Mixed Quantum-classical Molecular Dynamics Research Articles

Efficient implementation and performance analysis of the independent electron surface hopping method for dynamics at metal surfaces.

Independent electron surface hopping (IESH) is a computational algorithm for simulating the mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics of adsorbate atoms and molecules interacting with metal surfaces. It is capable of modeling the nonadiabatic effects of electron-hole pair excitations on molecular dynamics. Here, we present a transparent, reliable, and efficient implementation of IESH, demonstrating its ability to predict scattering and desorption probabilities across a variety of systems, ranging from model Hamiltonians to full dimensional atomistic systems. We further show how the algorithm can be modified to account for the application of an external bias potential, comparing its accuracy to results obtained using the hierarchical quantum master equation. Our results show that IESH is a practical method for modeling coupled electron-nuclear dynamics at metal surfaces, especially for highly energetic scattering events.

Trap-Seeking or Trap-Digging? Photoinjection of Hydrated Electrons into Aqueous NaCl Solutions

It is well-known that when excess electrons are injected into an aqueous solution, they localize and solvate in ∼1 ps. Still debated is whether localization occurs via "trap-digging", in which the electron carves out a suitable localization site, or by "trap-seeking", where the electron prefers to localize at pre-existing low-energy trap sites in solution. To distinguish between these two possible mechanisms, we study the localization dynamics of excess electrons in aqueous NaCl solutions using both ultrafast spectroscopy and mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics simulations. By introducing pre-existing traps in the form of Na+ ions, we can use the cation-induced blue-shift of the hydrated electron's absorption spectrum to directly monitor the site of electron localization. Our experimental and computational results show that the electron prefers to localize directly at the sites of Na+ traps; the presence of concentrated electrolytes otherwise has little impact on the way trap-seeking hydrated electrons relax following injection.

Exciton Dissociation in a Model Organic Interface: Excitonic State-Based Surface Hopping versus Multiconfigurational Time-Dependent Hartree.

Quantum dynamical simulations are essential for a molecular-level understanding of light-induced processes in optoelectronic materials, but they tend to be computationally demanding. We introduce an efficient mixed quantum-classical nonadiabatic molecular dynamics method termed eXcitonic state-based Surface Hopping (X-SH), which propagates the electronic Schrödinger equation in the space of local excitonic and charge-transfer electronic states, coupled to the thermal motion of the nuclear degrees of freedom. The method is applied to exciton decay in a 1D model of a fullerene–oligothiophene junction, and the results are compared to the ones from a fully quantum dynamical treatment at the level of the Multilayer Multiconfigurational Time-Dependent Hartree (ML-MCTDH) approach. Both methods predict that charge-separated states are formed on the 10–100 fs time scale via multiple “hot-exciton dissociation” pathways. The results demonstrate that X-SH is a promising tool advancing the simulation of photoexcited processes from the molecular to the true nanomaterials scale.

An accurate, non-empirical method for incorporating decoherence into Ehrenfest dynamics.

In mixed quantum-classical nonadiabatic molecular dynamics methods, the anchoring of the electronic wave function to a single nuclear geometry results in both quantitative and qualitative errors in the dynamics. In the context of both Ehrenfest and trajectory surface hopping methods, methods for incorporating decoherence are widely used to eliminate these errors. However, the accuracy of these methods often depends strongly on the parameterization of the decoherence time and/or other related quantities. Here, we present a refinement of the recently introduced collapse to a block (TAB) scheme for incorporating decoherence into Ehrenfest dynamics. The proposed approach incorporates an approximation to the history of the population dynamics and treats the coherence decay as Gaussian, rather than exponential. This method uses parameters that can be obtained from first principles, rather than empirical fitting. Application to one-dimensional models indicates excellent agreement with numerically exact simulations. We also introduce a second refinement to the TAB method: a robust linear least-squares algorithm for determining collapse probabilities.

High-order geometric integrators for representation-free Ehrenfest dynamics.

Ehrenfest dynamics is a useful approximation for ab initio mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics that can treat electronically nonadiabatic effects. Although a severe approximation to the exact solution of the molecular time-dependent Schrödinger equation, Ehrenfest dynamics is symplectic, is time-reversible, and conserves exactly the total molecular energy as well as thenormof the electronic wavefunction. Here, we surpass apparent complications due to the coupling of classical nuclear and quantum electronic motions and present efficient geometric integrators for "representation-free" Ehrenfest dynamics, which do not rely on a diabatic or adiabatic representation of electronic states and are of arbitrary even orders of accuracy in the time step. These numerical integrators, obtained by symmetrically composing the second-order splitting method and exactly solving the kinetic and potential propagation steps, are norm-conserving, symplectic, and time-reversible regardless of the time step used. Using a nonadiabatic simulation in the region of a conical intersection as an example, we demonstrate that these integrators preserve the geometric properties exactly and, if highly accurate solutions are desired, can be even more efficient than the most popular non-geometric integrators.

Water structure near the surface of Weyl semimetals as catalysts in photocatalytic proton reduction.

In this work, second-generation Car–Parrinello-based mixed quantum-classical mechanics molecular dynamics simulations of small nanoparticles of NbP, NbAs, TaAs, and 1T-TaS2 in water are presented. The first three materials are topological Weyl semimetals, which were recently discovered to be active catalysts in photocatalytic water splitting. The aim of this research was to correlate potential differences in the water structure in the vicinity of the nanoparticle surface with the photocatalytic activity of these materials in light induced proton reduction. The results presented herein allow explaining the catalytic activity of these Weyl semimetals: the most active material, NbP, exhibits a particularly low water coordination near the surface of the nanoparticle, whereas for 1T-TaS2, with the lowest catalytic activity, the water structure at the surface is most ordered. In addition, the photocatalytic activity of several organic and metalorganic photosensitizers in the hydrogen evolution reaction was experimentally investigated with NbP as the proton reduction catalyst. Unexpectedly, the charge of the photosensitizer plays a decisive role for the photocatalytic performance.

Ultrafast Charge Transfer and Structural Dynamics Following Outer-Valence Ionization of a Halogen-Bonded Dimer.

We study the temporal evolution of the CH2O···ClF halogen-bonded dimer following vertical ionization out of outer-valence molecular orbitals on a femtosecond time scale, employing mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics simulations. The charge density pattern in the ground state that is suitable for the formation of the ground-state halogen bond can be changed upon ionization. Depending on the molecular orbital that gets ionized, the change in the charge density transiently strengthens or weakens the halogen bond through altering the electrostatic interaction. A transient increase in the halogen bond strength is observed if the ionization enhances the positive charge on the halogen atom provided that the electron donor site possesses some negative charge. The evolution of the system following ionization is driven by energetic stabilization through transferring the electronic charge from the halogen bond acceptor/electron donor (CH2O) to the halogen bond donor/electron acceptor (ClF). The charge transfer oscillations are at the same time governed by the covalent bond vibrations.

Nonadiabatic molecular dynamics with decoherence and detailed balance under a density matrix ensemble formalism

Author(s): Kang, J; Wang, LW | Abstract: The mixed quantum-classical nonadiabatic molecular dynamics (NAMD) is a powerful tool to study many phenomena, especially ultrafast carrier transport and cooling. Carrier decoherence and detailed balance are two major issues in NAMD. So far, there is no computationally inexpensive approach to incorporate both effects. While the decoherence effect can be easily included in the state density matrix formalism and the detailed balance can be included in surface hopping or the wave function collapse approach, it is difficult to include both of them in a unified formalism. In this work we introduce a state density matrix formalism (referred to as P-matrix) including both the decoherence and detailed balance effects for NAMD. This method is able to explicitly treat the decoherence between different pairs of adiabatic states. Moreover, the off-diagonal density matrix elements are divided into two parts, corresponding to energy-increasing and energy-decreasing transitions. The detailed balance is then enforced by a Boltzmann factor applied to the energy-increasing transition part. The P-matrix formalism is applied to study hot-hole cooling and transfer processes in Si quantum dot (QD) systems. The calculated hot-carrier relaxation time is consistent with experiments. In a QD-pair system, the hot-hole cooling time shows weak dependence on the QD spacing. However, the hot-carrier transfer rate from one QD to another is found to decrease exponentially with the QD-QD distance. When the QD spacing is small (∼1 nm), the hot-carrier transfer can be very efficient. It is also shown that the explicit treatment of decoherence time is important in order to treat this hot-carrier transfer correctly.

Uncovered Dynamic Coupling Resolves the Ambiguous Mechanism of Phenylalanine Hydroxylase Oxygen Binding.

Phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) is an iron enzyme catalyzing the oxidation of l-Phe to l-Tyr during phenylalanine catabolism. Dysfunction of PAH leads to the debilitating condition phenylketonuria (PKU), which prompted research into the structure and function of PAH over the last 50 years. Despite intensive study, there is no consensus on the atomistic details of the mechanism of O2 binding and splitting by wild-type (WT) PAH and how it varies with PKU-inducing mutations, Arg158Gln and Glu280Lys. We studied structures involved in a proposed mechanism for the WT and mutants using extensive mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics simulations. Simulations reveal a previously unobserved dynamic coupling between the active site and the mutation sites, suggesting how they can affect the catalytic performance of PAH. Furthermore, the effect of the coupling on the PAH structure agrees with and expands our understanding of the experimentally observed differences in activity between the WT and mutants.

Excited-state solvation structure of transition metal complexes from molecular dynamics simulations and assessment of partial atomic charge methods.

In this work, we investigate the excited-state solute and solvation structure of [Ru(bpy)3]2+, [Fe(bpy)3]2+, [Fe(bmip)2]2+ and [Cu(phen)2]+ (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine; bmip = 2,6-bis(3-methyl-imidazole-1-ylidine)-pyridine; phen = 1,10-phenanthroline) transition metal complexes (TMCs) in terms of solute-solvent radial distribution functions (RDFs) and evaluate the performance of some of the most popular partial atomic charge (PAC) methods for obtaining these RDFs by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. To this end, we compare classical MD of a frozen solute in water and acetonitrile (ACN) with quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (QM/MM BOMD) simulations. The calculated RDFs show that the choice of a suitable PAC method is dependent on the coordination number of the metal, denticity of the ligands, and type of solvent. It is found that this selection is less sensitive for water than ACN. Furthermore, a careful choice of the PAC method should be considered for TMCs that exhibit a free direct coordination site, such as [Cu(phen)2]+. The results of this work show that fast classical MD simulations with ChelpG/RESP or CM5 PACs can produce RDFs close to those obtained by QM/MM MD and thus, provide reliable solvation structures of TMCs to be used, e.g. in the analysis of scattering data.

Infrared-laser-pulse-enhanced ultrafast fragmentation of N22+ following Auger decay: Mixed quantum-classical simulations

We employ mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the fragmentation of ${\mathrm{N}}_{2}$ molecules after core-level photoionization by an x-ray laser, subsequent Auger decay, and followed by a femtosecond IR pulse that interacts with ${{\mathrm{N}}_{2}}^{2+}$. The delayed IR pulse couples the dissociative electronic states of ${{\mathrm{N}}_{2}}^{2+}$ with electronic states that can support long-lived vibrational resonances. We compare our simulations with previous quantum dynamics calculations in a quasidiabatic representation, which employed a small number of electronic states. Good agreement for both the Auger spectrum as well as the influence of the delayed IR pulse is found. By employing the mixed quantum-classical treatment, we can greatly reduce the computational cost to simulate the fragmentation dynamics compared to the quantum dynamics simulations. Furthermore, we reinvestigate the title process by employing an extended set of adiabatic potential energy surfaces and also investigate the role of nonadiabatic coupling in the process. The use of the full set of adiabatic potentials increases the dissociation probability and changes the details of the interaction with the IR pulse, but no effect due to the nonadiabatic coupling is found.

Efficient and Deterministic Propagation of Mixed Quantum-Classical Liouville Dynamics.

We propose a highly efficient mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics scheme based on a solution of the quantum-classical Liouville equation (QCLE). By casting the equations of motion for the quantum subsystem and classical bath degrees of freedom onto an approximate set of coupled first-order differential equations for c-numbers, this scheme propagates the composite system in time deterministically in terms of independent classical-like trajectories. To demonstrate its performance, we apply the method to the spin-boson model, a photoinduced electron transfer model, and a Fenna-Matthews-Olsen complex model, and find excellent agreement out to long times with the numerically exact results, using several orders of magnitude fewer trajectories than surface-hopping solutions of the QCLE. Owing to its accuracy and efficiency, this method promises to be very useful for studying the dynamics of mixed quantum-classical systems.

Quantum trajectory simulation for nonadiabatic molecular dynamics

The mixed quantum-classical (MQC) molecular dynamics (MD) approaches are extremely important in practice since, with the increase of atomic degrees of freedom, a full quantum mechanical evaluation for molecular dynamics would quickly become intractable. Moreover, in some cases, the nonadiabatic effects are of crucial importance in the proximity of conical intersection of potential energy surfaces (PESs), where the energy separation between different PESs becomes comparable to the nonadiabatic coupling. In the past decades, there has been great interest in developing and improving various nonadiabatic MQC-MD protocols. The widely known nonadiabatic MD proposals include the so-called Ehrenfest or time-dependent-Hartree mean-field approach, the trajectory surface-hopping method, and their mixed scheme. Among the trajectory-based surface hopping methods, the most popular one is Tully's fewest switches surface hopping approach. In this approach, the nonadiabatic dynamics is treated by allowing hops from one PES to another, with the hopping probability determined by a certain artificial hopping algorithm. In our present work, we extend the study of a recent work on the nonadiabatic MQC-MD scheme, which is based on a view that the nonadiabatic MQC-MD actually implies an effective quantum measurement on the electronic states by the classical motion of atoms. The new protocol, say, the quantum trajectory (QT) approach, provides a natural interface between the separate quantum and classical treatments, without invoking artificial surface hopping algorithm. Moreover, it also connects two widely adopted nonadiabatic dynamics methods, the Ehrenfest mean-field theory and the trajectory surface-hopping method. In our present study, we implement further the QT approach to simulate several typical potential-surface models, i.e., including the single avoided crossing, dual avoided crossing, extended coupling, dumbbell and double arch potentials. In particular, we simulate and compare three decoherence rates, which are from different physical considerations, i.e., the frozen Gaussian approximation, energy discrimination and force discrimination. We also design simulation algorithms to properly account for the energy conservation and force direction change associated with the surface hopping. In most cases, we find that the QT results are in good agreement with those from the full quantum dynamics, which is insensitive to the specific form of the decoherence rate. But for the model involving strong quantum interference, like other nonadiabatic MQC-MD schemes, the QT approach cannot give desirable results. Developing better method should be useful for future investigations in this research area.

Excess electrons in methanol clusters: Beyond the one-electron picture.

We performed a series of comparative quantum chemical calculations on various size negatively charged methanol clusters, CH3OHn-. The clusters are examined in their optimized geometries (n = 2-4), and in geometries taken from mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics simulations at finite temperature (n = 2-128). These latter structures model potential electron binding sites in methanol clusters and in bulk methanol. In particular, we compute the vertical detachment energy (VDE) of an excess electron from increasing size methanol cluster anions using quantum chemical computations at various levels of theory including a one-electron pseudopotential model, several density functional theory (DFT) based methods, MP2 and coupled-cluster CCSD(T) calculations. The results suggest that at least four methanol molecules are needed to bind an excess electron on a hydrogen bonded methanol chain in a dipole bound state. Larger methanol clusters are able to form stronger interactions with an excess electron. The two simulated excess electron binding motifs in methanol clusters, interior and surface states, correlate well with distinct, experimentally found VDE tendencies with size. Interior states in a solvent cavity are stabilized significantly stronger than electron states on cluster surfaces. Although we find that all the examined quantum chemistry methods more or less overestimate the strength of the experimental excess electron stabilization, MP2, LC-BLYP, and BHandHLYP methods with diffuse basis sets provide a significantly better estimate of the VDE than traditional DFT methods (BLYP, B3LYP, X3LYP, PBE0). A comparison to the better performing many electron methods indicates that the examined one-electron pseudopotential can be reasonably used in simulations for systems of larger size.

Vibrational fingerprints of the Mn4CaO5 cluster in Photosystem II by mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics

A detailed knowledge of the structures of the catalytic steps along the Kok-Joliot cycle of Photosystem II may help to understand the strategies adopted by this unique enzyme to achieve water oxidation. Vibrational spectroscopy has probed in the last decades the intermediate states of the catalytic cycle, although the interpretation of the data turned out to be often problematic. In the present work we use QM/MM molecular dynamics on the S2 state to obtain the vibrational density of states at room temperature. To help the interpretation of the computational and experimental data we propose a decomposition of the Mn4CaO5 moiety into five separate parts, composed by “diamond” motifs involving four atoms. The spectral signatures arising from this analysis can be easily interpreted to assign experimentally known bands to specific molecular motions. In particular, we focused in the low frequency region of the vibrational spectrum of the S2 state. We can therefore identify the observed bands around 600–620cm−1 as characteristic for the stretching vibrations involving Mn1-O1-Mn2 or Mn3-O5 moieties.

On the applicability of one- and many-electron quantum chemistry models for hydrated electron clusters.

We evaluate the applicability of a hierarchy of quantum models in characterizing the binding energy of excess electrons to water clusters. In particular, we calculate the vertical detachment energy of an excess electron from water cluster anions with methods that include one-electron pseudopotential calculations, density functional theory(DFT) based calculations, and ab initio quantum chemistry using MP2 and eom-EA-CCSD levels of theory. The examined clusters range from the smallest cluster size (n = 2) up to nearly nanosize clusters with n = 1000 molecules. The examined cluster configurations are extracted from mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics trajectories of cluster anions with n = 1000 water molecules using two different one-electron pseudopotenial models. We find that while MP2 calculations with large diffuse basis set provide a reasonable description for the hydrated electron system, DFT methods should be used with precaution and only after careful benchmarking. Strictly tested one-electron psudopotentials can still be considered as reasonable alternatives to DFT methods, especially in large systems. The results of quantum chemistry calculations performed on configurations, that represent possible excess electron binding motifs in the clusters, appear to be consistent with the results using a cavitystructure preferring one-electron pseudopotential for the hydrated electron, while they are in sharp disagreement with the structural predictions of a non-cavity model.

Automated quantum chemistry based molecular dynamics simulations of electron ionization induced fragmentations of the nucleobases Uracil, Thymine, Cytosine, and Guanine.

The gas-phase decomposition pathways of electron ionization (EI)-induced radical cations of the nucleobases uracil, thymine, cytosine, and guanine are investigated by means of mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics. No preconceived fragmentation channels are used in the calculations. The results compare well to a plethora of experimental and theoretical data for these important biomolecules. With our combined stochastic and dynamic approach, one can access in an unbiased way the energetically available decomposition mechanisms. Additionally, we are able to separate the EI mass spectra of different tautomers of cytosine and guanine. Our method (previously termed quantum chemistry electron ionization mass spectra) reproduces free nucleobase experimental mass spectra well and provides detailed mechanistic in-sight into high-energy unimolecular decomposition processes.

A molecular dynamics study of intramolecular proton transfer reaction of malonaldehyde in solution based upon a mixed quantum-classical approximation. II. Proton transfer reaction in non-polar solvent.

The intramolecular proton transfer reaction of malonaldehyde in neon solvent has been investigated by mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics (QCMD) calculations and fully classical molecular dynamics (FCMD) calculations. Comparing these calculated results with those for malonaldehyde in water reported in Part I [A. Yamada, H. Kojima, and S. Okazaki, J. Chem. Phys. 141, 084509 (2014)], the solvent dependence of the reaction rate, the reaction mechanism involved, and the quantum effect therein have been investigated. With FCMD, the reaction rate in weakly interacting neon is lower than that in strongly interacting water. However, with QCMD, the order of the reaction rates is reversed. To investigate the mechanisms in detail, the reactions were categorized into three mechanisms: tunneling, thermal activation, and barrier vanishing. Then, the quantum and solvent effects were analyzed from the viewpoint of the reaction mechanism focusing on the shape of potential energy curve and its fluctuations. The higher reaction rate that was found for neon in QCMD compared with that found for water solvent arises from the tunneling reactions because of the nearly symmetric double-well shape of the potential curve in neon. The thermal activation and barrier vanishing reactions were also accelerated by the zero-point energy. The number of reactions based on these two mechanisms in water was greater than that in neon in both QCMD and FCMD because these reactions are dominated by the strength of solute-solvent interactions.

Atomistic Modeling of Two-Dimensional Electronic Spectra and Excited-State Dynamics for a Light Harvesting 2 Complex

The Light Harvesting 2 (LH2) complex is a vital part of the photosystem of purple bacteria. It is responsible for the absorption of light and transport of the resulting excitations to the reaction center in a highly efficient manner. A general description of the chromophores and the interaction with their local environment is crucial to understand this highly efficient energy transport. Here we include this interaction in an atomistic way using mixed quantum-classical (molecular dynamics) simulations of spectra. In particular, we present the first atomistic simulation of nonlinear optical spectra for LH2 and use it to study the energy transport within the complex. We show that the frequency distributions of the pigments strongly depend on their positions with respect to the protein scaffold and dynamics of their local environment. Furthermore, we show that although the pigments are closely packed the transition frequencies of neighboring pigments are essentially uncorrelated. We present the simulated linear absorption spectra for the LH2 complex and provide a detailed explanation of the states responsible for the observed two-band structure. Finally, we discuss the energy transfer within the complex by analyzing population transfer calculations and 2D spectra for different waiting times. We conclude that the energy transfer from the B800 ring to the B850 ring is mediated by intermediate states that are delocalized over both rings, allowing for a stepwise downhill energy transport.

A molecular dynamics study of intramolecular proton transfer reaction of malonaldehyde in solutions based upon mixed quantum-classical approximation. I. Proton transfer reaction in water.

In order to investigate proton transfer reaction in solution, mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics calculations have been carried out based on our previously proposed quantum equation of motion for the reacting system [A. Yamada and S. Okazaki, J. Chem. Phys. 128, 044507 (2008)]. Surface hopping method was applied to describe forces acting on the solvent classical degrees of freedom. In a series of our studies, quantum and solvent effects on the reaction dynamics in solutions have been analysed in detail. Here, we report our mixed quantum-classical molecular dynamics calculations for intramolecular proton transfer of malonaldehyde in water. Thermally activated proton transfer process, i.e., vibrational excitation in the reactant state followed by transition to the product state and vibrational relaxation in the product state, as well as tunneling reaction can be described by solving the equation of motion. Zero point energy is, of course, included, too. The quantum simulation in water has been compared with the fully classical one and the wave packet calculation in vacuum. The calculated quantum reaction rate in water was 0.70 ps(-1), which is about 2.5 times faster than that in vacuum, 0.27 ps(-1). This indicates that the solvent water accelerates the reaction. Further, the quantum calculation resulted in the reaction rate about 2 times faster than the fully classical calculation, which indicates that quantum effect enhances the reaction rate, too. Contribution from three reaction mechanisms, i.e., tunneling, thermal activation, and barrier vanishing reactions, is 33:46:21 in the mixed quantum-classical calculations. This clearly shows that the tunneling effect is important in the reaction.