Electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) is used to convert atmospheric nitrogen (N2) to ammonia (NH3) at ambient temperature and pressure. In general, acidic electrolytes are used to provide protons (H+) for the reduction process. However, this leads to a low NH3 selectivity because of H2 by-product formation via the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Recently, we showed that a Ti2N MXene is active and selective for NRR. We demonstrated that this catalyst works through a Mars-van Krevelen (MvK) mechanism rather than the conventional associative/dissociative mechanisms. However, the effect of pH and electrolyte on its catalytic activity and selectivity was not well understood. Here, we investigate these effects by performing experiments in varying electrolytic conditions and develop relations between pH, electrolyte choice, and performance. The Ti2N nitride MXene was synthesized via an oxygen-assisted molten salt fluoride etching technique and characterized through XRD and Raman and FTIR spectroscopies. Our findings showed that changing pH does not affect the NRR onset potential. We found that as pH increases, selectivity towards NH3 also increases presumably due to a lack of free H+ available to participate in HER. We also found that smaller cations with smaller solvation shells suppress HER activity, while smaller anions prevent catalyst poisoning during the NRR process, as evidenced by cyclic voltammetry before and after experimental conditions. We confirm production rates and the method of NH3 formation via NMR analytical techniques, including isotopic exchange. We plan to expand these findings to other materials and systems, and use the knowledge obtained from these studies to design optimal electrolytic conditions to produce NH3 through NRR.