A family of group 4 permethylpentalene complexes, Pn*MCpRX (M = Ti, Zr; CpR = Cp, CpMe, CptBu, CpnBu, CpMe3, Ind; X = Cl, Me), has been synthesized and fully characterized by multinuclear NMR spectroscopy, elemental analysis, and single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies. These complexes were immobilized on an insoluble polymethylaluminoxane (sMAO), MAO-modified silica (ssMAO), and a MAO-modified layered double hydroxide (LDH-MAO). The effect of substitution around the Cp ligand was examined in relation to their performance (activity, Mw, PDI, polymer morphology) for ethylene polymerization measured both in solution and in slurry phase. Maximum solution-phase activities of 3585 kg/mol·h·bar were recorded at modest [Zr]:[Al] ratios of 1:250. These were compared to the activities recorded using the equivalent solid-supported complexes, and it was observed that sMAO was a superior support material with average increases in activity of 5.3 and 2.3 times relative to ssMAO and LDH-MAO, respectively. Most strikin...