Mechanical Properties Of Native Cartilage Research Articles

Microscale strain concentrations in tissue-engineered osteochondral implants are dictated by local compositional thresholds and architecture

Tissue-engineered osteochondral implants manufactured from condensed mesenchymal stem cell bodies have shown promise for treating focal cartilage defects. Notably, such manufacturing techniques have shown to successfully recapture the bulk mechanical properties of native cartilage. However, the relationships among the architectural features, local composition, and micromechanical environment within tissue-engineered cartilage from cell-based aggregates remain unclear. Understanding such relationships is crucial for identifying critical parameters that can predict in vivo performance. Therefore, this study investigated the relationship among architectural features, composition, and micromechanical behavior of tissue-engineered osteochondral implants. We utilized fast-confocal microscopy combined with a strain mapping technique to analyze the micromechanical behavior under quasi-static loading, as well as Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy to analyze the local compositions. More specifically, we investigated the architectural features and compositional distributions generated from tissue maturation, along with macro- and micro-level strain distributions. Our results showed that under compression, cell-based aggregates underwent deformation followed by body movement, generating high local strain around the boundaries, where local aggrecan concentration was low and local collagen concentration was high. By analyzing the micromechanics and composition at the single aggregate length scale, we identified a strong threshold relationship between local strain and compositions. Namely at the aggrecan concentration below 0.015 arbitrary unit (A.U.) and the collagen concentration above 0.15 A.U., the constructs experienced greater than threefold increase in compressive strain. Overall, this study suggests that local compositional features are the primary driver of the local mechanical environment in tissue-engineered cartilage constructs, providing insight into potential quality control parameters for manufacturing tissue-engineered constructs.

Direct 3D printing of decellularized matrix embedded composite polycaprolactone scaffolds for cartilage regeneration.

Treatment options for large osteochondral injuries (OCIs) are limited by donor tissue scarcity, morbidity, and anatomic mismatch. 3D printing technology can produce patient-specific scaffolds to address these large defects. Thermoplastics like polycaprolactone (PCL) offer necessary mechanical properties, but lack bioactivity. We fabricated 3D printed PCL scaffolds embedded with polylactic acid microspheres containing decellularized cartilage matrix (DM). DM incorporation within polylactic acid microspheres prevented its thermal degradation during the 3D printing process. The scaffolds replicated the mechanical properties of native cartilage and demonstrated controlled release of DM proteins. Human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) seeded on the composite scaffolds with DM and cultured in basal media self-assembled into aggregates mimicking mesenchymal condensates during embryonic development. The DM composite scaffolds also induced higher expression of biochemical markers of cartilage development than controls, providing evidence for their translational application in the treatment of OCIs. The present study demonstrates the potential of direct incorporation of DM with thermoplastics for 3D printing of patient-specific scaffolds for osteochondral regeneration.

Enhanced Biomechanical Properties of Polyvinyl Alcohol-Based Hybrid Scaffolds for Cartilage Tissue Engineering

Articular cartilage damage is a primary feature of osteoarthritis and other inflammatory joint diseases (i.e., rheumatoid arthritis). Repairing articular cartilage is highly challenging due to its avascular/aneural nature and low cellularity. To induce functional neocartilage formation, the tissue substitute must have mechanical properties which can adapt well to the loading conditions of the joint. Among the various biomaterials which may function as cartilage replacements, polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) hydrogels stand out for their high biocompatibility and tunable mechanical features. This review article describes and discusses the enrichment of PVA with natural materials (i.e., collagen, hyaluronic acid, hydroxyapatite, chitosan, alginate, extracellular matrix) ± synthetic additives (i.e., polyacrylic acid, poly-lactic-co-glycolic acid, poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate, graphene oxide, bioactive glass) to produce cartilage substitutes with enhanced mechanical performance. PVA-based hybrid scaffolds have been investigated mainly by compression, tensile, friction, stress relaxation and creep tests, demonstrating increased stiffness and friction properties, and with cartilage-like viscoelastic behavior. In vitro and in vivo biocompatibility studies revealed positive outcomes but also many gaps yet to be addressed. Thus, recommendations for future research are proposed in order to prompt further progress in the fabrication of PVA-based hybrid scaffolds which increasingly match the biological and mechanical properties of native cartilage.

Bi-layered micro-fibre reinforced hydrogels for articular cartilage regeneration

Articular cartilage has limited capacity for regeneration and when damaged cannot be repaired with currently available metallic or synthetic implants. We aim to bioengineer a microfibre-reinforced hydrogel that can capture the zonal depth-dependent mechanical properties of native cartilage, and simultaneously support neo-cartilage formation. With this goal, a sophisticated bi-layered microfibre architecture, combining a densely distributed crossed fibre mat (superficial tangential zone, STZ) and a uniform box structure (middle and deep zone, MDZ), was successfully manufactured via melt electrospinning and combined with a gelatin–methacrylamide hydrogel. The inclusion of a thin STZ layer greatly increased the composite construct’s peak modulus under both incongruent (3.2-fold) and congruent (2.1-fold) loading, as compared to hydrogels reinforced with only a uniform MDZ structure. Notably, the stress relaxation response of the bi-layered composite construct was comparable to the tested native cartilage tissue. Furthermore, similar production of sulphated glycosaminoglycans and collagen II was observed for the novel composite constructs cultured under mechanical conditioning w/o TGF-ß1 supplementation and in static conditions w/TGF-ß1 supplementation, which confirmed the capability of the novel composite construct to support neo-cartilage formation upon mechanical stimulation. To conclude, these results are an important step towards the design and manufacture of biomechanically competent implants for cartilage regeneration. Statement of SignificanceDamage to articular cartilage results in severe pain and joint disfunction that cannot be treated with currently available implants. This study presents a sophisticated bioengineered bi-layered fibre reinforced cell-laden hydrogel that can approximate the functional mechanical properties of native cartilage. For the first time, the importance of incorporating a viable superficial tangential zone (STZ) – like structure to improve the load-bearing properties of bioengineered constructs, particularly when in-congruent surfaces are compressed, is demonstrated. The present work also provides new insights for the development of implants that are able to promote and guide new cartilaginous tissue formation upon physiologically relevant mechanical stimulation.

Enhanced nutrient transport improves the depth-dependent properties of tri-layered engineered cartilage constructs with zonal co-culture of chondrocytes and MSCs.

Articular cartilage is a highly organized tissue driven by zonal heterogeneity of cells, extracellular matrix proteins and fibril orientations, resulting in depth-dependent mechanical properties. Therefore, the recapitulation of the functional properties of native cartilage in a tissue engineered construct requires such a biomimetic design of the morphological organization, and this has remained a challenge in cartilage tissue engineering. This study demonstrates that a layer-by-layer fabrication scheme, including co-cultures of zone-specific articular CHs and MSCs, can reproduce the depth-dependent characteristics and mechanical properties of native cartilage while minimizing the need for large numbers of chondrocytes. In addition, introduction of a porous hollow fiber (combined with a cotton thread) enhanced nutrient transport and depth-dependent properties of the tri-layered construct. Such a tri-layered construct may provide critical advantages for focal cartilage repair. These constructs hold promise for restoring native tissue structure and function, and may be beneficial in terms of zone-to-zone integration with adjacent host tissue and providing more appropriate strain transfer after implantation.

Surface zone articular chondrocytes modulate the bulk and surface mechanical properties of the tissue-engineered cartilage.

The central hypothesis of functional tissue engineering is that an engineered construct can serve as a viable replacement tissue in vivo by replicating the structure and function of native tissue. In the case of articular cartilage, this requires the reproduction of the bulk mechanical and surface lubrication properties of native hyaline cartilage. Cartilage tissue engineering has primarily focused on achieving the bulk mechanical properties of native cartilage such as the compressive aggregate modulus and tensile strength. A scaffold-free self-assembling process has been developed that produces engineered cartilage with compressive properties approaching native tissue levels. Thus, the next step in this process is to begin addressing the friction coefficient and wear properties of these engineered constructs. The superficial zone protein (SZP), also known as lubricin or PRG4, is a boundary mode lubricant that is synthesized by surface zone (SZ) articular chondrocytes. Under conditions of high loading and low sliding speeds, SZP reduces friction and wear at the articular surface. The objective of this investigation was to determine whether increasing the proportion of SZ chondrocytes in cartilage constructs, in the absence of external stimuli such as growth factors and mechanical loading, would enhance the secretion of SZP and improve their frictional properties. In this study, cartilage constructs were engineered through a self-assembling process with varying ratios of SZ and middle zone (MZ) chondrocytes (SZ:MZ): 0:100, 25:75, 50:50, 75:25, and 100:0. Constructs containing different ratios of SZ and MZ chondrocytes did not significantly differ in the glycosaminoglycan composition or compressive aggregate modulus. In contrast, tensile properties and collagen content were enhanced in nearly all constructs containing greater amounts of SZ chondrocytes. Increasing the proportion of SZ chondrocytes had the hypothesized effect of improving the synthesis and secretion of SZP. However, increasing the SZ chondrocyte fraction did not significantly reduce the friction coefficient. These results demonstrate that additional factors, such as SZP-binding macromolecules, surface roughness, and adhesion, need to be examined to modulate the lubrication properties of engineered cartilage.

The role of hydrogel structure and dynamic loading on chondrocyte gene expression and matrix formation

Crosslinked poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) hydrogels are attractive scaffolds for cartilage tissue engineering because of their ability to mimic the aqueous environment and mechanical properties of native cartilage. In this study, hydrogel crosslinking density was varied to study the influence of gel structure and the application of dynamic loading (continuous, 1 Hz, 15% amplitude strain) on chondrocyte gene expression over ∼1 week culture. Gene expression was quantified using real-time RT-PCR for collagen II and aggrecan, the major cartilage extracellular matrix (ECM) components, and collagen I, an indicator of chondrocyte de-differentiation. When chondrocytes were encapsulated in PEG gels with low or high crosslinking, a high collagen II expression compared to collagen I expression (1000 or 100,000:1, respectively) indicated the native chondrocyte phenotype was retained. In the absence of loading, relative gene expression for collagen II and aggrecan was significantly higher (e.g., 2-fold and 4-fold, respectively, day 7) in the low crosslinked gels compared to gels with higher crosslinking. Dynamic loading, however, showed little effect on ECM gene expression in both crosslinked systems. To better understand the cellular environment, ECM production was qualitatively assessed using an in situ immunofluorescent technique and standard histology. A pericellular matrix (PCM) was observed as early as day 3 post-encapsulation and the degree of formation was dependent on gel crosslinking. These results suggest the PCM may protect the cells from sensing the applied loads. This study demonstrates that gel structure has a profound effect on chondrocyte gene expression, while dynamic loading has much less of an effect at early culture times.

On the Horizon From the ORS

On the Horizon From the ORS

Nanomechanical properties of alginate-recovered chondrocyte matrices for cartilage regeneration

Tissue-engineered cartilage constructs designed for in-vivo applications intuitively should mimic the mechanical properties of native cartilage. The objective of the present work was to characterize the nanomechanical properties of alginate-recovered chondrocyte matrices as a function of ex-vivo incubation time. Chondrocytes isolated from the articular cartilage of the mature bovine metacarpophalangeal joints were cultured with alginate hydrogel to allow for the formation of extracellular matrices. The recovered chondral constructs after 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks of ex-vivo incubation were analysed using nanoindentation with atomic force microscopy to determine their mechanical properties. Chondral constructs had average Young's moduli of 123 +/- 22 kPa, 174 +/- 31 kPa, 373 +/- 40 kPa, and 564 +/- 79 kPa after incubation for 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks respectively, indicating the gradual attainment of mechanical stiffness. This escalating trend of micromechanical properties as a function of increasing ex-vivo incubation time suggests that chondral constructs via a tissue-engineering approach are capable of elaborating extracellular matrices and increase mechanical stiffness. The relationship between Young's modulus and incubation time of the chondral constructs is useful in the design and fabrication of tissue-engineered cartilage constructs.

Long-Term Intermittent Compressive Stimulation Improves the Composition and Mechanical Properties of Tissue-Engineered Cartilage

Tissue engineering of articular cartilage is a promising alternative for cartilage repair. However, it has been difficult to develop tissue in vitro that mimicks native cartilage. Cartilaginous tissue formed in vitro does not accumulate enough extracellular matrix, is deficient in collagen, and possesses only a fraction of the mechanical properties of native cartilage. In this study, we investigated whether long-term intermittent compressive stimulation would improve the quality of the generated tissue. Chondrocyte cultures were established on the surface of porous calcium polyphosphate substrates and allowed to form cartilaginous tissue. In vitro-formed tissues were subjected to different stimulation protocols for 1 week. The optimal mechanical stimulation parameters identified in this short-term study were then applied to the cultures for up to 4 weeks. Mechanical stimulation applied at a 5% compressive amplitude at a frequency of 1 Hz for 400 cycles every second day resulted in the greatest increase in collagen synthesis (37 +/- 9% over control) while not significantly affecting proteoglycan synthesis (2 +/- 8% over control). This condition, applied to the chondrocyte cultures for 4 weeks, resulted in a significant increase in the amount of tissue that formed (stimulated, 2.4 +/- 0.2 mg dry wt; unstimulated, 1.61 +/- 0.08 mg dry wt). Stimulated tissues contained approximately 40% more collagen (stimulated, 590 +/- 58 microg; unstimulated, 420 +/- 42 microg), and 30% more proteoglycans (stimulated, 393 +/- 34 microg; unstimulated, 302 +/- 32 microg) as well as displaying a 2- to 3-fold increase in compressive mechanical properties (maximal equilibrium stress: stimulated, 10 +/- 1 kPa; unstimulated, 5 +/- 1 kPa; maximal equilibrium modulus: stimulated, 80 +/- 23 kPa; unstimulated, 24 +/- 6 kPa). The results of this study demonstrate that intermittent mechanical stimulation can increase collagen synthesis and, when applied over a 4-week period, can accelerate extracellular matrix accumulation as well as improve the material properties of the developed tissue. Interestingly, only short periods of mechanical stimulation (6 min every second day) were needed to affect the quality of cartilaginous tissue formed in vitro.

Effect of biomechanical conditioning on cartilaginous tissue formation in vitro.

Although tissue engineering of articular cartilage is a promising approach for cartilage repair, it has been difficult to develop cartilaginous tissue in vitro that mimics the properties of native cartilage. Isolated chondrocytes grown in culture typically do not accumulate enough extracellular matrix, and the generated tissue possesses only a fraction of the mechanical properties of native cartilage. One potential explanation for this might be that the cells are grown in an environment that lacks the mechanical stimuli to which the chondrocytes are exposed in vivo. In this study, we compared the long-term effects of both dynamic compressive and shearing forces on cartilaginous tissue formation in vitro. Bovine articular chondrocytes were grown on the surface of porous ceramic substrates and were maintained under static, free-swelling conditions for a period of four weeks. Cultures were then subjected to six minutes of mechanical stimulation every other day, in either compression or shear, for an additional four-week period. Cartilaginous tissues cultured in the presence of intermittent compression or shear were significantly thicker (p < 0.05) and had accumulated more extracellular matrix (p < 0.01) compared with the unstimulated controls. However, when normalized by the wet weight of the tissue, cultures stimulated in the presence of shearing forces contained more proteoglycans and collagen compared with compression-stimulated cultures. These cultures also displayed the largest increase in mechanical properties, with a threefold increase in equilibrium stress and a fivefold increase in equilibrium modulus. The results of this study demonstrate that a brief application of mechanical forces applied periodically over a long duration can improve the quality of cartilaginous tissue formed in vitro. However, the changes in tissue composition and mechanical properties were dependent on the specific mode of the applied mechanical forces, with shear stimulation eliciting the greater effect. This finding suggests that chondrocytes may respond differently to different modes of applied forces.