.e., the probability of being detected). We first analyze how to distribute the risk evenly among colluders when they receive fingerprinted copies of scalable resolutions due to network and device heterogeneity. We show that generating a colluded copy of higher resolution puts more severe constraints on achieving fairness. We then analyze the effectiveness of fair collusion. Our results indicate that the attackers take a larger risk of being captured when the colluded copy has higher resolution, and they have to take this tradeoff into consideration during collusion. Finally, we analyze the collusion resistance of the scalable fingerprinting systems in various scenarios with different system requirements, and evaluate the maximum number of colluders that the fingerprinting systems can withstand

Collusion-resistant fingerprinting for multimedia

Digital fingerprinting is a technology for enforcing digital rights policies whereby unique labels, known as digital fingerprints, are inserted into content prior to distribution. For multimedia content, fingerprints can be embedded using conventional watermarking techniques that are typically concerned with robustness against a variety of attacks mounted by an individual. These attacks, known as multiuser collusion attacks, provide a cost-effective method for attenuating each of the colluder's fingerprints and poses a real threat to protecting media data and enforcing usage policies. In this article, we review some major design methodologies for collusion-resistant fingerprinting of multimedia and highlight common and unique issues of different fingerprinting techniques. It also provides detailed discussions on the two major classes of fingerprinting strategies, namely, orthogonal fingerprinting and correlated fingerprinting.