ABSTRACT We separately assess elemental abundances in active galactic nuclei's (AGNs) broad and narrow emission line regions (BLR and NLR), based on a critical assessment of published results together with new photoionization models. We find (1) He/H enhancements in some AGN, exceeding what can be explained by normal chemical evolution and confirm, (2) super-solar α abundance, though to a lesser degree than previously reported. We also reaffirm, (3) an N/O ratio consistent with secondary production, (4) solar or slightly sub-solar Fe abundance, and (5) red-shift independent metallicity, in contrast with galactic chemical evolution. We interpret (6) the larger metallicity in the BLR than NRL in terms of an in situ stellar evolution and pollution in AGN discs (SEPAD) model. We attribute (a) the redshift independence to the heavy element pollutants being disposed into the disc and accreted onto the central supermassive black hole (SMBH), (b) the limited He excess to the accretion–wind metabolism of a top-heavy population of evolving massive main sequence stars, (c) the super-solar CNO enrichment to the nuclear synthesis during their post-main-sequence evolution, (d) the large N/O to the byproduct of multiple stellar generations, and (e) the Mg, Si, and Fe to the ejecta of type II supernovae in the disc. These results provide supporting evidence for (f) ongoing self-regulated star formation, (g) adequate stellar luminosity to maintain marginal gravitational stability, (h) prolific production of seeds, and (i) dense coexistence of subsequently grown residual black hole populations in AGN discs.