Minor-groove Agents Research Articles

Drug design and DNA structural research inspired by the Neidle laboratory: DNA minor groove binding and transcription factor inhibition by thiophene diamidines

The understanding of sequence-specific DNA minor groove interactions has recently made major steps forward and as a result, the goal of development of compounds that target the minor groove is an active research area. In an effort to develop biologically active minor groove agents, we are preparing and exploring the DNA interactions of diverse diamidine derivatives with a 5′-GAATTC-3′ binding site using a powerful array of methods including, biosensor-SPR methods, and X-ray crystallography. The benzimidazole-thiophene module provides an excellent minor groove recognition component. A central thiophene in a benzimidazole-thiophene-phenyl aromatic system provides essentially optimum curvature for matching the shape of the minor groove. Comparison of that structure to one with the benzimidazole replaced with an indole shows that the two structures are very similar, but have some interesting and important differences in electrostatic potential maps, the DNA minor groove binding structure based on x-ray crystallographic analysis, and inhibition of the major groove binding PU.1 transcription factor complex. The binding KD for both compounds is under 10 nM and both form amidine H-bonds to DNA bases. They both have bifurcated H-bonds from the benzimidazole or indole groups to bases at the center of the -AATT- binding site. Analysis of the comparative results provides an excellent understanding of how thiophene compounds recognize the minor groove and can act as transcription factor inhibitors.

Identification of a 3-(5-methyl-2-thiazolylamino)phthalide as a new minor groove agent

A new 3-(5-methyl-2-thiazolylamino)phthalide molecule, 3-((5-methylthiazol-2-yl)amino)isobenzofuran-1(3H)-one, was synthesized and characterized experimentally by FT-IR, NMR, UV-Vis, and single-crystal X-ray analysis and theoretically by quantum chemical calculations. The single-crystal X-ray studies revealed that the compound crystallizes in the monoclinic space group P-21/c with unit-cell parameters a = 8.0550(6) Å, b = 6.1386(3) Å, c = 23.3228(18) Å, β = 97.724(6)° and Z = 4. Optimized geometries and the vibrational frequencies were studied at the density functional theory (DFT) level by using the hybrid functional B3LYP with a 6-311 G (d,p) basis set. The title compound was evaluated for its anti-quorum sensing (anti-QS) activity on Chromobacterium violaceum 12472 and additionally for its antibacterial activity against Staphylococcus aureus 29213, Staphylococcus epidermidis 12228, Pseudomonas aeruginosa 27853, Escherichia coli 25922, and Proteus mirabilis 14153. The lowest MIC value was 0.24 μg/mL for S. aureus 29213 and the highest MIC value was 30.75 μg/mL for E. coli 25922. While anti-bacterial activity was observed in those other than the S. epidermidis and P. Mirabilis, anti-QS activity wasn’t detected. Investigations on dsDNA binding affinity indicate that the title compound binds to dsDNA via the groove binding mode. Molecular docking calculations and molecular dynamics simulations results showed also that the title compound prefers binding to the minor groove of dsDNA and remains stable in the minor groove throughout the molecular dynamics simulation. Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma

Systematic synthetic and biophysical development of mixed sequence DNA binding agents.

It is now well established that, although only about 5% of the human genome codes for protein, most of the DNA has some function, such as synthesis of specific, functional RNAs and/or control of gene expression. These functional sequences open immense possibilities in both biotechnology and therapeutics for the use of cell-permeable, small molecules that can bind mixed-base pair sequences of DNA for regulation of genomic functions. Unfortunately very few types of modules have been designed to recognize mixed DNA sequences and for progress in targeting specific genes, it is essential to have additional classes of compounds. Compounds that can be rationally designed from established modules and which can bind strongly to mixed base pair DNA sequences are especially attractive. Based on extensive experience in design of minor-groove agents for AT recognition, a small library of compounds with two AT specific binding modules, connected through linkers which can recognize the G·C base pairs, were prepared. The compound-DNA interactions were evaluated with a powerful array of biophysical methods and the results show that some pyridyl-linked compounds bind with the target sequence with sub-nanomolar KD, with very slow dissociation kinetics and 200 times selectivity over the related sequence without a G·C base pair. Interestingly, a set of compounds with AT module connected by different linkers shows cooperative dimer recognition of related sequences. This type of design approach can be expanded to additional modules for recognition of a wide variety of sequences.

Complexity in the binding of minor groove agents: netropsin has two thermodynamically different DNA binding modes at a single site

Structural results with minor groove binding agents, such as netropsin, have provided detailed, atomic level views of DNA molecular recognition. Solution studies, however, indicate that there is complexity in the binding of minor groove agents to a single site. Netropsin, for example, has two DNA binding enthalpies in isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) experiments that indicate the compound simultaneously forms two thermodynamically different complexes at a single AATT site. Two proposals for the origin of this unusual observation have been developed: (i) two different bound species of netropsin at single binding sites and (ii) a netropsin induced DNA hairpin to duplex transition. To develop a better understanding of DNA recognition complexity, the two proposals have been tested with several DNAs and the methods of mass spectrometry (MS), polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in addition to ITC. All of the methods with all of the DNAs investigated clearly shows that netropsin forms two different complexes at AATT sites, and that the proposal for an induced hairpin to duplex transition in this system is incorrect.

DNA Minor Groove Binding by Diamidine:Water Molecule in Ligand Recognition

Molecular dynamics simulations were used to investigate the interaction of DB921 with the DNA oligonucleotide d[CGCGAATTCGCG]2. A 7 ns MD calculation was performed to study the DB921-DNA complex and the results indicated that DB921 was inserted in the minor groove of DNA, binding to the region of duplex AATTC bases. A water molecule forms bifurcated pair of H-bonds between the N atom of benzimidazole ring and N3 atom of the adenine 5 in the DB921-DNA complex. This water molecule performs a key bridging role which induces a more favorable curvature configuration and matches well the DNA minor groove topology. Molecular dynamics studies complemented the structural analysis and offered a clear picture of the water-bridge, providing the theoretical guidance for the design of biologically active minor groove agents.

Design of DNA Minor Groove Binding Diamidines That Recognize GC Base Pair Sequences: A Dimeric-Hinge Interaction Motif

The classical model of DNA minor groove binding compounds is that they should have a crescent shape that closely fits the helical twist of the groove. Several compounds with relatively linear shape and large dihedral twist, however, have been found recently to bind strongly to the minor groove. These observations raise the question of how far the curvature requirement could be relaxed. As an initial step in experimental analysis of this question, a linear triphenyl diamidine, DB1111, and a series of nitrogen tricyclic analogues were prepared. The goal with the heterocycles is to design GC binding selectivity into heterocyclic compounds that can get into cells and exert biological effects. The compounds have a zero radius of curvature from amidine carbon to amidine carbon but a significant dihedral twist across the tricyclic and amidine-ring junctions. They would not be expected to bind well to the DNA minor groove by shape-matching criteria. Detailed DNase I footprinting studies of the sequence specificity of this set of diamidines indicated that a pyrimidine heterocyclic derivative, DB1242, binds specifically to a GC-rich sequence, -GCTCG-. It binds to the GC sequence more strongly than to the usual AT recognition sequences for curved minor groove agents. Other similar derivatives did not exhibit the GC specificity. Biosensor-surface plasmon resonance and isothermal titration calorimetry experiments indicate that DB1242 binds to the GC sequence as a highly cooperative stacked dimer. Circular dichroism results indicate that the compound binds in the minor groove. Molecular modeling studies support a minor groove complex and provide an inter-compound and compound-DNA hydrogen-bonding rational for the unusual GC binding specificity and the requirement for a pyrimidine heterocycle. This compound represents a new direction in the development of DNA sequence-specific agents, and it is the first non-polyamide, synthetic compound to specifically recognize a DNA sequence with a majority of GC base pairs.

Binding-Linked Protonation of a DNA Minor-Groove Agent

The energetics for binding of a diphenyl diamidine antitrypanosomal agent CGP 40215A to DNA have been studied by spectroscopy, isothermal titration calorimetry, and surface plasmon resonance biosensor methods. Both amidines are positively charged under experimental conditions, but the linking group for the two phenyl amidines has a pK a of 6.3 that is susceptible to a protonation process. Spectroscopic studies indicate an increase of 2.7 pK a units in the linking group when the compound binds to an A/T minor-groove site. Calorimetric titrations in different buffers and pH conditions support the proton-linkage process and are in a good agreement with spectroscopic titrations. The two methods established a proton-uptake profile as a function of pH. The exothermic enthalpy of complex formation varies with different pH conditions. The observed binding enthalpy increases as a function of temperature indicating a negative heat capacity change that is typical for DNA minor-groove binders. Solvent accessible surface area calculations suggest that surface burial accounts for about one-half of the observed intrinsic negative heat capacity change. Biosensor and calorimetric experiments indicate that the binding affinities vary with pH values and salt concentrations due to protonation and electrostatic interactions. The surface plasmon resonance binding studies indicate that the charge density per phosphate in DNA hairpins is smaller than that in polymers. Energetic contributions from different factors were also estimated for the ligand/DNA complex.

Unique Cooperative Binding Interaction Observed between a Minor Groove Binding Pt Antitumor Agent and Hoeschst Dye 33258

The trinuclear compound [{Pt(NH3)3}2mu-{trans-Pt(NH3)2(H2N(CH2)6NH2)}2(6+) (0,0,0/t,t,t) binds to DNA only through noncovalent hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions. The presence of this 6+ cation allows discrimination of binding modes for common DNA ligands: binding of minor-groove agents such as Hoechst 33258 is cooperative, and dye-DNA interaction is enhanced whereas intercalation as exemplified by ethidium bromide is competitively inhibited.

Thiophene-Based Diamidine Forms a “Super” AT Binding Minor Groove Agent

The DNA minor groove is the interaction site for many enzymes and transcription control proteins and as a result, development of compounds that target the minor groove is an active research area. In an effort to develop biologically active minor groove agents, we are preparing and exploring the DNA interactions of a systematic set of diamidine derivatives with a powerful array of methods including DNase I footprinting, biosensor-SPR methods, and X-ray crystallography. Surprisingly, conversion of the parent phenyl-furan-phenyl diamidine to a phenyl-thiophene-benzimidazole derivative yields a compound with over 10-fold-increased affinity for the minor groove at AT sequences. Single conversion of the furan to a thiophene or a phenyl to benzimidazole does not cause a similar increase in affinity. X-ray results indicate a small bond angle difference between the C-S-C angle of thiophene and the C-O-C angle of furan that, when amplified out to the terminal amidines of the benzimidazole compounds, yields a very significant difference in the positions of the amidines and their DNA interaction strength.

DNA sequence dependent monomer-dimer binding modulation of asymmetric benzimidazole derivatives.

A number of studies indicate that DNA sequences such as AATT and TTAA have significantly different physical and interaction properties. To probe these interaction differences in detail and determine the influence of charge, we have synthesized three bisbenzimidazole derivatives, a diamidine, DB185, and monoamidines, DB183 and DB210, that are related to the well-known minor groove agent, Hoechst 33258. Footprinting studies with several natural and designed DNA fragments indicate that the synthetic compounds bind at AT sequences in the minor groove and interact more weakly at sites with TpA steps relative to sites without such steps. Circular dichroism spectroscopy also indicates that the compounds bind in the DNA minor groove. Surprisingly, Tm studies as a function of ratio indicate that the monoamidines bind to TTAA sequences as dimers, whereas the diamidine binds as a monomer. Biosensor-surface plasmon resonance (SPR) studies allowed us to quantitate the interaction differences in more detail. SPR results clearly show that the monoamidine compounds bind to the TTAA sequence in a cooperative 2:1 complex but bind as monomers to AATT. The dication binds to both sequences in monomer complexes but the binding to AATT is significantly stronger than binding to TTAA. Molecular dynamics simulations indicate that the AATT sequence has a narrow time-average minor groove width that is a very good receptor site for the bisbenzimidazole compounds. The groove in TTAA sequences is wider and the width must be reduced to form a favorable monomer complex. The monocations thus form cooperative dimers that stack in an antiparallel orientation and closely fit the structure of the TTAA minor groove. The amidine groups in the dimer are oriented in the 5' direction of the strand to which they are closest. Charge repulsion in the dication apparently keeps it from forming the dimer. It instead reduces the TTAA groove width, in an induced fit process, sufficiently to form a minor groove complex. The dimer-binding mode of DB183 and DB210 is a new DNA recognition motif and offers novel design concepts for selective targeting of DNA sequences with a wider minor groove, including those with TpA steps.

Comparative thermodynamics for monomer and dimer sequence-dependent binding of a heterocyclic dication in the DNA minor groove

Phenylamidine cationic groups linked by a furan ring (furamidine) and related symmetric diamidine compounds bind as monomers in the minor groove of AT sequences of DNA. DB293, an unsymmetric derivative with one of the phenyl rings of furamidine replaced with a benzimidazole, can bind to AT sequences as a monomer but binds more strongly to GC-containing minor-groove DNA sites as a stacked dimer. The dimer-binding mode has high affinity, is highly cooperative and sequence selective. In order to develop a better understanding of the correlation between structural and thermodynamic aspects of DNA molecular recognition, DB293 was used as a model to compare the binding of minor-groove agents with AT and mixed sequence DNA sites. Isothermal titration calorimetry and surface plasmon resonance results clearly show that the binding of DB293 and other related compounds into the minor groove of AT sequences is largely entropy-driven while the binding of DB293 as a dimer into the minor groove of GC-containing sequences is largely enthalpy-driven. At 25 °C, for example, the AT binding has Δ G°, Δ H° and TΔ S° values of −9.6, −3.6 and 6.0 kcal/mol while the values for dimer binding to a GC-containing site are −9.0, −10.9 and −1.9 kcal/mol (per mol of bound compound), respectively. These results show that the thermodynamic components for binding of compounds of this type to DNA are very dependent on the structure, solvation and sequence of the DNA binding site.

Effects of bizelesin (U-77779), a bifunctional alkylating minor groove agent, on genomic and simian virus 40 DNA.

Bizelesin is a bifunctional covalent minor groove binding agent which forms adducts with 3'-adenines on opposite DNA strands. DNA lesions induced by bizelesin in genomic DNA of BSC-1 cells, as well as intracellular and purified simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA, were examined. Alkaline sucrose sedimentation analysis indicated a nonrandom distribution of heat-labile damage in BSC-1 cell genomic DNA with frequencies of 1-60 lesions/10(6) base pairs (bp) for bizelesin concentrations from 10 to 400 nM, respectively. Extrapolation of these data suggested that, at 0.15 nM bizelesin, approximately 10(2) adducts per cell may be sufficient to inhibit cell growth by 90% (D10). While the frequency of bizelesin adducts in intracellular SV40 DNA was comparable to that in genomic DNA, higher levels of lesion formation are observed with purified SV40 DNA. Chromatin structure has little effect on localization of bizelesin adducts since treatment of either infected cells or purified SV40 DNA reveals a similar pattern of drug-induced damage. Bizelesin adduction sites (mapped on the SV40 genome as thermally-induced strand breaks at 50-100 bp resolution) are found in regions centered at 4200, 3900, 4700, and approximately 5200. The location of these regions of intense bizelesin bonding coincides with the sites of potential cross-links predicted using the 5'-T-(A/T)4-A-3' sequence. The analysis of bizelesin adducts at the sequence level in the 3943-4451 SV40 DNA fragment indicated that 40% of total damage was in potential cross-linking sites and an additional 35% in the 5'-A-(A/T)4-A-3' monoalkylating sites.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)