Current methods for tracing decades-old groundwaters rely on isotope geochemistry to determine groundwater age and altitude at the point of infiltration. Temporal and spatial variability in atmospheric conditions, and waterârock interactions, can make the interpretation of isotopes uncertain. Here, we propose a new method of groundwater tracing based on the fingerprinting of natural dissolved organics. We present our initial findings from the Grimsel Test Site in Switzerland, located within a fractured granite. Using 2D gas chromatography, we derive detailed organic fingerprints from surface soils at several locations and show that different soils produce distinctly different dissolved organic signatures. We then compare the soils with groundwater and lake water using a non-targeted approach employing principal component analysis and hierarchical cluster analysis. Our analysis finds three statistically significant clusters. Most groundwaters are clustered with the lake-water samples but two are clustered with soil from the highest altitude surface sampling location. We hypothesize that for samples to form a significant cluster, they must have been derived from a common environment, with a unique combination of organic compounds. For groundwaters to cluster with soil samples or lake water, we theorize there must be a hydraulic connection between the type of infiltration environment and the groundwater sampling locations within each cluster. Our research demonstrates that organic molecules derived from the surface environment can be used to discriminate near-surface environment(s) through which meteoric groundwater has infiltrated. Organic fingerprinting could prove a powerful tool for improved understanding of groundwater flow systems, particularly when combined with other complementary techniques. Supplementary material : Compound alignment data set and supplementary tables are available at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.7129987 Thematic collection: This article is part of the Sustainable geological disposal and containment of radioactive waste collection available at: https://www.lyellcollection.org/topic/collections/radioactive