Metacarpal Extension Osteotomy Research Articles

Diagnosis and Treatment of Carpometacarpal Instability.

Hypermobility of the first CMC joint may adversely affect hand function and may lead to osteoarthritis later in life. It presents more commonly in younger women with generalized joint hypermobility or postmenopausal women with early stages of arthritis. It may follow trauma and deletive surgical interventions. Clinically, joint subluxation manifests with a prominent and unstable thumb base, and is radiographically confirmed by stress views. A variety of ligament reconstruction techniques are available to stabilize the CMC joint including open ligament reconstruction with or without temporary Kirschner-wire fixation, arthroscopic debridement with capsular shrinkage, metacarpal extension osteotomy, internal proprietary anchors, and arthrodesis.

Outcomes of First Metacarpal Extension Osteotomy for Base of Thumb Arthritis.

First metacarpal extension osteotomy (FMEO) aims to correct the adduction deformity associated with thumb arthritis, as well as improve the congruity at the first carpometacarpal (FCMC) joint. However, the benefits of this procedure are currently unclear. The purpose of this study is to investigate the outcomes of FMEO in the treatment of FCMC joint arthritis. Electronic databases were searched systematically for original data studies in the English language reporting outcomes following FMEO for base of thumb arthritis. Data were extracted from the text, tables, and figures of publications and meta-analyzed where possible. Ten publications comprising 211 thumbs were included. FMEO was associated with an improvement in pain relief and patient-reported functional outcomes, however meta-analysis showed no significant long-term improvement in grip strength or lateral pinch grip. Although there was disease progression in one third of patients after FMEO, most did not require further procedures. Outcomes following secondary procedures was not analyzed in the literature. FMEO produced a range of minor complications, however, major complications were rare. The available evidence suggests FMEO does not improve grip or pinch strength. However, it may have a role in analgesia and improvement in functional outcomes. Further studies should compare outcomes of FMEO to continued nonoperative treatment, or other surgical options including arthroscopy or ligamentous reconstruction.

Survival and Long-Term Outcomes of Thumb Metacarpal Extension Osteotomy for Symptomatic Carpometacarpal Laxity and Early Basal Joint Arthritis

To evaluate the survival and long-term outcomes of thumb metacarpal extension osteotomy for early carpometacarpal (CMC) arthritis. Patients who underwent a thumb extension osteotomy between years 2000 and 2011 were identified. Patient demographics, complications, and reoperations were recorded. The Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was used with subsequent CMC surgery defined as failure. Patients who had undergone surgery 10 years or more before the study date underwent radiographic assessment, grip and pinch strength testing, and completed the Patient Rated Wrist/Hand Evaluation (PRWHE) and the Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (QuickDASH) questionnaires. Thirty-two procedures in 7 males and 21 females were performed (mean age, 44.8 y). There were no cases of nonunion. Nine of 32 thumbs developed pin site erythema and were treated with oral antibiotics. Two thumbs developed osteomyelitis. Seven of 32 thumbs (22%) required reoperation. The Kaplan-Meier analysis indicated a 70% probability that patients who have this procedure will not require additional CMC surgery up to 14 years. Seven patients with a mean follow-up of 12.3 years (minimum 10 y) returned for clinical evaluation. The mean PRWHE and QuickDASH scores were 32.1 and 27.7, respectively. Examination revealed 124% pinch and 98% grip strength relative to the preoperative values. One thumb did not progress from stage II disease; 2 thumbs progressed from stage I to stage II; 1 thumb progressed from stage II to stage III; 1 thumb progressed from stage II to stage IV; 1 thumb did not have disease progression at the CMC joint, but developed scaphotrapeziotrapezoidal arthritis. Although reoperation rates and superficial infections with the described method of fixation were relatively high, thumb metacarpal osteotomy provides some degree of pain relief and improvement of function. This procedure may have utility as a temporizing measure in younger patients as it does not compromise future reconstructive procedures. Therapeutic IV.

Long-term follow-up of first metacarpal extension osteotomy for early CMC arthritis.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate long-term outcomes of first metacarpal extension osteotomy for early trapeziometacarpal arthritis. We retrospectively reviewed 13 patients who underwent first metacarpal extension osteotomy at our institution between 1996 and 2005 and obtained subjective and objective outcome data. Mean follow-up was 9.9years (range 6 to 14years). Ten of the 13 patients (77%) were either satisfied or very satisfied with their results. Mean pain level was 2.00 on a scale of 1 (nonexistent) to 7 (unbearable). Mean QuickDASH score was 24.17, with a median score of 9.09. Mean pinch strength was 13.1lbs compared to 12.8lbs in the nonoperative extremity. Mean radial abduction of the thumb was 45.5° which was equal to the nonoperative extremity. Of the eight patients who agreed to repeat radiographs, five had no progression of degenerative changes compared to pre-op radiographs. Based on subjective and objective follow-up data, first metacarpal extension osteotomy can provide good long-term results in terms of patient satisfaction, pain relief, and upper extremity function. It is a reasonable alternative to ligament reconstruction in patients with early-stage trapeziometacarpal arthritis.

Opening Wedge Trapezial Osteotomy as Possible Treatment for Early Trapeziometacarpal Osteoarthritis: A Biomechanical Investigation of Radial Subluxation, Contact Area, and Contact Pressure

Radial subluxation and cartilage thinning have been associated with initiation and accelerated development of osteoarthritis of the trapeziometacarpal joint. Few investigators have reported on the benefits of opening wedge trapezial osteotomy for altering the contact mechanics of the trapeziometacarpal joint as a possible deterrent to the initiation or progression of osteoarthritis. We used cadaveric specimens to determine whether opening wedge osteotomy of the trapezium was successful in reducing radial subluxation of the metacarpal base and to quantify the contact area and pressure on the trapezial surface during simulated lateral pinch. We used 8 fresh-frozen specimens in this study. The flexor pollicis longus, abductor pollicis longus, adductor pollicis, abductor pollicis brevis, and flexor pollicis brevis/opponens pollicis tendons were each loaded to simulate the thumb in lateral pinch position. We measured radial subluxation from anteroposterior radiographs before and after placement of a 15° wedge. We used real-time sensors to analyze contact pressure and contact area distribution on the trapezium. Center of force in the normal joint under lateral pinch loading was primarily located in the dorsal region of the trapezium. After wedge placement, contact pressure increased in the ulnar-dorsal region by 76%. Mean contact area increased in the ulnar-dorsal region from 0.05 to 0.07 cm(2), and in the ulnar-volar region from 0.003 to 0.024 cm(2). The average reduction in joint subluxation was 64%. The 15° opening wedge osteotomy of the trapezium reduced radial subluxation of the metacarpal on the trapezium and increased contact pressure and contact area away from the diseased compartments of the trapezial surface. Trapezial osteotomy addresses the 2 preeminent theories about the initiation and progression of osteoarthritis. By reducing radial subluxation and altering contact pressure and contact area, trapezial osteotomy may prove an alternative to first metacarpal extension osteotomy or ligament reconstruction in early stages of degenerative arthritis of the trapeziometacarpal joint.

Basal Metacarpal Osteotomy for Osteoarthritis of the Thumb

Thumb metacarpal extension osteotomy provides effective treatment for the hypermobile trapeziometacarpal joint consistent with Eaton stage 1 disease. This procedure is a useful alternative to Eaton ligament reconstruction. Clinical outcomes are favorable and, should symptoms persist, the procedure does not jeopardize satisfactory execution of trapezial resection arthroplasty in the future.

Long-Term Outcomes of First Metacarpal Extension Osteotomy in the Treatment of Carpal-Metacarpal Osteoarthritis

The purpose of this study was to investigate the long-term outcomes of first metacarpal extension osteotomy in the treatment of osteoarthritis of the thumb carpal-metacarpal joint. We retrospectively reviewed 8 patients treated by a single surgeon with first metacarpal extension osteotomy. Preoperative Eaton stage was I in 3 patients, II in 3 patients, and III in 2 patients. Mean follow-up was 9 years (range, 6-13 years). Average lateral pinch strength, oppositional pinch strength, and grip strength were measured as 5 kg, 3 kg, and 19 kg, respectively (129%, 103%, and 108% of contralateral). Eaton stage was preserved in 5 of the 8 patients, with excellent functional outcomes in 6 of 8 patients at a mean of 9 years. Our data suggest that first metacarpal extension osteotomy can be an effective and durable procedure that does not limit future salvage procedures such as trapeziectomy or arthroplasty and support use of this treatment in early and moderate Eaton stages. Therapeutic IV.

Advances in treatment of basal joint arthritis of the thumb

Purpose of review Various forms of surgery have been successfully used to treat trapeziometacarpal osteoarthritis. However, no conclusive evidence is available to recommend one form of surgery over another. This is a review of recent surgical techniques and current concepts in the treatment of this common condition. Recent findings Early disease (stages 1 and 2) treated with ligament reconstruction or metacarpal extension osteotomy produces good results. Advanced disease (stages 3 and 4) continues to be treated successfully with trapezial excision, with or without additional soft-tissue procedures. Trapeziometacarpal joint replacement provides adequate pain relief, but loosening remains a concern. Satisfactory short-term results have been obtained using trapeziometacarpal arthroscopic procedures in stages 1 to 3 disease. Summary The initial management of basal joint arthritis should be nonsurgical. If this fails, surgery is recommended. Joint preserving procedures produce good outcomes in early disease. In advanced disease, some form of trapezial excision is required, and present evidence suggests that simple trapezial excision produces functional results equivalent to the more complex reconstructive procedures. Arthroscopy offers all the advantages of minimally invasive surgery, and early results are encouraging. There is a need for further comparative studies to determine if any procedure is superior to the others.

Thumb Carpal Metacarpal Arthritis

The thumb carpometacarpal (CMC) joint is the most common site of surgical reconstruction for osteoarthritis in the upper extremity. In patients older than age 75 years, thumb CMC osteoarthritis has a radiographic prevalence of 25% in men and 40% in women. The thumb CMC joint obtains its stability primarily through ligamentous support. A diagnosis of thumb CMC arthritis is based on symptoms of localized pain, tenderness and instability on physical examination, and radiographic evaluation. A reproducible radiographic classification for disease severity is based on the four-stage system described by Eaton. Nonsurgical treatment options include hand therapy, splinting, and injection. Surgical treatment is tailored to the extent of arthritic involvement and may include ligament reconstruction, metacarpal extension osteotomy, arthroscopic partial trapeziectomy, implant arthroplasty, and trapeziectomy with or without ligament reconstruction and tendon interposition.

An In Vitro Analysis of Ligament Reconstruction or Extension Osteotomy on Trapeziometacarpal Joint Stability and Contact Area

Painful instability of the minimally osteoarthritic thumb carpometacarpal (CMC) joint can be treated successfully by either ligament reconstruction or metacarpal extension osteotomy. The purpose of this study was to measure the laxity of cadaveric thumb CMC joints and to determine the influence of ligament reconstruction and metacarpal osteotomy on joint laxity and contact area. The baseline laxity of CMC joints from 25 fresh-frozen human cadaveric specimens (average age, 42 y; range, 18-55 y) was measured in the position of lateral pinch on a custom-designed CMC joint laxity tester. Joint laxity was measured again after 2 surgical simulations consisting of either a metacarpal extension osteotomy (at 10 degrees and 15 degrees) or a simulated Eaton-Littler ligament reconstruction (including total, volar, and dorsal ligament reconstructions relative to the plane of the thumbnail). Contact area between the thumb metacarpal and trapezium during testing was determined using stereophotogrammetry. The 15 degrees extension osteotomy significantly reduced CMC joint laxity in the radial-ulnar, dorsal-volar, pronation-supination, and distraction directions in the position of lateral pinch. The 10 degrees osteotomy reduced laxity only in the dorsal-volar direction. The total ligament reconstruction significantly reduced joint laxity in the radial-ulnar, dorsal-volar, and pronation-supination directions. The dorsal ligament reconstruction reduced laxity in the dorsal-volar direction only; the volar ligament reconstruction reduced laxity in both dorsovolar and radioulnar directions. The 10 degrees and 15 degrees osteotomies produced a dorsal shift of the weighted centroid of contact on the metacarpal and trapezium, whereas the ligament reconstruction did not produce such an effect. In the position of lateral pinch the 15 degrees osteotomy and total ligament reconstruction significantly reduced laxity of the thumb CMC joint in all directions tested. The isolated dorsal or volar ligament reconstructions both reduced dorsal-volar laxity. Metacarpal extension osteotomy may stabilize the thumb CMC joint in lateral pinch to a degree similar to that of a standard ligament reconstruction.

Simulated extension osteotomy of the thumb metacarpal reduces carpometacarpal joint laxity in lateral pinch

Purpose: To assess the effect of an extension osteotomy of the thumb metacarpal on thumb carpometacarpal (CMC) joint laxity with respect to the lateral pinch position. Methods: Seven fresh-frozen specimens were dissected. The metacarpal, trapezium, and trapezoid were removed en bloc and rigidly fixed proximally and distally. The laxity of each specimen was measured by cyclically loading the CMC joint in a custom-built laxity testing device designed to allow relative movement of the trapezium and first metacarpal in 4 directions. The position of the CMC joint in lateral pinch was used as the baseline joint position. An extension osteotomy then was simulated by flexing the metacarpal base 30°, thus placing the joint in the relationship it would assume if an extension osteotomy was performed and the specimen was positioned in lateral pinch. Laxity measurements then were repeated. Results: The simulated extension osteotomy reduced laxity in all directions tested: dorsal-volar (40% reduction), radial-ulnar (23% reduction), distraction (15% reduction), and pronation-supination (29% reduction). Conclusions: The beneficial clinical effects of a thumb metacarpal extension osteotomy may be partially due to reduced joint laxity in the position of lateral pinch.

TREATMENT OF EATON STAGE I TRAPEZIOMETACARPAL DISEASE

Although the cause of TM joint hypermobility may be multifactorial, translational laxity and instability appear to be related to degeneration of the beak ligament. Indeed, the forces experienced at the normal TM joint with grip and pinch are magnified several fold and are concentrated in the palmar aspect of the joint. The TM stress test used in preoperative assessment of thumbs with hypermobile TM joints reflects nonphysiologic dorsal translation and correlates with histologic evidence of detachment of the metacarpal origin of the beak ligament. Ligament reconstruction of the painful TM joint reflects the importance of the beak ligament in providing stability and in limiting dorsal translation of the metacarpal that normally occurs during dynamic pinch activity. Metacarpal extension osteotomy, by contrast, shifts mechanical loading at the TM joint more dorsally and redirects force vectors. Its precise role in the treatment of TM disease has long remained ill-defined because of a lack of correlation between preoperative disease status and postoperative functional result. It appears now, however, that for stage I disease, metacarpal extension osteotomy may result in satisfactory pain relief and improved grip and pinch strength--at least in the short term. Indeed, extension osteotomy may be an efficacious alternative to ligament reconstruction, but long-term follow-up and additional clinical studies will be helpful in shedding additional light on this topic.

Treatment of Eaton stage I trapeziometacarpal disease with thumb metacarpal extension osteotomy.

The current benchmark for the treatment of Eaton stage I disease of the trapeziometacarpal (TMC) joint includes palmar oblique ligament reconstruction and reflects its primary role in providing stability during lateral pinch. This study prospectively evaluates the efficacy of an alternative extra-articular approach using a 30 degrees extension osteotomy of the thumb metacarpal to redistribute trapeziometacarpal contact area and load, obviating the need for ligament reconstruction. Preoperative and postoperative subjective and objective data are reported for 12 patients enrolled in the study between 1995 and 1998. Trapeziometacarpal arthrotomy allowed accurate intra-articular assessment and verified palmar oblique ligament incompetence in each case. The average follow-up period was 2.1 years (range, 6-46 months). All osteotomies healed at an average of 7 weeks. Eleven patients were satisfied with outcome. Grip and pinch strength increased an average of 8.5 and 3.0 kg, respectively. Thumb metacarpal extension osteotomy is an effective biomechanical alternative to ligament reconstruction in the treatment of Eaton stage I disease of the trapeziometacarpal joint.