Mouse Aggregation Chimaeras Research Articles

Re-evaluation of the causes of variation among mouse aggregation chimaeras.

ABSTRACTThe composition of adult mouse aggregation chimaeras is much more variable than X-inactivation mosaics. An early theoretical model proposed that almost all the extra variation in chimaeras arises, before X-inactivation occurs, by spatially constrained, geometrical allocation of inner cell mass (ICM) cells to the epiblast and primitive endoderm (PrE). However, this is inconsistent with more recent embryological evidence. Analysis of published results for chimaeric blastocysts and mid-gestation chimaeras suggested that some variation exists among chimaeric morulae and more variation arises both when morula cells are allocated to the ICM versus the trophectoderm (TE) and when ICM cells are allocated to the epiblast versus the PrE. Computer simulation results were also consistent with the conclusion that stochastic allocation of cells to blastocyst lineages in two steps, without the type of geometrical sampling that was originally proposed, could cause a wide variation in chimaeric epiblast composition. Later allocation events will cause additional variation among both chimaeras and X-inactivation mosaics. We also suggest that previously published U-shaped frequency distributions for chimaeric placenta composition might be explained by how TE cells are allocated to the polar TE and/or the subsequent movement of cells from polar TE to mural TE.

Selection against BALB/c strain cells in mouse chimaeras.

ABSTRACTIt has been shown previously that BALB/c strain embryos tend to contribute poorly to mouse aggregation chimaeras. In the present study we showed that BALB/c cells were not preferentially allocated to any extraembryonic lineages of mouse aggregation chimaeras, but their contribution decreased during the early postimplantation period and they were significantly depleted by E8.5. The development of BALB/c strain preimplantation embryos lagged behind embryos from some other strains and the contribution that BALB/c and other embryos made to chimaeras correlated with their developmental stage at E2.5. This relationship suggests that the poor contribution of BALB/c embryos to aggregation chimaeras is at least partly a consequence of generalised selection related to slow or delayed preimplantation development. The suitability of BALB/c embryos for maximising the ES cell contribution to mouse ES cell chimaeras is also discussed.

The effects of embryo stage and cell number on the composition of mouse aggregation chimaeras.

Studies with intact preimplantation mouse embryos and some types of chimaeric aggregates have shown that the most advanced cells are preferentially allocated to the inner cell mass (ICM) rather than the trophectoderm. Thus, differences between 4-cell and 8-cell stage embryos could contribute to the tendency for tetraploid cells to colonise the trophectoderm more readily than the ICM in 4-cell tetraploid<-->8 cell diploid chimaeras. The aim of the present study was to test whether 4-cell stage embryos in 4-cell diploid<-->8-cell diploid aggregates contributed equally to all lineages present in the E12.5 conceptus. These chimaeras were compared with those produced from standard aggregates of two whole 8-cell embryos and aggregates of half an 8-cell embryo with a whole 8-cell embryo. As expected, the overall contribution of 4-cell embryos was lower than that of 8-cell embryos and similar to that of half 8-cell stage embryos. In the 4-cell<-->8-cell chimaeras the 4-cell stage embryos did not contribute more to the trophectoderm than the ICM derivatives. Thus, differences between 4-cell and 8-cell embryos cannot explain the restricted tissue distribution of tetraploid cells previously reported for 4-cell tetraploid<-->8-cell diploid chimaeras. It is suggested that cells from the more advanced embryo are more likely to contribute to the ICM but, for technical reasons, are prevented from doing so in simple aggregates of equal numbers of whole 4-cell and whole 8-cell stage embryos.

A quantitative test for developmental neutrality of a transgenic lineage marker in mouse chimaeras

The mouse transgene, provisionally designated TgN(Hbb-b1)83Clo, was produced by Dr C. Lo by pronuclear injection of the cloned beta-major globin gene and comprises a highly reiterated sequence that is readily detected by DNA in situ hybridization on histological sections. This fulfils many of the requirements of an ideal genetic cell marker and has been widely used for lineage studies with mouse chimaeras. However, it is not known whether it causes cell selection or influences developmental processes, such as cell mixing, in chimaeric tissues. In the present study, non-transgenic genetic markers (electrophoretic polymorphisms of glucose phosphate isomerase and differences in eye pigmentation) revealed no significant effect of the presence of hemizygous transgenic cells on the overall composition, size or gross morphology of 12 1/2 d chimaeric foetuses, placentas or extraembryonic membranes. Also, a previously described maternal genetic effect on the composition of chimaeric tissues occurred in the presence or absence of the transgene. These tests have demonstrated that hemizygous cells are not at a significant selective disadvantage, when incorporated into mouse aggregation chimaeras with non-transgenic cells. Further studies are needed to test whether homozygous transgenic cells are also selectively neutral and to test whether hemizygous or homozygous transgenic cells influence developmental processes, such as cell mixing, that were not tested.

Quantitative analysis of mid-gestation mouse aggregation chimaeras: non-random composition of the placenta.

Mouse chimaeras were produced by aggregating eight-cell embryos from two different F2 matings, abbreviated to AF2 and BF2 respectively: (C57BL/ OIa.AKR-Gpi-1s a, c/Ws female × BALB/c male)F2 and (C57BL/Ws female × CBA/Ca male)F2. Quantitative electrophoresis of glucose phosphate isomerase (GPI-1) was used to estimate the proportions of the two cell populations in different tissues of the 12[Formula: see text] day chimàeric conceptuses, with the % GPI-1A indicating the percentage of cells derived from the AF2 embryos. The % GPI-1A was found to be highly positively correlated within the primitive ectoderm lineage (between the fetus, amnion and yolk sac mesoderm) and within the primitive endoderm lineage (between the yolk sac endoderm and the parietal endoderm) but no correlation (either positive or negative) was seen between the two lineages. This confirms the results of a previous,study of chimaeras made between partially congenic strains and suggests the original conclusions have general validity. The % GPI-1A in the placenta was corrected for the expected contribution of maternal GPI-1, based on control experiments involving transfer of homozygous Gpi-1s b /Gpi-1s b embryos to the uteri of Gpi-1s a /Gpi-1s a pseudopregnant females. The corrected % GPI- lA in the placenta was positively correlated with that in each of the three primitive ectoderm derivatives. This suggests either (1) exchange of cells between the polar trophectoderm and the underlying part of the inner cell mass that forms the primitive ectoderm or (2) cells are incompletely mixed in the chimaeric blastocyst and patches of AF2 and BF2 cells straddle the boundary between the polar trophectoderm and the underlying primitive ectoderm. The second explanation does not imply the existence of shared developmental lineages between trophectoderm and primitive ectoderm in non-chimaeric embryos. Unlike that of any other tissue, the distribution of placental GPI-1A was U-shaped; in 17/28 placenta samples the proportion of the minor component was 10% or less. This suggests that the placental trophoblast is derived from a small number of coherenct clones of polar trophectoderm cells (either a small number of polar trophectoderm cells or a larger number if the two cell populations are not finely intermingled). Thus, although as a population the placentas of chimaeric conceptuses are balanced with respect to the % GPI-1A (mean close to 50%), individually most placentas are extremely unbalanced in their chimaeric composition (< 10% or > 90% GPI-IA). This non-random composition of the chimaeric placentas is in contrast to the widely held assumption that the distribution of cells in chimaeric conceptuses is normally random.

Beige granules as a cell marker for clonal analysis in kidney and liver of mouse aggregation chimaeras, and three-dimensional reconstruction from serial paraffin sections.

Anomalous giant granules of beige (bg) mice have been used as a cell marker in the study of cell lineage of mast cells. Similar granules are known to exist in other tissues including kidney proximal tubules and liver parenchymal cells. In the present study, these granules were found to give yellow or orange autofluorescence when the tissue had been fixed with formaldehyde and embedded in paraffin. Thus, the granules can be used as a cell marker that can be visualized in serial paraffin sections without any specific histochemical staining. Chimaeric mice were produced by aggregation of 8-cell-stage embryos of beige (C57BL/6J-bgJ/bgJ) and A/J strains. The chimaeric liver showed beige cell patches with complicated shapes, although the patches frequently conformed to the shape of parenchymal cell cord or plate structures. In chimaeric kidney, beige cells formed coherent patches in the proximal tubules. The tubules were found to contain more than one clone. The patches frequently had long extended shapes suggesting growth of the clone along the tubule axis. Three-dimensional image reconstruction from the serial paraffin sections was carried out with the aid of a computer-assisted image analysis system, resulting in a clearer image of the patch shape.

Studies of Sl/Sl d↔ + / + mouse aggregation chimaeras : II. Effect of the steel locus on spermatogenesis

Mutant mice of Sl/Sld genotype are deficient in melanocytes, erythrocytes, mast cells and germ cells. Deficiency of melanocytes, erythrocytes and mast cells is not attributable to an intrinsic defect in their precursor cells but to a defect in the tissue environment that is necessary for migration, proliferation and/or differentiation. We investigated the mechanism of germ cell deficiency in male Sl/Sld mice by producing aggregation chimaeras from Sl/Sld and +/+ embryos. Chimaeric mice with apparent white stripes were obtained. Two of four such chimaeras were fertile and the phenotypes of resulting progenies showed that some Sl/Sld germ cells had differentiated into functioning sperms in the testis of the chimaeras. In cross sections of the testes of chimaeras, both differentiated and nondifferentiated tubules were observed. However, the proportions of type A spermatogonia to Sertoli cells in both types of tubules were comparable to the values observed in differentiated tubules of normal +/+ mice. We reconstructed the whole length of four tubules from serial sections. Differentiated and nondifferentiated segments alternated in a single tubule. The shortest differentiated segment contained about 180 Sertoli cells and the shortest nondifferentiated segment about 150 Sertoli cells. These results suggest that Sertoli cells of either Sl/Sld or +/+ genotype make discrete patches and that differentiation of type A spermatogonia does not occur in patches of Sl/Sld Sertoli cells.

Studies of Sl/Sld in equilibrium with +/+ mouse aggregation chimaeras. I. Different distribution patterns between melanocytes and mast cells in the skin.

In spite of their different origin, both melanocytes and mast cells are deficient in the skin of mutant mice of the Sl/Sld genotype. Since the neural crest and the liver of Sl/Sld embryos contain normal precursors of melanocytes and mast cells, respectively, the deficiency is attributed to a defect in tissue environment necessary for migration and/or differentiation of precursor cells. We investigated whether the tissue environment used for differentiation of melanocytes and mast cells was identical by producing aggregation chimaeras from Sl/Sld and +/+ embryos. Chimaeric mice with apparent pigmented and nonpigmented stripes were obtained. In the nonpigmented stripes of these Sl/Sld in equilibrium with +/+ chimaeras, melanocytes were not detectable in hair follicles but were detectable in the dermis. In contrast, melanocytes were detectable neither in hair follicles nor in the dermis of nonchimaeric Sl/Sld mice. Concentrations of mast cells were comparable in the pigmented and nonpigmented stripes of Sl/Sld in equilibrium with +/+ chimaeras, but the average concentration of mast cells significantly varied in the chimaeras (from 8% to 74% of the value observed in control +/+ mice). The present result suggests that mesodermal cells that support the migration and differentiation of both melanocyte precursors and mast-cell precursors mix homogeneously in the dermis and that ectodermal cells that influence the invasion of differentiating melanocytes into hair follicles make discrete patches.

Prenatal fate of parthenogenetic cells in mouse aggregation chimaeras

Parthenogenetically activated BCF1 and fertilized BALB/c embryos were aggregated to form chimaeras. The fate of the parthenogenetic component was followed in the conceptus during the second half of gestation. The results indicate an early strong selection against parthenogenetic cells in the extra-embryonal part, which is presumably complete by term, and a weaker selective process in the embryo. During early development, parthenogenetic cells have nearly normal developmental potency in the embryo, which allows their balanced contribution in the chimaeras on day 12. Later, this contribution declines significantly resulting in an unbalanced relation to the advantage of the fertilized counterpart. From the results, we suggest that gametic imprinting may play a role not only in the key steps of preimplantation and early postimplantation development, but later in cell and tissue differentiation.

Immunohistochemistry in the analysis of mouse aggregation chimaeras.

We have used cellular mosaicism in chimaeric mice to study the clonal organization of normal tissues. The mosaicism has been demonstrated in sections and in whole mounts of intestinal epithelium, aortic endothelium and retinal pigment epithelium using H2 antigens and a carbohydrate polymorphism recognized by Dolichos biflorus lectin as strain-specific markers. The results show that the epithelium of each adult intestinal crypt is derived from a single progenitor cell. Because crypts of differing genotype may contribute cells to the same villus, the pathways of cell migration up the villi can be demonstrated. The ability to stain mosaic patches in two dimensions in large intact sheets of epithelium has permitted a more satisfactory analysis in terms of clonal development than was previously possible with data from tissue sections. We have adapted statistical procedures from plant ecology to examine the scale of clustering of patches of like genotype, and thence to recognize 'descendent' clones, i.e. groups of cells which are not contiguous, but are related by descent from a common ancestor in embryogenesis.

Clonal analysis of chimaeric patterns in aortic endothelium

The mosaicism in aortic endothelium of mouse aggregation chimaeras is demonstrated using the lectin Dolichos biflorus agglutinin as a strain-specific marker. The general fragmentary appearance and considerable size range of patches suggests that endothelial cells do not proliferate in a highly coherent manner. The developmental significance of the observed patterns is investigated by means of a quantitative statistical analysis-the Greig-Smith analysis of variance. This method examines the spatial distribution of patches and is able to detect and characterize pattern at various scales. The results show that (1) patches are non-randomly distributed at all scales examined and (2) 'clusters of clusters' occur at one small and one large scale, defining territories of 'primary' and 'secondary' descendent clones, which arose respectively during early and late periods in the development of the endothelium. We conclude from this analysis that (1) cell mixing is never complete, even in the early embryo and (2) cell mingling is not uniform during development. A different pattern was previously demonstrated for intestinal epithelium (Schmidt, Wilkinson & Ponder, 1985c) indicating the potential value of the method for quantitative comparison of mosaicism between tissues and also different developmental stages. Our results suggest that the analysis of patch sizes is likely to be less informative in terms of developmental mechanisms, than the analysis of the spatial arrangement of patches.

Non-random spatial arrangement of clone sizes in chimaeric retinal pigment epithelium

Clonal analysis of whole-mount preparations of entire retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), using SWR in equilibrium C57BL/6JLac and DDK in equilibrium C3H/Bi mouse aggregation chimaeras in which one of the two parental components predominated, revealed a markedly non-random spatial arrangement of patch (clone) sizes. Single-cell and small patches predominated in an area around the optic nerve head while large patches occurred most frequently near the periphery. Mechanisms are discussed which may explain these results. Patch size frequency distributions were concave and skewed. Singletons were the most frequent size class, but a wide range of sizes and a smaller number of much larger patches were also always found. The results preclude the use of statistical methods previously employed to calculate clone sizes from the geometric means of observed patch sizes. Instead, the median and interquartile range may provide the best summary of the observed patch size frequency distributions. Our findings support a stochastic model of tissue growth.

Derivation of mouse intestinal crypts from single progenitor cells.

Adult intestinal epithelium consists of a sheet of single-cell thickness which is morphologically highly organized into tubular invaginations (crypts) and finger-like projections (villi). Proliferation of the cells is confined to the base of the crypts, from which cells migrate to the villi, where they are shed. The villi are formed during embryogenesis from a multilayered epithelium. In mice, crypts develop at about the time of birth from the epithelium between the villi, which by this stage is no longer multilayered. So far it has remained unknown how many progenitor cells contribute to each crypt, and whether they develop by the proliferation of already committed progenitors, or as a result of local inductive tissue interactions. Here, we have used mouse aggregation chimaeras as an experimental system to demonstrate immunohistochemically that the epithelium of individual crypts in small and large intestine of adult mice is always composed of cells of a single parental type. We have confirmed that this result is not an artefact of the chimaeric system by examining female mice that are mosaic for the X-linked alleles Pgk-1a and Pgk-1b. We conclude that the epithelium of each adult crypt is derived from a single progenitor cell.

Clonal analysis of intestinal crypt populations in mouse aggregation chimaeras

The epithelium of each individual intestinal crypt in adult mouse aggregation chimaeras is composed of cells of a single parental genotype (Ponder et al. 1985). Using a carbohydrate polymorphism recognized by Dolichos biflorus agglutinin as a strain-specific marker on entire sheets of intestinal mucosa, we have analysed the two-dimensional mosaic patterns of patches of the chimaeric intestinal crypt population. The relative proportions of each genotype varied greatly along the length of any one intestine. In chimaeras with highly unbalanced proportions, the minority component occurred as discrete patches. Patches of single or a few crypts were most frequent, but a smaller number of much larger patches was always present. The size frequency distribution of discrete patches was highly concave and departed significantly from a geometric distribution (a model for non-differential proliferation), but fitted the more skewed negative binomial model. The data are consistent with the interpretation that most progenitor crypts never or rarely divide, while a minority proliferate to a greater extent. We discuss ways in which our system could be analysed further to examine this interpretation. Our results also support Whitten's (1978) conclusion from a computer simulation that the mean patch size, as it has previously been used in statistical analyses of chimaeric tissue, 'is not a reliable statistic on which to judge mosaicism'.

Viability of trisomy 12 cells in mouse chimaeras

Mouse aggregation chimaeras consisting of trisomy 12 and normal euploid cells were produced. The analysis of one trisomy 12↔euploid chimaera, using biochemical and cytological markers, showed that the trisomic cells were able to participate in the formation of most tissues including the ovary. On the other hand, no trisomy 12 cells were found in lymphocyte populations, which is most likely due to early selection in this particular cell lineage. The viability of two adult trisomy 12 chimaeras demonstrates that trisomy 12 cells are able to develop beyond the fetal stage which is not observed in completely trisomic fetuses.

Investigation of variability among mouse aggregation chimaeras and X-chromosome inactivation mosaics

Mouse aggregation chimaeras were produced by aggregating C3H/HeH and C3H/HeHa-Pgk-1a/Ws embryos. At mid-term the proportions of the two cell populations in these conceptuses and the X-inactivation mosaic female progeny of C3H/HeH female X C3H/HeHa-Pgk-1a/Ws male matings were estimated using quantitative electrophoresis of phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK-1) allozymes. The percentage of PGK-1B was more variable in the foetus, amnion and yolk sac mesoderm of the chimaeras than in the corresponding tissues of the mosaic conceptuses. Positive correlations were found for the percentage of PGK-1B between these three primitive ectoderm tissues in both chimaeras and mosaics and between the two primitive endoderm tissues (yolk sac endoderm and parietal endoderm) of the chimaeras. There was no significant correlation between the primitive ectoderm and primitive endoderm tissues of the chimaeras. The results suggest that unequal allocation of cell populations to the primitive ectoderm and primitive endoderm considerably increases the variability among chimaeras but variation probably exists before this segregation occurs. The variation that arises before and at this allocation event is present before X-chromosome inactivation occurs in the primitive ectoderm lineage and explains why the proportions of the two cell populations are more variable among chimaeras than mosaics. Additional variation arises within the primitive ectoderm lineage, after X-inactivation. This variation may be greater in chimaeras than mosaics but the evidence is inconclusive. The results also have some bearing on the nature of the allocation of cells to the primitive ectoderm and primitive endoderm lineages and the timing of X-chromosome inactivation in the primitive ectoderm lineage.

Thymus differentiation and T-cell specificity in nu/nu +/+ mouse aggregation chimaeras.

Thymus development and T cell differentiation were studied in mouse chimaeras produced by aggregating pre-implantation embryos of thymus-deficient nude BALB/c (nu/nu) and wild-type C57BL/6 (+/+) mice and vice versa. Chimaeras showed mosaic distribution of skin and coat pigmentation, of hair follicles, of glucosephosphate isomerase within all tested organs and of lymphocytes expressing the different major transplantation antigens (H-2). When tested for their capacity to generate vaccinia virus-specific and self-H-2 specific cytotoxic T cells, all chimaeras of BALB/c (nu/nu) H-2d in equilibrium C57BL/6 (+/+) H-2b type generated T cells of one or both parental origins that were specific for virus and for self-H-2 of the +/+ (H-2b) type only. In contrast, some BALB/c (+/+) H-2d in equilibrium C57BL/6 (nu/nu) H-2b chimaeras generated vaccinia virus-specific cytotoxic T cells specific for either H-2d (+/+) type or for H-2b (nu/nu) type. These asymmetrical results can be interpreted to indicate the following: (i) The +/+ thymus part alone is functional, but because of asymmetrical cross-reactivities of anti-self-H-2 specificities, the observed T cell restriction phenotypes differ. (ii) Both nu/nu and +/+ thymus parts are functional but immune response defects may be exaggerated in such chimaeras producing unexpected non-responsiveness to vaccinia virus linked to H-2d in H-2b (+/+) in equilibrium H-2d (nu/nu).

Clonal development of the retinal epithelium in mouse chimaeras and X-inactivation mosaics

ABSTRACT A comparative study of coherent clones in the retinal epithelium is presented for mouse aggregation chimaeras and X-inactivation mosaics. There is a basic similarity in the number of coherent clones and the pattern of clonal development between mosaics and chimaeras. While this similarity is compatible with the difference in mean patch size reported by other authors this is at variance with some interpretations of previous work and suggests that no conclusive evidence on the timing of X-inactivation is provided by comparisons of patch sizes between chimaeras and mosaics. The present clonal analysis also suggests that at days post coitum the cells in the retinal epithelium are distributed almost randomly while, in the adult, the cells are grouped into small coherent clones, which comprise an average of five or six nuclei. However, these data could also be explained by larger, irregular coherent clones.

A theoretical approach to the relation between patch size and clone size in chimaeric tissue

A simple model is used to investigate the relationship between clone number and patch number for each of two cell types in one and two-dimensional arrays. Considering the two cell types separately, this relationship is shown to vary with the relative proportions of the two cell types. If both cell types are considered, the total number of patches in a one-dimensional array reaches a maximum when the two cell types are present in equal proportions. Over the range considered for a two-dimensional array, the total number of patches is at a minimum when the two cell types are present in equal proportions because aggregation of patches is then maximal. The significance of these results is discussed in the light of previous interpretations of work with mouse aggregation chimaeras.