Motion Direction Discrimination Task Research Articles

Comparing conventional and action video game training in visual perceptual learning.

Action video game (AVG) playing has been found to transfer to a variety of laboratory tasks in visual cognition. More recently, it has even been found to transfer to low-level visual "psychophysics tasks. This is unexpected since such low-level tasks have traditionally been found to be largely "immune" to transfer from another task, or even from the same task but a different stimulus attribute, e.g., motion direction. In this study, we set out to directly quantify transfer efficiency from AVG training to motion discrimination. Participants (n = 65) trained for 20h on either a first-person active shooting video game, or a motion direction discrimination task with random dots. They were tested before, midway, and after training with the same motion task and an orientation discrimination task that had been shown to receive transfer from AVG training, but not from motion training. A subsequent control group (n = 18) was recruited to rule out any test-retest effect, by taking the same tests with the same time intervals, but without training. We found that improvement in motion discrimination performance was comparable between the AVG training and control groups, and less than the motion discrimination training group. We could not replicate the AVG transfer to orientation discrimination, but this was likely due to the fact that our participants were practically at chance for this task at all test points. Our study found no evidence, in either accuracy or reaction time, that AVG training transferred to motion discrimination. Overall, our results suggest that AVG training transferred little to lower-level visual skills, refining understanding of the mechanisms by which AVGs may affect vision. Protocol registration The accepted stage 1 protocol for this study can be found on the Open Science Framework at https://osf.io/zdv9c/?view_only=5b3b0c161dad448d9d1d8b14ce91ab11 . The stage 1 protocol for this Registered Report was accepted in principle on 01/12/22. The protocol, as accepted by the journal, can be found at: https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/ZDV9C.

Time courses of brain plasticity underpinning visual motion perceptual learning

Visual perceptual learning (VPL) refers to a long-term improvement of visual task performance through training or experience, reflecting brain plasticity even in adults. In human subjects, VPL has been mostly studied using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). However, due to the low temporal resolution of fMRI, how VPL affects the time course of visual information processing is largely unknown. To address this issue, we trained human subjects to perform a visual motion direction discrimination task. Their behavioral performance and magnetoencephalography (MEG) signals responding to the motion stimuli were measured before, immediately after, and two weeks after training. Training induced a long-lasting behavioral improvement for the trained direction. Based on the MEG signals from occipital sensors, we found that, for the trained motion direction, VPL increased the motion direction decoding accuracy, reduced the motion direction decoding latency, enhanced the direction-selective channel response, and narrowed the tuning profile. Following the MEG source reconstruction, we showed that VPL enhanced the cortical response in early visual cortex (EVC) and strengthened the feedforward connection from EVC to V3A. These VPL-induced neural changes co-occurred in 160–230 ms after stimulus onset. Complementary to previous fMRI findings on VPL, this study provides a comprehensive description on the neural mechanisms of visual motion perceptual learning from a temporal perspective and reveals how VPL shapes the time course of visual motion processing in the adult human brain.

How to reward animals based on their subjective percepts: A Bayesian approach to online estimation of perceptual biases.

Elucidating the neural basis of perceptual biases, such as those produced by visual illusions, can provide powerful insights into the neural mechanisms of perceptual inference. However, studying the subjective percepts of animals poses a fundamental challenge: unlike human participants, animals cannot be verbally instructed to report what they see, hear, or feel. Instead, they must be trained to perform a task for reward, and researchers must infer from their responses what the animal perceived. However, animals' responses are shaped by reward feedback, thus raising the major concern that the reward regimen may alter the animal's decision strategy or even intrinsic perceptual biases. We developed a method that estimates perceptual bias during task performance and then computes the reward for each trial based on the evolving estimate of the animal's perceptual bias. Our approach makes use of multiple stimulus contexts to dissociate perceptual biases from decision-related biases. Starting with an informative prior, our Bayesian method updates a posterior over the perceptual bias after each trial. The prior can be specified based on data from past sessions, thus reducing the variability of the online estimates and allowing it to converge to a stable estimate over a small number of trials. After validating our method on synthetic data, we apply it to estimate perceptual biases of monkeys in a motion direction discrimination task in which varying background optic flow induces robust perceptual biases. This method overcomes an important challenge to understanding the neural basis of subjective percepts.

Distinct basal ganglia contributions to learning from implicit and explicit value signals in perceptual decision-making

Metacognitive evaluations of confidence provide an estimate of decision accuracy that could guide learning in the absence of explicit feedback. We examine how humans might learn from this implicit feedback in direct comparison with that of explicit feedback, using simultaneous EEG-fMRI. Participants performed a motion direction discrimination task where stimulus difficulty was increased to maintain performance, with intermixed explicit- and no-feedback trials. We isolate single-trial estimates of post-decision confidence using EEG decoding, and find these neural signatures re-emerge at the time of feedback together with separable signatures of explicit feedback. We identified these signatures of implicit versus explicit feedback along a dorsal-ventral gradient in the striatum, a finding uniquely enabled by an EEG-fMRI fusion. These two signals appear to integrate into an aggregate representation in the external globus pallidus, which could broadcast updates to improve cortical decision processing via the thalamus and insular cortex, irrespective of the source of feedback.

The possible positive effects of physical exercise on the global motion perception aging: the cognitive mechanism.

Sensitivity to global motion perception (GMP) decreases gradually with age, and the mechanism to effectively alleviate its aging process is still unclear. This study aimed to examine the impact and mechanism of exercise on GMP aging. This study adopted the global motion direction discrimination task and used motion coherence thresholds to assess GMP sensitivity. It adopted the perceptual template model (PTM) to fit the GMP processing efficiency. The threshold for the elderly group with no exercise was higher than that of the elderly group with exercise, while the threshold of the latter was higher than that of the youth group. The results of the model fitting showed that both models, Aa and Af, corresponding to the elderly group with exercise and the elderly group with no exercise, respectively, were the best-fitted models when compared with that of the youth group. Compared to the elderly group with no exercise, models Aa and Af, were the best-fitted models. These results showed that good exercise habits might have a certain degree of positive effect on GMP aging, by lower their internal additive noise (Aa), and improve the ability to eliminate external noise (Af).

Transcranial static magnetic field stimulation over hMT+ inhibits visual motion discriminability

Visuomotor performance acting on a moving target is fundamentally based on visual motion discriminability, and its neural basis is presumed to be human MT (hMT+), a motion vision center of the dorsal visual pathway. In this study, we investigated whether and how the accuracy and speed of motion discrimination are affected by applying transcranial static magnetic field stimulation (tSMS) to hMT+, which reduces cortical excitability. Sixteen participants performed a motion direction discrimination (MDD) task using a random dot kinematogram before (Pre-test) and during (During-test) application of the tSMS over left hMT+. The correct rate of the MDD task was significantly lower in the During-test compared to the Pre-test, an effect not seen with the sham condition. The inhibition effects were observed only for the right visual field corresponding to hMT+ in the stimulated hemisphere. On the other hand, no modulatory effect of tSMS was observed in the reaction time. We, therefore, demonstrated the inhibitory effect of tSMS on the left hMT+ impairs the accuracy but not the speed of motion information processing in the contralateral visual field.

EEG‐based Analysis Reveals Different Effective Connectivity Patterns between Healthy Controls and MCI Patients in Motion Detection Tasks

AbstractBackgroundBrain connectivity has been proposed to identify people at risk for mild cognitive impairment (MCI). Existing work has mainly focused on functional connectivity which reflects the mutual dependence between brain regions. Effective connectivity, which represents the directed connectivity from one brain region to the other, is expected to provide more details on directed information flow in the brain network. The present study investigates how cognitive engagement changes the effective connectivity in the brain.MethodOur research focuses on task‐based EEG (64‐channel), where participants were asked to perform a motion direction discrimination task. The current dataset includes 56 consensus‐diagnosed, community‐dwelling African Americans (ages 60‐90 years, 28 healthy controls (HC) and 28 MCI patients) recruited through the Wayne State Institute of Gerontology and Michigan Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center with subjective cognitive complaints.We evaluated the effective connectivity at different time periods of the motion‐detection task across all the possible EEG region pairs using causalized convergent cross‐mapping (cCCM) of the current source density. For each task trial, the successive time periods being examined included: (I) stimulus onset to Go indication, (II) Go indication to motion‐stop, and (III) the button‐press period. For each subject, we calculated the mean, maximum and minimum of the cCCM vector for each EEG region pair and each time‐period, then selected the region pairs where the cCCM‐based effective connectivity of HC and MCI show a significant difference (p‐value<0.05).ResultOur analysis indicated that typically, MCI participants show more active effective connectivity or need more effort from stimulus onset to Go indication and then to motion stop, but HC participants show higher maximum and minimum effective connectivity values during the button‐press period, where coherent coordination is required among many region pairs.ConclusionHC and MCI do show significant differences in effective connectivity during each of the three periods of a motion detection task (marked by stimulus onset, Go indication, and button‐press) over many region pairs. Our analysis provides a massive pool of possible features for future biomarker development for effective discrimination of HC and MCI. Funding: NSF‐2032709/Li; NIH‐1R21AG046637‐01A1/Kavcic and NIH‐1R01AG054484‐01A1/Kavcic; NIH‐P30AG053760/Paulson and NIH‐P30AG072931/Paulson.

Differences in Functional Connectivity between Normal Controls and Mild Cognitive Impairment in Motion Detection Tasks

AbstractBackgroundIt has long been observed that the abnormal brain functions in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and mild cognitive impairment (MCI) are closely related to the weakening or loss of functional connectivity across certain brain regions. At the same time, the decreased cross‐connectivity is often accompanied by increased connectivity between some other regions, and this was considered to reflect the compensatory mechanisms of the brain. In this research, we investigate the differences in time‐varying functional connectivity between normal controls (NC) and MCI patients in motion detection tasks.MethodOur research is based on task‐based EEG (64‐channel), where the participants were asked to perform a motion direction discrimination task. The current dataset includes 60 consensus‐diagnosed, community‐dwelling African Americans (ages 60‐90 years, 30 NC and 30 MCI) recruited through the Wayne State Institute of Gerontology Healthy Black Elders Center and the Michigan Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center with subjective cognitive complaints.We evaluated the time‐varying functional connectivity at different time periods of the motion‐detection task across all the possible EEG region pairs, in terms of the Pearson correlation vector of the current source density. For each task trial, the successive time periods being examined included: stimulus onset to Go/NoGo indication, Go/NoGo indication to motion‐stop, and the button‐press period. For each subject, we calculated the mean, maximum and minimum of the Pearson correlation vector for each EEG region pair and each time period as features, and then selected the features where NC and MCI show a significant difference (p‐value<0.05 in the t‐test).ResultOur analysis indicated that NC shows significantly higher connectivity across EEG region pairs Right Frontal‐Left Central (through most periods), Left Temporal‐Medial Central and Left Temporal‐Occipital (in button‐press period). On the other hand, MCI shows signigicantly high connectivity across Medial Parietal‐Occipital (through all the periods), which may reflect the compensatory mechanisms of the brain.ConclusionHC and MCI do show significant difference in functional connectivity during the motion detection task, and the EEG regions pairs Medial Parietal‐Occipital, and Right Frontal‐Left Central shown to be excellent choices for biomarker development for the discrimination of NC and MCI.Funding: NSF‐2032709/Li; NIH‐ P30AG05376004/Paulson; NIH‐1R21AG046637‐01A1/Kavcic and NIH‐1R01AG054484‐01A1/Kavcic;

Mild Cognitive Impairment in African Americans Is Associated with Differences in EEG Theta/Beta Ratio.

Identification of older individuals with increased risk for cognitive decline can contribute not only to personal benefits (e.g., early treatment, evaluation of treatment), but could also benefit clinical trials (e.g., patient selection). We propose that baseline resting-state electroencephalography (rsEEG) could provide markers for early identification of cognitive decline. To determine whether rsEEG theta/beta ratio (TBR) differed between mild cognitively impaired (MCI) and healthy older adults. We analyzed rsEEG from a sample of 99 (ages 60-90) consensus-diagnosed, community-dwelling older African Americans (58 cognitively typical and 41 MCI). Eyes closed rsEEGs were acquired before and after participants engaged in a visual motion direction discrimination task. rsEEG TBR was calculated for four midline locations and assessed for differences as a function of MCI status. Hemispheric asymmetry of TBR was also analyzed at equidistant lateral electrode sites. Results showed that MCI participants had a higher TBR than controls (p = 0.04), and that TBR significantly differed across vertex location (p < 0.001) with the highest TBR at parietal site. MCI and cognitively normal controls also differed in hemispheric asymmetries, such that MCI show higher TBR at frontal sites, with TBR greater over right frontal electrodes in the MCI group (p = 0.003) and no asymmetries found in the cognitively normal group. Lastly, we found a significant task aftereffect (post-task compared to pre-task measures) with higher TBR at posterior locations (Oz p = 0.002, Pz p = 0.057). TBR and TBR asymmetries differ between MCI and cognitively normal older adults and may reflect neurodegenerative processes underlying MCI symptoms.

Optimal policy for uncertainty estimation concurrent with decision making

Decision making often depends on vague information that leads to uncertainty, which is a quantity contingent not on choice but on probability distributions of sensory evidence and other cognitive variables. Uncertainty may be computed in parallel and interact with decision making. Here, we adapt the classic random-dot motion direction discrimination task to allow subjects to indicate their uncertainty without having to form a decision first. The subjects' choices and reaction times for perceptual decisions and uncertainty responses are measured, respectively. We then build a value-based model in which decisions are based on optimizing value computed from a drift-diffusion process. The model accounts for key features of subjects' behavior and the variation across the individuals. It explains how the addition of the uncertainty option affects perceptual decision making. Our work establishes a value-based theoretical framework for studying uncertainty and perceptual decisions that can be readily applied in future investigations of the underlying neural mechanism.

Asymmetries in the theta/beta ratio distinguish cognitively normal elderly from those with mild cognitive impairment

AbstractBackgroundThe search for psychophysiological markers that distinguish normal from abnormal aging has produced many candidate EEG dynamics, but relatively little research has been done (or at least reported) on the theta/beta ratio or brain wave asymmetries.MethodsWe previously reported frontal asymmetries (frontal alpha and frontal beta asymmetry) originally investigated in the context of anxiety and approach‐avoidance motivation that distinguish MCI from healthy, cognitively normal persons (HC). Another potentially more cognitively‐involved marker, the ratio of theta to beta frequencies (TBR), originally investigated as a marker of attention deficits, might also usefully distinguish cognitive HC from MCI. We took advantage of a previously collected data set to conduct an exploratory analysis of the pattern of TBR in HC and MCI participants. Resting state EEG (rsEEG) was measured before and after a simple motion direction discrimination task. We investigated the standard frontal TBR as measured at frontal electrode FZ. We estimated power spectral density in the resting state (eyes closed) for both pre‐ and post‐task, extracting estimates of TBR at electrode Fz.ResultsWe found that MCI had significantly higher TBR than cognitively normal elderly, F(1,95)=4.98, p=0.028, with no effect of timepoint and no interaction. We then explored the possibility that TBR itself has meaningful asymmetries, calculating the TBR asymmetry at the following electrode pairs: F3‐F4, C3‐C4, CP3‐CP4, P3‐P4, PO3‐PO4. This analysis revealed an interesting pattern, with group (HC vs. MCI) interacting with location, F(4,380)=5.25, p&lt;0.001. Relative to HC, MCI participants had higher TBR on the right (positive TBR asymmetry) in frontal electrodes (F3‐F4), but higher TBR on the left (negative TBR asymmetry) over parietal‐occipital sites (P3‐P4 and PO3‐PO4). The parietal asymmetry may reflect the early spread of lesions from inferior temporal regions to areas subserving language and visuospatial processing, but the frontal asymmetry is less obviously tied to known progression of brain lesions, and may reflect heterogeneity in the underlying pathogenesis of this sample of people with MCI.ConclusionTBR asymmetries obtained in rsEEG can contribute significantly to successful discrimination of older persons with MCI from those with normal cognitive functioning.

Pre vs post‐task modulation of resting state EEG functional connectivity and network topology

AbstractBackgroundRecently, we have shown a significant decrease in resting‐state EEG (rsEEG) spectral power at post‐task as compared to pre‐task cognitive engagement in older adults. Further, older adults with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) showed greater decreases in rsEEG in temporal and central cortical regions at post‐task than healthy controls (HC). Here, we present functional connectivity (FC) and network topology derived from the same pre‐ to post‐rsEEG changes.MethodWe studied a sample of community dwelling African American older participants over age 60 years, consisting of consensus‐based diagnosis for 58 HC and 41 MCI. rsEEGs were recorded before and after approximately 20 minutes of a visual motion direction discrimination task. FC between channels was assessed by the phase lag index, while minimum spanning tree (MST) was used to characterize network topology.ResultFor both HC and MCI groups, when compared to pre‐task measurements, the post‐task FC was significantly increased within the middle frontal, middle central, and left temporal regions in the lower alpha frequency band. An opposite pattern with decreased FC was found within the right parietal region in the delta, theta, lower alpha, upper alpha, and beta frequency bands. In contrast, compared to HC, the MCI group did show significantly decreased FC within the middle frontal region in the delta band, following the cognitive task. All results from network topology failed to demonstrate differences between HC and MCI. On average, both groups' post‐task functional network topology showed significant decreased eccentricity and diameter in the delta and beta bands, indicating a higher global network integration.ConclusionOur findings suggest that visual‐based cognitive engagement affects both post‐task FC and network topology similarly in both HC and MCI. For the most part, increased FC and functional topology in both groups are likely associated with after‐task effects, resulting from additional time to return to baseline, though decreased FC in MCI as compared to HC was seen within the middle frontal region in the delta. Our results demonstrate that both FC and topoloty are responsive to cognitive challenge, though frontal/executive‐driven differences in FC may be an area of future promise in distinguishing HC and MCI.

Daily fluctuations in visual motion discriminability contribute to daily fluctuations in continuous visuomotor performance.

In ball sports such as table tennis, in which a ball moving at high speed is hit, an athlete's brain needs to process the motion information of the ball, predict the arrival point, and form a motor command to direct the racket there. Therefore, day-to-day fluctuations in visuomotor performance may be ascribed to fluctuations in visual motion discriminability, but it is not clear how the two are related. To examine this point, university table tennis players performed a motion direction discrimination (MDD) task and continuous visuomotor (CVM) task over 10 days as an estimation of visual motion discriminability and visuomotor performance, respectively. In the MDD task, using a joystick, participants distinguished the direction of a global coherent motion of target dots moving in the same direction on a PC monitor from innumerable dots moving in random directions. In the CVM task, participants hit sequential targets moving fast from right to left on the PC monitor by operating the cursor on the left side of the monitor up and down using the prehensile force of their thumb and index finger. The scores in the MDD and CVM tasks fluctuated day by day and showed a significant and moderate correlation between the MDD task score for the visual field in which the participants captured the target in the CVM task and the CVM task score. This correlation was confirmed even with the target moving from left to right. The fluctuations in the onset latency and the endpoint position of the cursor movement approaching the target were correlated with those of the visual motion discriminability, suggesting the contribution of motion vision to the speed and accuracy of the visuomotor performance. Moreover, these relationships were prominent in veteran players. For table tennis athletes, especially experienced players, fluctuations in the visual motion discrimination performance in a visual field specific for capturing a ball may be responsible for the fluctuations in continuous visuomotor (striking) performance.

Motion processing impaired by transient spatial attention: Potential implications for the magnocellular pathway

Spatial cues presented prior to the presentation of a static stimulus usually improve its perception. However, previous research has also shown that transient exogenous cues to direct spatial attention to the location of a forthcoming stimulus can lead to reduced performance. In the present study, we investigated the effects of transient exogenous cues on the perception of briefly presented drifting Gabor patches. The spatial and temporal frequencies of the drifting Gabors were chosen to mainly engage the magnocellular pathway. We found better performance in the motion direction discrimination task when neutral cues were presented before the drifting target compared to a valid spatial cue. The behavioral results support the hypothesis that transient attention prolongs the internal response to the attended stimulus, thus reducing the temporal segregation of visual events. These results were complemented by applying a recently developed model for perceptual decisions to rule out a speed-accuracy trade-off and to further assess cueing effects on visual performance. In a model-based assessment, we found that valid cues initially enhanced processing but overall resulted in less efficient processing compared to neutral cues, possibly caused by reduced temporal segregation of visual events.

EEG asymmetry and cognitive testing in MCI identification

BackgroundFinding the baseline resting-state EEG markers for early identification of cognitive decline can contribute to the identification of individuals at risk of further change. Potential applications include identifying participants for clinical trials, early treatment, and evaluation of treatment, accessible even from a community setting. MethodsAnalyses were completed on a sample of 99 (ages 60–90) consensus-diagnosed, community-dwelling African Americans (58 cognitively typical/HC, and 41 mildly cognitively impaired/MCI), who were recruited from the Michigan Alzheimer's Disease Research Center (MADRC) and the Wayne State University Institute of Gerontology. In addition to neuropsychological testing with CogState and Toolbox computerized batteries, resting-state EEGs (rsEEG, eyes closed) were acquired before and after participants were engaged in a visual motion direction discrimination task. rsEEG frontal alpha asymmetry (FAA) and frontal beta asymmetry (FBA) were calculated. ResultsFAA showed no difference across groups for the pre-task resting state. FBA was significantly different between groups, with more asymmetric frontal beta in MCI. Both physiological indices, however, along with computerized neuropsychological tests were significant predictors in logistic regression classification of MCI vs. control participants. ConclusionrsEEG asymmetries can contribute significantly to successful discrimination of older persons with MCI from those without, over and above cognitive testing, alone.

Improvement in visual perception after high-frequency transcranial random noise stimulation (hf-tRNS) in those with migraine: An equivalent noise approach

Migraine is a common neurological disorder with strong links to vision. Interictal migraine is thought to be characterised by internal noise in the brain, possibly due to increased variability in neural firing, which can be estimated using equivalent noise tasks. High-frequency transcranial random noise stimulation (hf-tRNS) can be used to modulate levels of internal noise in the brain, and so presents a possible therapy to redress noise levels in the migraine brain. This is a case-control study using a 2-alternative forced choice (2AFC) design. Hf-tRNS and Sham control stimulation were used alongside a global motion direction discrimination task and visually based equivalent noise tasks. The migraine group demonstrated increased baseline internal noise levels compared to the control group. Internal noise levels, and sampling, were reduced using hf-tRNS but not Sham stimulation. However, there were no differences in terms of coherence thresholds, slopes, and lapse rate for global motion discrimination between the two groups. This is the first demonstration of the possibility of decreasing internal noise levels in migraine using hf-tRNS. Future work could explore the possibility of neurostimulation as a therapy for migraine.

Electrophysiological aftereffects of high-frequency transcranial random noise stimulation (hf-tRNS): an EEG investigation

There is evidence that high-frequency transcranial random noise stimulation (hf-tRNS) is effective in improving behavioural performance in several visual tasks. However, so far there has been limited research into the spatial and temporal characteristics of hf-tRNS-induced facilitatory effects. In the present study, electroencephalogram (EEG) was used to investigate the spatial and temporal dynamics of cortical activity modulated by offline hf-tRNS on performance on a motion direction discrimination task. We used EEG to measure the amplitude of motion-related VEPs over the parieto-occipital cortex, as well as oscillatory power spectral density (PSD) at rest. A time–frequency decomposition analysis was also performed to investigate the shift in event-related spectral perturbation (ERSP) in response to the motion stimuli between the pre- and post-stimulation period. The results showed that the accuracy of the motion direction discrimination task was not modulated by offline hf-tRNS. Although the motion task was able to elicit motion-dependent VEP components (P1, N2, and P2), none of them showed any significant change between pre- and post-stimulation. We also found a time-dependent increase of the PSD in alpha and beta bands regardless of the stimulation protocol. Finally, time–frequency analysis showed a modulation of ERSP power in the hf-tRNS condition for gamma activity when compared to pre-stimulation periods and Sham stimulation. Overall, these results show that offline hf-tRNS may induce moderate aftereffects in brain oscillatory activity.

Distractors Selectively Modulate Electrophysiological Markers of Perceptual Decisions.

Current models of perceptual decision-making assume that choices are made after evidence in favor of an alternative accumulates to a given threshold. This process has recently been revealed in human EEG recordings, but an unresolved issue is how these neural mechanisms are modulated by competing, yet task-irrelevant, stimuli. In this study, we tested 20 healthy participants on a motion direction discrimination task. Participants monitored two patches of random dot motion simultaneously presented on either side of fixation for periodic changes in an upward or downward motion, which could occur equiprobably in either patch. On a random 50% of trials, these periods of coherent vertical motion were accompanied by simultaneous task-irrelevant, horizontal motion in the contralateral patch. Our data showed that these distractors selectively increased the amplitude of early target selection responses over scalp sites contralateral to the distractor stimulus, without impacting on responses ipsilateral to the distractor. Importantly, this modulation mediated a decrement in the subsequent buildup rate of a neural signature of evidence accumulation and accounted for a slowing of RTs. These data offer new insights into the functional interactions between target selection and evidence accumulation signals, and their susceptibility to task-irrelevant distractors. More broadly, these data neurally inform future models of perceptual decision-making by highlighting the influence of early processing of competing stimuli on the accumulation of perceptual evidence.

Prefrontal cortex represents heuristics that shape choice bias and its integration into future behavior

Goal-directed behavior requires integrating sensory information with prior knowledge about the environment. Behavioral biases that arise from these priors could increase positive outcomes when the priors match the true structure of the environment, but mismatches also happen frequently and could cause unfavorable outcomes. Biases that reduce gains and fail to vanish with training indicate fundamental suboptimalities arising from ingrained heuristics of the brain. Here, we report systematic, gain-reducing choice biases in highly trained monkeys performing a motion direction discrimination task where only the current stimulus is behaviorally relevant. The monkey's bias fluctuated at two distinct time scales: slow, spanning tens to hundreds of trials, and fast, arising from choices and outcomes of the most recent trials. Our findings enabled single trial prediction of biases, which influenced the choice especially on trials with weak stimuli. The pre-stimulus activity of neuronal ensembles in the monkey prearcuate gyrus represented these biases as an offsetalong the decision axis in the state space. This offset persisted throughout the stimulus viewing period, when sensory information was integrated, leading to a biased choice. The pre-stimulus representation of history-dependent bias was functionally indistinguishable from the neural representation of upcoming choice before stimulus onset, validating our model of single-trial biases and suggesting that pre-stimulus representation of choice could be fully defined by biases inferred from behavioral history. Our results indicate that the prearcuate gyrus reflects intrinsic heuristics that compute bias signals, as well as the mechanisms that integrate them into the oculomotor decision-making process.

Variable Statistical Structure of Neuronal Spike Trains in Monkey Superior Colliculus.

Popular models of decision-making propose that noisy sensory evidence accumulates until reaching a bound. Behavioral evidence as well as trial-averaged ramping of neuronal activity in sensorimotor regions of the brain support this idea. However, averaging activity across trials can mask other processes, such as rapid shifts in decision commitment, calling into question the hypothesis that evidence accumulation is encoded by delay period activity of individual neurons. We mined two sets of data from experiments in four monkeys in which we recorded from superior colliculus neurons during two different decision-making tasks and a delayed saccade task. We applied second-order statistical measures and spike train simulations to determine whether spiking statistics were similar or different in the different tasks and monkeys, despite similar trial-averaged activity across tasks and monkeys. During a motion direction discrimination task, single-trial delay period activity behaved statistically consistent with accumulation. During an orientation detection task, the activity behaved superficially like accumulation, but statistically consistent with stepping. Simulations confirmed both findings. Importantly, during a simple saccade task, with similar trial-averaged activity, neither process explained spiking activity, ruling out interpretations based on differences in attention, reward, or motor planning. These results highlight the need for exploring single-trial spiking dynamics to understand cognitive processing and raise the interesting hypothesis that the superior colliculus participates in different aspects of decision-making depending on task differences.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT How are decisions based on sensory information transformed into actions? We report that single-trial neuronal activity dynamics in the superior colliculus of monkeys show differences in decision-making tasks depending on task idiosyncrasies and requirements and despite similar trial-averaged ramping activity. These results highlight the importance of exploring single-trial spiking dynamics to understand cognitive processing and raise the interesting hypothesis that the superior colliculus participates in different aspects of decision-making depending on task requirements.