Objective: In recent years, allegations of medical errors in Turkey have been increasing. These allegations are generally concentrated on the issue of consent. Since most children are medically and legally incapable of making their own decisions on consent issues and the decision is made by the legal representative instead, various legal and ethical dilemmas arise. Pediatrics ranks first in lawsuits filed for medical errors. In our study, we aimed to evaluate the awareness of forensic legal issues among pediatricians. Materials and Methods: Our study is prospective and cross-sectional. Participants were asked 25 questions based on 14 possible case examples. They were asked to give a score between 1 and 5 points for each question about their feeling of adequacy regarding the information, consent, documents, and procedures that should be done according to these cases. Mann‒Whitney U and Kruskal‒Wallis tests were used statistically; p<0.05 was considered significant. Results: Two hundred nine pediatricians answered the questions. Sixty-six percent of the participants were working in tertiary care hospitals. Pediatricians were undecided about feeling adequate regarding the necessary information, consent, documents, and procedures to be performed for children (3.19/5) and felt inadequate when facing the refusal of treatment (2.77/5). There was no statistically significant difference between feeling competent in terms of title and professional seniority. Only 2% of the pediatricians stated that children under 12 years of age have the power of discernment, and only 7% stated that children over 15 years of age do not have the power of discernment. Conclusion: The general conclusion we reached in our study is that pediatricians do not feel adequate even concerning basic legal issues such as information, consent, and refusal of treatment. Therefore, they need to gain knowledge of these issues. For this reason, educational activities such as adding legal education to the medical school curriculum, legal training for pediatricians, and regular seminars effectively eliminate the lack of knowledge on this issue and prevent lawsuits.
Read full abstract