Petrographic and geochemical data (major and trace elements) are presented for Oligocene flood basalts and Miocene shield lavas from the Mertolemariam-Abamineos area, northwestern Ethiopian Plateau to examine the petrogenesis of the erupted magmas and the nature of mantle source compositions. The Mertolemariam flood basalts have mainly aphyric and plagioclase phyric textures. The Abamineos shield lavas have sparsely clinopyroxene phyric to highly plagioclase-clinopyroxene phyric textures. Geochemical classification shows that the Mertolemariam Oligocene flood basalts are sub-alkaline in composition, whereas the Abamineos Miocene shield lavas are highly alkaline in composition. The Abamineos shield has a unique composition (i.e., basanites) compared with all other shield basalts (transitional to alkaline) in the northwestern Ethiopian Plateau. Major and trace element compositions display two distinct trends between Mertolemariam flood basalts and Abamineos shield basanites. Fractional crystallization, partial melting, and crustal contamination of a homogeneous mantle source cannot explain the compositional variations between the Mertolemariam flood basalts and the Abamineos shield basanites. The trace element composition suggests that the Mertolemariam Oligocene flood basalts were more likely generated from the mixing of OIB (mantle plume) and E-MORB (enriched asthenosphere) mantle components. The Abamineos Miocene shield basanites were derived from the mantle plume (OIB) component. LREE/MREE and LREE/HREE indicate that both groups possibly originated from a mantle source within the stability field of spinel and garnet. In comparison, the Mertolemariam flood basalts were formed by a higher degree of partial melting from relatively shallow depths than the Abamineos shield basanites. We propose a scenario that explains the magmatic genesis in the northwestern Ethiopian Plateau: volcanism initiated by the initial arrival of the mantle plume (OIB-like) beneath the lithosphere, which comes across a geochemically fertile and enriched MORB (E-MORB) mantle component in the upper asthenosphere. The hot mantle plume triggered melting of the fertile and enriched MORB, and then melting occurred in the plume (OIB-like) at depth in the stability field of spinel and garnet. Melts from the mantle plume (OIB-like) and E-MORB components mixed to produce sub-alkaline flood basalts during the Oligocene in the northwestern Ethiopian Plateau Subsequently, melts from the advanced upwelling mantle plume (OIB-like) produced Miocene shield lavas in the northwestern Ethiopian Plateau.