Point-of-care (POC) devices are rapid, simple, portable, inexpensive, and convenient, but typically they only deliver qualitative results when used in the form of a lateral flow assay (LFA). Electrochemical detection could improve their sensitivity and ensure quantitative detection; however, a breakthrough in material-based technology is needed. We demonstrate a new concept in which electrodes are directly embedded within the lateral flow, enabling flow-through and hence interaction with the entire sample. This is accomplished through laser-induced carbon nanofibers (LCNFs) made by electrospinning Matrimid into nanofiber mats with subsequent pyrolyzing of electrode structures through a CO2 laser. Their highly porous 3D structure and superior graphene-like electrochemical properties are ideally suited for flow-through electrochemical LFA (EC-LFA), where the LCNFs are simply added in line with the other membranes. After optimization of the setup, biological binding assays typical for LFA diagnostics were successfully implemented, enabling the highly sensitive and quantitative detection of 137 pM DNA target sequences of a pathogenic organism that rivals the performance of pump-controlled microfluidic bioassays. This demonstrates that LCNF-based transducers can transform paper-based diagnostic tests to enable precise, quantitative analysis without reliance on cost-intensive read-out systems.