Red blood cell (RBC) populations are inherently heterogeneous, given mature RBC lack the transcriptional machinery to re-synthesize proteins affected during in vivo aging. Clearance of older, less functional cells thus aids in maintaining consistent hemorheological properties. Scenarios occur, however, where portions of mechanically impaired RBC are re-introduced into blood (e.g., damaged from circulatory support, blood transfusion) and may alter whole blood fluid behavior. Given such perturbations are associated with poor clinical outcomes, determining the tolerable level of abnormal RBC in blood is valuable. Thus, the current study aimed to define the critical threshold of blood fluid properties to re-infused physically-impaired RBC. Cell mechanics of RBC were impaired through membrane cross-linking (glutaraldehyde) or intracellular oxidation (phenazine methosulfate). Mechanically impaired RBC were progressively re-introduced into the native cell population. Negative alterations of cellular deformability and high shear blood viscosity were observed following additions of only 1-5% rigidified RBC. Low-shear blood viscosity was conversely decreased following addition of glutaraldehyde-treated cells; high-resolution microscopy of these mixed cell populations revealed decreased capacity to form reversible aggregates and decreased aggregate size. Mixed RBC populations, when exposed to supraphysiological shear, presented with compounded mechanical impairment. Collectively, key determinants of blood flow behavior are sensitive to mechanical perturbations in RBC, even when only 1-5% of the cell population is affected. Given this fraction is well-below the volume of rigidified RBC introduced during circulatory support or transfusion practice, it is plausible that some adverse events following surgery and/or transfusion may be related to impaired blood fluidity.