In 2013, Kedarnath, India, faced a devastating landslide-induced flood, causing substantial damage, loss of life, and displacement. This event highlights a gap in post-disaster relocation models, hindering efficient transportation to preferred locations. The challenge intensifies as coordinating relocation with individual preferences, coupled with post-disaster data uncertainty, complicates efforts and triggers a series of effects on community acceptance, psychological well-being, and overall resilience. The study addresses post-disaster relocation gaps by introducing a multi-objective transportation model (MOTM) with psychological support, optimizing resettlement to minimize budget impact, distance, and economic and social disruption (ESD). The proposed interval-valued pentagonal neutrosophic number (IVPN) and defuzzification technique advances disaster management theory and offers a practical solution for uncertainty in data, bridging theory, and practical application in the disaster response phase. The MOTM efficiently minimizes transportation, psychological intervention, and rental costs through fuzzy goal programming (FGP), global criterion method (GCM), and neutrosophic compromise approach (NCA), implemented with LINGO optimization software. The values of parameters considered in the MOTM are captured in IVPN format and converted to crisp values, availing the proposed defuzzification technique. The performance evaluation of the defuzzification technique is carried out through a comparative analysis of past literature. The proposed MOTM and IVPN were implemented in the 2013 Kedarnath flood case study to generate diverse relocation options. GCM provides relocation options at a higher cost and distance but with minimal ESD by providing a preferred location to a family count as high as 3324 out of 3491 families. The FGP technique provides results similar to NCP that reduce the costs and distance of the relocation process by 6.95% and 0.88%, respectively; however, it increases ESD by allocating preferred locations to only 2623 out of 3491 families. The study provides Pareto optimal solutions for the smooth application of MOTM for diverse post-disaster instances.