MR Thermometry Measurements Research Articles

Magnetic resonance temperature imaging of laser-induced thermotherapy using proton resonance frequency shift: evaluation of different sequences in phantom and porcine brain at 7T.

The present study aimed to evaluate magnetic resonance (MR) thermometry using proton resonance frequency shift (PRFS) during laser-induced thermotherapy (LITT), and to compare the results of using different sequences at a field strength of 7-Tesla to identify the optimal for use in ablation so that the surrounding healthy tissues may be protected from damaging in real time. LITT was applied to agarose gel phantoms and ex-vivo porcine brains. We reconstructed both magnitude and phase images to perform MR thermometry based on PRFS methods. We tested four different sequences: a gradient-echo (GRE), a segmented gradient-echo echoplanar imaging (EPI-GRE), a fast-low angle shot (FLASH), and a true fast imaging with steady precession (TRUFI). Temperature was monitored and verified using a fiber-optic thermometry device. All sequences showed good linear correlations (R = 0.97-0.99) between the measured temperature and the calculated MR-thermometry measurements. The phantom/porcine brain experiments revealed the temperature precisions at 1.53/0.69°C (GRE), 0.61/0.43°C (EPI-GRE), 1.64/1.32°C (FLASH), and 0.58/1.52°C (TRUFI), respectively. Furthermore, we performed a Bland-Altman analysis and the temperature accuracies were found to be - 1.32/- 0.60°C (GRE), 0.42/- 0.33°C (EPI-GRE), - 1.28/- 0.98°C (FLASH), and 0.14/0.46°C (TRUFI) in the phantom/porcine brain experiments, respectively. Our experiments recommend that EPI-GRE sequence be the best of the all sequences for MR temperature imaging with PRFS in the LITT on 7T magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) systems because of its relatively higher precision and accuracy.

Measuring radiofrequency field-induced temperature variations in brain MRI exams with motion compensated MR thermometry and field monitoring.

An MR thermometry (MRT) method with motion and field fluctuation compensation is proposed to measure non-invasively sub-degree brain temperature variations occurring through radiofrequency (RF) power deposition during MR exams. MRT at 7T with a multi-slice echo planar imaging (EPI) sequence and concurrent field monitoring was first tested in vitro to assess accuracy in the presence of external field perturbations, an optical probe being used for ground truth. In vivo, this strategy was complemented by a motion compensation scheme based on a dictionary pre-scan, as reported in some previous work, and was adapted to the human brain. Precision reached with this scheme was assessed on eight volunteers with a 5 minute-long low specific absorption rate (SAR) scan. Finally, temperature rise in the brain was measured twice on the same volunteers and with the same strategy, this time by employing a 20-minutes scan at the maximum SAR delivered with a commercial volume head coil. In vitro, the root mean square (RMS) error between optical probe and MRT measurements was 0.02°C with field sensor correction. In vivo, the low SAR scan returned a precision in temperature change measurement with field monitoring and motion compensation of 0.05°C. The 20-minutes maximum SAR scan returned a temperature rise throughout the inner-brain in the range of 0-0.2°C. Brain periphery remained too sensitive with respect to motion to lead to equally conclusive results. Sub-degree temperature rise in the inner human brain was characterized experimentally throughout RF exposure. Potential applications include improvement of human thermal models and revision of safety margins.

A T1-based correction method for proton resonance frequency shift thermometry in breast tissue.

Develop and evaluate the effectiveness of a T1-based correction method for errors in proton resonant frequency shift thermometry due to non-local field effects caused by heating in fatty breast tissues. Computational models of human breast tissue were created by segmenting MRI data from a healthy human volunteer. MR-guided focused ultrasound (MRgFUS) heating and MR thermometry measurements were simulated in several locations in the heterogeneous segmented breast models. A T1-based correction method for PRF thermometry errors was applied and the maximum positive and negative errors and the root mean squared error (RMSE) in a region around each heating location was evaluated with and without correction. The method uses T1measurements to estimate the temperature change in fatty tissues and correct for their influence. Experimental data from a heating study in cadaver breast tissue were analyzed, and the expected PRFS error computed. The simulated MR thermometry had maximum single voxel errors ranging between 10% and 18% when no correction was applied. Applying the correction led to a considerable improvement, lowering the maximum error range to 2%-5%. The 5th to 95th percentile interval of the temperature error distribution was also lowered with correction, from approximately 3.5 to 1°C. This correction worked even when T1 times were uniformly raised or lowered by 5%-10%. The experimental data showed predicted errors of 15%. This simulation study demonstrates that the T1-based correction method reduces MR thermometry errors due to non-local effects from heating in fatty tissues, potentially improving the accuracy of thermometry measurements during MRgFUS treatments. The presented correction method is reliant on having a patient-specific 3D model of the breast, and may be limited by the accuracy of the fat temperatures which in turn may be limited by noise or bias present in the T1measurements.

A simple head-sized phantom for realistic static and radiofrequency characterization at high fields.

To demonstrate a simple head-sized phantom for realistic static and RF field characterization in high field systems. The head-sized phantom was composed of an ellipsoidal compartment and a spherical cavity to mimic the nasal cavity. The phantom was filled with an aqueous solution of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), to mimic the average dielectric properties of brain tissue. The static and RF field distributions were characterized on a 7T MRI system and compared to in vivo measurements and simulations. MR thermometry was performed, and the results were compared to thermal simulations for RF validation purposes. Accurate reproduction of both static and RF fields patterns observed in vivo was confirmed experimentally and was shown to be strongly affected by the inclusion of the spherical cavity. MR thermometry and transmit efficiency ( B1+) measurements were obtained in close agreement with simulations (peak values agreeing within 0.3 °C and 0.02 μT/√W) as well as fiber optic thermal probes (RMSE < 0.18 °C). A simple head-sized phantom has been presented that produces B0 and B1+ nonuniformities similar to those encountered in the human head and allows for accurate MR thermometry measurements, making this a suitable reference phantom for RF validation and methodological development in high field MRI.

Evaluation and selection of anatomic sites for magnetic resonance imaging-guided mild hyperthermia therapy: a healthy volunteer study

Purpose: Since mild hyperthermia therapy (MHT) requires maintaining the temperature within a narrow window (e.g. 40–43 °C) for an extended duration (up to 1 h), accurate and precise temperature measurements are essential for ensuring safe and effective treatment. This study evaluated the precision and accuracy of MR thermometry in healthy volunteers at different anatomical sites for long scan times.Methods: A proton resonance frequency shift method was used for MR thermometry. Eight volunteers were subjected to a 5-min scanning protocol, targeting chest wall, bladder wall, and leg muscles. Six volunteers were subjected to a 30-min scanning protocol and three volunteers were subjected to a 60-min scanning protocol, both targeting the leg muscles. The precision and accuracy of the MR thermometry were quantified. Both the mean precision and accuracy <1 °C were used as criteria for acceptable thermometry.Results: Drift-corrected MR thermometry measurements based on 5-min scans of the chest wall, bladder wall, and leg muscles had accuracies of 1.41 ± 0.65, 1.86 ± 1.20, and 0.34 ± 0.44 °C, and precisions of 2.30 ± 1.21, 1.64 ± 0.56, and 0.48 ± 0.05 °C, respectively. Measurements based on 30-min scans of the leg muscles had accuracy and precision of 0.56 ± 0.05 °C and 0.42 ± 0.50 °C, respectively, while the 60-min scans had accuracy and precision of 0.49 ± 0.03 °C and 0.56 ± 0.05 °C, respectively.Conclusions: Respiration, cardiac, and digestive-related motion pose challenges to MR thermometry of the chest wall and bladder wall. The leg muscles had satisfactory temperature accuracy and precision per the chosen criteria. These results indicate that extremity locations may be preferable targets for MR-guided MHT using the existing MR thermometry technique.

Non-invasive monitoring of branched Au nanoparticle-mediated photothermal ablation.

Nanoparticle-mediated photothermal therapy for treatment of different types of tumors has attracted tremendous attention in recent years. One major factor that drives this therapy is the ability to carefully control and prevent inadvertent damage to local tissues, while focusing therapeutic heating to specific regions of the tumor tissues. To this end, it is critical to generate efficient heating in the targeted tumors while monitoring the extent and distribution of heating. In our study, we demonstrated the photothermal heating properties of our synthesized branched Au nanoparticles (b-AuNPs) using non-invasive MR thermometry (MRT) techniques to assess its effects both in vitro and in vivo. 75 nm b-AuNPs were synthesized; these b-AuNPs demonstrated strong near infrared (NIR) absorption and high heat transducing efficiency. Proton resonance frequency MRT approaches for monitoring b-AuNPs mediated heating were validated using in vitro agar phantoms and further evaluated during in vivo animal model tumor ablation studies. In vitro phantom studies demonstrated a strong linear correlation between MRT and reference-standard thermocouple measurements of b-AuNPs-mediated heating upon NIR laser irradiation; temperatures increased with both an increase in laser power and increased exposure duration. Localized photothermal heating in regions containing the b-AuNPs was confirmed through MRT generated temperature maps acquired serially at increasing depths during both phantom and in vivo studies. Our results suggested that b-AuNPs exposed to NIR radiation produced highly efficient localized heating that can be accurately monitored dynamically using non-invasive MRT measurements. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater Res Part B: Appl Biomater, 105B: 2352-2359, 2017.

Evaluation of a three‐dimensional MR acoustic radiation force imaging pulse sequence using a novel unbalanced bipolar motion encoding gradient

MR guided focused ultrasound procedures require accurate focal spot localization in three dimensions. This study presents a three-dimensional (3D) pulse sequence for acoustic radiation force imaging (ARFI) that efficiently localizes the focal spot by means of ultrasound induced tissue displacement over a large field-of-view. A novel unbalanced bipolar motion encoding gradient was implemented to maximize time available for motion encoding, reduce echo times, and allow for longer echo train lengths. Two advanced features, kz reduction factor (KZRF) and kz -level interleaving, were implemented to reduce tissue heating. Studies in gelatin phantoms compared the location of peak displacement and temperature measured by 3D MR thermometry. MR-ARFI induced tissue heating was evaluated through a parametric study of sequence parameters and MR thermometry measurements during repeated application of ARFI sonication patterns. Sequence performance was characterized in the presence of respiration and tissue inhomogeneity. The location of peak displacement and temperature rise agreed within 0.2 ± 0.1 mm and 0.5 ± 0.3 mm in the transverse and longitudinal direction, respectively. The 3D displacement maps were acquired safely, and the KZRF and kz -level interleaving features reduced tissue heating by 51%. High quality displacement maps were obtained despite respiration and tissue inhomogeneities. This sequence provides a safe, accurate, and simple approach to localizing the focal spot in three dimensions with a single scan. Magn Reson Med 76:803-813, 2016. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Spatiotemporal filtering of MR-temperature artifacts arising from bowel motion during transurethral MR-HIFU.

Transurethral MR-HIFU is a minimally invasive image-guided treatment for localized prostate cancer that enables precise targeting of tissue within the gland. The treatment is performed within a clinical MRI to obtain real-time MR thermometry used as an active feedback to control the spatial heating pattern in the prostate and to monitor for potential damage to surrounding tissues. This requires that the MR thermometry measurements are an accurate representation of the true tissue temperature. The proton resonance frequency shift thermometry method used is sensitive to tissue motion and changes in the local magnetic susceptibility that can be caused by the motion of air bubbles in the rectum, which can impact the performance of transurethral MR-HIFU in these regions of the gland. A method is proposed for filtering of temperature artifacts based on the temporal variance of the temperature, using empirical and dynamic positional knowledge of the ultrasonic heating beam, and an estimation of the measurement noise. A two-step correction strategy is introduced which eliminates artifact-detected temperature variations while keeping the noise level low through spatial averaging. The filter has been evaluated by postprocessing data from five human transurethral ultrasound treatments. The two-step correction process led to reduced final temperature standard deviation in the prostate and rectum areas where the artifact was located, without negatively affecting areas distal to the artifact. The performance of the filter was also found to be consistent across all six of the data sets evaluated. The evaluation of the detection criterion parameter M determined that a value of M = 3 achieves a conservative filter with minimal loss of spatial resolution during the process. The filter was able to remove most artifacts due to the presence of moving air bubbles in the rectum during transurethral MR-HIFU. A quantitative estimation of the filter capabilities shows a systematic improvement in the standard deviation of the corrected temperature maps in the rectum zone as well as in the entire acquired slice.

In vitro demonstration of focused ultrasound thrombolysis using bifrequency excitation.

Focused ultrasound involving inertial cavitation has been shown to be an efficient method to induce thrombolysis without any pharmacological agent. However, further investigation of the mechanisms involved and further optimization of the process are still required. The present work aims at studying the relevance of a bifrequency excitation compared to a classical monofrequency excitation to achieve thrombolysis without any pharmacological agent. In vitro human blood clots were placed at the focus of a piezoelectric transducer. Efficiency of the thrombolysis was assessed by weighing each clot before and after sonication. The efficiencies of mono- (550 kHz) and bifrequency (535 and 565 kHz) excitations were compared for peak power ranging from 70 W to 220 W. The thrombolysis efficiency appears to be correlated to the inertial cavitation activity quantified by passive acoustic listening. In the conditions of the experiment, the power needed to achieve 80% of thrombolysis with a monofrequency excitation is reduced by the half with a bifrequency excitation. The thermal effects of bifrequency and monofrequency excitations, studied using MR thermometry measurements in turkey muscle samples where no cavitation occurred, did not show any difference between both types of excitations when using the same power level.

Accumulation of phase-shift nanoemulsions to enhance MR-guided ultrasound-mediated tumor ablation in vivo.

Magnetic resonance-guided high intensity focused ultrasound (MRgHIFU) is being explored as a non-invasive technology to treat solid tumors. However, the clinical use of HIFU for tumor ablation applications is currently limited by the long treatment times required. Phase-shift nanoemulsions (PSNE), consisting of liquid perfluorocarbon droplets that can be vaporized into microbubbles, are being developed to accelerate HIFU-mediated heating. The purpose of this study was to examine accumulation of PSNE in intramuscular rabbit tumors in vivo. MR images were acquired before and after intravenous injection of gadolinium-containing PSNE. MR signal enhancement was observed in rabbit tumors up to six hours after injection, indicating that PSNE accumulated in the tumors. In addition, PSNE vaporization was detected in the tumor with B-mode ultrasound imaging, and MR thermometry measurements indicated that PSNE accelerated the rate of HIFU-mediated heating. These results suggest that PSNE could dramatically improve the efficiency and clinical feasibility of MRgHIFU.

MR‐based Thermometry of Laser Induced Thermotherapy: Temperature Accuracy and Temporal Resolution In vitro at 0.2 and 1.5 T Magnetic Field Strengths

To evaluate MR-thermometry using fast MR sequences for laser induced interstitial thermotherapy (LITT) at 0.2 and 1.5 T systems. In-vitro experiments were performed using Agarose gel mixture and lobes of porcine liver. MR-thermometry was performed by means of longitudinal relaxation time (T1) and proton resonance frequency shift (PRF) methods under acquisition of amplitude and phase shift images. Four different sequences were used for T1 thermometry: A gradient-echo (GRE), a True Fast Imaging with Steady Precession (TRUFI), a Saturation Recovery Turbo-FLASH (SRTF), and an Inversion Recovery Turbo-FLASH (IRTF) sequence (FLASH-Fast Low Angle Shot). PRF was measured with four sequences: Two fast-spoiled GRE sequences (one as WIP sequence), a Turbo-FLASH (TFL) sequence (WIP sequence), and a multiecho-TrueFISP sequence. Temperature was controlled and verified using a fiber-optic Luxtron device. The temperature was correlated with the MR measurement. All sequences showed a good linear correlation R(2) = 0.97-0.99 between the measured temperature and the MR-thermometry measurements. The only exception was the TRUFI sequence in the Agarose phantom that showed a non-linear calibration curve R(2) = 0.39-0.67. At 1.5 T, the Agarose experiments revealed similar temperature accuracies of 4-6°C for all sequences excluding TRUFI. During experiments with the liver, the PRF sequences showed better performance than the T1, with accuracies of 5-12°C, contrary to the T1 sequences at 14-18°C. The accuracy of the Siemens PRF-FLASH sequence was 5.1°C. At 0.2 T, the Agarose experiments provided the highest accuracy of 3.3°C for PRF measurement. At the liver experiments the T1 sequences SRTF and FLASH revealed the best accuracies at 6.4 and 7.0°C. The accuracy and speed of MR temperature measurements are sufficient for controlling the temperature-based tumor destruction. For 0.2 T systems SRTF and FLASH sequences are recommended. For 1.5 T systems SRTF and FLASH are the most accurate.

Effects of air susceptibility on proton resonance frequency MR thermometry

The temperature dependence of the proton resonance frequency (PRF) is often used in MR thermometry. However, this method is prone to even very small changes in local magnetic field strength. Here, we report on the effects of susceptibility changes of surrounding air on the magnetic field inside an object and their inferred effect on the measured MR temperature. MR phase thermometry was performed on spherical agar phantoms enclosed in cylindrical containers at 7 T. The air susceptibility inside the cylindrical container was changed by both heating the air and changing the gas composition. Changing the temperature of surrounding air from 23 to 69°C caused an apparent MR temperature error of 2 K. When ambient air was displaced by 100% oxygen, the MR temperature error increased to 40 K. The magnetic field shift and therefore error in inferred MR temperature scales linearly with volume susceptibility change and has a strong and nontrivial dependence on the experimental configuration. Air susceptibility changes associated with oxygen concentration changes greatly affect PRF MR thermometry measurements. Air temperature changes can also affect these measurements, but to a smaller degree. For uncalibrated MR thermometry, air susceptibility changes may be a significant source of error.

MR thermometry-based feedback control of efficacy and safety in minimum-time thermal therapies: Phantom and in-vivo evaluations

The experimental validation of a model-based, thermal therapy control system which automatically and simultaneously achieves the specified efficacy and safety objectives of the treatment is reported. MR-thermometry measurements are used in real-time to control the power of a stationary, focused ultrasound transducer in order to achieve the desired treatment outcome in minimum time without violating the imposed safety constraints. Treatment efficacy is quantified in terms of the thermal dose delivered to the target. Normal tissue safety is ensured by automatically maintaining normal tissue temperature below the imposed limit in the user-specified locations. To reflect hardware limitations, constraints on the maximum applied power are also imposed. At the pretreatment stage, MR imaging and thermometry are used to localize the treatment target and identify thermal and actuation models. The results of phantom and canine experiments demonstrate that spatially-distributed, real-time MR temperature measurements enhance one's ability to robustly achieve the desired treatment outcome in minimum time without violating safety constraints. Post-treatment evaluation of the outcome using T2-weighted images of canine muscle showed good spatial correlation between the sonicated area and thermally damaged tissue.