Mechanical Properties Of Amyloid Fibrils Research Articles

Simulated mechanical testing of amyloid fibril structures using molecular dynamics simulations with enhanced sampling.

Amyloid fibrils are a class of locally ordered protein aggregates known for their well-documented association with protein misfolding diseases such as Alzheimer's disease. These fibrils are characterized by the highly conserved cross- secondary structure spanning the fibril growth axis. X-ray crystallography is a leading experimental technique for resolving amyloid fibril structures from crystallized proteins. These experimental techniques have made invaluable contributions to our understanding of many protein structures; however, inherent limitations such as crystallization conditions that are far removed from physiological conditions, leave open the possibility that crystal structures generated under such circumstances may not be representative of amyloid fibril structures formed under in vivo conditions. Another experimental technique used to study fibril structures is atomic force microscopy (AFM). AFM has been used to determine key structural forces relating to the fibril steric zipper, as well as mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils, such as Young's modulus (a stiffness measure). Here, we demonstrate an approach that uses molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to study select mechanical properties of an amyloid fibril constructed from a crystal unit cell of human insulin chain B included in the Protein Data Bank as an amyloid fibril structure (PDB ID: 3hyd). Specifically, Steered MD was used to apply artificial forces to the fibrils to the point of breakage, while maintaining experimentally similar conditions to the AFM experiments. Mechanical characteristics such as stress-strain curves, were compared to measurements from AFM experiments. The MD simulations matched well with the experimental measurements from the AFM, suggesting that our in silico mechanical testing methodology can be used to provide supporting data for amyloid fibril structures resolved using x-ray crystallography.

Correlation between the hierarchical structures and nanomechanical properties of amyloid fibrils

Amyloid fibrils have recently been highlighted due to their excellent mechanical properties, which not only play a role in their biological functions but also imply their applications in biomimetic material design. Despite recent efforts to unveil how the excellent mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils originate, it has remained elusive how the anisotropic nanomechanical properties of hierarchically structured amyloid fibrils are determined. Here, we characterize the anisotropic nanomechanical properties of hierarchically structured amyloid fibrils using atomic force microscopy experiments and atomistic simulations. It is shown that the hierarchical structure of amyloid fibrils plays a crucial role in determining their radial elastic property but does not make any effect on their bending elastic property. This is attributed to the role of intermolecular force acting between the filaments (constituting the fibril) on the radial elastic modulus of amyloid fibrils. Our finding illustrates how the hierarchical structure of amyloid fibrils encodes their anisotropic nanomechanical properties. Our study provides key design principles of amyloid fibrils, which endow valuable insight into the underlying mechanisms of amyloid mechanics.

Mapping the Broad Structural and Mechanical Properties of Amyloid Fibrils

Amyloids are fibrillar nanostructures of proteins that are assembled in several physiological processes in human cells (e.g., hormone storage) but also during the course of infectious (prion) and noninfectious (nonprion) diseases such as Creutzfeldt-Jakob and Alzheimer’s diseases, respectively. How the amyloid state, a state accessible to all proteins and peptides, can be exploited for functional purposes but also have detrimental effects remains to be determined. Here, we measure the nanomechanical properties of different amyloids and link them to features found in their structure models. Specifically, we use shape fluctuation analysis and sonication-induced scission in combination with full-atom molecular dynamics simulations to reveal that the amyloid fibrils of the mammalian prion protein PrP are mechanically unstable, most likely due to a very low hydrogen bond density in the fibril structure. Interestingly, amyloid fibrils formed by HET-s, a fungal protein that can confer functional prion behavior, have a much higher Young’s modulus and tensile strength than those of PrP, i.e., they are much stiffer and stronger due to a tighter packing in the fibril structure. By contrast, amyloids of the proteins RIP1/RIP3 that have been shown to be of functional use in human cells are significantly stiffer than PrP fibrils but have comparable tensile strength. Our study demonstrates that amyloids are biomaterials with a broad range of nanomechanical properties, and we provide further support for the strong link between nanomechanics and β-sheet characteristics in the amyloid core.

Nano-mechanical characterization of disassembling amyloid fibrils using the Peak Force QNM method.

The comprehensive understanding of disassembly mechanism of amyloid fibrils requires nano-scale characterization of the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils during the disassembly process. In this work, gemini surfactant C12 C6 C12 Br2 micelles were used as a probe to disassemble Aβ(1-40) fibrils. The microstructure evolution and nano-mechanical properties of Aβ(1-40) fibrils during the disassembly process were systematically investigated by the Peak Force Quantitative Nano-mechanical (PF-QNM) technique. The results show an obvious decrease in Young's modulus of mature fibrils with high β-sheet contents (2.4 ± 1.0 GPa) in comparison to the resulting peptide/surfactant complexes (1.1 ± 0.8 GPa) with loose surface structures. Interestingly, the Young's modulus of spherical peptide/surfactant complexes on the core was more than 3 GPa. This strategy can be used as a standard protocol to investigate the interaction mechanism between amyloid fibrils and small molecules, which may open up new possibilities to explore the mechanism of relevant human diseases.

Determination of the elastic modulus of β-lactoglobulin amyloid fibrils by measuring the Debye-Waller factor

Although amyloid fibrils are associated with amyloidoses, they are now being considered as novel biomaterials for industrial use due to their structural stability in the matured state. Therefore, the physical characteristics of these materials need to be clarified prior to their industrial application. In the present study, the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils precursored by β-lactoglobulin were investigated. Previous studies have examined the stiffness or modulus values of these fibrils using atomic force microscopy. However, the modulus values reported, even for amyloid fibrils from the same precursor proteins, range over three orders of magnitude, from a few MPa to GPa, depending on the experimental methods employed under specific loading conditions. We determined the elastic modulus of amyloid fibrils by measuring spontaneous thermal fluctuations in the material, the Debye-Waller factor. This method does not require any contact between the probe and material or any loading. The vibrational modes of a fibril were considered in order to estimate mechanical parameters. The modulus value determined along the fibril axis for single amyloid fibrils was slightly smaller than those reported in the literature. The smaller modulus value suggests the existence of less ordered proto-fibrils in our specimen, which was confirmed by the AFM images.

Nanomechanical Characterization of Amyloid Fibrils Using Single-Molecule Experiments and Computational Simulations

Amyloid fibrils have recently received much attention due to not only their important role in disease pathogenesis but also their excellent mechanical properties, which are comparable to those of mechanically strong protein materials such as spider silk. This indicates the necessity of understanding fundamental principles providing insight into how amyloid fibrils exhibit the excellent mechanical properties, which may allow for developing biomimetic materials whose material (e.g., mechanical) properties can be controlled. Here, we describe recent efforts to characterize the nanomechanical properties of amyloid fibrils using computational simulations (e.g., atomistic simulations) and single-molecule experiments (e.g., atomic force microscopy experiments). This paper summarizes theoretical models, which are useful in analyzing the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils based on simulations and experiments, such as continuum elastic (beam) model, elastic network model, and polymer statistical model. In this paper, we suggest how the nanomechanical properties of amyloid fibrils can be characterized and determined using computational simulations and/or atomic force microscopy experiments coupled with the theoretical models.

End Capping Alters the Structural Characteristics and Mechanical Properties of Transthyretin (105-115) Amyloid Protofibrils.

Pathological amyloid proteins are associated with degenerative and neurodegenerative diseases. These amyloid proteins develop as oligomer, fibrillar, and plaque forms, due to the denatured and unstable status of the amyloid monomers. Specifically, the development of fibrillar amyloid proteins has been investigated through several experimental studies. To understand the generation of amyloid fibrils, environmental factors such as point mutations, pH, and polymorphic characteristics have been considered. Recently, amyloid fibril studies related to end-capping effects have been conducted to understand amyloid fibril development. However, atomic-level studies to determine the stability and mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils based on end capping have not been undertaken. In this study, we show that end capping alters the structural characteristics and conformations of transthyretin (TTR) amyloid fibrils by using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Variation in the structural conformations and characteristics of the TTR fibrils through end capping are observed, due to the resulting electrostatic energies and hydrophobicity characteristics. Moreover, the end capping changes the mechanical properties of TTR fibrils. Our results shed light on amyloid fibril formation under end-capping conditions.

Morphology and mechanical properties of multi-stranded amyloid fibrils probed by atomistic and coarse-grained simulations

Amyloid fibrils are responsible for pathogenesis of various diseases and exhibit the structural feature of an ordered, hierarchical structure such as multi-stranded helical structure. As the multi-strandedness of amyloid fibrils has recently been found to be highly correlated with their toxicity and infectivity, it is necessary to study how the hierarchical (i.e. multi-stranded) structure of amyloid fibril is formed. Moreover, although it has recently been reported that the nanomechanics of amyloid proteins plays a key role on the amyloid-induced pathogenesis, a critical role that the multi-stranded helical structure of the fibrils plays in their nanomechanical properties has not fully characterized. In this work, we characterize the morphology and mechanical properties of multi-stranded amyloid fibrils by using equilibrium molecular dynamics simulation and elastic network model. It is shown that the helical pitch of multi-stranded amyloid fibril is linearly proportional to the number of filaments comprising the amyloid fibril, and that multi-strandedness gives rise to improving the bending rigidity of the fibril. Moreover, we have also studied the morphology and mechanical properties of a single protofilament (filament) in order to understand the effect of cross-β structure and mutation on the structures and mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils. Our study sheds light on the underlying design principles showing how the multi-stranded amyloid fibril is formed and how the structure of amyloid fibrils governs their nanomechanical properties.

Role of Sequence and Structural Polymorphism on the Mechanical Properties of Amyloid Fibrils

Amyloid fibrils playing a critical role in disease expression, have recently been found to exhibit the excellent mechanical properties such as elastic modulus in the order of 10 GPa, which is comparable to that of other mechanical proteins such as microtubule, actin filament, and spider silk. These remarkable mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils are correlated with their functional role in disease expression. This suggests the importance in understanding how these excellent mechanical properties are originated through self-assembly process that may depend on the amino acid sequence. However, the sequence-structure-property relationship of amyloid fibrils has not been fully understood yet. In this work, we characterize the mechanical properties of human islet amyloid polypeptide (hIAPP) fibrils with respect to their molecular structures as well as their amino acid sequence by using all-atom explicit water molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. The simulation result suggests that the remarkable bending rigidity of amyloid fibrils can be achieved through a specific self-aggregation pattern such as antiparallel stacking of β strands (peptide chain). Moreover, we have shown that a single point mutation of hIAPP chain constituting a hIAPP fibril significantly affects the thermodynamic stability of hIAPP fibril formed by parallel stacking of peptide chain, and that a single point mutation results in a significant change in the bending rigidity of hIAPP fibrils formed by antiparallel stacking of β strands. This clearly elucidates the role of amino acid sequence on not only the equilibrium conformations of amyloid fibrils but also their mechanical properties. Our study sheds light on sequence-structure-property relationships of amyloid fibrils, which suggests that the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils are encoded in their sequence-dependent molecular architecture.

Polymer physics inspired approaches for the study of the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils

ABSTRACTAmyloid structures constitute a class of highly ordered nanomaterials formed by insoluble protein aggregates. These aggregates are characterized by a cross‐β structural motif in which β‐sheets are oriented perpendicular to the fibril axis and bound together by a dense hydrogen bonding network. Although they have been associated with several neurodegenerative disorders, such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases, amyloid fibrils have also been found in many physiologically beneficial roles, for instance in adhesives and hormone storage. Inspired by this natural occurrence of functional amyloid, the hierarchal self‐assembly of these structures has recently been used to develop artificial biomaterials for applications in medicine and nanotechnology. In order to realize the full potential of amyloids as functional materials, it is important to understand their fundamental mechanical properties. This review explores a range of experimental strategies to determine the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils and discusses the results in the context of polymer physics concepts. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part B: Polym. Phys. 2014, 52, 281–292

Fibrillogenesis of huntingtin and other glutamine containing proteins.

This chapter focuses on the aggregation of glutamine containing peptides and proteins with an emphasis on huntingtin protein, whose aggregation leads to the development of Huntington's disease. The kinetics that leads to the formation of amyloids, the structure of aggregates of various types and the morphological mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils are described. The kinetics of amyloid fibril formation has been proposed to follow a nucleation dependent polymerization model, dependent upon the size of the nucleus. This model and the effect of the polyglutamine length on the nucleus size are reviewed. Aggregate structure is characterized at two different levels. The atomic-scale resolution structure of fibrillar and crystalline aggregates of polyglutamine containing proteins and peptides was determined by X-ray crystallography and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The chapter outlines the results obtained by both these techniques. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was instrumental in elucidating the morphology of fibrils, their organization and assembly. The chapter also discusses the high stability of amyloid fibrils, including their mechanical properties as revealed by AFM.

Mechanical Characterization of Amyloid Fibrils Using Coarse‐Grained Normal Mode Analysis

AbstractRecent experimental studies have shown that amyloid fibril formed by aggregation of β peptide exhibits excellent mechanical properties comparable to other protein materials such as actin filaments and microtubules. These excellent mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils are related to their functional role in disease expression. This indicates the necessity of understanding how an amyloid fibril achieves the remarkable mechanical properties through self‐aggregation with structural hierarchy. However, the structure‐property–function relationship still remains elusive. In this work, the mechanical properties of human islet amyloid polypeptide (hIAPP) are studied with respect to its structural hierarchies and structural shapes by coarse‐grained normal mode analysis. The simulation shows that hIAPP fibril can achieve the excellent bending rigidity via specific aggregation patterns such as antiparallel stacking of β peptides. Moreover, the length‐dependent mechanical properties of amyloids are found. This length‐dependent property has been elucidated from a Timoshenko beam model that takes into account the shear effect on the bending of amyloids. In summary, the study sheds light on the importance of not only the molecular architecture, which encodes the mechanical properties of the fibril, but also the shear effect on the mechanical (bending) behavior of the fibril.

Failure of Aβ(1-40) amyloid fibrils under tensile loading

Amyloid fibrils and plaques are detected in the brain tissue of patients affected by Alzheimer’s disease, but have also been found as part of normal physiological processes such as bacterial adhesion. Due to their highly organized structures, amyloid proteins have also been used for the development of nanomaterials, for a variety of applications including biomaterials for tissue engineering, nanolectronics, or optical devices. Past research on amyloid fibrils resulted in advances in identifying their mechanical properties, revealing a remarkable stiffness. However, the failure mechanism under tensile loading has not been elucidated yet, despite its importance for the understanding of key mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils and plaques as well as the growth and aggregation of amyloids into long fibers and plaques. Here we report a molecular level analysis of failure of amyloids under uniaxial tensile loading. Our molecular modeling results demonstrate that amyloid fibrils are extremely stiff with a Young’s modulus in the range of 18–30 GPa, in good agreement with previous experimental and computational findings. The most important contribution of our study is our finding that amyloid fibrils fail at relatively small strains of 2.5%–4%, and at stress levels in the range of 1.02 to 0.64 GPa, in good agreement with experimental findings. Notably, we find that the strength properties of amyloid fibrils are extremely length dependent, and that longer amyloid fibrils show drastically smaller failure strains and failure stresses. As a result, longer fibrils in excess of hundreds of nanometers to micrometers have a greatly enhanced propensity towards spontaneous fragmentation and failure. We use a combination of simulation results and simple theoretical models to define critical fibril lengths where distinct failure mechanisms dominate.

Structural and Mechanical Properties of TTR105-115 Amyloid Fibrils from Compression Experiments

Amyloid fibrils, originally associated with neurodegenerative diseases, are now recognized to have interesting mechanical properties. By using synchrotron x-ray diffraction at high pressure in a diamond anvil cell we determined the bulk modulus of TTR105-115 amyloid fibrils in water and in silicone oil to be 2.6 and 8.1 GPa, respectively. The compression characteristics of the fibrils are quite different in the two media, revealing the presence of cavities along the axis of the fibrils, but not between the β-sheets, which are separated by a dry interface as in a steric zipper motif. Our results emphasize the importance of peptide packing in determining the structural and mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils.

Compressive deformation of ultralong amyloid fibrils

Involved in various neurodegenerative diseases, amyloid fibrils and plaques feature a hierarchical structure, ranging from the atomistic to the micrometer scale. At the atomistic level, a dense and organized hydrogen bond network is resembled in a beta-sheet rich secondary structure, which drives a remarkable stiffness in the range of 10–20GPa, larger than many other biological nanofibrils, a result confirmed by both experiment and theory. However, the understanding of how these exceptional mechanical properties transfer from the atomistic to the nanoscale remains unknown. Here we report a multiscale analysis that, from the atomistic-level structure of a single fibril, extends to the mesoscale level, reaching size scales of hundreds of nanometers. We use parameters directly derived from full atomistic simulations of Aβ (1–40) amyloid fibrils to parameterize a mesoscopic coarse-grained model, which is used to reproduce the elastic properties of amyloid fibrils. We then apply our mesoscopic model in an analysis of the buckling behavior of amyloid fibrils with different lengths and report a comparison with predictions from continuum beam theory. An important implication of our results is a severe reduction of the effective modulus due to buckling, an effect that could be important to interpret experimental results of ultra-long amyloid fibrils. Our model represents a powerful tool to mechanically characterize molecular structures on the order of hundreds of nanometers to micrometers on the basis of the underlying atomistic behavior. The work provides insight into structural and mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils and may enable further analysis of larger-scale assemblies such as amyloidogenic bundles or plaques as found in disease states.

Failure of Abeta(1-40) amyloid fibrils under tensile loading

AbstractAmyloid fibrils and plaques are detected in the brain tissue of patients affected by Alzheimer’s disease, but have also been found as part of normal physiological processes such as bacterial adhesion. Due to their highly organized structures, amyloid proteins have also been used for the development of novel nanomaterials, for a variety of applications including biomaterials for tissue engineering, nanolectronics, or optical devices. Past research on amyloid fibrils resulted in advances in identifying their mechanical properties, revealing a remarkable stiffness. However, the failure mechanism under tensile loading has not been elucidated yet, despite its importance for the understanding of key mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils and plaques as well as the growth and aggregation of amyloids into long fibers and plaques. Here we report a molecular level analysis of failure of amyloids under uniaxial tensile loading. Our molecular modeling results demonstrate that amyloid fibrils are extremely stiff with a Young’s modulus in the range of 18-30 GPa, in good agreement with previous experimental and computational findings. The most important contribution of our study is our finding that amyloid fibrils fail at relatively small strains of 2.5% to 4%, and at stress levels in the range of 1.02 to 0.64 GPa, in good agreement with experimental findings. Notably, we find that the strength properties of amyloid fibrils are extremely length dependent, and that longer amyloid fibrils show drastically smaller failure strains and failure stresses. As a result, longer fibrils in excess of hundreds of nanometers to micrometers have a greatly enhanced propensity towards spontaneous fragmentation and failure. We use a combination of simulation results and simple theoretical models to define critical fibril lengths where distinct failure mechanisms dominate.

Alzheimer's Aβ(1-40) Amyloid Fibrils Feature Size-Dependent Mechanical Properties

Amyloid fibrils are highly ordered protein aggregates that are associated with several pathological processes, including prion propagation and Alzheimer's disease. A key issue in amyloid science is the need to understand the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils and fibers to quantify biomechanical interactions with surrounding tissues, and to identify mechanobiological mechanisms associated with changes of material properties as amyloid fibrils grow from nanoscale to microscale structures. Here we report a series of computational studies in which atomistic simulation, elastic network modeling, and finite element simulation are utilized to elucidate the mechanical properties of Alzheimer's Aβ(1-40) amyloid fibrils as a function of the length of the protein filament for both twofold and threefold symmetric amyloid fibrils. We calculate the elastic constants associated with torsional, bending, and tensile deformation as a function of the size of the amyloid fibril, covering fibril lengths ranging from nanometers to micrometers. The resulting Young's moduli are found to be consistent with available experimental measurements obtained from long amyloid fibrils, and predicted to be in the range of 20–31 GPa. Our results show that Aβ(1-40) amyloid fibrils feature a remarkable structural stability and mechanical rigidity for fibrils longer than ≈100 nm. However, local instabilities that emerge at the ends of short fibrils (on the order of tens of nanometers) reduce their stability and contribute to their disassociation under extreme mechanical or chemical conditions, suggesting that longer amyloid fibrils are more stable. Moreover, we find that amyloids with lengths shorter than the periodicity of their helical pitch, typically between 90 and 130 nm, feature significant size effects of their bending stiffness due the anisotropy in the fibril's cross section. At even smaller lengths (⪅50 nm), shear effects dominate lateral deformation of amyloid fibrils, suggesting that simple Euler-Bernoulli beam models fail to describe the mechanics of amyloid fibrils appropriately. Our studies reveal the importance of size effects in elucidating the mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils. This issue is of great importance for comparing experimental and simulation results, and gaining a general understanding of the biological mechanisms underlying the growth of ectopic amyloid materials.

Shear-induced structure and mechanics of β-lactoglobulin amyloid fibrils

Alzheimer first identified amyloid plaques during autopsies of the brains of dementia patients in 1905. Considerable effort has since been directed to understanding the composition, structure and formation mechanism of amyloid fibrils. A variety of proteins have now been shown to self-assemble into amyloid fibrils. Furthermore, the association between misfolded proteins and a wide range of diseases is now established. Here we examine the effect of shear on the formation, structure and mechanical properties of amyloid fibrils. Atomic force microscopy is used to both image and measure the nanomechanical properties of β-lactoglobulin (β-Lg) amyloid fibrils generated in controlled (Couette) and uncontrolled shear flows (stirring). Controlled shear-induced fibrils with ‘beaded’ morphologies have lower mechanical strengths than fibrils formed in uncontrolled shear which show twisted ribbon like morphologies. The mechanical strengths of amyloid fibrils are determined by fibril structure and vary depending on the type of shear exposure during in vitro formation. These findings may have implications regarding the different toxicities of amyloid fibrils and linear aggregates that form in vivo.