Multiple Predators Research Articles

Oceanic whitetip shark cookies: Evidence of multiple predation events by an opportunistic mesopelagic predator on a large epipelagic shark

Oceanic whitetip shark cookies: Evidence of multiple predation events by an opportunistic mesopelagic predator on a large epipelagic shark

Assessing biological invasion predatory impacts through interaction strengths and morphological trophic profiling

AbstractBiological invasions are a major stressor on ecosystems worldwide, but tools to predict their predatory impact remain limited. Here, we quantified invader impacts using two complementary approaches: functional responses (to reveal per capita and multiple predator interaction strengths) and ecomorphology (to reveal trophic profiles and competitive overlap). We compared Mozambique tilapia Oreochromis mossambicus, a native southern African cichlid, and a near-trophically analogous invasive congener, the Nile tilapia Oreochromis niloticus. Both Nile tilapia and Mozambique tilapia exhibited a potentially prey population destabilizing Type II functional response. In both single and multiple predator pairings, invasive Nile tilapia had significantly greater prey consumption rates than native Mozambique tilapia, and thereby a greater predatory impact than its native congeneric. Attack rates were greater for Nile tilapia than Mozambique tilapia, with both species showing more similar handling times and maximum feeding rates. No evidence for multiple predator effects was detected within or between these species, and therefore impacts of both species increased additively in the presence of conspecific or heterospecific competitors. Morphological trait analyses found general differences between these two species, with the invasive Nile tilapia having distinctively larger lower jaw closing force, gill resistance and gill raker length, which facilitated greater feeding capacities over the native species. Trophic profiles predicted using morphological trait differences showed high dietary overlap and served as evidence for potential exploitative competition between the two species. These results reveal superior interaction strengths and ecomorphological trait profiles of an invasive over native species which could influence impact and native species replacement dynamics. Novel applications of functional response and ecomorphology provide complementary insights into predatory and competitive impacts from invasive species, aiding impact prediction across environmental contexts.

Marine predators segregate interspecifically by space and time in a sheltered coastal bay.

Marine predators are vital to the healthy functioning of coastal ecosystems, but to understand their roles, it is necessary to elucidate their movement ecology, particularly in relation to one another. A decade's worth of acoustic telemetry data (2011-2020) from Algoa Bay, South Africa, was investigated to determine how two mesopredatory species (teleosts: dusky kob Argyrosomus japonicus, n = 11, and leervis Lichia amia, n = 16) and two top predatory species (sharks: ragged-tooth sharks Carcharias taurus, n = 45, and white sharks Carcharodon carcharias, n = 31) used and shared this bay ecosystem. Multi-annual seasonal fidelity to the bay was exhibited by all species, but differences in residency were observed among species. Similarly, species used space in the bay differently-the teleosts moved less and had movements restricted to the central and western inshore regions of the bay. Conversely, the sharks roamed more, but detections were concentrated in the western part of the bay for C. taurus and in the eastern part of the bay for C. carcharias. Social network analysis showed that species segregated in space and time on a fine scale. However, there was some interaction observed between C. taurus, L. amia, and A. japonicus, but to varying degrees. This is likely because of strong habitat preferences exhibited by each species and predator-prey relationships between these predatory guilds. Results highlight that the sheltered marine Algoa Bay is a resource-rich environment, supporting multiple predators with different hunting strategies albeit similar prey preferences. Finally, these species are likely afforded some protection by the current Greater Addo Elephant National Park Marine Protected Area in the bay but are vulnerable to fishing pressure when they leave this ecosystem.

Predators control pests and increase yield across crop types and climates: a meta-analysis.

Pesticides have well-documented negative consequences to control crop pests, and natural predators are alternatives and can provide an ecosystem service as biological control agents. However, there remains considerable uncertainty regarding whether such biological control can be a widely applicable solution, especially given ongoing climatic variation and climate change. Here, we performed a meta-analysis focused on field studies with natural predators to explore broadly whether and how predators might control pests and in turn increase yield. We also contrasted across studies pest suppression by a single and multiple predators and how climate influence biological control. Predators reduced pest populations by 73% on average, and increased crop yield by 25% on average. Surprisingly, the impact of predators did not depend on whether there were many or a single predator species. Precipitation seasonality was a key climatic influence on biological control: as seasonality increased, the impact of predators on pest populations increased. Taken together, the positive contribution of predators in controlling pests and increasing yield, and the consistency of such responses in the face of precipitation variability, suggest that biocontrol has the potential to be an important part of pest management and increasing food supplies as the planet precipitation patterns become increasingly variable.

Non-additive effects of multiple predators alter the biological control of the coffee leaf miner (Leucoptera coffeella)

Although most prey are attacked by multiple predators, much of the ecological theory on prey suppression focuses on the effects of a single predator. The presence of multiple predators can lead to complex interactions such as trait-mediated interactions (TMIIs) and intraguild predation which can influence the suppression of pest populations. Here we explore the effect of two predators, a native anole lizard species Anolis cristatellus (Squamata: Dactyloidae) and a non-native ant species Wasmannia auropunctata (Hymenoptera: Formicidae), on the coffee leaf miner, Leucoptera coffeella (Lepidoptera: Lyonetiidae) (CLM). In a laboratory experiment we examined the effects of these two predators in isolation and when co-occurring. Our results show that when each predator is alone, they are able to consume the CLM in a comparable way. However, when they are together, their effect is not greater than when alone. This indicates that there is a negative effect when both predators co-occur. The results from this experiment have practical implications since both predators are present in coffee agroecosystems in Puerto Rico, where the CLM is considered the main insect pest. Furthermore, these results demonstrate the potential dynamics among several predators in agroecosystems and the potential implications for herbivore regulation.

Estimating individual exposure to predation risk in group-living baboons, Papio anubis.

In environments with multiple predators, vulnerabilities associated with the spatial positions of group-living prey are non-uniform and depend on the hunting styles of the predators. Theoretically, coursing predators follow their prey over long distances and attack open areas, exposing individuals at the edge of the group to predation risk more than those at the center (marginal predation). In contrast, ambush predators lurk unnoticed by their prey and appear randomly anywhere in the group; therefore, isolated individuals in the group would be more vulnerable to predators. These positions of vulnerability to predation are expected to be taken by larger-bodied males. Moreover, dominant males presumably occupy the center of the safe group. However, identifying individuals at higher predation risk requires both simultaneous recording of predator location and direct observation of predation events; empirical observations leave ambiguity as to who is at risk. Instead, several theoretical methods (predation risk proxies) have been proposed to assess predation risk: (1) the size of the individual 'unlimited domain of danger' based on Voronoi tessellation, (2) the size of the 'limited domain of danger' based on predator detection distance, (3) peripheral/center position in the group (minimum convex polygon), (4) the number and direction of others in the vicinity (surroundedness), and (5) dyadic distances. We explored the age-sex distribution of individuals in at-risk positions within a wild baboon group facing predation risk from leopards, lions, and hyenas, using Global Positioning System collars. Our analysis of the location data from 26 baboons revealed that adult males were consistently isolated at the edge of the group in all predation risk proxies. Empirical evidence from previous studies indicates that adult male baboons are the most frequently preyed upon, and our results highlights the importance of spatial positioning in this.

Trophic interactions of sharks and crocodylians with a sea cow (Sirenia) from the Miocene of Venezuela

ABSTRACT Evidence of trophic interactions are not scarce in the fossil record, yet these are mostly represented by fragmentary fossils exhibiting marks of ambiguous significance. Differentiating between marks of active predation and scavenging events is therefore often challenging. Here, we report on a dugongine sea cow skeleton (partial skull and vertebrae) from the Lower to Middle Miocene Agua Clara Formation (Venezuela) with shark and crocodylian bite marks. The sirenian is identified as Culebratherium sp. and preserves crocodylian bite marks across the skeleton. The most conspicuous correspond to deep tooth impacts with dragging effect, concentrated in the rostrum of the specimen. We interpret these as the result of active predation because of the similarity with those produced when a crocodylian holds or rolls a prey. Additionally, shark bite marks can be observed throughout the skeleton, also evidenced by the finding of an isolated tiger shark (Galeocerdo aduncus) tooth associated with this skeleton. Because of the irregular distribution of the shark bite marks, these are interpreted as scavenging. Overall, these findings constitute one of the few records documenting multiple predators over a single prey, and as such provide a glimpse of the trophic networks during the Miocene in the region.

Sustained ecological impacts of invasive crayfish following claw injury

ABSTRACT Human activities have significantly accelerated the translocation of species outside their native range with severe consequences for global biodiversity. Freshwater crayfish are a particularly successful group of invasive species, as exemplified by the increasingly widespread marbled crayfish Procambarus virginalis Lyko, 2017. A significant portion of crayfish populations has regenerating or missing claws. At the same time, claws play important roles in crayfish feeding and intraspecific interactions, altering their ability to invade new areas and impact native communities. Here, using functional response analyses, we combined laboratory experiments and modeling to investigate whether the number of claws on marbled crayfish modulates its ecological impact (focusing on predation rate) as well as its intraspecific interactions via population dynamic modeling. We found that the number of claws did not affect the marbled crayfish’s functional response type (hyperbolic type II), attack rates, or handling times when preying on chironomid larvae. Rates of partial prey consumption were overall low (<2%), and claw number had a significant effect on the partial consumption rate of prey, which tended to increase with the number of claws and prey density. The presence of multiple intraspecific predators influenced marbled crayfish non-trophic behavior, with antagonistic effects prevalent between crayfish pairs regardless of claw status. Moreover, the impact of multiple predators was prey density-dependent, with the highest levels of antagonism shown at the lowest prey density across crayfish groups. Our findings indicate that the ecological influence of invasive crayfish remains unchanged by the number of claws, highlighting the escalating, context-independent threat these species pose to freshwater ecosystems.

Golden mimics use multiple defenses to counter generalist and specialist predators

Abstract Many prey species employ multiple defenses during interactions with predators. Multiple defenses can provide a selective advantage against a single predator at different stages of the interaction or attack, as well as against multiple predator types. However, the efficacy of multiple defenses both during different sequences of an attack and against multiple predator types, remains poorly understood. We measured and classified defensive traits used by five mimics (Müllerian and Batesian) of the myrmecomorphic golden mimicry complex and one non-mimetic species. We then performed predatory trials using two different predators that differed markedly in their body size, trophic specialization, and how they handle prey—one being an ant specialist (spider) and the other a generalist which avoided ants (skink). We identified 12 defensive traits and classified them into four groups (primary, chemical, mechanical, and behavioral), which were strongly correlated. Skinks were much less likely to attack and capture mimics than the ant-eating spider predators. Our results show that multiple defenses (five or six) were used against each predator. The defensive behaviors and features that were most effective against skinks included appendage waving and large body size, whereas the golden “shine” warning signal, large body size, cuticle thickness, and defensive gland size were most effective against spiders. Most defenses appeared to be predator-specific. We conclude that potential prey in the golden mimicry complex have been selected for multiple defenses because of their vulnerability to different predator types and consequently, the efficacy of some of these defenses likely represents a trade-off.

Additive multiple predator effects increase prey mortality under experimental warming in a rocky intertidal food web

Climate warming is expected to alter species interactions, which are shaped by components of individual foraging behavior. Yet few studies examine species' behavioral responses to inform predictions about how species interactions will be affected by warming. Multiple predator effects (MPEs) may be mediated by climatic warming, especially in highly diverse coastal ecosystems that are prone to extreme warming events. In a laboratory experiment, we quantified the effects of elevated sea water temperature on mortality rates of mussels (Mytilus californianus, Conrad, 1837), and the behavioral responses of their predators: crabs (Romaleon antennarium, Stimpson, 1856) and sea stars (Pisaster ochraceus, Brandt, 1835), to understand how warming affects MPEs and if predators' behavioral responses to warming are indicative of the outcome of MPEs. Sea star effects on mussel mortality did not vary with temperature, but declined threefold in the presence of crabs, due to behavioral avoidance of physical contact with crabs. In contrast, the effect of crabs on mussel mortality was ten times higher under elevated temperature, but was unaffected by sea stars. In mixed predator treatments, crabs caused significant mussel mortality, but sea stars had weaker impacts, regardless of temperature. Consequently, multiple predators had effects that did not differ from those of the more effective crab predator. Increasing temperature in the eastern North Pacific may create locations where crabs become the dominant predator of mussels, with warming increasing predation risk for mussels in this region. Field studies should examine the effects of warming on crab predation on mussels in this system.

Predicting prey diversity with multiple predator effects

Emergent multiple predator effects can result in either risk enhancement or reduction for prey populations. However, whether emergent multiple predator effects influence survival of entire prey assemblages is unknown, which could alter community diversity. We tested whether emergent multiple predator effects would lead to changes in survival of multiple prey species that would subsequently alter prey diversity. We experimentally tested whether larval ringed (Ambystoma annulatum) and marbled salamanders (A. opacum) had additive or multiplicative effects on hatchlings of an assemblage of five amphibian prey species using outdoor mesocosms. We also examined this question using data from a previously published experiment. We extended the multiplicative risk model to estimate prey diversity based on individual prey survival probabilities from each mesocosm. We found that predators generally had additive effects on all prey species, as the expected survival of prey was not different from the observed data, indicating a lack of emergent multiple predator effects. Consistent with this result, observed diversity was not different from expected diversity based on our extension of the multiplicative risk model, further indicating predator species had additive effects. Re-analysis of previously published data showed that when emergent multiple predator effects resulted in risk reduction, diversity changed in a manner consistent that outcome. Overall, we found that additive and multiplicative effects of multiple predators contributed to structuring entire prey communities, including influencing community metrics like diversity. Future work should consider further under what conditions diversity enhancement or reduction would occur.

Predicting prey diversity with multiple predator effects

Predicting prey diversity with multiple predator effects

Mechanisms of group-hunting in vertebrates.

Group-hunting is ubiquitous across animal taxa and has received considerable attention in the context of its functions. By contrast much less is known about the mechanisms by which grouping predators hunt their prey. This is primarily due to a lack of experimental manipulation alongside logistical difficulties quantifying the behaviour of multiple predators at high spatiotemporal resolution as they search, select, and capture wild prey. However, the use of new remote-sensing technologies and a broadening of the focal taxa beyond apex predators provides researchers with a great opportunity to discern accurately how multiple predators hunt together and not just whether doing so provides hunters with a per capita benefit. We incorporate many ideas from collective behaviour and locomotion throughout this review to make testable predictions for future researchers and pay particular attention to the role that computer simulation can play in a feedback loop with empirical data collection. Our review of the literature showed that the breadth of predator:prey size ratios among the taxa that can be considered to hunt as a group is very large (<100 to >102 ). We therefore synthesised the literature with respect to these predator:prey ratios and found that they promoted different hunting mechanisms. Additionally, these different hunting mechanisms are also related to particular stages of the hunt (search, selection, capture) and thus we structure our review in accordance with these two factors (stage of the hunt and predator:prey size ratio). We identify several novel group-hunting mechanisms which are largely untested, particularly under field conditions, and we also highlight a range of potential study organisms that are amenable to experimental testing of these mechanisms in connection with tracking technology. We believe that a combination of new hypotheses, study systems and methodological approaches should help push the field of group-hunting in new directions.

Dipteran Prey Vulnerability in Intraguild Predation (IGP) System Involving Heteropteran Predators: Density and Habitat Effects

(1) Background: The effects of density and the habitat conditions on the prey vulnerability in the Intraguild Predation (IGP) system were evaluated using the water bug D. rusticus as the top predator. (2) Methods: Using two different density levels (low or high) of the dipteran prey (mosquito and chironomid), the IGP system was set with A. bouvieri as the IG prey. (3) Results: The prey vulnerability was reduced in complex habitat conditions, irrespective of the prey and predator density levels and the prey identity. Correspondingly, the IG prey vulnerability was higher in the low shared prey density and complex habitat. The IG prey consumption by the top predator was higher with the mosquito as shared prey than chironomid as shared prey. Observations on the prey consumption indicated that the consumption of both the chironomid and the mosquito prey dwindled with the time for all combinations of the prey density and the habitat conditions. On a comparative scale, the prey clearance rates were higher for mosquitoes in contrast to the chironomid larvae as shared prey. (4) Conclusions: Apparently, a complex set of interactions involving the habitat conditions, top predator and the prey determines mosquito prey vulnerability against the water bug. Such interactions provide evidence for the coexistence of the mosquito larvae along with multiple predators in the wetland ecosystem.

Predator and duck behaviours at depredated nests in wetlands of Great Salt Lake, Utah

Abstract Nest depredation is one of the greatest threats posed to ground-nesting ducks. We employed cameras to monitor 164 duck nests (71 cinnamon teal, Spatula cyanoptera, 44 gadwall, Mareca strepera, 38 mallard, Anas platyrhynchos, and 11 nests of unknown species) in the wetlands surrounding Great Salt Lake, from 2015–2021. Of the 164 nests, 21% were successful, 73% were depredated and 7% were abandoned. We observed predators at 99 of the 119 depredated nests; predators at 20 nests went undetected. Raccoons (Procyon lotor, depredated nests) and striped skunks (Mephitis mephitis, ) were the most common of the 99 nest predators recorded. Other predators that depredated nests included long-tailed weasels (Mustela frenata), northern harriers (Circus hudsonius), California gulls (Larus californicus), Sandhill cranes (Antigone canadensis), common ravens (Corvus corax), coyotes (Canis latrans) and red foxes (Vulpes vulpes). Neither the number of eggs removed per depredation event nor the number of eggs remaining varied by predator species. Depredated nests were easier for predators to find than undisturbed, incubated nests, resulting in 68% of depredated nests being visited by multiple predators. All hens detected the approach of a predator and flushed before the predator reached the nest; no hens attempted to defend their nest or attack the predator. Only 21% of hens returned to their depredated nest, and those that did remained off their nest an average of 33 h and 23 h after their nest was depredated by a raccoon or skunk, respectively. Seventeen percent of hens resumed incubation of their depredated nest, but only 1 nest to which a hen returned successfully hatched an egg. Depredation events of raccoons and skunks were not distributed randomly during the 24-hour day, but rather occurred most often during the night and nautical twilight, and rarely during the day. Depredation events of avian predators occurred during the day, rarely during twilight, and none during the night. Depredation events during the night were more likely when the wind was calm but temperature, humidity, and actual moon illumination had no impact. Depredation events by skunks and raccoons occurred more often during the 1st and 4th phases of the moon (new moon) than in the 2nd or 3rd phase.

Multiple predator effects are modified by search area and prey size

Multiple predator effects are modified by search area and prey size

High temperatures enhance the strength of multiple predator effects in a typical crab-clam system

Although marine heatwaves pose urgent threats to marine life, our understanding of how these events influence interactions between key species in marine ecosystems is still inadequate. Herein, we examined the behavioral mechanisms by which heat regulates multiple predator effects in different foraging systems that include Asian paddle crabs (Charybdis japonica) and swimming crabs (Portunus trituberculatus) by quantifying their predation and competition at two temperatures. Our results show that non-independent multiple predator effects occurred in the conspecific treatment of Asian paddle crabs and in the interspecific treatment, whereas independent multiple predator effects occurred in the conspecific treatment of swimming crabs. Asymmetrical behavior responses of these crabs to competition and heat triggered divergences in multiple predator effects. High temperatures increased the strength of multiple predator effects but did not alter their types. The reason is that heat negatively impacts predation by enhancing aggressive interactions, outweighing its direct positive effects on predation.

Identification of important forage fish and implications of increased predator demand through Ecopath modeling

Fisheries on lower trophic levels act as and compete with predators in aquatic ecosystems for potentially limited prey resources. Multiple predators in a system are often managed to achieve a Bmsy that could result in a total predator consumption level the ecosystem cannot support. We developed an Ecopath model for Pamlico Sound, NC and its tributaries to address this issue. The model is comprised of 43 compartments with an emphasis on piscivores and their prey and represents the 2012–13 time period. We estimated total predator demand for fish prey and identified important species of forage fish and top piscivorous predators in Pamlico Sound. We compared local fishing fleet removals and predator consumption in forage fish, penaeid shrimp, and blue crabs. Finally, we evaluated the impact of increased predator demand on the system, by increasing biomass levels of five predators to equal their management thresholds and using mixed trophic impact analysis. Atlantic menhaden (Brevoortia tyrannus), anchovy (Anchoa hepsetus and A. mitchilli), spot (Leiostomus xanthurus), and Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus) were the most important forage fish in the system, representing over 80% of the fish consumed (by weight). Lizardfish (Synodus foetens) and bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncates) were top predators based on trophic level, while bluefish and longnose gar (Lepisosteus osseus) were top predators in terms of total fish consumption. The highest overlap in forage fish usage exists between fisheries and piscivores for Atlantic croaker and spot. Total forage fish removals through predation and harvest was greater than 65% of the production for each of the four-forage fish and, under the higher predator biomass model, total removals exceeded production for spot; total removals in either scenario did not exceed the production of penaeid shrimp and blue crab. Thus, the tradeoff between fisheries for forage fish and piscivores should be considered when assessing and managing fisheries in Pamlico Sound.

Environmental and anthropogenic features mediate risk from human hunters and wolves for moose

AbstractLandscape characteristics, seasonal changes in the environment, and daylight conditions influence space use and detection of prey and predators, resulting in spatiotemporal patterns of predation risk for the prey. When predators have different hunting modes, the combined effects of multiple predators are mediated by the physical landscape and can result in overlapping or contrasting patterns of predation risk. Humans have become super‐predators in many anthropogenic landscapes by harvesting game species and competing with large carnivores for prey. Here, we used the locations of wolf (Canis lupus)‐killed and hunter‐killed moose (Alces alces) in south‐central Scandinavia to investigate whether environmental and anthropogenic features influenced where wolves and hunters killed moose. We predicted that the combined effects of wolves and hunters would result in contrasting spatial risk patterns due to differences in hunting modes. We expected these contrasting spatial risk patterns also to differ temporally. During the hunting season, the probability of a wolf kill increased with distance to bogs, whereas it decreased with increasing building density and distance to clearcuts and young forests. After the hunting season, the probability of a wolf kill increased with increasing terrain ruggedness and decreased with increasing building density, distance to main roads, and distance to clearcuts and young forests. The probability of a hunter kill was highest closer to bogs, main and secondary roads, in less rugged terrain and in areas with lower building density. Hunters killed all moose during the day, whereas wolves killed most moose at night during and after the hunting season. Our findings suggest that environmental and anthropogenic features mediate hunting and wolf predation risk. Additionally, we found that hunter‐ and wolf‐killed moose exhibited contrasting spatial associations to landscape features, most likely due to the different hunting modes displayed by hunters and wolves. However, wolf predation and hunting risks also contrasted over time since wolves killed mostly at night and hunters were restricted to hunting during daytime and during the hunting season. This temporal segregation in risk might therefore suggest that moose could minimize risk exposure by taking advantage of spatiotemporally vacant hunting domains.

The effect of water temperature, prey availability and presence of conspecifics on prey consumption of pikeperch (Sander lucioperca)

In this study, the effect of water temperature, predator’s sex, prey density, and the presence of conspecifics on prey consumption of pikeperch (Sander lucioperca) was experimentally tested. In Experiment 1, predators of both sexes [males: total length (TL) = 473 ± 22 mm and body weight (BW) = 1 070 ± 100 g and females: TL = 464 ± 12 mm and BW = 1 060 ± 100 g] were kept in separate tanks and exposed to different densities of prey (Pseudorasbora parva; 3, 6, 12, 24 and 48 prey fishes per tank) under fixed water temperatures of 4.5 °C, 8.5 °C, and 12.5 °C. After 63 days of this experiment, it was found that pikeperch predation was significantly affected by increasing water temperature. The effect of prey density was significant at all tested temperatures. Pikeperch females tended to have the higher prey consumption than males, although that trend was statistically insignificant. Results suggest that increased feeding demands at temperatures above 4.5 °C can lead to predator starvation in conditions of low prey availability. Due to the higher prey consumption, pikeperch females could be more vulnerable to low prey availability during their culture. In Experiment 2, pikeperch were kept at different densities of 1, 2, 4, and 8 individuals per tank supplied with a prey rate of 50 individuals per predator, ensuring ad libitum feeding rate. The average daily prey consumption was significantly higher in the tanks with multiple predators, accounting for 17.6 ± 3.57 prey fishes/day compared to 11.6 ± 2.33 prey fishes/day in the tank with a single predator. These results indicate that pikeperch predation activity and prey consumption can be significantly affected by the water temperature, prey availability, and the presence of conspecifics. The findings contribute to understanding the predatory function, natural feeding request of pikeperch and its potential importance for broodstock culture and broodstock final maturation for a successful spawning season. Also, this information can be used for better management of pikeperch pond aquaculture or bio-melioration process in open water bodies and ecosystems.