Medical Pathology Research Articles

Treatment of Nonsocial Environmental Fear in a Service Dog UsingFluoxetineand Behavior Modification.

Training and maintaining a service dog requires extensive time and financial resources. The emotional bond between service dogs and their handlers poses unique challenges when dogs develop behavioral issues. We present a case of an otherwise healthy adult service dog exhibiting acute environmental fears, hindering her job performance. The dog's fear responses escalated in various settings, including school and home environments. Diagnostic evaluation ruled out medical pathology, leading to a diagnosis of nonsocial environmental fear and generalized anxiety. A multimodal treatment approach involving environmental management, antidepressant medication (fluoxetine), and behavior modification was implemented. Desensitization and counterconditioning protocols targeted specific triggers, such as shiny floors and elevators. Eight weeks after treatment initiation, the dog showed improvement, enabling a modified behavior treatment plan to be implemented as she gradually returned to work with reduced fear responses. Follow-up revealed sustained progress with additional dosage adjustment of fluoxetine.

Polytrauma in a Jet Pilot After Low-Altitude Ejection Without Parachute Deployment

BACKGROUND: Ejection seats are designed to be a lifesaving device for aircrew in emergencies. Modern ejection seats are widely prevalent in fighter and bomber aircraft and are occasionally associated with acceleration injury from axial loading (Gz) during the catapult phase of ejection, limb flail injury due to windblast, or parachute landing fall, especially if the ejection is outside of the seat’s performance envelope. CASE REPORT: We present the first known case in the medical literature of a military pilot who survived a low-altitude, high-angulation (>90° of bank angle) ejection where the pilot’s ejection seat parachute did not deploy due to contact with the ground before completion of the ejection sequence. The patient’s initial exam upon arrival at a trauma center was significant for a Glasgow Coma Scale of 3T, with evidence of cranial and extremity trauma. The patient presented with respiratory acidosis and required upsizing of his endotracheal tube placed in the field. The patient’s injury list included bilateral subdural and subarachnoid hemorrhages, a Hangman’s fracture, spinal burst fractures, and extensive extremity fractures. After a prolonged hospital stay, the patient was discharged to rehabilitation. The patient made a functional and neurological recovery, including return to independent completion of his activities of daily living. DISCUSSION: This case provides evidence of favorable outcome after a low-altitude, high-angulation ejection without parachute deployment. This case details the medical and traumatic pathology medical personnel should expect from an ejection that occurs outside of the seat’s performance envelope. Zivkovic MM, Inman BL, Figlewicz MR, Burchett JA, Nowadly CD. Polytrauma in a jet pilot after low-altitude ejection without parachute deployment. Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2024; 95(11):862–866.

Artificial Intelligence in Medical Diagnostics

Artificial intelligence (AI) is an essential tool in the medical sector that contributes significantly to medical imaging, medical pathology, histology, genomic study, predictive analysis, etc. It is being increasingly used not only in breast and lung cancer diagnosis and screening, and genetic disease identification but also in personalized decision-making during the treatment of these diseases. The quality and availability of unbiased data is a key challenge. Algorithmic bias and interpretability are significant concerns as well. Improving the use of AI in medical diagnostics could be achieved through continuous monitoring, access to highly accurate datasets, and timely intervention by healthcare professionals. J Bangladesh Coll Phys Surg 2024; 42: 379-382

Unleashing the potential of AI in modern healthcare: Machine learning algorithms and intelligent medical robots

Artificial intelligence (AI) is playing an increasingly vital role in transforming the medical field, particularly in areas like medical imaging, clinical decision-making, pathology, and minimally invasive surgery. The rapid growth of medical data and the continuous refinement of machine learning algorithms have propelled AI's integration into healthcare. This study explores the advancements and applications of AI, specifically machine learning algorithms and intelligent medical robots, in enhancing diagnostics, treatment, and healthcare delivery. A comprehensive review of current AI applications in healthcare, including its use in medical imaging, pathology, clinical decision-making, and robotic-assisted surgery, was conducted. AI technologies such as the Da Vinci Surgical Robot and machine learning-based diagnostic tools have significantly improved diagnostic accuracy and the precision of minimally invasive surgeries. AI-driven systems also contributed to better clinical decision support, faster recovery times for patients, and more accurate treatment plans. Overall, AI, through machine learning algorithms and intelligent medical robots, is revolutionizing healthcare by offering promising improvements in diagnostics, surgical precision, and patient care.

Germline and somatic testing for homologous repair deficiency in patients with prostate cancer (part 1 of 2).

Unfortunately, not all metastatic castration resistant prostate cancer (mCRPC) patients receive available life-prolonging systemic therapies, emphasizing the need to optimize mCRPC treatment selections. Better guidelines are necessary to determine genetic testing in prostate cancer. In this two-part expert opinion-based guide, we provide an expert consensus opinion on the utilization of germline and somatic testing to detect HRR alterations in patients with mCRPC. This guide was developed by a multidisciplinary expert panel that convened in 2023-2024, including representatives from medical oncology, urology, radiation oncology, pathology, medical genomics, and basic science. We argue for the widespread adoption of germline testing in all patients with prostate cancer and for somatic mutations testing in patients at the time of recurrent/metastatic disease. In this first part, we review how genomic testing is performed. We also review how to overcome certain barriers to integrate genetic and biomarker testing into clinical practice.

Modified reconstruction approach after pancreaticoduodenectomy optimizes postoperative outcomes: Results from a multivariate cohort analysis.

Despite technical advances in recent decades and a decrease in hospital mortality (<5%), pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD) is still associated with major postoperative complications, even in high-volume centers. The present study aimed to assess the effect of a modified reconstruction technique on postoperative morbidity and mortality. A cohort study of all patients (n=218) undergoing PD between January 2010 and December 2019 was performed at Attikon University Hospital (Athens, Greece). Several variables were studied, including demographic data, past medical history, perioperative parameters, tumor markers and pathology, duration of hospitalization, postoperative complications, 30-day-survival, postoperative mortality and overall survival using multivariate logistic regression and survival analysis techniques. In this cohort, 123 patients [modified PD (mPD) group] underwent a modified reconstruction after a pylorus-preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy, which consisted of gastrojejunostomy and pancreaticojejunostomy on the same loop and an isolated hepaticojejunostomy on another loop. In the standard PD (StPD) group, 95 patients underwent standard reconstruction. The median age was 67 years, ranging from 25 to 89 years. Compared with in the StPD group, the mPD group had significantly lower rates of grade B and C pancreatic fistula (4.9% vs. 28.4%), delayed gastric emptying (7.3% vs. 42.1%), postoperative hemorrhage (3.3% vs. 20%), intensive care unit admission (8.1% vs. 18.9%), overall morbidity (Clavien-Dindo grade III-V: 14.7% vs. 42.0%), perioperative mortality (4.1% vs. 14.7%), and shorter hospitalization stay (11 days vs. 20 days). However, no difference was noted regarding median survival (35 months vs. 30 months). In this single-center series, a modified reconstruction after PD appears to be associated with improved postoperative outcomes. However, further evaluation in larger multi-center trials is required.

Therapeutic implications of homologous repair deficiency testing in patients with prostate cancer (Part 2 of 2).

Unfortunately, not all metastatic castration-resistant prostate cancer (mCRPC) patients receive available life-prolonging systemic therapies, emphasizing the need to optimize mCRPC treatment selections. Better guidelines are necessary to determine genetic testing for prostate cancer. In this two-part expert opinion-based guide, we provide an expert consensus opinion on the utilization of germline and somatic testing to detect HRR alterations in patients with mCRPC. This guide was developed by a multidisciplinary expert panel that convened in 2023-2024, including representatives from medical oncology, urology, radiation oncology, pathology, medical genomics, and basic science. In this second part, we highlight how genetic testing can lead to improved, life-prolonging mCRPC therapeutic strategies based on a review of the recent phase III trials and subsequent regulatory approvals for PARP inhibitors in mCRPC.

Evaluating ExpandED: Evaluating the effectiveness of a serious game expansion pack in teaching health professional students about interprofessional care.

The emergency department (ED) is a challenging fast-paced environment with high-acuity, undifferentiated patients who often require extensive interdisciplinary care. This paper introduces ExpandED, an expansion pack to the serious board game GridlockED, designed to enhance players' understanding of interprofessional collaboration in the ED and the diverse scope of practice of different ED professionals including physicians, residents, registered nurses, registered practical nurses, social workers, occupational therapists, and physiotherapists. This investigation evaluates the effectiveness of ExpandED as a teaching tool for medical and allied health professions students about interprofessional collaboration in the ED. A program evaluation harnessing a playtest framework was employed. Participants completed pre- and postgame surveys including quantitative measures (e.g., Likert scales) and qualitative free-text feedback that focused on participant familiarity with ED functioning, valuation of interprofessional collaboration before and after playing, and feedback on game usability and effectiveness. Recruitment was open to students in all health care and allied health professional programs at the institution. Forty-five participants were recruited from medical doctor, nursing, physiotherapy, and speech language pathology programs. ExpandED enhances participants' understanding of ED workflow (p < 0.001) and provides an enjoyable playing experience. However, participants' valuation of interdisciplinary teamwork did not change significantly before and after game play (p = 0.17). Participants expressed satisfaction with the game's accuracy in simulating the ED environment and appreciated the opportunity to collaborate with peers from different disciplines. Challenges reported included some tension among players, potential biases, and limitations of fidelity to a real-life ED. While this study has limitations regarding participant sampling and duration of gameplay sessions, it highlights the potential of ExpandED for teaching interprofessional collaboration in the ED. These findings will guide further development to optimize the expansion pack's effectiveness and its implementation into health care curricula.

Navigating the disclosure landscape: Parents' perspectives on healthcare professionals' role in supporting intersex children and families.

Intersex, an umbrella term, describes individuals with sex characteristics that cannot be exclusively categorized into binary definitions of male or female. The intersex community faces a lack of social visibility perpetuated by a history of medical discrimination and pathologization shaped by "normalizing" genital surgeries without the child's consent. Despite efforts to reform clinical practice, there remains a paucity of research centering the needs of the intersex community and their families. This study explored parents' perspectives on how healthcare professionals (HCPs), such as genetics professionals, can provide patient-centered education and support when parents first learn of their child's intersex variation, with the aim of offering recommendations to HCPs to promote parental adjustment and protect intersex children's right to autonomy. Thirteen qualitative semi-structured interviews were conducted with 14 parents of intersex children. Through reflexive thematic analysis, under the framework of an agency-based approach to intersex health, thematic categories were inductively conceptualized, including barriers and facilitators to HCPs' sensitivity and to parental adjustment in the early disclosure environment. Barriers to HCPs' sensitivity were imposed by educational, religious, or medical institutions, along with sociocultural prejudices and pathologizing language. Barriers to parental adaptation included uncertainty regarding their child's future, sociocultural gender norms, and unsuitable information provision. Incorporating parental needs in the disclosure environment can facilitate familial acceptance, including normalization of variations of sex characteristics (VSCs), enhanced medical education, facilitation of patients' navigation, and prioritization of parents' social support needs.

Tumor board simulation improves interdisciplinary decision-making in medical students

IntroductionTraining of interdisciplinary clinical reasoning and decision-making skills, essential in daily clinical practice in oncological specialties, are still underrepresented in medical education. Therefore, at LMU University Hospital Munich, we implemented a didactically modified tumor board simulation with experts from five different disciplines (medical oncology, pathology, radiation oncology, radiology, and surgery) presenting patient cases into a one-week course on the basic principles of oncology. In this survey, we examined the self-assessed impact of our course on the interdisciplinary decision-making skills of medical students.MethodsBetween November-December 2023 and January-February 2024, we surveyed two cohorts of medical students in the third year of medical school in our one-week course before and after participating in the tumor board simulation. The objective was to evaluate the self-assessed knowledge in interdisciplinary clinical decision-making, in integrating ethical considerations into clinical reasoning, and in comprehension of various professional viewpoints in interdisciplinary decision-making. Knowledge was assessed using a five-step Likert scale from 1 (no knowledge) to 5 (complete knowledge).ResultsThe survey was answered by 76 students before and 55 after the simulation, equaling 60–70% of all 100 course participants. Mean knowledge level regarding principles of interdisciplinary clinical decision-making improved significantly in all of the following exemplary aspects: purpose and procedure of tumor boards in clinical practice (from 2.4 ± 1.1 to 4.0 ± 1.0, Spearman’s ρ = 0.6, p < 0.001), principles of dealing with ethical challenges in oncology (from 2.4 ± 1.1 to 3.4 ± 1.0, ρ = 0.4, p < 0.001), and principles of shared decision-making in oncology (2.7 ± 1.1 to 3.7 ± 1.0, ρ = 0.4, p < 0.001). Students reported that their skills in clinical decision-making and ability to discuss oncological patient cases from different professional viewpoints improved due to the teaching course.ConclusionBy employing our interdisciplinary one-week course and a didactically modified tumor board simulation featuring experts from various oncological disciplines, medical students’ comprehension of interdisciplinary clinical decision-making in oncology improved significantly.

A vision-language foundation model for the generation of realistic chest X-ray images.

The paucity of high-quality medical imaging datasets could be mitigated by machine learning models that generate compositionally diverse images that faithfully represent medical concepts and pathologies. However, large vision-language models are trained on natural images, and the diversity distribution of the generated images substantially differs from that of medical images. Moreover, medical language involves specific and semantically rich vocabulary. Here we describe a domain-adaptation strategy for large vision-language models that overcomes distributional shifts. Specifically, by leveraging publicly available datasets of chest X-ray images and the corresponding radiology reports, we adapted a latent diffusion model pre-trained on pairs of natural images and text descriptors to generate diverse and visually plausible synthetic chest X-ray images (as confirmed by board-certified radiologists) whose appearance can be controlled with free-form medical text prompts. The domain-adaptation strategy for the text-conditioned synthesis of medical images can be used to augment training datasets and is a viable alternative to the sharing of real medical images for model training and fine-tuning.

Letters or not, here we come! A communal perspective on credentials needed for a productive career in veterinary pathology.

Veterinary pathology credentials serve as a concise means attesting to educational attainments and experiences indicating a readiness for professional practice. Given the cost, time, and stress associated with obtaining different qualifications, pathologists must consider what credentials enhance their readiness. In this commentary, the authors describe how their various degrees and certifications have facilitated their individual and organizational success. The minimum credentials for proficient veterinary pathology practice are a veterinary medical degree (DVM or equivalent) and advanced pathology training (residency and/or on-the-job "apprenticeship") ideally culminating in board certification in pathology (American College of Veterinary Pathologists [ACVP] diplomate status or equivalent). Graduate degrees (MS, PhD, MPH, etc) and/or other qualifications in allied biomedical fields (eg, board certification in internal medicine, laboratory animal medicine, poultry medicine, preventive medicine, or toxicology) may improve employability by affirming specialty knowledge in another complementary discipline. The authors note that pathology positions may be obtained without a long list of degrees or certifications, and that more credentials may provide occupational flexibility for some employers. However, a good work ethic, experience in the field, ability to adapt to changes, job satisfaction, good attitude, and demonstrated productivity are also important, and indeed, they are often the paramount criteria for career success as a veterinary pathologist.

Study of Tumor-Infiltrating Lymphocytes in Breast Carcinoma and Their Association With Pathological and Prognostic Factors and Pathological Tumor-Node-Metastasis (pTNM) Staging.

Breast carcinoma is the second most frequent type of cancer globally, with an estimated 2.08 million new carcinoma cases identified in 2018. Breast cancer prognosis is influenced by a number of variables, including the patient's age, morphological variant, stromal inflammatory reaction, elastotic, fibrotic focus, lymphovascular emboli, recurrence of tumor, etc. Recently, the morphological evaluation and extent of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) have also been studied in breast cancer. An attempt is being made to understand the role of TIL in determining the prognostication of carcinoma breast. Thus, the goal of the current academic study is to assess TILin breast carcinoma. The study was performed at a medical institution's pathology department, which covered newly diagnosed cases of infiltrating ductal carcinoma of the breast on histopathology during the January to December 2019 time frame. The gross and hematoxyline-eosin-stained paraffin sections were studied for histopathological examination. The study included 50 cases of infiltrating ductal carcinoma of the breast with a female-to-male ratio of 24:1. Stromal TIL was negative (0-10%) in 12 cases, while was positive (11-100 %) in 38 cases. The results of the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve study indicated that the specificity was 70.7% and the sensitivity was 85.3% when the cutoff of stromal TIL<11% was used to predict the live status of patients. Stromal TILis an important parameter that must be reported in breast carcinoma cases. Positive stromal TIL shows a statistically significant difference with pathological tumor-node-metastasis (pTNM) staging, tumor laterality, size of the tumor, and involvement of nipple and areola.

Compact common-path polarization holography for measurement of the Jones matrix of polarization-sensitive materials.

A compact common-path off-axis digital holographic imaging method is proposed utilizing polarization-angular-multiplexing for Jones matrix measurement. Our method employs a common-path off-axis configuration to capture multiplexed off-axis interferograms generated by orthogonally polarized object beams and a reference beam on a monochrome CCD camera. The modulation of the fringe direction is achieved by two homemade retro-reflector mirrors, allowing for the retrieval of the Jones matrix distribution of transparent specimens through a matrix-division algorithm. The stable common-path design and the expansive camera field of view facilitate the extraction of spatially resolved Jones matrix parameters. The feasibility of this method was validated through experiments involving standard objects and polarization-sensitive materials, conducted at both general and microscopic scales. Our system completed polarization imaging of cancerous tissues, unequivocally demonstrating its extraordinary potential in medical pathology diagnostics.

“This doctor knows shit about you, but the first thing he says is, ‘you need to lose some weight’”: Anti-fat bias and the contradictory effects of fat medicalization in Czech healthcare

ABSTRACT The anti-fat bias that is built on the premised principle antagonism between a fat and a healthy body remains entrenched in healthcare. Despite evidence that being fat is conditioned by many factors beyond a person’s control, fatness is often seen as a result of irresponsible behavior and moral failure and fat patients report being exposed to mistreatment, discrimination, and shaming in healthcare. Drawing on semi-structured interviews and written testimonies, we examine the experiences of people with fat embodiment in Czech healthcare contexts and explore how they approach their health, biomedicine, and weight management. Although obesity specialists are trying to address the weight stigma and create a respectful environment, an anti-fat bias dominates in the rest of the Czech healthcare system. Moreover, even if the medicalization of fatness contributes to reducing weight stigmatization in some contexts, it also reinforces the perception of fat as a medical pathology, which, in turn, creates an obligation for fat individuals to seek biomedical treatment. We identify three strategies that fat people employ to minimize their exposure to weight-based discrimination: avoiding all healthcare contexts; seeking out younger physicians, whom they find to be generally more supportive; and going to great effort to find a doctor with a non-judgmental approach to obesity. In conclusion, we argue for a more well-being-oriented than weight-centered understanding of human health that will go beyond standardized indicators in favor of more personalized care.

Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) in Healthcare: A Systematic Review.

Amid global health challenges, resilient health systems require continuous innovation and progress. Stakeholders highlight the critical role of digital technologies in accelerating this progress. However, the digital health field faces significant challenges, including the sensitivity of health data, the absence of evidence-based standards, data governance issues, and a lack of evidence on the impact of digital health strategies. Overcoming these challenges is crucial to unlocking the full potential of digital health innovations in enhancing healthcare delivery and outcomes. Prioritizing security and privacy is essential in developing digital health solutions that are transparent, accessible, and effective. Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have gained widespread attention, including in healthcare, offering innovative solutions and addressing challenges through blockchain technology. This paper addresses the gap in systematic-level studies on NFT applications in healthcare, aiming to comprehensively analyze use cases and associated research challenges. The search included primary studies published between 2014 and November 2023, searching in a balanced set of databases compiling articles from different fields. A review was conducted following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) framework and strictly focusing on research articles related to NFT applications in the healthcare sector. The electronic search retrieved 1902 articles, ultimately resulting in 15 articles for data extraction. These articles span applications of NFTs in medical devices, pathology exams, diagnosis, pharmaceuticals, and other healthcare domains, highlighting their potential to eliminate centralized trust sources in health informatics. The review emphasizes the adaptability and versatility of NFT-based solutions, indicating their broader applicability across various healthcare stages and expansion into diverse industries. Given their role in addressing challenges associated with enhancing data integrity, availability, non-repudiation, and authentication, NFTs remain a promising avenue for future research within digital health solutions.

Clinicopathological significance of mutation profile detected by next generation sequencing in different metastatic organs of non-small cell lung cancers

BackgroundThe primary tumor and it’s metastases show heterogeneity in molecular studies for targeted therapies in Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer(NSCLC), the leading cause of cancer-related deaths worldwide. The study aimed to identify somatic mutations in biopsies from NSCLC patients’ metastatic organs using Next-Generation Sequencing(NGS) and examine their association with clinicopathological parameters. Materials and methodsThe study included 128 NSCLC patients and, NGS was performed on tumor biopsies from different metastatic organs at Molecular Pathology laboratory of the Department of Medical Pathology in Aydın Adnan Menderes University Faculty of Medicine. The age, gender, histopathological diagnoses, metastatic organs, smoking and mutation status were all recorded, along with the analysis results of 72 genes and 4149 primers in the panel of the NGS system. Results53.9 % of the cases had a history of smoking and patients with brain metastases had a higher smoking rate(p=0.000). The most common occurrence(39.8 %) was lymph node metastasis, followed by brain(19.5 %). There was a strong correlation between mutation presence and metastasis in the liver(p=0.012), bone(p=0.002), and pleura(p=0.008). Smokers had a higher frequency of KRAS(p=0.000) and TP53(p=0.001) mutations. Brain metastases showed a statistically significant NF1 mutation(p=0.001), while the liver exhibited a significant BRAF mutation(p=0.000). NF1-TP53, PTEN-TP53 and NF1-PTEN were the most common concomitant mutations and, the brain was the most common metastatic organ in which they occurred. ConclusionOur results suggest prizing assessing detected mutations, in the prediction, follow-up and management of metastases, especially in patients with lung adenocarcinoma. The assessment also needs to consider the tumor's mutation status in metastatic organs. New therapeutic agents targeting NF1 mutations will be available in the future to treat NSCLC, especially in metastases.

Aetiology and epidemiology of surgical vitreoretinal presentations in an Australian paediatric population: A seven-year retrospective study.

Paediatric vitreoretinal pathology is distinct from adult cases in both presentation and surgical planning. Here we aim to report the aetiology and epidemiology in children 0-18 years requiring vitreoretinal surgery at a major tertiary paediatric hospital in Queensland, Australia. Retrospective review of cases requiring vitreoretinal surgery between May 2015 and October 2022 was conducted. Demographics, ocular and medical history, surgical pathology, procedures performed, and epidemiology data were retrieved. Patients were grouped into three main aetiologies: traumatic, syndromic, or secondary. A total of 124 patients, the majority male (87, 70.2%) with a mean age of 10.3 years underwent vitreoretinal surgery. Trauma accounted for 32.3% of cases requiring surgery of which 47% were due to a penetrating eye injury. 35.5% were associated with a syndromic cause with common aetiology including coats, congenital cataract, sticklers, and retinopathy of prematurity. 32.3% developed secondary pathology and retinal detachment was the primary cause for surgery (55%). The average time from symptom onset to presentation was 30 days (SD 56.88) with patients living an average of 306.2 km (SD 558.9) away from the Queensland Children's Hospital. Older age was significantly associated with increased days to presentation in the traumatic group (p < 0.05). This study provides an insight into the aetiology and epidemiology of paediatric vitreoretinal presentations in Queensland, Australia.

Socio-communicative aspects of the representation of disease symptoms in Renaissance art

Modern historical research devoted to the development of medical science and the art of healing increasingly involves the analysis of sociocultural and sociocommunicative aspects, which become part of historical analysis. The article examines the relationship between fine art and human anatomy as an element of sociocultural translation (communication) of knowledge in the history of medicine, in particular anatomy. The art of the Renaissance, primarily portraiture from life, copying the image of a specific person, can reflect signs of his health, symptoms of illness, and medical knowledge in historical retrospect is actually part of the culture of society. The artists often turned out to be medically observant, accurate in small details. In this study, the authors show several examples of the reflection of specific medical pathologies in paintings and come to the conclusion that works of art can transmit information about the state of health of the depicted person, the presence of clinical manifestations of diseases captured by the brush of an artist but probably not yet known and understood by the doctors of that epoque.

Wakefield's Harm-Based Critique of the Biostatistical Theory.

Jerome Wakefield criticizes my biostatistical analysis of the pathological-as statistically subnormal biological part-functional ability relative to species, sex, and age-for its lack of a harm clause. He first charges me with ignoring two general distinctions: biological versus medical pathology, and disease of a part versus disease of a whole organism. He then offers 10 counterexamples that, he says, are harmless dysfunctions but not medical disorders. Wakefield ends by arguing that we need a harm clause to explain American psychiatry's 1973 decision to declassify homosexuality. I reply, first, that his two distinctions are philosophic fantasies alien to medical usage, invented only to save his own harmful-dysfunction analysis (HDA) from a host of obvious counterexamples. In any case, they do not coincide with the harmless/harmful distinction. In reality, medicine admits countless chronic diseases that are, contrary to Wakefield, subclinical for most of their course, as well as many kinds of typically harmless skin pathology. As for his 10 counterexamples, no medical source he cites describes them as he does. I argue that none of his examples contradicts the biostatistical analysis: all either are not part-dysfunctions (situs inversus, incompetent sperm, normal-flora infection) or are indeed classified as medical disorders (donated kidney, Typhoid Mary's carrier status, latent tuberculosis or HIV, cherry angiomas). And if Wakefield's HDA fits psychiatry, the fact that it does not fit medicine casts doubt on psychiatry's status as a medical specialty.