Multi-crystal Averaging Research Articles

Molecular symmetry-constrained systematic search approach to structure solution of the coiled-coil SRGAP2 F-BARx domain.

SRGAP2 (Slit-Robo GTPase-activating protein 2) is a cytoplasmic protein found to be involved in neuronal branching, restriction of neuronal migration and restriction of the length and density of dendritic postsynaptic spines. The extended F-BAR (F-BARx) domain of SRGAP2 generates membrane protrusions when expressed in COS-7 cells, while most F-BARs induce the opposite effect: membrane invaginations. As a first step to understand this discrepancy, the F-BARx domain of SRGAP2 was isolated and crystallized after co-expression with the carboxy domains of the protein. Diffraction data were collected from two significantly non-isomorphous crystals in the same monoclinic C2 space group. A correct molecular-replacment solution was obtained by applying a molecular symmetry-constrained systematic search approach that took advantage of the conserved biological symmetry of the F-BAR domains. It is shown that similar approaches can solve other F-BAR structures that were previously determined by experimental phasing. Diffraction data were reprocessed with a high-resolution cutoff of 2.2 Å, chosen using less strict statistical criteria. This has improved the outcome of multi-crystal averaging and other density-modification procedures.

Solving the RNA polymerase I structural puzzle.

Knowing the structure of multi-subunit complexes is critical to understand basic cellular functions. However, when crystals of these complexes can be obtained they rarely diffract beyond 3 Å resolution, which complicates X-ray structure determination and refinement. The crystal structure of RNA polymerase I, an essential cellular machine that synthesizes the precursor of ribosomal RNA in the nucleolus of eukaryotic cells, has recently been solved. Here, the crucial steps that were undertaken to build the atomic model of this multi-subunit enzyme are reported, emphasizing how simple crystallographic experiments can be used to extract relevant biological information. In particular, this report discusses the combination of poor molecular replacement and experimental phases, the application of multi-crystal averaging and the use of anomalous scatterers as sequence markers to guide tracing and to locate the active site. The methods outlined here will likely serve as a reference for future structural determination of large complexes at low resolution.

Native SAD Structure Solution from Merohedrally Twinned Data

Up until now, comparatively few structures were solved by native SAD. Recent advances in multi crystal averaging [1] have shown that native SAD can be applied to an increasing number of cases. Though theoretically possible [2], successful structure solutions from twinned data have not been reported yet. Here, we report the structure solution of the human Centromere protein M from a merohedrally twinned crystal with a twinning fraction of 0.45 in the space group P3. The data were collected at the bending magnet beamline X06DA at the Swiss Light Source, which is equipped with the in-house developed multi-axis goniometer PRIGo and the PILATUS 2M detector. A highly redundant 2.2 Å dataset was collected in a number of different crystal orientations. A substructure solution could only be obtained after 50000 SHELXD [3] tries. Automatic model building after phasing and density modification resulted in a model with the majority of residues built correctly. We will present this particularly difficult case together with other more routine cases, all solved with the same experimental setup and at the beamline X06DA.

Crystal structure of the human COP9 signalosome

The COP9 signalosome (CSN) is a multifunctional ~350 kDa eight-protein complex with highly-specific isopeptidase activity, which regulates the vast cullin-RING family of ubiquitin ligases (CRLs). Ubiquitin ligases direct target-specific ubiquitination and are involved in a multitude of regulatory processes, ultimately linked to protein turnover by the proteosome. Humans have a repertoire of approximately 240 CRLs, more than any other ubiquitin ligase family. The entire human CSN has been structurally characterised de novo using low-resolution (4-Å) X-ray crystallography. The crystallographic analysis was complicated by rotational pseudo-symmetry and twinning, non-isomorphism as well as the absence of experimental phase information beyond ~8 Å resolution. Details of the structure determination procedures, which combined a cluster compound-based phasing strategy, analysis of seven differentially substituted selenomethionyl derivatives, multi-crystal averaging among non-isomorphous data sets with a multi-crystal co-refinement approach, will be described. Some implications of the structure and insight into the regulation of CSN will also be presented.

Crystal structure of a novel non-Pfam protein PF2046 solved using low resolution B-factor sharpening and multi-crystal averaging methods

Sometimes crystals cannot diffract X-rays beyond 3.0 Å resolution due to the intrinsic flexibility associated with the protein. Low resolution diffraction data not only pose a challenge to structure determination, but also hamper interpretation of mechanistic details. Crystals of a 25.6 kDa non-Pfam, hypothetical protein, PF2046, diffracted X-rays to 3.38 Å resolution. A combination of Se-Met derived heavy atom positions with multiple cycles of B-factor sharpening, multi-crystal averaging, restrained refinement followed by manual inspection of electron density and model building resulted in a final model with a R value of 23.5 (R(free)= 24.7). The asymmetric unit was large and consisted of six molecules arranged as a homodimer of trimers. Analysis of the structure revealed the presence of a RNA binding domain suggesting a role for PF2046 in the processing of nucleic acids.

Structure determination using poorly diffracting membrane-protein crystals: the H+-ATPase and Na+,K+-ATPase case history

An approach is presented for the structure determination of membrane proteins on the basis of poorly diffracting crystals which exploits molecular replacement for heavy-atom site identification at 6-9 A maximum resolution and improvement of the heavy-atom-derived phases by multi-crystal averaging using quasi-isomorphous data sets. The multi-crystal averaging procedure allows real-space density averaging followed by phase combination between non-isomorphous native data sets to exploit crystal-to-crystal nonisomorphism despite the crystals belonging to the same space group. This approach has been used in the structure determination of H(+)-ATPase and Na(+),K(+)-ATPase using Ca(2+)-ATPase models and its successful application to the Mhp1 symporter using LeuT as a search model is demonstrated.

A description of the structural determination procedures of a gap junction channel at 3.5 A resolution.

Intercellular signalling is an essential characteristic of multicellular organisms. Gap junctions, which consist of arrays of intercellular channels, permit the exchange of ions and small molecules between adjacent cells. Here, the structural determination of a gap junction channel composed of connexin 26 (Cx26) at 3.5 A resolution is described. During each step of the purification process, the protein was examined using electron microscopy and/or dynamic light scattering. Dehydration of the crystals improved the resolution limits. Phase refinement using multi-crystal averaging in conjunction with noncrystallographic symmetry averaging based on strictly determined noncrystallographic symmetry operators resulted in an electron-density map for model building. The amino-acid sequence of a protomer structure consisting of the amino-terminal helix, four transmembrane helices and two extracellular loops was assigned to the electron-density map. The amino-acid assignment was confirmed using six selenomethionine (SeMet) sites in the difference Fourier map of the SeMet derivative and three intramolecular disulfide bonds in the anomalous difference Fourier map of the native crystal.

Interpreting a Low Resolution Map of Human U1 snRNP Using Anomalous Scatterers

SummaryWe recently determined the crystal structure of the functional core of human U1 snRNP, consisting of nine proteins and one RNA, based on a 5.5 Å resolution electron density map. At 5–7 Å resolution, α helices and β sheets appear as rods and slabs, respectively, hence it is not possible to determine protein fold de novo. Using inverse beam geometry, accurate anomalous signals were obtained from weakly diffracting and radiation sensitive P1 crystals. We were able to locate anomalous scatterers with positional errors below 2 Å. This enabled us not only to place protein domains of known structure accurately into the map but also to trace an extended polypeptide chain, of previously undetermined structure, using selenomethionine derivatives of single methionine mutants spaced along the sequence. This method of Se-Met scanning, in combination with structure prediction, is a powerful tool for building a protein of unknown fold into a low resolution electron density map.

３．５Ａ分解能でのギャップ結合チャネルの構造決定手順

Gap junctions, which consist of arrays of intercellular channels, permit the exchange of ions and small molecules between adjacent cells. Here, we describe the structural determination of a gap junction channel composed of connexin 26 at 3.5 Å resolution. During each step of the purification process, the protein was examined using electron microscopy and/or dynamic light scattering. Dehydration of the crystals improved the resolution limits. Phase refinement using multi-crystal averaging in conjunction with non-crystallographic symmetry averaging resulted in an electron density map for model building. The amino-acid sequence of a protomer structure was assigned to the electron density map.

Determining the Structure of an Unliganded and Fully Glycosylated SIV gp120 Envelope Glycoprotein

HIV/SIV envelope glycoproteins mediate the first steps in viral infection. They are trimers of a membrane-anchored polypeptide chain, cleaved into two fragments known as gp120 and gp41. The structure of HIV gp120 bound with receptor (CD4) has been known for some time. We have now determined the structure of a fully glycosylated SIV gp120 envelope glycoprotein in an unliganded conformation by X-ray crystallography at 4.0 A resolution. We describe here our experimental and computational approaches, which may be relevant to other resolution-limited crystallographic problems. Key issues were attention to details of beam geometry mandated by small, weakly diffracting crystals, and choice of strategies for phase improvement, starting with two isomorphous derivatives and including multicrystal averaging. We validated the structure by analyzing composite omit maps, averaged among three distinct crystal lattices, and by calculating model-based, SeMet anomalous difference maps. There are at least four ordered sugars on many of the thirteen oligosaccharides.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray diffraction studies of a fungal hydrolase from Ophiostoma novo-ulmi.

Dutch elm disease fungus Ophiostoma novo-ulmi contains a hydrolase activity which catalyses the resolution of racemic ethyl naproxen to the corresponding acid. The recombinant enzyme has been crystallized by the vapour-diffusion method in two crystal forms. The crystals of the first form belong to space group P2(1)2(1)2, with unit-cell parameters a = 115.9, b = 174.4, c = 62.1 A. The enzyme also crystallizes in space group P2(1)2(1)2, with unit-cell parameters a = 72.9, b = 212.7, c = 61.7 A. Synchrotron data have been collected for both crystal forms to 2.6 and 2.3 A, respectively. A molecular-replacement solution has been found using a remote starting model of a bacterial esterase (23% sequence identity) for both crystal forms. Multicrystal averaging has resulted in interpretable electron-density maps.

Solution of the structure of the cofactor-binding fragment of CysB: a struggle against non-isomorphism.

The elucidation of the structure of CysB(88-324) by multiple isomorphous replacement (MIR) techniques was seriously delayed by problems encountered at every stage of the analysis. There was extensive non-isomorphism both between different native crystals and between native and heavy-atom-soaked crystals. The heavy-atom substitution was invariably weak and different soaking experiments frequently led to substitution at common sites. These correlated heavy-atom binding sites resulted in an overestimation of the phase information. Missing low-resolution reflections in the native data set, constituting only 2% of the total observations, reduced the power of density modification and phase refinement. Finally, the extensive dimer interface made it difficult to isolate a single molecule in the course of model building into the MIR maps. The power of maximum likelihood refinement (REFMAC) was exploited in solving the structure by means of iterative cycles of refinement of a partial model, initially comprising only 30% of the protein atoms in the final coordinate set. This technique, which uses experimental phases, can automatically discriminate the correct and incorrect parts of electron-density maps and give properly weighted combined phases which are better than the experimental or calculated ones. This allowed the model to be gradually extended by manual building into improved electron-density maps. A model generated in this way, containing just 50% of the protein atoms, proved good enough to find the transformations needed for multi-crystal averaging between different crystal forms. The averaging regime im-proved the phasing dramatically such that the complete model could be built. The problems, final solutions and some possible causes for the observed lack of isomorphism are discussed.

The structure of the cofactor-binding fragment of the LysR family member, CysB: a familiar fold with a surprising subunit arrangement

CysB is a tetrameric protein of identical subunits (M(r) = 36,000) which controls the expression of genes associated with the biosynthesis of cysteine in bacteria. CysB is both an activator and a repressor of transcription whose activity is responsive to the inducer N-acetylserine; thiosulphate and sulphide act as anti-inducers. CysB is a member of the LysR family of prokaryotic transcriptional regulatory proteins which share sequence similarities over approximately 280 residues including a putative helix-turn-helix DNA-binding motif at their N terminus. The aims of the present study were to explore further the complex molecular biology and curious ligand binding properties of CysB and to provide structural insights into the LysR family of proteins. The crystal structure of a dimeric chymotryptic fragment of Klebsiella aerogenes CysB comprising residues 88-324, has been solved by multiple isomorphous replacement and multi-crystal averaging and refined against data extending to 1.8 A resolution. The protein comprises two alpha/beta domains (I and II) connected by two short segments of polypeptide. The two domains enclose a cavity lined by polar sidechains, including those of two residues whose mutation is associated with constitutive expression of the cysteine regulon. A sulphate anion and a number of well ordered water molecules have been modelled into discrete electron-density peaks within this cavity. In the dimer, strands beta B from domain I and strands beta G from domain II come together so that a pair of antiparallel symmetry-related 11-stranded twisted beta-pleated sheets is formed. The overall structure of CysB(88-324) is strikingly similar to those of the periplasmic substrate-binding proteins. A similar fold has also been observed in the cofactor-binding domain of Lac repressor, implying a structural relationship between the Lac repressor and LysR families of proteins. In contrast to Lac repressor, in CysB the twofold axis of symmetry that relates the monomers in the dimer is perpendicular rather than parallel to the long axis of the cofactor-binding domain. This seems likely to place the DNA-binding domains at opposite extremes of the molecule possibly accounting for CysB's extended DNA footprints.