Mechanism Of Electron Capture Dissociation Research Articles

Mechanistic study on electron capture dissociation of the oligosaccharide-Mg²⁺ complex.

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) has shown great potential in structural characterization of glycans. However, our current understanding of the glycan ECD process is inadequate for accurate interpretation of the complex glycan ECD spectra. Here, we present the first comprehensive theoretical investigation on the ECD fragmentation behavior of metal-adducted glycans, using the cellobiose-Mg²⁺ complex as the model system. Molecular dynamics simulation was carried out to determine the typical glycan-Mg²⁺ binding patterns and the lowest-energy conformer identified was used as the initial geometry for density functional theory-based theoretical modeling. It was found that the electron is preferentially captured by Mg²⁺ and the resultant Mg⁺• can abstract a hydroxyl group from the glycan moiety to form a carbon radical. Subsequent radical migration and α-cleavage(s) result in the formation of a variety of product ions. The proposed hydroxyl abstraction mechanism correlates well with the major features in the ECD spectrum of the Mg²⁺-adducted cellohexaose. The mechanism presented here also predicts the presence of secondary, radical-induced fragmentation pathways. These secondary fragment ions could be misinterpreted, leading to erroneous structural determination. The present study highlights an urgent need for continuing investigation of the glycan ECD mechanism, which is imperative for successful development of bioinformatics tools that can take advantage of the rich structural information provided by ECD of metal-adducted glycans.

Refinements to the Utah–Washington Mechanism of Electron Capture Dissociation

Ab initio electronic structure calculations on a rather geometrically constrained doubly positivley charged parent peptide ion are combined with experimental data from others on three similar ions to refine understanding of the mechanistic steps in the Utah-Washington model of electron-capture and electron-transfer dissociation. The primary new findings are that (i) the electron need not first attach to a Rydberg orbital and subsequently be extracted by an SS σ* or amide π* orbital (rather, it can be guided directly into the SS σ* or amide π* orbital by the Rydberg orbital) and (ii) Coulomb and dipole potentials within the parent ion alter both the electron binding strengths and radial ranges of Rydberg orbitals located on the positively charged sites, which, in turn, alters the ranges over which the electron can be guided. These same potentials, when evaluated at disulfide or backbone amide sites, determine which disulfide σ* and amide π* orbitals are and are not susceptible to electron attachment leading to SS and N-Cα bond cleavage. Additional experiments on the same parent ions discussed here are proposed to further test and refine the UW model.

Transition Metal Ions: Charge Carriers that Mediate the Electron Capture Dissociation Pathways of Peptides

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) of model peptides adducted with first row divalent transition metal ions, including Mn(2+), Fe(2+), Co(2+), Ni(2+), Cu(2+), and Zn(2+), were investigated. Model peptides with general sequence of ZGGGXGGGZ were used as probes to unveil the ECD mechanism of metalated peptides, where X is either V or W; and Z is either R or N. Peptides metalated with different divalent transition metal ions were found to generate different ECD tandem mass spectra. ECD spectra of peptides metalated by Mn(2+) and Zn(2+) were similar to those generated by ECD of peptides adducted with alkaline earth metal ions. Series of c-/z-type fragment ions with and without metal ions were observed. ECD of Fe(2+), Co(2+), and Ni(2+) adducted peptides yielded abundant metalated a-/y-type fragment ions; whereas ECD of Cu(2+) adducted peptides generated predominantly metalated b-/y-type fragment ions. From the present experimental results, it was postulated that electronic configuration of metal ions is an important factor in determining the ECD behavior of the metalated peptides. Due presumably to the stability of the electronic configuration, metal ions with fully-filled (i.e., Zn(2+)) and half filled (i.e., Mn(2+)) d-orbitals might not capture the incoming electron. Dissociation of the metal ions adducted peptides would proceed through the usual ECD channel(s) via "hot-hydrogen" or "superbase" intermediates, to form series of c-/z(•)- fragments. For other transition metal ions studied, reduction of the metal ions might occur preferentially. The energy liberated by the metal ion reduction would provide enough internal energy to generate the "slow-heating" type of fragment ions, i.e., metalated a-/y- fragments and metalated b-/y- fragments.

Effects of Peptide Backbone Amide-to-Ester Bond Substitution on the Cleavage Frequency in Electron Capture Dissociation and Collision-Activated Dissociation

Probing the mechanism of electron capture dissociation on variously modified model peptide polycations has resulted in discovering many ways to prevent or reduce N-Cα bond fragmentation. Here we report on a rare finding of how to increase the backbone bond dissociation rate. In a number of model peptides, amide-to-ester backbone bond substitution increased the frequency of O-Cα bond cleavage (an analogue of N-Cα bonds in normal peptides) by several times, at the expense of reduced frequency of cleavages of the neighboring N-Cα bonds. In contrast, the ester linkage was only marginally broken in collisional dissociation. These results further highlight the complementarity of the reaction mechanisms in electron capture dissociation (ECD) and collision-activated dissociation (CAD). It is proposed that the effects of amide-to-ester bond substitution on fragmentation are mainly due to the differences in product ion stability (ECD, CAD) as well as proton affinity (CAD). This proposal is substantiated by calculations using density functional theory. The implications of these results in relation to the current understanding of the mechanisms of electron capture dissociation and electron transfer dissociation are discussed.

Top-down high-resolution electron capture dissociation mass spectrometry for comprehensive characterization of post-translational modifications in Rhesus monkey cardiac troponin I

Top-down high-resolution electron capture dissociation (ECD) mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful approach for comprehensive characterization of large proteins with labile post-translational modifications (PTMs). Phosphorylation of cardiac troponin I (cTnI) is a prominent determinant of cardiac function. Non-human primates (NHPs) are valuable models for biomedical research due to their genetic similarity to humans. To address the emerging need for in-depth understanding of NHP heart models, we have applied top-down high-resolution tandem mass spectrometry in conjugation with immunoaffinity chromatography purification to comprehensively characterize NHP cTnI. Our data revealed that cTnI affinity purified from NHP Rhesus monkey hearts was N-terminally acetylated and mono- or bis-phosphorylated. ECD unambiguously identified Ser22/Ser23 as the only basally phosphorylated sites with a phosphorylation order between these two sites (Ser23 phosphorylates prior to Ser22) which is different from those previously reported for mouse and human cTnI. Our study also strongly supports the nonergodic mechanism of ECD since no neutral loss of phosphates was observed in ECD spectra. Taken together, top-down MS with ECD is extremely valuable for studying labile PTMs in large proteins, which adds critical knowledge to our understanding of protein PTM regulations in health and disease.

Periodic Sequence Distribution of Product Ion Abundances in Electron Capture Dissociation of Amphipathic Peptides and Proteins

The rules for product ion formation in electron capture dissociation (ECD) mass spectrometry of peptides and proteins remain unclear. Random backbone cleavage probability and the nonspecific nature of ECD toward amino acid sequence have been reported, contrary to preferential channels of fragmentation in slow heating-based tandem mass spectrometry. Here we demonstrate that for amphipathic peptides and proteins, modulation of ECD product ion abundance (PIA) along the sequence is pronounced. Moreover, because of the specific primary (and presumably secondary) structure of amphipathic peptides, PIA in ECD demonstrates a clear and reproducible periodic sequence distribution. On the one hand, the period of ECD PIA corresponds to periodic distribution of spatially separated hydrophobic and hydrophilic domains within the peptide primary sequence. On the other hand, the same period correlates with secondary structure units, such as alpha-helical turns, known for solution-phase structure. Based on a number of examples, we formulate a set of characteristic features for ECD of amphipathic peptides and proteins: (1) periodic distribution of PIA is observed and is reproducible in a wide range of ECD parameters and on different experimental platforms; (2) local maxima of PIA are not necessarily located near the charged site; (3) ion activation before ECD not only extends product ion sequence coverage but also preserves ion yield modulation; (4) the most efficient cleavage (e.g. global maximum of ECD PIA distribution) can be remote from the charged site; (5) the number and location of PIA maxima correlate with amino acid hydrophobicity maxima generally to within a single amino acid displacement; and (6) preferential cleavage sites follow a selected hydrogen spine in an alpha-helical peptide segment. Presently proposed novel insights into ECD behavior are important for advancing understanding of the ECD mechanism, particularly the role of peptide sequence on PIA. An improved ECD model could facilitate protein sequencing and improve identification of unknown proteins in proteomics technologies. In structural biology, the periodic/preferential product ion yield in ECD of alpha-helical structures potentially opens the way toward de novo site-specific secondary structure determination of peptides and proteins in the gas phase and its correlation with solution-phase structure.

Electron Capture in Charge-Tagged Peptides. Evidence for the Role of Excited Electronic States

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) was studied with doubly charged dipeptide ions that were tagged with fixed-charge tris-(2,4,6-trimethoxyphenyl)phosphonium-methylenecarboxamido (TMPP-ac) groups. Dipeptides GK, KG, AK, KA, and GR were each selectively tagged with one TMPP-ac group at the N-terminal amino group while the other charge was introduced by protonation at the lysine or arginine side-chain groups to give (TMPP-ac-peptide + H)(2+) ions by electrospray ionization. Doubly tagged peptide derivatives were also prepared from GK, KG, AK, and KA in which the fixed-charge TMPP-ac groups were attached to the N-terminal and lysine side-chain amino groups to give (TMPP-ac-peptide-ac-TMPP)(2+) dications by electrospray. ECD of (TMPP-ac-peptide + H)(2+) resulted in 72% to 84% conversion to singly charged dissociation products while no intact charge-reduced (TMPP-ac-dipeptide + H)(+) ions were detected. The dissociations involved loss of H, formation of (TMPP + H)(+), and N-C(alpha) bond cleavages giving TMPP-CH(2)CONH(2)(+) (c(0)) and c(1) fragments. In contrast, ECD of (TMPP-ac-peptide-ac-TMPP)(2+) resulted in 31% to 40% conversion to dissociation products due to loss of neutral TMPP molecules and 2,4,6-trimethoxyphenyl radicals. No peptide backbone cleavages were observed for the doubly tagged peptide ions. Ab initio and density functional theory calculations for (Ph(3)P-ac-GK + H)(2+) and (H(3)P-ac-GK + H)(2+) analogs indicated that the doubly charged ions contained the lysine side-chain NH(3)(+) group internally solvated by the COOH group. The distance between the charge-carrying phosphonium and ammonium atoms was calculated to be 13.1-13.2 A in the most stable dication conformers. The intrinsic recombination energies of the TMPP(+)-ac and (GK + H)(+) moieties, 2.7 and 3.15 eV, respectively, indicated that upon electron capture the ground electronic states of the (TMPP-ac-peptide + H)(+*) ions retained the charge in the TMPP group. Ground electronic state (TMPP-ac-GK + H)(+*) ions were calculated to spontaneously isomerize by lysine H-atom transfer to the COOH group to form dihydroxycarbinyl radical intermediates with the retention of the charged TMPP group. These can trigger cleavages of the adjacent N-C(alpha) bonds to give rise to the c(1) fragment ions. However, the calculated transition-state energies for GK and GGK models suggested that the ground-state potential energy surface was not favorable for the formation of the abundant c(0) fragment ions. This pointed to the involvement of excited electronic states according to the Utah-Washington mechanism of ECD.

Long-Lived Electron Capture Dissociation Product Ions Experience Radical Migration via Hydrogen Abstraction

To explore the mechanism of electron capture dissociation (ECD) of linear peptides, a set of 16-mer peptides were synthesized with deuterium labeled on the alpha-carbon position of four glycines. The ECD spectra of these peptides showed that such peptides exhibit a preference for the radical to migrate to the alpha-carbon position on glycine via hydrogen (or deuterium) abstraction before the final cleavage and generation of the detected product ions. The data show c-type fragment ions, ions corresponding to the radical cation of the c-type fragments, c*, and they also show c*-1 peaks in the deuterated peptides only. The presence of the c*-1 peaks is best explained by radical-mediated scrambling of the deuterium atoms in the long-lived, metastable, radical intermediate complex formed by initial electron capture, followed by dissociation of the complex. These data suggest the presence of at least two mechanisms, one slow, one fast. The abundance of H* and -CO losses from the precursor ion changed upon deuterium labeling indicating the presence of a kinetic isotope effect, which suggests that the values reported here represent an underestimation of radical migration and H/D scrambling in the observed fragments.

Prediction of N [sbnd]C α bond cleavage frequencies in electron capture dissociation of Trp-cage dications by force-field molecular dynamics simulations

Fragment ion abundances observed in electron capture dissociation (ECD) of dications of four stereoisomers (all- l, d-Tyr 3, d-Gln 5 and d-Leu 7) of the Trp-cage protein correlated with the charge solvation patterns produced by molecular dynamics simulations (MDS) of the corresponding gas-phase structures. The degree of the correlation was however insufficient to distinguish the correct stereoisomers or make quantitative predictions. Much higher correlation was found between the ECD patterns and the frequencies of occurrence of neutral H-bonds to the carbonyls of the fragmenting amides. Based on this finding, a new ECD mechanism is suggested for N C α bond breakage, in which low-energy electrons are captured on a neutral hydrogen bond, with subsequent hydrogen atom transfer to the backbone carbonyl forming labile aminoketyl radical that rapidly fragments through α-cleavage. The neutral H-bonding model quantitatively predicted the ECD patterns of all four stereoisomers and correctly recognized them from the experimental data by comparing them to MDS results. The predictive power of the neutral H-bonding model may help in the future to solve gas-phase protein structures.

Toward a general mechanism of electron capture dissociation

The effects of positive charge on the properties of ammonium and amide radicals were investigated by ab initio and density functional theory calculations with the goal of elucidating the energetics of electron capture dissociation (ECD) of multiply charged peptide ions. The electronic properties of the amide group in N-methylacetamide (NMA) are greatly affected by the presence of a remote charge in the form of a point charge, methylammonium, or guanidinium cations. The common effect of the remote charge is an increase of the electron affinity of the amide group, resulting in exothermic electron capture. The N-Calpha bond dissociation and transition state energies in charge-stabilized NMA anions are 20-50 kJ mol(-1) greater than in the hydrogen atom adduct. The zwitterions formed by electron capture have proton affinities that were calculated as 1030-1350 kJ mol(-1), and are sufficiently basic for the amide carbonyl to exothermically abstract a proton from the ammonium, guanidinium and imidazolium groups in protonated lysine, arginine, and histidine residues, respectively. A new mechanism is proposed for ECD of multiply charged peptide and protein cations in which the electron enters a charge-stabilized electronic state delocalized over the amide group, which is a superbase that abstracts a proton from a sterically proximate amino acid residue to form a labile aminoketyl radical that dissociates by N-Calpha bond cleavage. This mechanism explains the low selectivity of N-Calpha bond dissociations induced by electron capture, and is applicable to dissociations of peptide ions in which the charge carriers are metal ions or quaternary ammonium groups. The new amide superbase and the previously proposed mechanisms of ECD can be uniformly viewed as being triggered by intramolecular proton transfer in charge-reduced amide cation-radicals. In contrast, remote charge affects N-H bond dissociation in weakly bound ground electronic states of hypervalent ammonium radicals, as represented by methylammonium, CH3NH3*, but has a negligible effect on the N-H bond dissociation in the strongly bound excited electronic states. This refutes previous speculations that loss of "hot hydrogen" can occur from an excited state of an ammonium radical.

Dissociative recombination cross section and branching ratios of protonated dimethyl disulfide and N-methylacetamide.

Dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) and N-methylacetamide are two first choice model systems that represent the disulfide bridge bonding and the peptide bonding in proteins. These molecules are therefore suitable for investigation of the mechanisms involved when proteins fragment under electron capture dissociation (ECD). The dissociative recombination cross sections for both protonated DMDS and protonated N-methylacetamide were determined at electron energies ranging from 0.001 to 0.3 eV. Also, the branching ratios at 0 eV center-of-mass collision energy were determined. The present results give support for the indirect mechanism of ECD, where free hydrogen atoms produced in the initial fragmentation step induce further decomposition. We suggest that both indirect and direct dissociations play a role in ECD.

Towards an Understanding of the Mechanism of Electron‐Capture Dissociation: A Historical Perspective and Modern Ideas

AbstractFor Abstract see ChemInform Abstract in Full Text.

N[bond]C(alpha) bond dissociation energies and kinetics in amide and peptide radicals. Is the dissociation a non-ergodic process?

Dissociations of aminoketyl radicals and cation radicals derived from beta-alanine N-methylamide, N-acetyl-1,2-diaminoethane, N(alpha)-acetyl lysine amide, and N(alpha)-glycyl glycine amide are investigated by combined density functional theory and Møller-Plesset perturbational calculations with the goal of elucidating the mechanism of electron capture dissociation (ECD) of larger peptide and protein ions. The activation energies for dissociations of N[bond]C bonds in aminoketyl radicals decrease in the series N[bond]CH(3) > N-CH(2)CH(2)NH(2) >> N[bond]CH(2)CONH(2) approximately N[bond]CH(CONH(2))(CH(2))(4)NH(2). Transition state theory rate constants for dissociations of N[bond]C(alpha) bonds in aminoketyl radicals and cation-radicals indicate an extremely facile reaction that occurs with unimolecular rate constants >10(5) s(-1) in species thermalized at 298 K in the gas phase. In neutral aminoketyl radicals the N[bond]C(alpha) bond cleavage results in fast dissociation. In contrast, N[bond]C(alpha) bond cleavage in aminoketyl cation-radicals results in isomerization to ion-molecule complexes that are held together by strong hydrogen bonds. The facile N[bond]C(alpha) bond dissociation in thermalized ions indicates that it is unnecessary to invoke the hypothesis of non-ergodic behavior for ECD intermediates.

Can the (M• — X) Region in Electron Capture Dissociation Provide Reliable Information on Amino Acid Composition of Polypeptides?

It has been suggested that small losses from reduced peptide molecular species in electron capture dissociation (ECD) could indicate the presence of certain amino acids [H.J. Cooper, R.R. Hudgins, K. Håkansson and A.G. Marshall, J. Am Soc. Mass Spectrom 13, 241 (2002)], similarly to immonium ions in high-energy collision-activated dissociation. The diagnostic value in ECD of the (M•–X) region (1 Da ≤ X ≤ 130 Da) was tested on several synthetic peptides. The insufficiency of the existing knowledge for making correct conclusions on the amino acid composition is demonstrated and new suggestions of the origin of losses are presented based on the “hot hydrogen atom” ECD mechanism. Generally, it is shown that not only protonation but also charge solvation is responsible for the small losses. The origin of 17 Da and 59 Da losses is revisited and a new mechanism for the 18 Da loss is suggested. The loss of a side chain plus a hydrogen atom is found to be a rather reliable indicator of the presence of histidine, tryptophan, tyrosine and, to a lesser degree, threonine. The overall conclusion is that the (M• - X) region does contain information on the amino acid composition, but extraction of this information requires additional studies.

Towards An Understanding of the Mechanism of Electron-Capture Dissociation: A Historical Perspective and Modern Ideas

Electron-capture dissociation (ECD) is a new fragmentation technique that utilizes ion–electron recombination reactions. The latter have parallels in other research fields; revealing these parallels helps to understand the ECD mechanism. An overview is given of ECD-related phenomena and of the history of ECD discovery and development. Current views on the ECD mechanism are discussed using both published and new examples.

Ionization in matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization: singly charged molecular ions are the lucky survivors.

A new model for the ionization processes in UV matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) which accounts for the major phenomena observed is presented and discussed. The model retains elements of earlier approaches, such as photoionization and photochemical reactions, but it redefines these in the light of new working questions, most importantly why only singly charged ions are detected. Based on experimental evidence, the formation of singly and multiply charged clusters by a deficiency/excess of ions and also by photoionization and subsequent photochemical processes is pointed out to be the major ionization processes, which typically occur in parallel. The generation of electrons and their partial loss into the surrounding vacuum and solid, on the one hand, results in a positively charged ion-neutral plume facilitating a high overall ionization yield. On the other hand, these electrons, and also the large excess of protonated matrix ions in the negative ion mode, induce effective ion reneutralization in the plume. These neutralization processes are most effective for the highly charged cluster ions initially formed. Their fragmentation behaviour is evidenced in fast metastable fragmentation characteristics and agrees well with an electron capture dissociation mechanism and the enthalpy transfer upon neutralization forms the rationale for the prominent fragmentation and intense chemical noise accompanying successful MALDI. Within the course of the paper, cross-correlations with other desorption/ionization techniques and with earlier discussions on their mechanisms are drawn.

Electron Capture Dissociation of Gaseous Multiply-Charged Proteins Is Favored at Disulfide Bonds and Other Sites of High Hydrogen Atom Affinity

Disulfide bonds in gaseous multiply-protonated proteins are preferentially cleaved in the mass spectrometer by low-energy electrons, in sharp contrast to excitation of the ions by photons or low-energy collisions. For S−S cyclized proteins, capture of one electron can break both an S−S bond and a backbone bond in the same ring, or even both disulfide bonds holding two peptide chains together (e.g., insulin), enhancing the sequence information obtainable by tandem mass spectrometry on proteins in trace amounts. Electron capture at uncharged S−S is unlikely; cleavage appears to be due to the high S−S affinity for H• atoms, consistent with a similar favorability found for tryptophan residues. RRKM calculations indicate that H• capture dissociation of backbone bonds in multiply-charged proteins represents nonergodic behavior, as proposed for the original direct mechanism of electron capture dissociation.