Patellar fixation is a common cause of lameness in horses and has been successfully treated by infection of the patellar ligaments with counterirritants. To investigate the effects of this treatment, the medial and middle patellar ligaments of 10 ponies were injected with an oil-based iodine counterirritant solution and then examined morphologically. Vacuoles of counterirritant were present in the paratenon and endotenon of the ligaments and caused severe necrosis and inflammation. At 1 day after injection, there was a marked neutrophilic infiltration which progressed to a lymphocytic infiltrate by 3 days. By 7 days, fibroplasia was present and became more organized with time. Disrupted collagen fibers and numerous, large, pale fibroblasts were present in the fasciculi, but neutrophilic infiltration was absent. The fibrous response in the fasciculi was similar to that present in the paratenon and endotenon. At 28 days, the drug was still present as lipid vacuoles in the paratenon and endotenon, and the damaged fasciculi had not regained their normal appearance. The clinical effect of this treatment was attributed to the change in size and shape of the patellar ligaments resulting from the inflammatory response. Approximately 90–95% of stifle lamenesses have been attributed to problems involving the patellar ligaments, 2 which are essentially continuations of the tendons of insertion of the quadriceps femoris and biceps femoris muscles. 3 Upward fixation of the patella has long been recognized in horses in which the stifle joint becomes locked in extension, thus preventing flexion and normal advancement of the limb. 6 If forced to advance the limb, the horse may drag its toe on the ground. A more common and subtle form of this condition also occurs. A momentary fixation of the patella may occur which results in a painful, inflamed joint, but obvious locking of the stifle is not seen. 8 This problem is common in performance horses. Diagnosis of the mild form of patellar fixation can be made by standing the horse squarely with the affected stifle in extension and the patella in its most proximal position. According to Habel, 4 this is the resting position of the patella as described by Preuss and Henschel. 10 With the palm of the hand placed on the patella (left hand for left patella, right hand for right patella), the examiner forces it caudally and slightly proximolaterally (Figure 1). While pressure is maintained on the patella in this manner, the person handling the horse is instructed to move the horse ahead one step. Normally, the medial parapatellar fibrocartilage, which is considered part of the medial patellar ligament, 3 will readily disengage from the medial femoral trochlea, 4 in our clinical experience, this is not the case in conditioned horses. Medial patellar desmotomy is commonly performed on horses with patellar fixation. 6 8 1 9 This procedure has the disadvantage of interrupting the horse's training program. An infrequent but disastrous sequel is rupture of the middle patellar ligament and the resulting inability to extend the stifle joint. As an alternative, application of external blisters to the stifle was recommended many years ago. 6 9 Injection of counterirritants into the medial and middle patellar ligaments has been described. 8 This latter treatment, in conjunction with a continued exercise program, has been used successfully by one of the authors (MPB) to treat clinical cases of patellar fixation. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the histological effects of injection of an iodine counterirritant solution into the patellar ligaments of ponies and relate these changes to the apparent clinical effectiveness of this treatment in horses with patellar fixation.
Read full abstract