Melanoma Detection Rate Research Articles

Does genetic risk modify the effect of skin screening on melanoma detection rates?

Skin screening is associated with higher melanoma detection rates, a potential indicator of overdiagnosis, but it remains possible that this effect is due to confounding by genetic risk. To compare melanoma incidence among screened vs. unscreened participants within tertiles of genetic risk. We investigated melanoma incidence in the QSkin study, a prospective cohort study which for this analysis comprised 15 283 participants aged 40-69 years with genotype data and no prior history of melanoma. We calculated a polygenic score (PGS) for melanoma. We first calculated the age-standardized rate (ASR) of melanoma within PGS tertiles, and then measured the association between skin examination and melanoma detection by calculating the hazard ratio (HR) and 95% confidence interval (95% CI), overall and within PGS tertiles. Melanoma incidence increased with PGS (ASR per 100 000 per year): tertile 1 = 442; tertile 2 = 519; tertile 3 = 871. We found that the HRs for all melanomas (i.e. in situ and invasive) associated with skin examination differed slightly across PGS tertiles [age- and sex-adjusted tertile 1 HR 1.88 (95% CI 1.26-2.81); tertile 2 HR 1.70 (95% CI 1.20-2.41); tertile 3 HR 1.96 (95% CI 1.43-2.70); fully adjusted tertile 1 HR 1.14 (95% CI 0.74-1.75); tertile 2 HR 1.21 (95% CI 0.82-1.78); tertile 3 HR 1.41 (95% CI 1.00-1.98)], but these differences were not statistically significant. HRs for in situ melanoma associated with skin examination were similar across PGS tertiles. For invasive melanomas, the point estimates appeared to be highest in PGS tertile 3 in both the minimally adjusted (age, sex) and fully adjusted models; however, these apparent differences were also not statistically significant. Genetic risk predicts subsequent melanoma incidence, and is weakly associated with screening behaviour, but it does not explain the higher rate of melanoma detection between screened and unscreened people.

An Examination of Melanoma Detection and Characteristics at a Nova Scotia Tertiary Care Centre, From 2015-2019.

Melanoma is one of the most common cancers in Canada,1 with the highest incidence in Nova Scotia (NS). To describe the demographics, lesion characteristics, and diagnostic accuracy of suspected melanomas excised at the largest center in NS. The dermatopathology database was interrogated for cases of possible melanoma from 2015 through 2019. Age, gender, site of lesion, pathologic diagnosis, Breslow depth, and equivocal pathology were assessed. 984 lesions had a clinical diagnosis of possible melanoma, identifying 301 melanomas. Of these, 142 (47%) were melanoma in situ (MIS) which in females occurred mostly on the extremities, while in males the head predominated. For invasive melanoma (IM), the extremities remained predominant for women, while the back was most common in men. Lower extremity lesions were more likely to be invasive and female patients were more likely to present with them at a younger age compared to males. The pathology was challenging for 23.94% of MIS, and 16.18% of IM. A mean of 3.1 lesions were excised for every melanoma identified. Early diagnosis of melanoma is challenging clinically and pathologically. Our melanoma detection rate was 31%, with an increasing trend in the proportion of MIS, and decreasing trend in the proportion of IM over the years. Almost 50% of melanomas were detected in early stages, supporting positive outcomes. Melanomas were more common on extremities in females and the back in males. Melanomas on the lower limbs were more likely to be invasive regardless of gender.

Lesion-directed screening to optimize skin cancer detection in dermatology practice: an observational study.

BackgroundEarly detection of skin cancer is still a major challenge in dermatology practice today. While surveillance programs are offered to high‐risk patients, systematic total‐body examination (TBE) in the general population is not cost‐effective. In the past, we demonstrated that a lesion‐directed screening (LDS) in the general population delivered similar detection rates to TBE and was less time‐consuming.ObjectivesTo study whether a lesion‐directed early‐access consultation can optimize skin cancer detection in dermatology practice.MethodsIn this observational study, we offered an early‐access consultation in patients contacting the dermatology department concerning 1 or 2 lesions of concern meeting predefined criteria.Results342 persons were seen at the dermatology department after triage by phone. Skin cancer detection rate was 13.2% (4.1% for melanoma). If advised/referred by a doctor skin cancer detection rate was 23.6% (9% for melanoma). With a history of skin cancer, detection rate was 24.3% (4.3% for melanoma). In patients with no referral and a negative history of skin cancer, detection rate was 7.7% (1.7% for melanoma), which is at least triple the rates reported by population‐based screening programs. In patients in whom the index lesion was benign, worry of having skin cancer had decreased significantly by the end of the consultation. Additional total‐body examination in these patients had low additional detection rate (0.5%) and a high number of unnecessary excisions (number needed to excise 13).ConclusionsAn early‐access dermatology consultation for LDS after triage by phone resulted in high overall skin cancer and melanoma detection rates. Our data indicate that performing TBE is especially useful if the index lesion is suspicious. In addition to surveillance programs in high‐risk patients, LDS may be a way to optimize skin cancer detection in the general population and use available time more efficiently in daily dermatology practice.

Marital Status and Survival in Patients Diagnosed with Melanoma.

Introduction Previous research suggests the presence of a spouse may considerably affect melanoma detection rates through more frequent examinations, better access to healthcare, and improved social support. Yet, the role of marital status on melanoma survival is currently unknown. The aim of this study is to assess whether marital status is associated with survival following melanoma diagnosis. Methods We performed secondary analysis of data from all participants of the Florida Cancer Data System (FCDS) and included adult melanoma patients diagnosed between 2001 and 2009 with follow-up information available until 2015. Marital status was categorized as single, married, divorced, or widowed. The primary outcome was survival interval after melanoma diagnosis, which was assessed according to the time from the date of diagnosis to the time of death or last contact. Cox proportional hazard models were used to assess the independent association between marital status and survival. Results We assessed data from 36,578 melanoma patients. Married patients were significantly more likely to survive than single patients (Hazard ratio (HR) = 0.65; 99% Confidence Interval (CI): 0.57–0.74; P < 0.001) after adjusting for age, sex, race, ethnicity, geographic location, insurance status, tobacco use, primary site, stage, and histology. There was no evidence of effect modification by gender (P=0.189). Conclusions Married patients, including both men and women, had a 35% reduction in the risk of death after melanoma diagnosis compared with single patients, and mechanisms independent of earlier detection, such as social support, may play a role in survival in patients with melanoma.

Evaluation of the National Swiss Skin Cancer Screening Campaign 2013: Do We Do the Right Thing

Background: Skin cancer prevention and screening programs are performed in many countries. Their benefit is discussed controversially. Objective: Our aim is to evaluate the Skin Cancer Screening Program 2013 in Switzerland by following up screenees upon interventions. Methods: Quality was assessed by personal follow-up via phone/e-mail of every patient that had been screened during this campaign and histological follow-up of all participants with suspicious skin lesions. Results: Of the 1,087 screenees requiring interventions, 263 agreed to participate in the follow-up. We were able to obtain 66 histology reports. During this campaign 33 malignant lesions (8 melanomas) were removed. Conclusion: The overall melanoma detection rate in our free Skin Cancer Screening Program is comparable to those in European public activities. The costs of free screening programs compare favorably with the prevented potential therapeutic costs of late-stage melanoma. The low response rate of screenees agreeing to be followed up limits conclusions of this study.

Unannounced standardized patients: A novel method of determining melanoma detection rates among internal medicine residents

Unannounced standardized patients: A novel method of determining melanoma detection rates among internal medicine residents

Medical Student Melanoma Detection Rates in White and African American Skin using Moulage and Standardized Patients

Medical Student Melanoma Detection Rates in White and African American Skin using Moulage and Standardized Patients

Incidental melanomas detected in veterans referred to dermatology

Early detection of melanoma is integral to preventing morbidity and mortality. We sought to characterize and compare incidental versus consult melanomas detected in veterans referred to the Minneapolis, MN, Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center dermatology clinic. We retrospectively reviewed charts of all dermatology consults between January 2004 and March 2012. Of the 28,405 consults sent during the study period, 17,174 met inclusion criteria. There were 231 melanomas identified in 221 patients. In all, 144 melanomas were identified on the consult and 87 melanomas were discovered incidentally. The incidental melanoma detection rate was 0.5% (84/17,174). Consult melanomas were more likely to be invasive than incidental melanomas (relative risk 1.51, 95% confidence interval 1.23-1.86, P < .0001) and less likely to have a Breslow depth of less than 1.00 mm (relative risk 0.73, 95% confidence interval 0.61-0.88, P = .0036). Incidental melanomas were smaller than consult melanomas (mean diameter 0.98 vs 1.3 cm, respectively) and thinner (mean Breslow depth 0.64 vs 1.74 mm). Consult melanomas were more likely to be detected on the head/neck (relative risk 1.25, 95% confidence interval 1.03-1.52, P = .0295). Nondiverse patient population is a limitation. Melanomas detected during an in-person skin examination by a dermatologist were more likely to be detected at an earlier stage of disease.

Melanoma incidence and patient compliance in a targeted melanoma screening intervention. One-year follow-up in a large French cohort of high-risk patients

Background: Early diagnosis of melanoma can save lives. However, mass screening is not recommended, and few studies have addressed targeted screening.Objective: To evaluate a targeted melanoma screening intervention by measuring the cumulative melanoma incidence and patient compliance with the screening.Methods: This was a prospective one-year follow-up of a cohort of 3923 French patients at elevated risk of melanoma who were recruited from April to October 2011 by 78 GPs using the Self-assessment of melanoma risk score. Following standard practice, based on the GPs’ opinions, a subset of these patients was referred to dermatologists. The dermatologists scheduled excisions when required. Melanomas were confirmed using pathology reports. Patient compliance with the clinical pathway was assessed retrospectively. The cohort was followed prospectively using three data sources (GPs, dermatologists and patients). Analyses of factors associated with compliance were performed using multiple logistic regression.Results: GPs examined the skin of 3923 high-risk patients, 1506 of whom were referred to dermatologists. Nine cases of melanoma were diagnosed, corresponding to a cumulative incidence of 229.4/100 000. Of the referred patients, 57.9% attended the dermatologist consultation. Patient attendance was better when the GPs provided a dermatologist's name (OR = 2.15, 95% CI: 1.51–3.09). A delay before consulting a dermatologist was inversely associated with the estimated lesion malignancy.Conclusion: Performing this targeted screening in a high-risk population resulted in a high melanoma detection rate, despite moderate compliance. Observations suggest that naming a dermatologist is a simple, inexpensive means of increasing patient compliance with the screening.

The Euromelanoma skin cancer prevention campaign in Europe: characteristics and results of 2009 and 2010

Euromelanoma is a skin cancer education and prevention campaign that started in 1999 in Belgium as 'Melanoma day'. Since 2000, it is active in a large and growing number of European countries under the name Euromelanoma. To evaluate results of Euromelanoma in 2009 and 2010 in 20 countries, describing characteristics of screenees, rates of clinically suspicious lesions for skin cancer and detection rates of melanomas. Euromelanoma questionnaires were used by 20 countries providing their data in a standardized database (Belgium, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, FYRO Macedonia, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Moldavia, Portugal, Serbia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and Ukraine). In total, 59,858 subjects were screened in 20 countries. Most screenees were female (64%), median ages were 43 (female) and 46 (male) and 33% had phototype I or II. The suspicion rates ranged from 1.1% to 19.4% for melanoma (average 2.8%), from 0.0% to 10.7% for basal cell carcinoma (average 3.1%) and from 0.0% to 1.8% for squamous cell carcinoma (average 0.4%). The overall positive predictive value of countries where (estimation of) positive predictive value could be determined was 13.0%, melanoma detection rates varied from 0.1% to 1.9%. Dermoscopy was used in 78% of examinations with clinically suspected melanoma; full body skin examination was performed in 72% of the screenees. Although the population screened during Euromelanoma was relatively young, high rates of clinically suspected melanoma were found. The efficacy of Euromelanoma could be improved by targeting high-risk populations and by better use of dermoscopy and full body skin examination.

Relationship between cause of referral and diagnostic outcome in pigmented lesion clinics: a multicentre survey of the Italian Multidisciplinary Group on Melanoma (GIPMe).

Pigmented lesion clinics (PLCs) are permanent units to which subjects presenting with suspicious pigmented skin lesions can be rapidly referred and which can provide a prompt response to an individual's concern about melanoma. However, little is known about the melanoma detection rate in these clinics, in particular with regard to intermediate risk populations. We report a survey involving more than 1000 subjects consecutively referred by family doctors to six Italian PLCs. Using a histological diagnosis of melanoma as the endpoint, the pooled melanoma detection rate at these PLCs was 1.5% (one melanoma for diagnosed every 64 subjects examined), and the ratio between the number of melanomas and benign lesions excised for diagnostic verification was 1: 5.8 (16 melanomas and 93 benign lesions). Almost all the melanomas (15 out of 16) were detected in subjects who had requested referral for a specific doubtful lesion (group A) or for the presence of melanoma risk factors (previous melanoma, large number of common and atypical naevi, family history of melanoma) (group B). Only one melanoma was detected amongst the 418 subjects seeking consultation for concern about their moles (group C) (P = 0.004). The positive and negative predictive values of the referral groups A and B combined were 2.5% and 99.7%, respectively. Since the probability of detecting a melanoma in subjects referred only for reassurance about their moles, which nevertheless represented 43% of the subjects examined, is very low, an optimized role for PLCs in melanoma prevention would be to limit consultation to subjects who present for examination of a specific lesion or who have one or more risk factors for melanoma.

In Vivo Detection of Small Subsurface Melanomas in Athymic Mice Using Noninvasive Fiber Optic Confocal Imaging

Fiber optic confocal imaging, following intravenous administration of fluorescently labeled antibodies and Texas Red-dextran, enabled in vivo detection of melanoma and surrounding blood vessels in athymic mice. Human melanoma cells (three cell lines) and cultured normal human skin cells were implanted intradermally into the haunch skin of anesthetized athymic BALB/C mice and allowed to grow to a maximum size of 2 mm diameter. Using three different fluorescein-isothiocyanate-labeled antimelanoma antibodies, single channel confocal images of melanoma cells were obtained in vivo. Using noninvasive techniques, the overall in vivo melanoma detection rate for tumors within 0.2 mm of the skin surface was 84% (27 of 32 tumors). Normal cultured human skin cells were found to have little or no fluorescence after administration of the fluorescein-isothiocyanate-labeled antibodies and tumors were not labeled by an isotype control antibody. Dual channel imaging of the implanted melanoma tumor and surrounding dermal vasculature in vivo showed increased blood vessel density at the melanoma site. Conventional immunoperoxidase histology confirmed that fiber optic confocal imaging was able to detect melanoma tumors up to 0.2 mm below the skin surface, in vivo.

Topodermatographic image analysis for melanoma screening and the quantitative assessment of tumor dimension parameters of the skin.

The clinical need to identify and evaluate changes of cutaneous lesions in melanoma screening or follow-up of patients with cancer is of paramount importance. Because skin-lesion changes may be small and numerous, clinical assessment alone does not meet the requirements of quantitative assessment. Using the computer as a diagnostic tool for the image analysis of sequentially captured skin surface images has resulted in the technical problem of insufficient registration reproducibility. This paper describes the technical logistics, setup procedure, and clinical evaluation of the novel technique termed "topodermatography," which performs the quantitative videographic image analysis of skin-lesion changes over time. Digitized measurements of skin-surface image parameters were performed using a high-speed processor with an onboard coprocessor, a high-resolution video camera, specifically designed image processing software, and a position framework for the adjustment of the patient's standing position. The topodermatographic image analysis was performed on 109 consecutive patients who were at risk for melanoma (N = 98), had lesions from Kaposi's sarcoma (N = 4), had metastatic skin deposits from melanoma (N = 3), and had breast cancer (N = 4). Skin lesion changes over time could be identified reliably within a few millimeters of diametric enlargement. In this series, a 0.51% early melanoma detection rate was assessed in 19 of 98 patients followed for 12 months. By monitoring manifest neoplastic skin lesions, tumor growth kinetics were analyzed quantitatively to determine the total area of skin involvement, thus facilitating precise response assessment. Topodermatographic image analysis helps to optimize screening and follow-up procedures for patients with melanoma and populations at risk for melanoma. In addition, metastatic tumor lesions on the skin can be monitored dynamically, facilitating the accurate evaluation of the impact of systemic therapy on multiple skin deposits from melanoma and nonmelanoma cancers.