Metronome Breathing Research Articles

Cardiovascular Autonomic Dysfunction in Hospitalized Patients with a Bacterial Infection: A Longitudinal Observational Pilot Study in the UK.

A temporal reduction in the cardiovascular autonomic responses predisposes patients to cardiovascular instability after a viral infection and therefore increases the risk of associated complications. These findings have not been replicated in a bacterial infection. This pilot study will explore the prevalence of cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction (CAD) in hospitalized patients with a bacterial infection. A longitudinal observational pilot study was conducted. Fifty participants were included: 13 and 37 participants in the infection group and healthy group, respectively. Recruitment and data collection were carried out during a two-year period. Participants were followed up for 6 weeks: all participants' cardiovascular function was assessed at baseline (week 1) and reassessed subsequently at week 6 so that the progression of the autonomic function could be evaluated over that period of time. The collected data were thereafter analyzed using STATA/SE version 16.1 (StataCorp). The Fisher Exact test, McNemar exact test, Mann-Whitney test and Wilcoxon test were used for data analysis. 32.4% of the participants in the healthy group were males (n = 12) and 67.6% were females (n = 25). Participants' age ranged from 33 years old to 76 years old with the majority being 40-60 years of age (62.1%) (Mean age 52.4 SD = 11.4). Heart rate variability (HRV) in response to Valsalva Maneuver, metronome breathing, standing and sustained handgrip in the infection group was lower than in the healthy group throughout the weeks. Moreover, both the HRV in response to metronome breathing and standing up showed a statistically significant difference when the mean values were compared between both groups in week 1 (p = 0.03 and p = 0.013). The prevalence of CAD was significantly higher in the infection group compared to healthy volunteers, both at the beginning of the study (p = 0.018) and at the end of follow up (p = 0.057), when all patients had been discharged. CAD, as assessed by the HRV, is a common finding during the recovery period of a bacterial infection, even after 6 weeks post-hospital admission. This may increase the risk of complications and cardiovascular instability. It may therefore be of value to conduct a wider scale study to further evaluate this aspect so recommendations can be made for the cardiovascular autonomic assessment of patients while they are recovering from a bacterial infectious process.

The Association between Inflammatory Biomarkers and Cardiovascular Autonomic Dysfunction after Bacterial Infection

Heart rate variability (HRV) is a known measure of cardiac autonomic function. A cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction (CAD), measured as changes in HRV, is usually presented after an infectious process. The aim of the present study is to assess the association between serum inflammatory markers and CAD. For this purpose, 50 volunteers (13 of them recovering from an infection) were recruited and followed-up for 6 weeks. Their serum inflammatory biomarkers (CRP, IL1, IL4, IL6, IL10, and TNFalpha) were quantified throughout those weeks, along with their HRV resting, in response to the Valsalva maneuver, metronome breathing, standing and sustained handgrip. The correlation of within-subject changes in both HRV and inflammatory biomarkers was assessed to evaluate the concurrent changes. An inverse within-subject correlation was found between CRP and HRV in response to the Valsalva maneuver (rho (95% CI): −0.517 (−0.877 to −0.001); p = 0.032) and HRV standing (rho (95% CI): −0.490 (−0.943 to −0.036); p = 0.034). At the beginning, increased values of CRP are found along with reduced levels of HRV. Then, the CRP was reduced, accompanied by an improvement (increase) in HRV. These results suggest that CRP is a potential marker of CAD. Whether it is the cause, the consequence or a risk indicator non-causally associated is still to be determined.

Continuous Monitoring of Vital Signs With Wearable Sensors During Daily Life Activities: Validation Study.

BackgroundContinuous telemonitoring of vital signs in a clinical or home setting may lead to improved knowledge of patients’ baseline vital signs and earlier detection of patient deterioration, and it may also facilitate the migration of care toward home. Little is known about the performance of available wearable sensors, especially during daily life activities, although accurate technology is critical for clinical decision-making.ObjectiveThe aim of this study is to assess the data availability, accuracy, and concurrent validity of vital sign data measured with wearable sensors in volunteers during various daily life activities in a simulated free-living environment.MethodsVolunteers were equipped with 4 wearable sensors (Everion placed on the left and right arms, VitalPatch, and Fitbit Charge 3) and 2 reference devices (Oxycon Mobile and iButton) to obtain continuous measurements of heart rate (HR), respiratory rate (RR), oxygen saturation (SpO2), and temperature. Participants performed standardized activities, including resting, walking, metronome breathing, chores, stationary cycling, and recovery afterward. Data availability was measured as the percentage of missing data. Accuracy was evaluated by the median absolute percentage error (MAPE) and concurrent validity using the Bland-Altman plot with mean difference and 95% limits of agreement (LoA).ResultsA total of 20 volunteers (median age 64 years, range 20-74 years) were included. Data availability was high for all vital signs measured by VitalPatch and for HR and temperature measured by Everion. Data availability for HR was the lowest for Fitbit (4807/13,680, 35.14% missing data points). For SpO2 measured by Everion, median percentages of missing data of up to 100% were noted. The overall accuracy of HR was high for all wearable sensors, except during walking. For RR, an overall MAPE of 8.6% was noted for VitalPatch and that of 18.9% for Everion, with a higher MAPE noted during physical activity (up to 27.1%) for both sensors. The accuracy of temperature was high for VitalPatch (MAPE up to 1.7%), and it decreased for Everion (MAPE from 6.3% to 9%). Bland-Altman analyses showed small mean differences of VitalPatch for HR (0.1 beats/min [bpm]), RR (−0.1 breaths/min), and temperature (0.5 °C). Everion and Fitbit underestimated HR up to 5.3 (LoA of −39.0 to 28.3) bpm and 11.4 (LoA of −53.8 to 30.9) bpm, respectively. Everion had a small mean difference with large LoA (−10.8 to 10.4 breaths/min) for RR, underestimated SpO2 (>1%), and overestimated temperature up to 2.9 °C.ConclusionsData availability, accuracy, and concurrent validity of the studied wearable sensors varied and differed according to activity. In this study, the accuracy of all sensors decreased with physical activity. Of the tested sensors, VitalPatch was found to be the most accurate and valid for vital signs monitoring.

Respiratory sinus arrhythmia stabilizes mean arterial blood pressure at high-frequency interval in healthy humans.

Arterial blood pressure variations are an independent risk factor for end organ failure. Respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA) is a sign of a healthy cardiovascular system. However, whether RSA counteracts arterial blood pressure variations during the respiratory cycle remains controversial. We restricted normal RSA with non-invasive intermittent positive pressure ventilation (IPPV) to test the hypothesis that RSA normally functions to stabilize mean arterial blood pressure. Ten young volunteers were investigated during metronome-paced breathing and IPPV. Heart rate (ECG), mean arterial blood pressure and left stroke volume (finger arterial pressure curve) and right stroke volume (pulsed ultrasound Doppler) were recorded, while systemic and pulmonary blood flow were calculated beat-by-beat. Respiratory variations (high-frequency power, 0.15-0.40 Hz) in cardiovascular variables were estimated by spectral analysis. Phase angles and correlation were calculated by cross-spectral analysis. The magnitude of RSA was reduced from 4.9 bpm(2) (95% CI 3.0, 6.2) during metronome breathing to 2.8 bpm(2) (95% CI 1.1, 5.0) during IPPV (p = 0.03). Variations in mean arterial blood pressure were greater (2.3 mmHg(2) (95% CI 1.4, 3.9) during IPPV than during metronome breathing (1.0 mmHg(2) [95% CI 0.7, 1.3]) (p = 0.014). Respiratory variations in right and left stroke volumes were inversely related in the respiratory cycle during both metronome breathing and IPPV. RSA magnitude is lower and mean arterial blood pressure variability is greater during IPPV than during metronome breathing. We conclude that in healthy humans, RSA stabilizes mean arterial blood pressure at respiratory frequency.

Heart rate asymmetry follows the inspiration/expiration ratio in healthy volunteers

Heart rate asymmetry (HRA) quantifies the uneven distribution of points above and below the identity-line in a Poincaré plot of RR-intervals. The authors investigated if HRA could be influenced by the inspiration/expiration ratio. Healthy volunteers (n = 18) were studied in the supine position at 4.5 s metronome breathing. ECG and breathing signals were recorded for 360 s at each breathing pattern: inspiration controlled, inspiration/expiration controlled (1:2, 1:1, 2:1 ratio), inspiration controlled again. Time domain, frequency domain and Poincaré plot heart rate variability (HRV) analysis with Porta's and Guzik's indices were performed on 300 s tachograms. There were no statistically significant differences in time domain, frequency domain and standard Poincaré plot parameters during the various breathing patterns, whereas Porta's and Guzik's indices significantly rose at 1:1 and 2:1 compared to physiological 1:2 breathing. There were no significant differences in the HRA parameters between the first and the last runs. In our population the inspiration/expiration ratio significantly influenced HRA, but not standard HRV parameters. Positive correlation of Guzik's and Porta's index reflects reciprocal changes of the number of points and their dispersion in the accelerating and decelerating sets of RR-intervals. HRA-analysis can be a promising method for investigating cardiovascular regulation/health particularly with further spreading of wearable monitors.

Respiratory rate extraction from pulse oximeter and electrocardiographic recordings

We present an algorithm of respiratory rate extraction using particle filter (PF), which is applicable to both photoplethysmogram (PPG) and electrocardiogram (ECG) signals. For the respiratory rate estimation, 1 min data are analyzed with combination of a PF method and an autoregressive model where among the resultant coefficients, the corresponding pole angle with the highest magnitude is searched since this reflects the closest approximation of the true breathing rate. The PPG data were collected from 15 subjects with the metronome breathing rate ranging from 24 to 36 breaths per minute in the supine and upright positions. The ECG data were collected from 11 subjects with spontaneous breathing ranging from 36 to 60 breaths per minute during treadmill exercises. Our method was able to accurately extract respiratory rates for both metronome and spontaneous breathing even during strenuous exercises. More importantly, despite slow increases in breathing rates concomitant with greater exercise vigor with time, our method was able to accurately track these progressive increases in respiratory rates. We quantified the accuracy of our method by using the mean, standard deviation and interquartile range of the error rates which all reflected high accuracy in estimating the true breathing rates. We are not aware of any other algorithms that are able to provide accurate respiratory rates directly from either ECG signals or PPG signals with spontaneous breathing during strenuous exercises. Our method is near real-time realizable because the computational time on 1 min data segment takes only 10 ms on a 2.66 GHz Intel Core2 microprocessor; the data are subsequently shifted every 10 s to obtain near-continuous breathing rates. This is an attractive feature since most other techniques require offline data analyses to estimate breathing rates.

Detection of Nonlinearity in Cardiovascular Variability Signals using Cyclostationary Analysis

A novel approach for detection of polynomial nonlinearity in the neuro-cardiovascular system based on cyclostationary analysis is presented. Metronome breathing is employed to provide a sinusoidal input to the neuro-cardiovascular system in which Heart Rate Variability (HRV) and Blood Pressure Variation (BPV) are considered as its outputs. The presence of new harmonics of the main respiratory rate in the HRV and BPV is investigated by using the concept of (self) phase and (self) frequency coupling. It is shown that a second order polynomial nonlinear system is actually involved in producing the HRV and BPV. The strength of this nonlinearity decreases with increasing the breathing rate.

Impaired autonomic function is associated with increased mortality, especially in subjects with diabetes, hypertension, or a history of cardiovascular disease: the Hoorn Study.

Measures of baroreflex sensitivity, heart rate variability (HRV), and the classical Ewing test parameters are currently used for the diagnosis of diabetic autonomic neuropathy and for mortality risk stratification after myocardial infarction. However, the strengths of the associations of these measures of autonomic function with risk of mortality have never been compared in one study population. Furthermore, no evidence is available on the possible effect of glucose tolerance on these associations. The study population (n = 605) consisted of a glucose tolerance-stratified sample from a general population (50-75 years of age). Cardiac cycle duration and continuous finger arterial pressure were measured under two conditions: at rest and on metronome breathing. From these readings, seven parameters of autonomic function were assessed (one Ewing, five HRV, and one baroreflex sensitivity). During 9 years of follow-up, 101 individuals died, 43 from cardiovascular causes. Subjects with diabetes and low levels of the autonomic function parameters, indicating impaired autonomic function, had an approximately doubled risk of mortality. This association was consistent, though not statistically significant, for all parameters. The elevated risk was not observed in subjects without diabetes, hypertension, or prevalent cardiovascular disease. Impaired autonomic function is associated with all-cause and cardiovascular mortality. Moreover, the results of the present study suggest that cardiac autonomic dysfunction in patients already at risk (diabetes, hypertension, or history of cardiovascular disease) may be especially hazardous.

Bimodal dose-dependent effect on autonomic, cardiac control after oral administration of Atropa belladonna

This single-blind placebo-controlled study was designed to investigate the dose-dependent vagolytic and vagotonic effects after a single oral administration of Atropa belladonna tincture (ABT, 0.1 mg/ml alkaloid concentration, atropine/scopolamine=20:1). In eight healthy young subjects, heart rate and noninvasive arterial finger blood pressure were recorded simultaneously over 4 h after oral application of four different doses of ABT (day 1: 2 ml, day 2: placebo, day 3: 5 ml, day 4: 1 ml). On each day, 14 20-min sequences under controlled experimental conditions were performed. Among others, mean RR interval (RR), high-frequency spectral power of heart rate variability (HF), and noninvasive baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) were calculated during metronome breathing in supine position. These parameters were robust markers of vagal activity. One hour after 5ml ABT, RR, HF and BRS decreased clearly in six of eight subjects. This effect was interpreted as vagolytic response. After 1 and 2 ml ABT, and after placebo, RR and HF increased markedly. The increase after ABT was much higher than the increase solely due to adaptation after placebo administration, and it could be clearly identified as an augmentation of vagal cardiac activity caused by low-dose ABT. In conclusion, low doses of orally administered ABT can be effectively used to stimulate parasympathetic activity in man. The mode of vagal activation changes between 2 and 5 ml ABT from vagotonic to vagolytic. ABT has no or very little effect on blood pressure control.

The effects of metronome breathing on the variability of autonomic activity measurements

Background: Many chiropractors hypothesize that spinal manipulation affects the autonomic nervous system (ANS). However, the ANS responses to chiropractic manipulative therapy are not well documented, and more research is needed to support this hypothesis. This study represents a step toward the development of a reliable method by which to document that chiropractic manipulative therapy does affect the ANS by exploring the use of paced breathing as a way to reduce the inherent variability in ANS measurements. Objective: To examine the hypothesis that the variability of ANS measurements would be reduced if breathing were paced to a metronome at 12 breaths/min. Setting: The study was performed at Parker College Research Institute. Eight normotensive subjects were recruited from the student body and staff. Methods: Respiration frequency was measured through a strain gauge. A 3-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) was used to register the electric activity of the heart, and arterial tonometry monitors were used to record the left and right radial artery blood pressures. Signals were recorded on an IBM-compatible computer with a sampling frequency of 100 Hz. Normal breathing was used for the first 3 recordings, and breathing was paced to a metronome for the final 3 recordings at 12 breaths/min. Fourier analysis was performed on the beat-by-beat fluctuations of the ECG-determined R-R interval and systolic arterial pressure (SBP). Low-frequency fluctuations (LF; 0.04-0.15 Hz) reflected sympathetic activity, whereas high-frequency fluctuations (HF; 0.15-0.4 Hz) represented parasympathetic activity. Sympathovagal indices were determined from the ratio of the two bandwidths (LF/HF). The coefficient of variation (CV%) for autonomic parameters was calculated ([average/SD] × 100%) to compare breathing normally and breathing to a metronome with respect to variability. One-way analysis of variance was used to detect differences. A value of P <.05 was considered statistically significant; all results are presented as average ± SD. Results: Three male and 5 female normotensive subjects were studied. Metronome breathing did not produce any significant changes in blood pressure for the left and right radial arteries, heart rate, or pressure pulse transmission time. Breathing to a metronome increased ECG-HF power (0.25 ± 0.07 vs 0.35 ± 0.09, P <.04), decreased ECG-LF/HF (1.08 ± 0.55 vs 0.57 ± 0.35, P <.05), and reduced the CV% for ECG-LF (47.6% ± 23.4% vs 23.8% ± 14.6%, P <.03), ECG-HF (46.2% ± 14.2% vs 25.8% ± 17.0%, P <.03) and ECG-LF/HF (50.1% ± 27.6% vs 23.4% ± 12.3%, P <.03) in comparison with normal breathing. Metronome breathing increased the left and right radial artery SBP-HF fluctuations (left, 0.11 ± 0.05 vs 0.30 ± 0.16, P <.007; right, 0.09 ± 0.05 vs 0.27 ± 0.15, P <.008) and decreased the SBP-LF/HF components (left, 3.42 ± 2.36 vs 1.14 ± 0.88, P >.03; right, 3.08 ± 1.77 vs 1.20 ± 0.93, P <.02). Metronome breathing did not significantly alter the CV% for SBP-HF, SBP-LF, and SBP-LF/HF. Conclusions: Metronome breathing increased parasympathetic activity, as evidenced by augmented HF power in the ECG and SBP data. The variability (CV%) of ECG-determined ANS measurements was significantly reduced with paced breathing at 12 breaths/min, but no significant reductions were observed for the SBP-determined ANS measurements. These findings indicate that ECG data are more sensitive than SBP data for future clinical trials. (J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2000;23:610-4)

Baroreflex sensitivity in the elderly: influence of age, breathing and spectral methods

Baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) has been proposed as a diagnostic parameter for neurological disorders and as a survival-prognosis parameter in diabetic and cardiac patients. Therefore reference values and the reproducibility of BRS were assessed, taking into account the possible influence of age, gender, test conditions and some analysis variants. Healthy subjects (n=191) were randomly selected from the 50-75-year-old general population (the Hoorn Study). Variations in blood pressure and heart rate were recorded non-invasively during three breathing modes: spontaneous (3 min), slow metronome (1 min; 6 breaths/min=0.1 Hz) and fast metronome (1 min; 15 breaths/min=0.25 Hz), all in a supine position. From these recordings, BRS was assessed as the transfer gain between changes in blood pressure and heart period, and as the alpha coefficient. BRS values ranged from 5.0 to 8.9 ms.mmHg(-1). Slow metronome breathing resulted in higher BRS values than fast breathing, while during spontaneous breathing BRS in the low-frequency band was lower than that in the high-frequency band (respiratory origin). BRS values decreased with lower coherence criteria. BRS-alpha was significantly higher than BRS-gain. While regression analysis showed no gender differences, BRS decreased with age. Therefore age-specific reference values were calculated. The reproducibility of BRS values was in general moderate, with reliability coefficients ranging from 43 to 81% and coefficients of variation ranging from 34 to 59%. In conclusion, this study shows age, breathing mode, frequency and coherence threshold to affect measures of BRS. Therefore these factors should be considered in clinical studies; appropriate reference values are given.

Characterization of the factors that determine the effect of sympathetic stimulation on heart rate variability.

Heart rate variability analysis has been used to derive indices of sympathetic tone. As different sympathetic stimuli may give rise to divergent changes in heart rate variability, this study was designed to characterize the factors responsible for these divergent responses. Twelve healthy subjects (7 males, age 24.8 +/- 3.1 years) were evaluated. Five-minute electrocardiographic recordings were obtained at baseline, following upright tilt, and during isoproterenol infusion (25 ng/kg per min) under control conditions and following parasympathetic blockade. Data were acquired during spontaneous respiration and when breathing was timed with a metronome (15 breaths/min). Under control conditions, both upright tilt and isoproterenol infusion resulted in significant decreases in the SD and MSSD from baseline values of 69 +/- 3 ms and 64 +/- 5 ms to 48 +/- 4 ms and 21 +/- 5 ms during tilt and 44 +/- 4 ms and 20 +/- 5 ms during isoproterenol infusion, respectively. LF power also significantly increased from 0.47 +/- 0.17 ln (beats/min)2 at baseline to 1.90 +/- 0.20. In (beats/min)2 and 1.34 +/- 0.18. In (beats/min)2 during tilt and isoproterenol infusion, respectively. No change in HF power was noted. Following parasympathetic blockade, all heart rate variability parameters were significantly decreased. No significant change from baseline in the SD, MSSD, or HF power was noted with either tilt or isoproterenol infusion. The LF power increased only with tilt from a baseline value of -3.17 +/- 0.17 in (beats/min)2 to -0.41 +/- 0.19 in (beats/min)2. Similar changes were noted during spontaneous respiration and metronome breathing. These findings demonstrate that the response of the sinus node to beta-adrenergic stimulation depends on the mode of stimulation. In addition, the associated level of parasympathetic tone affects the observed changes in heart rate variability that are associated with sympathetic stimulation.

Aging Effects on Heart Rate Variation

Heart rate variation was studied in 56 healthy subjects from ages 20-81 while supine and standing during spontaneous and metronome breathing. Time domain analyses revealed no age effect on supine heart rate but standing heart rate decreased with aging (p less than .008). The SD of R-R intervals decreased with increasing age in both positions (p less than .001). Frequency domain analysis (Fast Fourier Transformation of R-R interval data) showed total spectral content to decrease with aging (p less than .001). Both high frequency (0.20-0.32 Hz) and low frequency (0.04-0.12 Hz) content were reduced with aging (p less than .001). The ratio of high to low frequency content, however, was not affected by age in the supine position nor were changes in this ratio in response to standing during spontaneous breathing. Although the absolute increase in low frequency content upon standing was less with aging (p less than .001), the percent increase in low frequency content was not related to age. Metronome breathing decreased total spectral content (p less than .001) but increased high frequency content, especially in younger subjects (p less than .03). In response to standing, greater proportional and absolute decreases in high frequency content occurred in younger subjects resulting in age differences in the changes in ratios of high to low frequency content with standing during metronome breathing. In summary, decreased heart rate variation was seen with aging, but the balance between parasympathetic and beta-adrenergic input at rest and in response to postural changes does not appear to be influenced by age during spontaneous breathing. Metronome breathing altered spectral content within subjects and produced age-related differences in responses to postural maneuvers not seen during spontaneous breathing.