Metal-binding Pharmacophores Research Articles

Design and synthesis of 7-membered lactam fused hydroxypyridinones as potent metal binding pharmacophores (MBPs) for inhibiting influenza virus PAN endonuclease

Since influenza virus RNA polymerase subunit PAN is a dinuclear Mn2+ dependent endonuclease, metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) with Mn2+ coordination has been elucidated as a promising strategy to develop PAN inhibitors for influenza treatment. However, few attentions have been paid to the relationship between the optimal arrangement of the donor atoms in MBPs and anti-influenza A virus (IAV) efficacy. Given that, the privileged hydroxypyridinones fusing a seven-membered lactam ring with diverse side chains, chiral centers or cyclic systems were designed and synthesized. A structure-activity relationship study resulted in a hit compound 16l (IC50 = 2.868 ± 0.063 μM against IAV polymerase), the seven-membered lactam ring of which was fused a pyrrolidine ring. Further optimization of the hydrophobic binding groups on 16l afforded a lead compound (R, S)-16s, which exhibited a 64-fold more potent inhibitory activity (IC50 = 0.045 ± 0.002 μM) toward IAV polymerase. Moreover, (R, S)-16s demonstrated a potent anti-IAV efficacy (EC50 = 0.134 ± 0.093 μM) and weak cytotoxicity (CC50 = 15.35 μM), indicating the high selectivity of (R, S)-16s. Although the lead compound (R, S)-16s exhibited a little weaker activity than baloxavir, these findings illustrated the utility of a metal coordination-based strategy in generating novel MBPs with potent anti-influenza activity.

Masking thiol reactivity with thioamide, thiourea, and thiocarbamate-based MBPs.

Thioamides, thioureas, and thiocarbamates are introduced as stable, sulfur-based metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) for use in metalloenzyme fragment-based drug discovery (mFBDD). MBP reactivity, bioactivity, and structural studies show that these molecules can act as ligands for Zn(II)-dependent metalloenzymes including human carbonic anhydrase II (hCAII) and matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2).

Carboxylic Acid Isostere Derivatives of Hydroxypyridinones as Core Scaffolds for Influenza Endonuclease Inhibitors.

Among the most important influenza virus targets is the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase acidic N-terminal (PAN) endonuclease, which is a critical component of the viral replication machinery. To inhibit the activity of this metalloenzyme, small-molecule inhibitors employ metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) that coordinate to the dinuclear Mn2+ active site. In this study, several metal-binding isosteres (MBIs) were examined where the carboxylic acid moiety of a hydroxypyridinone MBP is replaced with other groups to modulate the physicochemical properties of the compound. MBIs were evaluated for their ability to inhibit PAN using a FRET-based enzymatic assay, and their mode of binding in PAN was determined using X-ray crystallography.

MeDBA: the Metalloenzyme Data Bank and Analysis platform.

Metalloenzymes are attractive research targets in fields of chemistry, biology, and medicine. Given that metalloenzymes can manifest conservation of metal-coordination and ligand binding modes, the excavation and expansion of metalloenzyme-specific knowledge is of interest in bridging metalloenzyme-related fields. Building on our previous metalloenzyme-ligand association database, MeLAD, we have expanded the scope of metalloenzyme-specific knowledge and services, by forming a versatile platform, termed the Metalloenzyme Data Bank and Analysis (MeDBA). The MeDBA provides: (i) manual curation of metalloenzymes into different categories, that this M-I, M-II and M-III; (ii) comprehensive information on metalloenzyme activities, expression profiles, familyand disease links; (iii) structural information on metalloenzymes, in particular metal binding modes; (iv) metalloenzyme substrates and bioactive molecules acting on metalloenzymes; (v) excavated metal-binding pharmacophoresand (vi) analysis tools for structure/metal active site comparison and metalloenzyme profiling. The MeDBA is freely available at https://medba.ddtmlab.org.

Targeting undruggable carbohydrate recognition sites through focused fragment library design

Carbohydrate-protein interactions are key for cell-cell and host-pathogen recognition and thus, emerged as viable therapeutic targets. However, their hydrophilic nature poses major limitations to the conventional development of drug-like inhibitors. To address this shortcoming, four fragment libraries were screened to identify metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) as novel scaffolds for inhibition of Ca2+-dependent carbohydrate-protein interactions. Here, we show the effect of MBPs on the clinically relevant lectins DC-SIGN, Langerin, LecA and LecB. Detailed structural and biochemical investigations revealed the specificity of MBPs for different Ca2+-dependent lectins. Exploring the structure-activity relationships of several fragments uncovered the functional groups in the MBPs suitable for modification to further improve lectin binding and selectivity. Selected inhibitors bound efficiently to DC-SIGN-expressing cells. Altogether, the discovery of MBPs as a promising class of Ca2+-dependent lectin inhibitors creates a foundation for fragment-based ligand design for future drug discovery campaigns.

Developing Metal-Binding Isosteres of 8-Hydroxyquinoline as Metalloenzyme Inhibitor Scaffolds.

The use of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) in fragment-based drug discovery has proven effective for targeted metalloenzyme drug development. However, MBPs can still suffer from pharmacokinetic liabilities. Bioisostere replacement is an effective strategy utilized by medicinal chemists to navigate these issues during the drug development process. The quinoline pharmacophore and its bioisosteres, such as quinazoline, are important building blocks in the design of new therapeutics. More relevant to metalloenzyme inhibition, 8-hydroxyquinoline (8-HQ) and its derivatives can serve as MBPs for metalloenzyme inhibition. In this report, 8-HQ isosteres are designed and the coordination chemistry of the resulting metal-binding isosteres (MBIs) is explored using a bioinorganic model complex. In addition, the physicochemical properties and metalloenzyme inhibition activity of these MBIs were investigated to establish drug-like profiles. This report provides a new group of 8-HQ-derived MBIs that can serve as novel scaffolds for metalloenzyme inhibitor development with tunable, and potentially improved, physicochemical properties.

Computational Prediction of the Binding Pose of Metal-Binding Pharmacophores.

Computational modeling of inhibitors for metalloenzymes in virtual drug development campaigns has proven challenging. To overcome this limitation, a technique for predicting the binding pose of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) is presented. Using a combination of density functional theory (DFT) calculations and docking using a genetic algorithm, inhibitor binding was evaluated in silico and compared with inhibitor-enzyme cocrystal structures. The predicted binding poses were found to be consistent with the cocrystal structures. The computational strategy presented represents a useful tool for predicting metalloenzyme-MBP interactions.

Targeting Metalloenzymes by Boron-Containing Metal-Binding Pharmacophores.

Metalloenzymes have critical roles in a wide range of biological processes and are directly involved in many human diseases; hence, they are considered as important targets for therapeutic intervention. The specific characteristics of metal ion(s)-containing active sites make exploitation of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) critical to inhibitor development targeting metalloenzymes. This Perspective focuses on boron-containing MBPs, which display unique binding modes with metalloenzyme active sites, particularly via mimicking native substrates or tetrahedral transition states. The design concepts regarding boron-containing MBPs are highlighted through the case analyses on five distinct classes of clinically relevant nucleophilic metalloenzymes from medicinal chemistry perspectives. The challenges (e.g., selectivity) faced by some boron-containing MBPs and possible strategies (e.g., bioisosteres) for metalloenzyme inhibitor transformation are also discussed.

Evaluating Metal-Ligand Interactions of Metal-Binding Isosteres Using Model Complexes.

Bioisosteres are a useful approach to address pharmacokinetic liabilities and improve drug-like properties. Specific to developing metalloenzyme inhibitors, metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) have been combined with bioisosteres, to produce metal-binding isosteres (MBIs) as alternative scaffolds for use in fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD). Picolinic acid MBIs have been reported and evaluated for their metal-binding ability, pharmacokinetic properties, and enzyme inhibitory activity. However, their structural, electronic, and spectroscopic properties with metal ions other than Zn(II) have not been reported, which might reveal similarities and differences between MBIs and the parent MBPs. To this end, [M(TPA)(MBI)]+ (M = Ni(II) and Co(II), TPA = tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine) is presented as a bioinorganic model system for investigating picolinic acid, four heterocyclic MBIs, and 2,2'-bipyridine. These complexes were characterized by X-ray crystallography as well as NMR, IR, and UV-vis spectroscopies, and their magnetic moments were accessed. In addition, [(TpPh,Me)Co(MBI)] (TpPh,Me = hydrotris(3,5-phenylmethylpyrazolyl)borate) was used as a second model compound, and the limitations and attributes of the two model systems are discussed. These results demonstrate that bioinorganic model complexes are versatile tools for metalloenzyme inhibitor design and can provide insights into the broader use of MBIs.

Hydroxypyridinethione Inhibitors of Human Insulin-Degrading Enzyme.

Insulin-degrading enzyme (IDE) is a human mononuclear Zn2+ -dependent metalloenzyme that is widely regarded as the primary peptidase responsible for insulin degradation. Despite its name, IDE is also critically involved in the hydrolysis of several other disparate peptide hormones, including glucagon, amylin, and the amyloid β-protein. As such, the study of IDE inhibition is highly relevant to deciphering the role of IDE in conditions such as type-2 diabetes mellitus and Alzheimer disease. There have been few reported IDE inhibitors, and of these, inhibitors that directly target the active-site Zn2+ ion have yet to be fully explored. In an effort to discover new, zinc-targeting inhibitors of IDE, a library of ∼350 metal-binding pharmacophores was screened against IDE, resulting in the identification of 1-hydroxypyridine-2-thione (1,2-HOPTO) as an effective Zn2+ -binding scaffold. Screening a focused library of HOPTO compounds identified 3-sulfonamide derivatives of 1,2-HOPTO as inhibitors of IDE (Ki values of ∼50 μM). Further structure-activity relationship studies yielded several thiophene-sulfonamide HOPTO derivatives with good, broad-spectrum activity against IDE that have the potential to be useful pharmacological tools for future studies of IDE.

19F-Tagged metal binding pharmacophores for NMR screening of metalloenzymes.

This study demonstrates the screening of a collection of twelve 19F-tagged metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) against the Zn(ii)-dependent metalloenzyme human carbonic anhydrase II (hCAII) by 19F NMR. The isomorphous replacement of Zn(ii) by Co(ii) in hCAII produces enhanced sensitivity and reveals the potential of 19F NMR-based techniques for metalloenzyme ligand discovery.

Identification of Adenosine Deaminase Inhibitors by Metal-binding Pharmacophore Screening.

Adenosine deaminase (ADA) is a human mononuclear Zn2+ metalloenzyme that converts adenosine to inosine. ADA is a validated drug target for cancer, but there has been little recent work on the development of new therapeutics against this enzyme. The lack of new advancements can be partially attributed to an absence of suitable assays for high-throughput screening (HTS) against ADA. To facilitate more rapid drug discovery efforts for this target, an in vitro assay was developed that utilizes the enzymatic conversion of a visibly emitting adenosine analogue to the corresponding fluorescent inosine analogue by ADA, which can be monitored via fluorescence intensity changes. Utilizing this assay, a library of ∼350 small molecules containing metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) was screened in an HTS format to identify new inhibitor scaffolds against ADA. This approach yielded a new metal-binding scaffold with a Ki value of 26±1 μM.

SAR Exploration of Tight-Binding Inhibitors of Influenza Virus PA Endonuclease.

Significant efforts have been reported on the development of influenza antivirals including inhibitors of the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase PA N-terminal (PAN) endonuclease. Based on recently identified, highly active metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) for PAN endonuclease inhibition, a fragment-based drug development campaign was pursued. Guided by coordination chemistry and structure-based drug design, MBP scaffolds were elaborated to improve activity and selectivity. Structure-activity relationships were established and used to generate inhibitors of influenza endonuclease with tight-binding affinities. The activity of these inhibitors was analyzed using a fluorescence-quenching-based nuclease activity assay, and binding was validated using differential scanning fluorometry. Lead compounds were found to be highly selective for PAN endonuclease against several related dinuclear and mononuclear metalloenzymes. Combining principles of bioinorganic and medicinal chemistry in this study has resulted in some of the most active in vitro influenza PAN endonuclease inhibitors with high ligand efficiencies.

MeLAD: an integrated resource for metalloenzyme-ligand associations.

Metalloenzymes are attractive targets for therapeutic intervention owing to their central roles in various biological processes and pathological situations. The fast-growing body of structural data on metalloenzyme-ligand interactions is facilitating efficient drug discovery targeting metalloenzymes. However, there remains a shortage of specific databases that can provide centralized, interconnected information exclusive to metalloenzyme-ligand associations. We created a Metalloenzyme-Ligand Association Database (MeLAD), which is designed to provide curated structural data and information exclusive to metalloenzyme-ligand interactions, and more uniquely, present expanded associations that are represented by metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs), metalloenzyme structural similarity (MeSIM) and ligand chemical similarity (LigSIM). MeLAD currently contains 6086 structurally resolved interactions of 1416 metalloenzymes with 3564 ligands, of which classical metal-binding, non-classical metal-binding, non-metal-binding and metal water-bridging interactions account for 63.0%, 2.3%, 34.4% and 0.3%, respectively. A total of 263 monodentate, 191 bidentate and 15 tridentate MBP chemotypes were included in MeLAD, which are linked to different active site metal ions and coordination modes. 3726 and 52740 deductive metalloenzyme-ligand associations by MeSIM and LigSIM analyses, respectively, were included in MeLAD. An online server is provided for users to conduct metalloenzyme profiling prediction for small molecules of interest. MeLAD is searchable by multiple criteria, e.g. metalloenzyme name, ligand identifier, functional class, bioinorganic class, metal ion and metal-containing cofactor, which will serve as a valuable, integrative data source to foster metalloenzyme related research, particularly involved in drug discovery targeting metalloenzymes. MeLAD is accessible at https://melad.ddtmlab.org. Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Metal Coordination Is Crucial for Geranylgeranyl Diphosphate Synthase-Bisphosphonate Interactions: A Crystallographic and Computational Analysis.

Geranylgeranyl diphosphate synthase (GGPPS) is a central metalloenzyme in the mevalonate pathway, crucial for the prenylation of small GTPases. As small GTPases are pivotal for cellular survival, GGPPS was highlighted as a potential target for treating human diseases, including solid and hematologic malignancies and parasitic infections. Most available GGPPS inhibitors are bisphosphonates, but the clinically available compounds demonstrate poor pharmacokinetic properties. Although the design of novel bisphosphonates with improved physicochemical properties is highly desirable, the structure of wild-type human GGPPS (hGGPPS) bound to a bisphosphonate has not been resolved. Moreover, various metal-bisphosphonate-binding stoichiometries were previously reported in structures of yeast GGPPS (yGGPPS), hampering computational drug design with metal-binding pharmacophores (MBP). In this study, we report the 2.2 Å crystal structure of hGGPPS in complex with ibandronate, clearly depicting the involvement of three Mg2+ ions in bisphosphonate-protein interactions. Using drug-binding assays and computational docking, we show that the assignment of three Mg2+ ions to the binding site of both hGGPPS and yGGPPS greatly improves the correlation between calculated binding energies and experimentally measured affinities. This work provides a structural basis for future rational design of additional MBP-harboring drugs targeting hGGPPS. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Bisphosphonates are inhibitors of geranylgeranyl diphosphate synthase (GGPPS), a metalloenzyme crucial for cell survival. Bisphosphonate binding depends on coordination by Mg2+ ions, but various Mg2+-bisphosphonate-binding stoichiometries were previously reported. In this study, we show that three Mg2+ ions are vital for drug binding and provide a structural basis for future computational design of GGPPS inhibitors.

Metal-Binding Pharmacophore Library Yields the Discovery of a Glyoxalase 1 Inhibitor.

Anxiety and depression are common, highly comorbid psychiatric diseases that account for a large proportion of worldwide medical disability. Glyoxalase 1 (GLO1) has been identified as a possible target for the treatment of anxiety and depression. GLO1 is a Zn2+-dependent enzyme that isomerizes a hemithioacetal, formed from glutathione and methylglyoxal, to a lactic acid thioester. To develop active inhibitors of GLO1, fragment-based drug discovery was used to identify fragments that could serve as core scaffolds for lead development. After screening a focused library of metal-binding pharmacophores, 8-(methylsulfonylamino)quinoline (8-MSQ) was identified as a hit. Through computational modeling and synthetic elaboration, a potent GLO1 inhibitor was developed with a novel sulfonamide core pharmacophore. A lead compound was demonstrated to penetrate the blood-brain barrier, elevate levels of methylglyoxal in the brain, and reduce depression-like behavior in mice. These findings provide the basis for GLO1 inhibitors to treat depression and related psychiatric illnesses.

Metal-Binding Isosteres as New Scaffolds for Metalloenzyme Inhibitors.

The principle of isosteres or bioisosteres in medicinal chemistry is a central and essential concept in modern drug discovery. For example, carboxylic acids are often replaced by bioisosteres to mitigate issues related to lipophilicity or acidity while retaining acidic characteristics in addition to hydrogen bond donor/acceptor abilities. Separately, the development of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) for binding to the active site metal ion in metalloenzymes of therapeutic interest is an emerging area in the realm of fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD). The direct application of the bioisostere concept to MBPs has not been well-described or systematically investigated. Herein, the picolinic acid MBP is used as a case study for the development of MBP isosteres (so-called MBIs). Many of these isosteres are novel compounds, and data on their physicochemical properties, metal binding capacity, and metalloenzyme inhibition characteristics are presented. The results show that MBIs of picolinic acid generally retain metal coordinating properties and exhibit predictable metalloenzyme inhibitory activity while possessing a broad range of physicochemical properties (e.g., p Ka, log P). These findings demonstrate the use of bioisosteres results in an untapped source of metal binding functional groups suitable for metalloenzyme FBDD. These MBIs provide a previously unexplored route for modulating the physicochemical properties of metalloenzyme inhibitors and improving their drug-likeness.

A Bioinorganic Approach to Fragment-Based Drug Discovery Targeting Metalloenzymes.

Metal-dependent enzymes (i.e., metalloenzymes) make up a large fraction of all enzymes and are critically important in a wide range of biological processes, including DNA modification, protein homeostasis, antibiotic resistance, and many others. Consequently, metalloenzymes represent a vast and largely untapped space for drug development. The discovery of effective therapeutics that target metalloenzymes lies squarely at the interface of bioinorganic and medicinal chemistry and requires expertise, methods, and strategies from both fields to mount an effective campaign. In this Account, our research program that brings together the principles and methods of bioinorganic and medicinal chemistry are described, in an effort to bridge the gap between these fields and address an important class of medicinal targets. Fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) is an important drug discovery approach that is particularly well suited for metalloenzyme inhibitor development. FBDD uses relatively small but diverse chemical structures that allow for the assembly of privileged molecular collections that focus on a specific feature of the target enzyme. For metalloenzyme inhibition, the specific feature is rather obvious, namely, a metal-dependent active site. Surprisingly, prior to our work, the exploration of diverse molecular fragments for binding the metal active sites of metalloenzymes was largely unexplored. By assembling a modest library of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs), we have been able to find lead hits for many metalloenzymes and, from these hits, develop inhibitors that act via novel mechanisms of action. A specific case study on the use of this strategy to identify a first-in-class inhibitor of zinc-dependent Rpn11 (a component of the proteasome) is highlighted. The application of FBDD for the development of metalloenzyme inhibitors has raised several other compelling questions, such as how the metalloenzyme active site influences the coordination chemistry of bound fragments, how one can identify the best fragments for a given metalloenzyme, and many others. Among the most significant, and concerning, questions for metalloenzyme inhibition are those that reside around issues of specificity and whether metalloenzyme inhibitors can be as selective and specific as other small molecule inhibitors (i.e., compounds that inhibit enzymes that do not utilize a metal at their active site). This also leads to the question of whether metalloenzyme inhibitors might interfere more broadly with the metallome. Efforts to address these and related questions are discussed, with the expectation that our findings will illuminate some of these topics, alleviate some of these concerns, and encourage greater interest in this important, undervalued class of drug targets.

Effect of donor atom identity on metal-binding pharmacophore coordination.

The inhibition and binding of three metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs), 2-hydroxycyclohepta-2,4,6-trien-1-one (tropolone), 2-mercaptopyridine-N-oxide (1,2-HOPTO), and 2-hydroxycyclohepta-2,4,6-triene-1-thione (thiotropolone) to human carbonic anhydrase II (hCAII) and a mutant protein hCAII L198G were investigated. These MBPs displayed bidentate coordination to the active site Zn(II) metal ion, but the MBPs respond to the mutation of L198G differently, as characterized by inhibition activity assays and X-ray crystallography. The L198G mutation increases the active site volume thereby decreasing the steric pressure exerted on MBPs upon binding, allowing changes in MBP coordination to be observed. When comparing the binding mode of tropolone to thiotropolone or 1,2-HOPTO (O,O versus O,S donor sets), structural modifications of the hCAII active site were shown to have a stronger effect on MBPs with an O,O versus O,S donor set. These findings were corroborated with density functional theory (DFT) calculations of model coordination complexes. These results suggest that the MBP binding geometry is a malleable interaction, particularly for certain ligands, and that the identity of the donor atoms influences the response of the ligand to changes in the protein active site environment. Understanding underlying interactions between a MBP and a metalloenzyme active site may aid in the design and development of potent metalloenzyme inhibitors.

Discovery of an Inhibitor of the Proteasome Subunit Rpn11.

The proteasome plays a crucial role in degradation of normal proteins that happen to be constitutively or inducibly unstable, and in this capacity it plays a regulatory role. Additionally, it degrades abnormal/damaged/mutant/misfolded proteins, which serves a quality-control function. Inhibitors of the proteasome have been validated in the treatment of multiple myeloma, with several FDA-approved therapeutics. Rpn11 is a Zn2+-dependent metalloisopeptidase that hydrolyzes ubiquitin from tagged proteins that are trafficked to the proteasome for degradation. A fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) approach was utilized to identify fragments with activity against Rpn11. Screening of a library of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) revealed that 8-thioquinoline (8TQ, IC50 value ∼2.5 μM) displayed strong inhibition of Rpn11. Further synthetic elaboration of 8TQ yielded a small molecule compound (35, IC50 value ∼400 nM) that is a potent and selective inhibitor of Rpn11 that blocks proliferation of tumor cells in culture.